Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Woodlands bartender arrested for serving too much

who's talking here?

hummer 1
SleightOfHand 4
Perfection 1
AngieKaye 3
TexasOma 2
doglady 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 2
Work in Progress 5
Good Ole USA 1
Dorothy Parker 3
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
IbarraFam222 1
LillyDivine 1
Loki 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

What do you guys think about this one? I'm surprised that bartenders are held criminally responsible for how much someone else drinks.

A bartender from The Woodlands who allegedly served liquor to a man so drunk he was stumbling around and yelling racial epithets was arrested, a sign of increasing focus by law enforcement on those who over-serve alcohol to patrons.

Montgomery County's undercover Bars and Cars Task Force formed earlier this year to curb a resurgence of intoxication manslaughter in the county, where the traffic fatality rate is twice that in Harris County.

Chelsea Willburn, the 24-year-old bartender, was arrested on a liquor violation charge about 2:30 a.m. Saturday at Baker Street Pub, 25 Waterway Avenue in The Woodlands. She was placed in jail and released on $750 bail, said Warren Diepraam, vehicular crimes section chief for the Montgomery County District Attorney's Office.

Willburn could not be reached for comment Wednesday.

A Baker Street Pub employee, Serena Dameshghi, said, "All I can say is we conduct thorough training for all of our bartenders and wait staff on compliance with TABC (Texas Alcohol Beverage Comission) regulations. As a policy, I can't comment any further." 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

link to story 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

While on the surface this appears good it is quite unfortunate that now an employee is held responsible for the actions of a customer.

What precautions will be given to an employee if a customer feels discriminated against or strikes out at an employee?

What is next, a grocer being arrested for selling food to a fatty?

A clerk arrested for selling cigarettes to a smoker? 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

I think it should stand.

My husband and another man stopped an intoxicated woman from leaving a local bar when she couldn't even walk in the parking lot. She fell twice, couldn't speak clearly and was about to get behind the wheel of a huge truck!!

I saw the bartenders continue serving her after she fell in the bar...twice!!!

I think if someone is too impaired to walk or speak, the bartenders sure as hell should refuse to serve them.

If we hadn't stopped that woman from getting into her truck, she could have killed someone. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

If we hadn't stopped that woman from getting into her truck, she could have killed someone.

Thank you for stopping her! 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

unprovable.

The customer could have been drinking extra out of a flask. She wasn't, but no way to prove she wasn't.

There are many other holes in this law.

Even a cut rate lawyer would win this. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

I have never seen someone so intoxicated in my life! It was embarrassing to see her behavior in the bar and they kept serving her!!

After my husband and the guy stopped her, I asked the bartender to please call a cab, that she was trying to drive away. He called the police instead and she got a public intoxication charge.

I felt bad for her, but damn!! She truly was a danger to herself and others. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

After my husband and the guy stopped her, I asked the bartender to please call a cab, that she was trying to drive away. He called the police instead and she got a public intoxication charge.

You did the right thing. You probably saved her life, as well as those of God knows how many others. I hope she thanked you, but she's probably mad at being arrested. 

doglady --- 13 years ago -

I was a flight attendant for 29 years, and "refused to serve" drunks! This is something I would not tolerate!!! I had a man removed from the flight once. After those doors close, you never know what someone is capable if doing!
Haven't been to a bar, as far as hanging out, in many years, but I would stop someone in an instant!
Drunks do not belong behind the wheel!!!
If you don't care about yourself that's one thing. Putting others lives at risk isn't gonna fly with me!
I DETEST DRUNKS!!!!! 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

a drunk doesn't know how drunk they are. Most alcoholics dont know their limits or Big guys think they can drink more and not get drunk as others.

I think its fair! Only the bartender or barbacks know how much a person has drank and they should be accountable. What if they served someone way too much and they died of alcohol poisoning? Its happened! 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

She was angry....but, there was no way we could watch her get behind the wheel and do nothing to stop her.

I blame the bartenders in her case for clearly serving someone who was beyond drunk....had she left and killed someone or herself, some of the blame is on them, imo. 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

and old friend of mine (rather ex friend) always drives drunk with her kids in tow! I used to get so pissed off but she would cover it up with a "big gulp" cup and say it was tea or something. She has issues severe.. tis why she's not my friend anymore! and yes I have reported her to family but no one will do anything! 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 13 years ago -

I have been to this bar many times and it is almost impossible for someone to tell if they are intoxicated or not. the place is loud and dark so unless it was a slow night i am not sure it was fair.. i do think people should be responsible and like i told a co worker yesterday who's to say that the ones that leave drunk dont have a friend buy the drinks for them so a bartender wouldnt see how intoxicated that person is.. i do think something needs to give but what about more police or someone at the door to report if someone is too drunk to drive. i am torn on this.. the accidents that caused this sting were by my house and i have been to these places around here and seen the people that leave the bars.. so i dunno what the answer should be :( 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 13 years ago -

I have been to this bar many times and it is almost impossible for someone to tell if they are intoxicated or not. the place is loud and dark so unless it was a slow night i am not sure it was fair.. i do think people should be responsible and like i told a co worker yesterday who's to say that the ones that leave drunk dont have a friend buy the drinks for them so a bartender wouldnt see how intoxicated that person is.. i do think something needs to give but what about more police or someone at the door to report if someone is too drunk to drive. i am torn on this.. the accidents that caused this sting were by my house and i have been to these places around here and seen the people that leave the bars.. so i dunno what the answer should be :( 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

Hey Angie, if you know when that mom is doing it, you can always call the police and report that license plate as "weaving all over the road."

Her poor kids! 

LillyDivine --- 13 years ago -

As a bartender you have to be careful. You have to be observant and pay attention.

Say some guy drinks 15 bottles of beer at wherever, home, car, another bar, doesn't matter. Then this guy comes into your bar and you serve him ONE drink, you are liable.

Also, it takes about an hour to see the results of each drink kick in. Its a tricky thing.

I used to cut people off right and left. Ive been called many things for it too.

Id also tell people they had two choices, i could call em a cab, or i could call the police. When your choices are cops or cab, most people choose cab. 

IbarraFam222 --- 13 years ago -

I ran across a lawsuit last year where the family of man sued Mambos Seafood for this reason. The guy died riding home on a mortocycle. The family sued the restaurant and they won. The waiter served the table of 4 several buckets of beers over a 2 hour period. His kids will receive money for years from Mambos.

My thoughts on this... You're responsible for your own self. No one should baby sit an adult. 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

No one should baby sit an adult.


Actually I feel you do :( Alcoholics are like babies sticking metal objects in the light sockets, if you dont plug it up they wont stop. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I saw the bartenders continue serving her after she fell in the bar...twice!!!
You're responsible for your own self. No one should baby sit an adult.


I'm torn. The logical side of me says if you are a bartender and see someone smashed, it's only moral to follow the laws in place that stop serving them.

The other side says it's no one elses responsibility to individually police others. But is it policing if you stop somone who isn't lucid from killing themselves or others? If you saw a wacko chasing down a kid and you could intervene, would you? Is that policing others or just being a good prudent citizen?

I think not policing others is allowing them freedom to mess themselves up if you want. But maybe the line is crossed when it starts to affect other innocent people. 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

I don't see the issue. In order to serve alcohol in Texas, you must take a TABC class and get certified. They are taught that it is against the law to serve booze to a person who appears to not have control of their mental or physical faculties, ie obviously drunk. 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

It's a stupid law for many reasons.

But then, there are a lot of stupid people requiring the need for stupid laws.

:/

Sure be great if stupid people didn't ruin it for the rest of us. Hard to have a truly free society when you need government to babysit pathetic so called adults. 

TexasOma --- 13 years ago -

As a bartender you have to be careful. You have to be observant and pay attention.

Say some guy drinks 15 bottles of beer at wherever, home, car, another bar, doesn't matter. Then this guy comes into your bar and you serve him ONE drink, you are liable.

Also, it takes about an hour to see the results of each drink kick in. Its a tricky thing.




At what point does this enforcement filter down to homeowners who serve or have alcoholic beverages at home gatherings? Does the homeowner monitor who drinks what & how much? Does the homeowner have an obligation to physically stop someone from leaving when they are 'sorta intoxicated'?

The scenario the LillieDevine laid out is one of the problems I see. A busy, busy bartender is preparing the drinks - there is usually a server who serves the drinks to the customer --- why isn't that person held liable for the drunk? What about the bar owner - shouldn't he/she be on the premises or hire police to monitor the consumption & check the breath alcohol before the customer leaves the premises. Really ---- where does the ball stop?

I agree, something needs to be done, but arresting a 21 year old for a drunk's actions? Does she know how many drinks he consumed before he came into the restaurant? Give stiffer sentences to the drunks --- maybe then they will 'get it'. If not, they'll be in jail long enough to think long and hard about drinking & driving. 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

TexasOma, I believe the law is only for those holding a TABC license. Even then, there are tons of civil cases out there finding homeowners liable when a drunk leaves their house. 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

"It's a stupid law for many reasons. "

Sadly, one doesn't get to pick and choose which laws they are going to follow and which ones they'll break with out getting into trouble. If you don't like the law, try to get it changed. 

Good Ole USA --- 13 years ago -

I don't think servers should be held responsible. A bouncer or security could observe action and take care of anyone inebbriated but servers can barely keep up with orders and may just be flinging stuff out unaware of who they are serving. 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

Sadly, one doesn't get to pick and choose which laws they are going to follow and which ones they'll break with out getting into trouble. If you don't like the law, try to get it changed.

Doesn't apply to me since I'm a techie and not a bartender.

While it's a stupid law it's one of countless such laws. Not worth the effort.

We have so many laws on the books at the federal and state level, that I bet that every single person is breaking one of them at least once a week. 

TexasOma --- 13 years ago -

SleightOfHand --- 45 min ago - quote - hide comments

TexasOma, I believe the law is only for those holding a TABC license. Even then, there are tons of civil cases out there finding homeowners liable when a drunk leaves their house.



SOH --- for nowthis applies to the TABC license holders, but I can foresee that the law gets expanded. Civil lawsuits against business owners who serve drunks could work just as well.

There are enough ambulance chasers out there who would gladly pursue the rich bar owner insurance policy. If that happened enough, the BAR OWNER/MANAGER would then start paying more attention to who drinks & how much and would make a concerted effort to stop the drunks or would go out of business.

Why should the lowly employee be penalized for something she may not know about (the number of drinks the drunk had prior to the one she prepared). IMO it should be the bar owner (or restaurant owner) who suffers the consequences, not the employee. This is getting to nanny state out of control.

I guess the bar owner is getting off the hook because he has the money to pay lobbyists to help pass legislation that protects him....the lowly employee doesn't - she/he just needs a job. 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

"We have so many laws on the books at the federal and state level, that I bet that every single person is breaking one of them at least once a week. "

There are over 10,000 codified federal laws that have attached penalties. 

hummer --- 13 years ago -

Unfortunately drinkers have to be baby sat.
Lots of drunks still out there killing people.
Don't drink and drive. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground