Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Wants vs Needs again

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
Rebecca 1
wayward1 4
KWPlanner 11
ladybeachbum 2
SoupIsGoodFood 4
Polly Ester 8
Perfection 16
Hiro Protagonist 8
voice of reason 4
jtcitrus 2
JohnLynch 1
TexasOma 14
RedMulch 1
Tipsyhic 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
Work in Progress 5
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
BCSKW 1
Dorothy Parker 15
itstxdaddy 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
justforfun1 10
txsassy 5
SmoochieAndTheBean 2
Lets Be Fair 15
tredanis 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

What are you willing to give up on a want to fullfill a need?

Should you have to give up wants to take care of your needs or should government supply all the needs allowing you to focus solely on wants?

What are the needs and wants that should be individual responsibilities and what are the ones that should be supplied? 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

In my opinions needs need to be taken care of before anything else. While wants make us comfortable and make us feel normal, it is my responsibility to supply my needs first before buying anything else.

I was reading an article today about a protest over in Austin on the Medicaid expansion for adults and in the picture I saw people with cell phones and nails done.

To me, my first thought it instead of those items, they could be saving that money to apply to insurance premiums.

Sure, insurance isn't cheap - but that doesn't mean you can't pay for it by eliminating want spending. 

ladybeachbum --- 14 years ago -

The government gives me roads, I need those! Otherwise, a sense of safety maybe.
I'm with you. Pay your bills before the nails, cell phone and designer purses and clothes. I give the government so they can have their nails done! I really need to get mine done. What number do they call? 

KWPlanner --- 14 years ago -

I do a lot of pro-bono work for people who admit they are in financial trouble and need help getting a game plan together to get them out of the hole they're in but can't afford the fees I typically charge for my work.

In the 20+ years I've been doing financial planning I've developed a keen eye on peoples habits, hobbies, etc. I would say that in easily 90% of the people I help (mentioned above), I am able to identify at least two or three areas of 'want' spending before they even finish telling me about their situation. Ladybb touched on a couple already (nicely manicured nails, sending me emails from their iPhones, etc). One couple even had pictures of their annual ski trips to Vail and yet were arguing about who should get a second job so that the electricity wouldn't be cut again. What?!

I tell everyone that personal finance is 20% knowledge and 80% behavior, and until they change their behavior they shouldn't expect to see anything change. Your life is a reflection of the decisions you have made. If you don't like your life, then make better decisions. In the end, taking credit for your successes will feel so much better than blaming others for your failures. 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

Well said, KWPlanner. I see people who are dressed up in designer clothes using food stamps. I always wonder why I am paying for their groceries! 

KWPlanner --- 14 years ago -

Well said, KWPlanner.

Thanks. I must admit, though, that I'm not always the most popular guy when our meeting's over...and I even tell them that when we first sit down! lol 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

I tell everyone that personal finance is 20% knowledge and 80% behavior, and until they change their behavior they shouldn't expect to see anything change. Your life is a reflection of the decisions you have made. If you don't like your life, then make better decisions. In the end, taking credit for your successes will feel so much better than blaming others for your failures.


Wow, I want to steal this!!!!

LOVE IT 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

Well, sometimes the truth hurts, but in the long run, I bet they are very appreciative when they get out of debt. 

KWPlanner --- 14 years ago -

Wow, I want to steal this!!!!

LOVE IT


Even though it came from a Purdue grad?? :)

I can't take all the credit. The last few sentences I paraphrased from a great book I read a few years back called "You're Broke Because You Want To Be", by Larry Winget. Highly recommended. 

SmoochieAndTheBean --- 14 years ago -

Well you know we are supplying the cell phones now to them as a need. I guess the manicures will be next. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

We have very few needs compared to our wants.


We need food, water and a roof over our head, everything else is a bonus. 

wayward1 --- 14 years ago -

Even though it came from a Purdue grad?? :)

As a Hoosier, that is hilarious. 

KWPlanner --- 14 years ago -

It's important to note that there is absolutely nothing wrong with going out and buying a 'want' or paying a monthly fee for a 'want'. The problem rears it's ugly head when the wants take precedence over needs.

Food, shelter, clothing, and reasonable transportation should be taken care of first. What you do with any excess $$ after that defines your value system. 

KWPlanner --- 14 years ago -

As a Hoosier, that is hilarious.

:) Inside joke Perfection & I have since she's an IU grad. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

It's important to note that there is absolutely nothing wrong with going out and buying a 'want' or paying a monthly fee for a 'want'. The problem rears it's ugly head when the wants take precedence over needs.

Food, shelter, clothing, and reasonable transportation should be taken care of first. What you do with any excess $$ after that defines your value system.




I totally understand that. Our basic needs should come first and then we decide if we can afford a want. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

While getting nails done is a luxury, many people can and do their own nails...it's not a difficult task.

Designer clothes are also easily attainable with thrift stores and consignment shops, ebay, estate sales etc etc etc. I have a vintage Dooney bag that I found at Goodwill for $11. Should I not carry it around because I didn't buy it brand new at full price?

The assumptions made about people are out of control. Unless you know them and their direct circumstances, you can't judge their wants and needs.

As far as cell phones, there are so many deals and plans out there and old phones sold cheap, there's no way of knowing how they came by that phone unless you ask them. If you're saying poor people shouldn't have phones at all, I guess you have a right to your opinion. 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -

Spoken as a true liberal/democrat!!!!

And, as usual, didn't understand or get the message! 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Even though it came from a Purdue grad?? :)

Sometimes even PU gets it right LOL.

I can't wait for BB season, now that's a NEED right there!!!! 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

While getting nails done is a luxury, many people can and do their own nails...it's not a difficult task.

Designer clothes are also easily attainable with thrift stores and consignment shops, ebay, estate sales etc etc etc. I have a vintage Dooney bag that I found at Goodwill for $11. Should I not carry it around because I didn't buy it brand new at full price?

The assumptions made about people are out of control. Unless you know them and their direct circumstances, you can't judge their wants and needs.

As far as cell phones, there are so many deals and plans out there and old phones sold cheap, there's no way of knowing how they came by that phone unless you ask them. If you're saying poor people shouldn't have phones at all, I guess you have a right to your opinion.



Correct - that is exactly what we are saying. Give up on those things until the NEEDS are met, then start adding them.

But don't say you don't have what is needed if you have those items, no matter how cheaply you can purchase them. Use that money for the NEEDS first. 

wayward1 --- 14 years ago -

I can't wait for BB season, now that's a NEED right there!!!! 

True that! KU just fills that void until the mid Nov. tip off. 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -

And if you currently have any of the 'want' items with an electric/gas/water/mortgage/food bill due --- SELL THE PRECIOUS ITEM AND USE THAT MONEY WISELY!!!!!

Even if you purchased the item during good times, it has value that can be used to put food on the table. If you paid $11.00 for it & have to sell it for $10.00 --- that's $10.00 worth of food for your family - or use that money to go towards taking care of the needs.

THAT IS THE MESSAGE!!! 

jtcitrus --- 14 years ago -

Should you have to give up wants to take care of your needs or should government supply all the needs allowing you to focus solely on wants?

Honestly, our needs in the U.S. are so thoroughly taken care of that I think most people have no idea where the line between want and need really is.

Just talk to anyone who has ever done Doctors w/out Borders or a similar program.


...sort of like my rant on "anything in moderation" when discussing dieting. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 14 years ago -

i have lived before as the brokest you can imagine ( which i have mentioned before) and gave up everything i wanted and lived off needed.. now i still dont make excellent money and i have come a very long way i still live a basic lifestyle with a few perks here and there when i can afford them but bottom line is i still help my son and bf's kids as does he so until our kids are out of college and on their own we will live like this. i get my nails done if it fits in the budget.. if not i do it myself.. haircuts are a min for me and bf does his himself. we have cells but no home phone and that and cable is our extra we afford ourselves. both cars paid off- no trips ( the last one we were on he was working and i came along for the ride) we go to galveston for fun and all it costs is gas.

we count pennies and we stay home 98% of the time on weekends. free movies on Yahoo is our new thing and now i am downsizing our house so we can move next yr to a better and cheper place


It can be done.. do i miss things? sure when my co workers talk about their shopping trips or go on vacation it makes me sad but we are also financially better off then them too. they are always talking about moving money around or how in debt they are in, we are cash only except one cc with a $ 200 limit for emergencies. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

Let's see now, I have a cell phone which is a want, not a need. I also have XM radio, there again a want. I have a phone in my SUV which is a lot of comfort because if I need it, it's there. I have On Star in an emergency but could do without it. We have internet, again a want. We have cable, again a want. All of these things could be given up when times are bad. It would be different without them but I could adjust. Our bills come first and our wants are what we decide to keep. 

jtcitrus --- 14 years ago -

I tell everyone that personal finance is 20% knowledge and 80% behavior

AMEN. People think I'm crazy when I tell them that I wont pay for cable tv or a smartphone or a mobile data plan.

It can be so easy to forget that though especially since 90%+ of the personal finance tv/print/radio is about what should be no more than 15% of your assets.

Our vice is eating out. we loose weight every month we stick to our budget. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

I guess you all missed my point. You don't have to make 6 figures to dress nice or have nice hair and nails. You can buy nice clothes that are used, cheaper than buying new at Walmart....and you're getting better quality, longer lasting items.

You're assuming because you saw people in a photo with nail polish and cell phones, that they're putting wants above needs...when you have no way of knowing how much they spent or what their actual bills are each month. 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -

And you are missing the point ---


If you have all these things, they have monetary value and can be sold to pay for the necessities. Even a bottle of fingernail polish has value --- sell it to by some fruit for your family.

One does not have to be 'styling' ---- one does have to pay their bills, buy food & pay the rent/mortgage. Clean clothes & clean body is all one needs to look nice. Anymore than that is just 'dressing up'.

Sorry you don't understand that. 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

Dorothy, do you really believe what you are saying? 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

Should you have to give up wants to take care of your needs or should government supply all the needs allowing you to focus solely on wants?



what a stupid trolling question. 

KWPlanner --- 14 years ago -

You're assuming because you saw people in a photo with nail polish and cell phones, that they're putting wants above needs...when you have no way of knowing how much they spent or what their actual bills are each month.

I am basing those observations on the fact that when we get down to the nitty gritty, there's a negative number in the monthly cash flow calculations.

Again, I have no issues with people buying/wearing/consuming nice things....as long as their necessities are not being compromised.

Heck, even if there was a $10k positive net cash flow at the end of the month, I would still recommend buying clothes at resale shops, buying used cars over new cars, etc. Just because you may have the $$ doesn't mean you should pay full price for the 'wants'. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Fingernail polish is a dollar at Walmart. Are you saying someone shouldn't be able to buy a dollar bottle of nail polish if they're struggling to make ends meet? How about Shampoo? Should they forego that "luxury" as well?

We're back to the fun KU adage: "poor people should look poor and destitute"....they don't deserve to look nice because then they appear to have money...and that pisses people off!!!

Whatever....enjoy your hate and resentment...it suits you. 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

If you have all these things, they have monetary value and can be sold to pay for the necessities. Even a bottle of fingernail polish has value --- sell it to by some fruit for your family.


jesus christ get a grip oma!
$4 for a good bottle that will last a year. 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

You don't have to make 6 figures to dress nice or have nice hair and nails. You can buy nice clothes that are used, cheaper than buying new at Walmart....and you're getting better quality, longer lasting items.



my friend does this. all her clothes and shoes from thrift shops. she cuts her own hair. polishes her own nails. she looks great and spends very little. her cell phone is on a program with other relatives so cost is low.

it is not only possible. it is reality.







Whatever....enjoy your hate and resentment...it suits you.


n.s.s. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Yes...I believe what I'm saying. I live for thrift stores and consignment shops. I can stretch a dollar further than anyone I know and I don't resent people who are struggling financially because they have nail polish on! How petty!

Even during the great depression, people went to the movies....do you begrudge them that escape? Women in those days always had nice hair and nails....do you think they were terrible for that?

Ugh...stupid thread same old argument. 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

Dorothy,
We don't hate poot people because we disagree with you. Every time someone disagrees with you, you call them a hater. The truth is you want to keep these people poor. Let the government give them things so they need the government and will always vote for the person who vows to continue the gravy train. That is called slavery!

The more reasonable solution is to give the poor job skills and training so they don't have to live off the government and can take pride in earning a living for their family. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

I've always advocated for work and education programs for welfare recipients...this thread wasn't about that....it's about poor people having nail polish and cell phones. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

The more reasonable solution is to give the poor job skills and training so they don't have to live off the government and can take pride in earning a living for their family.



The government should be working to make people independent, not dependent. What we see is government wanting to keep people down and poor and blame others for their failure. You can bet when times get tough and that is coming very soon that we have so many things we can give up and a bottle of nail polish or a cell phone will not be what I am wanting. Food and shelter will be my needs and everything else will be a bonus. 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

Wow, Dorothy, it is about cell phones and nail polish. It is about people buying things that they cannot aford. Can you not see it?

Question:
If you only had $11 to feed your family. Would you,
A. Go buy a designer purse at Goodwill
B. Buy food
C. Expect the government to feed my family so I can buy nail polish 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

I don't resent people who are struggling financially because they have nail polish on! How petty!

nope...it isn't...nail polish is still a WANT

all those little wants add up 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

Come on Dorothy, I know it is a tough decision. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground