Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is Gulf seafood safe to consume yet?

who's talking here?

mamadog53 1
AuthorMan 1
ShookUpRamen 1
SleightOfHand 1
Perfection 4
jtcitrus 1
tinman 2
TexasOma 3
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
shiney side up 2
LuckyTexasGirl 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Researchers reviewing to see what impact gulf seafood is having on our bodies

The Macondo well blowout on the floor of the Gulf of Mexico lays bare just how little scientists know about that great expanse of saltwater and its creatures, but in fishing communities from Florida to Louisiana, some people have vital questions of their own.

Could hydrocarbons from the 2010 Deepwater Horizon explosion be building up in people through the seafood they commonly eat - brown shrimp, white shrimp, oysters, blue crab, redfish, speckled trout and mackerel - and what does it mean if they are?

"Right now, all we have is the FDA recommendation of two 3-ounce servings a week. But these are fishing communities," says Sharon Petronella Croisant, an epidemiologist at the University of Texas Medical Branch and director of the Community-Based Research Facility affiliated with the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences.

At a research consortium centered in Galveston, scientists, together with a colleague in Philadelphia, are recruiting 100 people each from three especially seafood-dependent Gulf Coast communities in Mississippi and Louisiana, and another 100 from Galveston. Those in the study will be asked to give blood and urine samples. Scientists also hope to add 10 pregnant women each year who will give breast milk and umbilical cord blood once they deliver.

The researchers are looking for the family of compounds called polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, which dissolve in fat and have the potential to be stored in human fat, sometimes with harmful consequences.


If anything good can be said to have come from the ruin of the well blowout, it's that to a degree unmatched in the past, serious money has flowed into answering questions about nature in the Gulf. Even now, universities continue sending scientists and graduate students out on research vessels.

In a close collaboration that's still rare but becoming more common, fisher folk in Galveston, Gulfport and Biloxi in Mississippi, Bayou La Batre in Alabama and the United Houma Nation in Louisiana have been pulling fin and shellfish from the Gulf and handing them to researchers from UTMB, Texas A&M University at Galveston, Louisiana State University and the University of Pennsylvania. The scientists are probing for petroleum fingerprints that tell the story of where the sea life has been.

"We're hoping to find nothing, but we've already found some things," said John Sullivan, director of public forums at the UTMB Center in Environmental Toxicology. Initial measurements show "modestly more" contamination in oysters and crabs from Alabama and Louisiana than in Texas, which is generally regarded as beyond the reach of the oil disaster.

They have not firmly fingerprinted this contamination as emanating from the Macondo well.

Now the research moves from fish and shellfish to humans.


Chemicals that store away in fat merit scrutiny in part because when women's bodies make breast milk, they make it from fat, and what's in their fat gets mobilized into milk.

Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons also have the ability to cross the placenta. But it's too early to say whether anything from the Deepwater Horizon is actually making its way into people's bodies, much less into their babies.

That's because until now, most research on this family of hydrocarbons has focused on those that are generated from burning petroleum. But the oil that gushed into the Gulf when the Deepwater Horizon collapsed mostly never burned.

This study breaks new ground, says UTMB's Petronella Croisant, because it looks at these "petrogenic" or unburned polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons.

"The question is, are they similarly toxic?" asks Cornelis Elferink, a researcher and professor in the UTMB Department of Toxicology and Pharmacology.

Some polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons are known to be carcinogenic.

"But it is very clear polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons have a host of health effects other than cancer," says Trevor Penning, professor of pharmacology, biochemistry and biophysics at the University of Pennsylvania. "We know they can be immuno-suppressive, which means they make someone more prone to infection over time.

"That's a very important component. We also know there can be endocrine-disrupting properties. We know they can cross the placenta, and there are reproductive hazards."

Cells to be tested

But as sobering as that sounds, the researchers say they may discover that the human body successfully defends itself against these crude oil hydrocarbons when they turn up in seafood.

Elferink points out that in order to be dangerous, the compounds first have to be available in a way the body recognizes, and they have to cause a response. If they don't cause a response and are excreted, you have a substance that is nontoxic.

The good news is scientists believe they have a good test for this. It's a cell test in the lab. If certain specially engineered cells light up brightly in response to the polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, Elferink says, the scientists know they probably are looking at a petroleum compound that could cause harm to people. And they can calculate how much seafood a person would have to consume to see that effect.

"We don't have to wait 20-25 years for the cancer to appear," said the University of Pennsylvania's Penning.

In fact, the communities in Mississippi and Louisiana are asking the scientists for a briefing on the seafood part of the study as soon as possible. And scientists say they've committed to sharing the findings with them first. 

ShookUpRamen --- 14 years ago -

What a joke - people more worried about a few aromatic hydrocarbons than they are about the effects of deep-frying the fish. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

What a joke - people more worried about a few aromatic hydrocarbons than they are about the effects of deep-frying the fish.


Ok, that's funny!!!

And sadly true 

tinman --- 14 years ago -

Not all seafood is deep fried.

Personally speaking...I am worried about the raw oysters I start to eat at this time every year. The reefs in the Bay are just now starting to produce again. They got walloped with Ike in '08 and just when they came back from that, the mega drought in 2011 killed them off with high amounts of salinity.


Without those Bay oysters, folks like me are driven to other sources such as further South along the coast and of course, Louisiana. The Texas Coastal oysters are probably safe to eat, but won't be plentiful because of last year's drought. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

I know this is going to sound gross but I stopped eating gulf seafood after Katrina, Rita and Ike. I just didn't trust all the garbage, decaying animals and humans and other things that the seafood were consuming down there.

Sad but true. 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -

Don't care --- I've been eating Gulf shrimp for a while since they gave the OK. And I'm headed down to San Leon, Hillman's Seafood, today to get some fresh shrimp off the boats. 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -

Perfection --- that stuff was in the water long before the hurricanes. The rivers flush crap down to the ocean/gulf waters all the time. No different now than before. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

Hillman's Seafood


Hillmans is the best and the only American shrimper left in the area that I know of. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

On another note east coast oysters are awesome. I am a shrimpers daughter, grew up eating all things gulf coast as it was cheaper than chicken. LOVE cold water east coast oysters. They are the best. 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -



Hillmans is the best and the only American shrimper left in the area that I know of.



I love my trips down there. My friend from Huntsville wants to see where it's located so we're on a road trips today......Y'all have fun now - Ya hear!!! :-) It's a beautiful day for a road trip. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Raw oysters?

YUCK!!! 

tinman --- 14 years ago -

We will be having our semi annual boys fishing trip this weekend in the Bay.

We hope to rip the lips off of a box full of trout, reds, and flounder.

Since it's out of the Bay, I don't worry about eating what we catch.

Speaking of San Leon, we will be spending the night Friday night in Bacliffe and our first stop is going to be Gilhooleys, in San Leon, for some smoked oysters.

Then it's off to Noah's Ark where we hope to make a Scary Sherry sighting.

If you have to ask about Scary Sherry, you really don't need to know. 

LuckyTexasGirl --- 14 years ago -

Raw oysters?

YUCK!!!




amature 

shiney side up --- 14 years ago -

that stuff was in the water long before the hurricanes. The rivers flush crap down to the ocean/gulf waters all the time. No different now than before.

several million gallons of corexit were sprayed all over the Gulf of Mexico 

jtcitrus --- 14 years ago -

gulf seafood after Katrina, Rita and Ike. I just didn't trust all the garbage, decaying animals and humans and other things that the seafood were consuming down there.

If it worried you after Katrina, it should have worried you before. It's amazing the amount of $h14 (literally and figuratively) that gets flushed down the Mississippi.

several million gallons of corexit were sprayed all over the Gulf of Mexico


Millions. That sounds like a big number or something. Of course it's a drop in the bucket.../scratch that, Swimming Pool.../scratch that, Ok, there really isn't a good example of how inconsequential a volume that is. It mixed with the oil causing it so precipitate down to the depths. showed up for a while in some fish (mostly larger predators) May have been associated with some birth defects in dolphins (was it the corexit, or the direct hit from oil)

not saying it isn't of some concern, but don't throw that number around like its significant.
In the finaly analysis, I'd be willing to bet that louisiana will have been harmed more by breathing the formaldehyde in FEMA trailers than all the corexit they may have consumed subsisting on relatively large quantities of gulf-seafood. 

mamadog53 --- 14 years ago -

tinman, you need to report back on those Gilhooly's oysters. We were thinking of stopping in last Friday night but ended up in Galveston at Shrimp & Stuff instead. 

shiney side up --- 14 years ago -

Millions. That sounds like a big number or something. Of course it's a drop in the bucket.../scratch that, Swimming Pool.../scratch that, Ok, there really isn't a good example of how inconsequential a volume that is. It mixed with the oil causing it so precipitate down to the depths. showed up for a while in some fish (mostly larger predators) May have been associated with some birth defects in dolphins (was it the corexit, or the direct hit from oil)

not saying it isn't of some concern, but don't throw that number around like its significant.
In the finaly analysis, I'd be willing to bet that louisiana will have been harmed more by breathing the formaldehyde in FEMA trailers than all the corexit they may have consumed subsisting on relatively large quantities of gulf-seafood.




whoever I quoted said it's no different from what gets washed into the gulf regularly.....there's a big difference

before you start betting on anything you might want to look into the studies that are being conducted right now 

AuthorMan --- 14 years ago -

I am hoping the Gulf seafood lubricates my knees! :-) 

SleightOfHand --- 14 years ago -

I love me some seafood!! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground