Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Bill Restricting Westboro Military Funeral Protests

who's talking here?

JDB2 11
Rubicon 1
hummer 3
Perfection 8
zapper007 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
TexasOma 3
Quixote 2
Dr Aborto 1
austin 5
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
ganderif 5
thankfulformyfour 3
SagaciousSighFiGurl 3
ddmoon 1
txsassy 1
Pat Barry 1
FluffyPenguin 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -

Obama did something today that I think we can all agree on!!!!


Huffington Post


Honoring America's Veterans Act Signed By Obama, Restricting Westboro Military Funeral Protests

The Huffington Post | By Nick Wing

President Barack Obama signed the Honoring America’s Veterans and Caring for Camp Lejeune Families Act of 2012 into law on Monday, providing a wide-ranging package of benefits to military personnel and enacting new restrictions on protests of service member funerals.

"We have a moral sacred duty to our men and women in uniform," Obama said before signing the bill, according to a pool report. "The graves of our veterans are hallowed grounds."

The new law will have strong implications for the Westboro Baptist Church, a Kansas-based organization which the Southern Poverty Law Center and the Anti-Defamation League have labeled a hate group. Westboro Baptist Church has drawn media attention for its brand of protest, which frequently links the deaths of soldiers to America's growing acceptance of gays.

Under the new legislation, protests must be held at least 300 feet from military funerals and are prohibited two hours before or after a service. The law counters a 2011 Supreme Court ruling, which found that displays such as Westboro's were protected under the First Amendment.

Members of the church responded defiantly to a Huffington Post report following Congress' passage of the bill, claiming that the law's restrictions could also have an effect on counter-demonstrations organized in response to Westboro's attempts to disrupt military services.

Two of these counter-efforts drew national attention last month, when large groups of people turned out in both Missouri and in Texas in an attempt to create "human walls" to shield attendees of military funerals from Westboro's demonstrations.

(Photos of the Texas event below)

In an interview over the weekend, Westboro spokesman Steven Drain told CNN that the new law was "not going to change our plans at all."

According to the Army Times, future violations of The Honoring America’s Veterans Act would include the possibility of $50,000 in statutory damages.

For more on The Honoring America’s Veterans and Caring for Camp Lejeune Families Act of 2012, click here.
 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Oh, yay!

Somehow we got to get those 8 Westboro Baptist into the brig!! They made enough trouble to be 800 people! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

well done!! 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -

It said on the news just now that the Westboro Baptist clan say they will follow the law but will continue their protests. At least this will limit their protests somewhat. 

ganderif --- 14 years ago -

Another blow against the first amendment. Why don't we just appeal the constitution and give the President the power to choose what, where, and when we can protest?

Oh wait, we already did... 

Rubicon --- 14 years ago -

It's a shame that a law needs to be passed for people to be respectful. 

austin --- 14 years ago -

Unconstitutional. Shouldn't hold up in court, but we know how that goes recently.

I hate the WBC, but they have the same rights as all of us. If Obama can take their protests away, you know he's already thinking how else he could use this power. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

it is unconstitutional. What we really need is to have the cops turn the other way. We used to have blanket parties in the Army if we needed to have someone get back in line...a good ol' butt whoopin is what those knuckleheaded westboro idiots need. 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -

Actually, Obama did not take away their rights to protest, he set a limit on just where they could do their protesting......300 feet from the church. That's not too bad.

And the WBC leaders even agreed to it. They said they would abide by the law, but would still be there to protest.

No rights were trounced.

I find it funny that I, the staunch Republican, would defend anything Obama said. 

austin --- 14 years ago -

I understand the limits, but I don't believe there should be free speech zones.

You can't say we have a right to speech and then say where we can exercise it.

If its public property it's fair game, if it's private property, It could be trespassing. 

hummer --- 14 years ago -

Because of idiots like Westboro there has to be limits. The families of these young soldiers deserve privacy and free from harassment. 

ganderif --- 14 years ago -

No, there doesn't have to be limits. The constitution doesn't say you have a right sometimes. If you want to avoid free speech or protest feel free to buy some private property and build yourself some sound proof walls.

Look up free speech zones in wikepedia to see what the future hold. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

The problem is that the rest of us don't have the right to kick their butts. There are and should be consequences or rewards for how you choose to exercise your free speech...let the public handle it. 

hummer --- 14 years ago -

Would you want Westboro or other hate groups to come to your funeral and harass and bully your family? 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

here is a better way of saying what I believe. There are in fact limits to your freedom of speech. When there is a conflict or when your freedom restricts my rights, something has to give and concessions have to be made. At a military funeral, we are recognizing and showing respect for our military as we send them off on one last journey. For the family and others, this is the last chance to say goodbye. Westboro idiots may be free to say what they want and act like fools all they want, but they do not have a right to inflict this pain on the family and they do not have a right to prevent me from respecting our military.

So, to sum it up in technical terms, stay away or risk a butt whoopin...lol 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

and it is a problem when we carry some of these issues too far. There is so much ignorance in the US these days because law supercedes logic. Like cutting off our noses... 

austin --- 14 years ago -

Take your emotions out of it. There are good intentions behind the law, but it's unconstitutional. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

They are going against the Supreme Court and the Constitution. The President and Congress do not have this right/power.

I don't agree with what they are doing, but they have the right as guaranteed in our Constitution.

If we allow them to take away this right, we cannot limit how much they take in the future. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

I agree that it is unconstitutional...I also think that it is ridiculous to think that we shoud just allow anyone to do anything they choose to do. If you and your family choose to see a movie and those idiots surround you and ruin your chance to enjoy yourselves, by removing emotions, we have to agree that you just have to live with the ruined event, right? I think the folks defending the rights for the westboro idiots may have just as much emotion in this. Where is the line for you Austin? At what point will you agree that something needs to be done? What if your child was being buried and these knuckleheads did this? Is it ok then? 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

I don't agree with what they are doing, but they have the right as guaranteed in our Constitution.

the problem is the conflict with the rights of the family...and the concern that we have the opposite result of your deduction. If we allow this, can't I pretty much do anything that I choose to do? 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

jdb, every situation is like that. A conflict of rights.

We cannot and should not censor rights, but we can and should hold people accountable and responsible for the consequences of their actions.

If people choose to exercise their freedom of speech that is great, the manner in which others have exercised their freedom to block them, also great.

Censorship by taking away a right is never a good thing.

I am repulsed that we have done this. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

If we allow this, can't I pretty much do anything that I choose to do?


You have had that right all along. What is different is that you think about the consequences of your actions. Some dont - and they need to be held accountable.

To take away a freedom - that is wrong. The only time people should lose freedom is if they violate a law, not just if they voice their opinion. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

Censorship by taking away a right is never a good thing.

in premise I agree. However, if my right to respect a person at a funeral is violated and my right to hold the violators accountable is not afforded to me, then what? (I'm used to free markets where things are brought back to equilibrium Perfection...lol) 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

that is the problem. there are no consequences for these knuckleheads....but then again, that is what I said in my first thread...lol.

Have a great day! I'm late for work! 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

To take away a freedom - that is wrong. The only time people should lose freedom is if they violate a law, not just if they voice their opinion.

ok, contradictory statement! If we create a law, then we can take their rights...but none of us want more laws...please clarify! 

thankfulformyfour --- 14 years ago -

Unconstitutional or not...the Westboro people are infringing on any kind of common decency out there. Whatever happened to allowing someone to lay their loved ones to rest without a bunch of people raising a stink? Whatever happened to respect for the dead?

I wonder how the families of the Westboro people will feel should one of them die and people from all over stand outside of their church and sing "ding dong the witch is dead?" I can assure you, they won't be happy. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

It reminds me of being in school when ONE kid would do something wrong and the whole class was punished.

I hate that crap. If the 8 people of Westboro would just act HUMAN, then we wouldn't all be punished. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

There are societal consequences. They are ostracized as they are now, others encircle the funeral and ensure the family privacy. We take care of our own.


To take away a freedom - that is wrong. The only time people should lose freedom is if they violate a law, not just if they voice their opinion.

ok, contradictory statement! If we create a law, then we can take their rights...but none of us want more laws...please clarify!



Not really contradictory. If you create a law to remove a freedom from one group then we have done a bad law.

You cannot limit rights/freedoms by segregating people by opinions. We simply cannot do that.

Laws such as murder, rape, burglary are not rights/freedoms so that allows us to take away an individual's freedoms. But to create a law to limit a freedom. That is inherently wrong. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

BTW, have a great day at work today. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

We cannot legislate and define decency. We are a Country of different genders, religious, values, norms, cultures, etc - defining decency would entail choosing one of those over the other.

While on the surface I really do get it, it's an emotional issue - logically however it is flawed. 

thankfulformyfour --- 14 years ago -

But to create a law to limit a freedom.

IMO is gives freedom to the families of the deceased to know they will have a peaceful funeral for their family member. 

hummer --- 14 years ago -

I don't get where freedom of speech is of issue here. They can still go to a corner but not within so many feet of funeral and show their signs of hate. And have their speeches of hate.
If they violate the distance then police now have the right to move them. Before police couldn't do anything.
I say privacy and respect for funeral family trumps the right of anyone being disrespectful and hateful.
The families should have freedom from bullies and hate. 

thankfulformyfour --- 14 years ago -

I say privacy and respect for funeral family trumps the right of anyone being disrespectful and hateful.
The families should have freedom from bullies and hat


AMEN to that!

I am not an Obama fan by any means...but I have to give him props for this one! 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

I find it funny that I, the staunch Republican, would defend anything Obama said. 

It's because you like what he said obviously. If you didn't agree you still wouldn't be defending him.

He is wrong on this, the supreme court has already ruled on this.

The families of those being protested need to take Westboro to court and sue them for emotional duress. The courts need to award big bucks over it and then it will stop. Obama could have signed something to stream line that process without trying to overrule the supreme court and the constitution. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

If Obama can take their protests away, you know he's already thinking how else he could use this power.


But they still have the right to their protests, just further away and at a different time. I'm fine with this even tho I know it's a hinderance of free speech in a way.

The way I see it, actions have consequences. If you abuse something, then you yourself have elected to have your free speech in the form of a mutation, lol.

People who use common sense, exercise free speech with a regard for respect of others and the laws, get the full version.

That being said, the process should continue and that would be a law suit by WB, so have at it. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Ok, after thinking about this, maybe the families affected by this could get a restraining order against WB considering they could be stalking??

Maybe they have already tried this, IDK. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

If Obama (or any government official) decides what is decent then what is to stop them from saying conservative radio is not decent and limit the times it can be on or access to the stations?

What is to say they couldn't say liberal radio is not decent and limit the times it can be on or access to the station?

You cannot allow a government to define decent speech and limit that freedom. 

ddmoon --- 14 years ago -

I don't agree with the protestors, but I absolutely disagree with King Obama overriding a court ruling. Is this a democracy or a dictatorship? 

austin --- 14 years ago -

Other than the unconstitutional part, I have a big issue with the 2 hrs before or after the event. That is 4 hours not including the actual event length.

This basically comes close to just flat out banning the free speech. If someone you didn't agree with was giving an hour long speech at noon, and you wanted to organize a protest you would have to stop protesting at 10am and couldn't start back up until 3pm. Why even bother to protest? Who is going to be around to hear it?

Again, I hate WBC, but this could set the standard and your particular cause or beliefs could be next. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Again, I hate WBC, but this could set the standard and your particular cause or beliefs could be next.


Bingo! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground