Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

I have a question for the mods

who's talking here?

~grandma again~ 7
Justwatching72 1
steinhoister 2
ghostpost 8
ExLady In Blue 1
rEVOLution 1
Perfection 2
Laurabeth 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
TexasOma 1
The Pretty Plumber 1
allday 1
Work in Progress 3
Butterfly Kisses 3
Puss In Boots 1
Dorothy Parker 3
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
BiggieSmalls 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

I am asking this question with respect but I would really appreciate a dialogue. When you ice someone, what is the criteria you use to delete all the old comments for whatever number of hours instead of just editing or deleting the offensive comment? Since it isn't consistently applied to users I think it is a fair question.

I can understand if someone has slammed the board with post after post of porn and gore or if there too many posts of profanity to go back and edit all of them..which is why Adam made that feature available in the first place.

But when just one or two comments were out of line, I don't see the point of 24 hours or 36 hours or whatever it is to be deleted. I can speculate, but prefer not to.


Know in advance, that I respect the service you do on KU but I also think that letting comments stand and just editing out the swear word or name or offensive remark and letting the posters other comments stand would help threads flow better as well as allow users to see what it is that got someone iced in the first place.

I have raised this issue before and some mods said they agreed with this reasoning but apparently at least one mod still deletes old comments when they ice certain posters. I would like to hear other opinions but this sincere question is not about mod bashing. However, I do think open discussion can bring about better understanding. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I have wondered the same thing about deleting a chunk of past comments when one gets iced. I don't remember them always doing that? I'm curious too about what the point of that is. 

Justwatching72 --- 15 years ago -

Only two of them do it, and they are both Edited. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

I know that if the person is someone who has a history of editing their comments from the icebox, they get their comments deleted along with their icing. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

I know that if the person is someone who has a history of editing their comments from the icebox, they get their comments deleted along with their icing.

How can someone edit from the icebox since you can't post when you are iced? 

~grandma again~ --- 15 years ago -

i made that mistake a couple of times when icing people when adam first put the option for mods on here but once i realized what was happening i stopped.

as a mod, i would now only delete the comment that was offensive or edit it. if many comments need to be edited then i would use the feature to delete recent comments.

i can not speak for all the other mods though. good question ghostpost. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

You can edit your old comments that you posted in the last hour.

Some of the people get really vile because they are angry about being iced, so they edit their comments to have profanity directed at the mods, the other people on the site, etc. 

ExLady In Blue --- 15 years ago -

What Cruella says is true. I have seen posts edited SEVERAL TIMES from the icebox. To me, if you have a reputation of editing from the icebox, you should know what's coming. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

Thanks, GA. I really appreciate your take on it and that you took the time to reply. I think it is useful to be able to check the icebox and see what offenses were committed. I think it helps people learn from others mistakes and also helps with consistently enforcing the TOS. 

~grandma again~ --- 15 years ago -

unless it is porn or REALLY bad, i have learned to leave the comment as is so others can see for themselves why that person was iced. some people still complain. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

If you do remove the comment, you get complaints from those who wanted to see it.

And if you don't remove the comment, you get complaints from people who didn't.

It's just a judgment call, and it won't make all of the people happy all of the time. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

I delete the comments. I think Adam has a like 18 hour time on that. Maybe it is more or less but the option states recent. I do it because if I see something that is ice-deserving I really don't want to waste time reading all their comments in the recent past to see what else needs to be edited.

The people I have iced have had numerous edits prior to icing so I can guess they had comments on other threads I missed. 

~grandma again~ --- 15 years ago -

it really is the mods call, as we know. i actually think if someone says something to get iced, they know it and should expect all of their recent comments to be deleted. Or don't post anything to get iced or edited. of course if that happened, we would not even need mods. it is a never ending circle. we have been through this numerous times. ku has been a good site and i think the mods are doing a good job. 

Butterfly Kisses --- 15 years ago -

I personally think the mods do a great job. 

~grandma again~ --- 15 years ago -

thank you, wonderwoman. that is appreciated more than you know. :) 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

wonderwoman --- 1 min ago - quote - hide comments

I personally think the mods do a great job.




DITTO

I think the people that don't like the job the mods are doing are those who feel the site should be a free for all. This is a community bulletin forum and should reflect the likes and opinions of ALL of the community - not just those of the few. 

steinhoister --- 15 years ago -

I don't think there's much biased moderating happening here...there's just no consistency. 

BiggieSmalls --- 15 years ago -

TexasOma --- 2 min ago - quote - hide comments

wonderwoman --- 1 min ago - quote - hide comments

I personally think the mods do a great job.



DITTO

I think the people that don't like the job the mods are doing are those who feel the site should be a free for all. This is a community bulletin forum and should reflect the likes and opinions of ALL of the community - not just those of the few.


The mods aren't even close to doing a fair job. It would be nice if they would, but that's not going to happen just like them being transparent. 

~grandma again~ --- 15 years ago -

that sounds like it might be sort of a compliment, steiny. it is true about the consistency but that is actually impossible to do. it has never been consistent. mods not being on and reading 100% of the comments is probably the biggest reason for that. it is not the end of the world however. we can only do what we can do. 

Butterfly Kisses --- 15 years ago -

I think this is the best group of mods right now that I can remember in the last 1 1/2 years or so that I have been here. They pretty much stay out of it unless someone really steps over the line. I don't envy them their job. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

I delete the comments.

Thanks for the candor, Chunky. Even though I don't completely share your point of view, I see your point and appreciate that you took the time to discuss it.

I personally think the mods do a great job.

I would agree with that.


I think the people that don't like the job the mods are doing are those who feel the site should be a free for all. This is a community bulletin forum and should reflect the likes and opinions of ALL of the community - not just those of the few.


I'm not sure what you are alluding to Oma, but the point of this thread was not to say I did not like or support the mods. I also have no problem abiding by the terms of service and although from time to time I may take issue with a mod decision or have a question for them, that has nothing to do with appreciating that they have a job to do and it is not a job I would want. I think the board has been running smoothly lately and along with the majority of great posters on KU, I also credit the mods with that.

However, I don't think there is anything inappropriate with asking questions or taking issue with an action as long as it is done with respect. That is how we always operated in our home and I guess it carries over to how I tend to deal with my participation on here.

I really appreciate that the mods would take the time to discuss their reasoning and interpretation of the ice box rules. We also have a lot of KU newbies lately and I am sure some of them were wondering how some of this works as well. 

Butterfly Kisses --- 15 years ago -

I delete the comments.

Thanks for the candor, Chunky. Even though I don't completely share your point of view, I see your point and appreciate that you took the time to discuss it.

I personally think the mods do a great job.

I would agree with that.


I think the people that don't like the job the mods are doing are those who feel the site should be a free for all. This is a community bulletin forum and should reflect the likes and opinions of ALL of the community - not just those of the few.

I'm not sure what you are alluding to Oma, but the point of this thread was not to say I did not like or support the mods. I also have no problem abiding by the terms of service and although from time to time I may take issue with a mod decision or have a question for them, that has nothing to do with appreciating that they have a job to do and it is not a job I would want. I think the board has been running smoothly lately and along with the majority of great posters on KU, I also credit the mods with that.

However, I don't think there is anything inappropriate about asking questions or taking issue with an action as long as it is done with respect. That is how we always operated in our home and I guess it carries over to how I tend to deal with my participation on here.

I really appreciate that the mods would take the time to discuss their reasoning and interpretation of the ice box rules. We also have a lot of KU newbies lately and I am sure some of them were wondering how some of this works as well.



Very well said ghostpost. :) 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

There are two hard parts for me. First I don't read every thread so I miss a lot. Second I am on my phone a lot and cannot ice from there only from a desktop pc.

I can and do edit from my phone. 

steinhoister --- 15 years ago -

By most forum standards it's ok to moderate after the fact...in other words you can ice someone tomorrow for what they said yesterday. 

Laurabeth --- 15 years ago -

I "heart" you ghostpost! You're always right on the money and so tactful about it too! 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Consistency is the biggest issue on this site.

One person can say something and be edited, someone else says it and is iced immediately.

The other thing is, supposedly, so many threads are missed. I say to that, if you're taking on the responsibility of moderating a website, you should take the time and effort to read all the threads in an effort to be more consistent. I know Chunky tends to be on early in the morning whereas Rev is on late at night, between the two of them, they could cover a lot of ground. GA and AM and Steve could take the "day" shift and try to be more consistent.

jmo. 

~grandma again~ --- 15 years ago -

well, when adam sat the mod deal up, he said just be there as and when you can...no big deal. if someone wants a schedule maybe they need to talk him in to hiring mods full time and paying them. lol. this is not employment..it is pleasure. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

this is not employment..it is pleasure.


right, but if you're willing to do it, you should put forth the effort to actually do it consistently.

That may be too much to ask though... 

~grandma again~ --- 15 years ago -

i am not going to get in to a battle with you momof5. it is not worth it and life is too short to fret over it. g'nite. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

i am not going to get in to a battle with you momof5.


well that's good, since I wasn't looking for one...lol.

I'm sorry if my opinion of the moderating offended you. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

it is pleasure.


It must be! Seems like some people just can't let go of the position! 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

I appreciate the mods that took the time to address my question and the posters that weighed in as well. But, I'm not in the mood for any drama tonight, so although I don't usually do this..I'm putting this thread to bed. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

I am unlocking this thread to give our other mods a chance to add their input. I didn't start this thread for mod bashing or for those want to call out the perceived "other side" so I would appreciate it if people would start their own thread if that is what is on their agenda. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Pffffft. 

allday --- 15 years ago -

SETAREDEFNOC!!!!!

Laughing again. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

Thanks for responding to my question, Steve. I appreciate it. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

as a mod, i would now only delete the comment that was offensive or edit it. if many comments need to be edited then i would use the feature to delete recent comments.

This is pretty much where I stand on the issue as well. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

Thanks, Rev. I think when we can see the comments or at least the context of the offensive posts then the reason for icing should be pretty clear to the rest of the board and it cuts down on a lot of speculation.

One other thing that I noticed the other day...GA came onto a thread that was getting heated and personal. She made a blanket statement to all that the personal insults needed to stop and if the thread did not get back on track she was going to lock it.

I have seen other mods give a similar heads up and I really appreciate that type of moderating. If gives everyone a chance to take a deep breath and a fair warning has been issued to all involved.

I don't expect the mods to be everywhere and see everything...and I think I speak for most of KU on that. 

The Pretty Plumber --- 15 years ago -

some people still complain.

Can't make them all happy grandma - How ya doing? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground