Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

kings manor elementary denies child use of her walker

who's talking here?

Jen 1
ghostpost 6
Perfection 1
voice of reason 4
TexasOma 2
kidsfan3 4
LiveFreeOrDie 1
Good Ole USA 1
Winning 2
Blinker 1
Jennygirl 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

and she has cerebral palsy!!!!! what bs.

http://www.lovethatmax.com/2012/03/school-bans-kid-with-cerebral-palsy.html

A mom of a kid with cerebral palsy is gearing up to file a lawsuit against her school district, because a special education director is saying her little girl can't use her walker. Pick your jaw up off the floor and read on.

LaKay Roberts, who's 5, uses her walker to, er, walk. You know, as kids with CP often do. She's been using it for three years, and attends Kings Manor Elementary School in Kingwood, near Houston. Occasionally, she also uses a wheelchair.

Her mom, Kristi Roberts, says that weeks ago the school district, New Caney ISD, told her that LaKay could no longer use her walker at school. Kristi taped a meeting with the district special education director, Gary Lemley; she uploaded part of it to YouTube. An excerpt:

Kristi: "Why can't she use a walker?"
Lemley: "We don't feel like it's safe any longer." [LaKay had fallen in the parking lot when her walker collapsed, while she was with her mom.]
Kristi: "How many kids fall down at recess? Do you make them take their shoes off and buy new ones?"
Lemley: "No, ma'am."
Kristi: "OK!"
Lemley: "They're not using walkers."

Up until this part of the video, I was thinking the special ed director was being a blockheaded bureaucrat, perhaps concerned that the district could get sued if LaKay hurt herself on the premises. Obviously, if LaKay's walker is collapsing it needs to be fixed, although barring it seems excessive (and hel-lo, discrimination). Here—listen for yourself (and check out how adorable LaKay is):

go to above link for all vids.

The part of the YouTube video that convinced me something was seriously wrong with this guy was when he said to Kristi, "You're not concerned about LaKay."

What?!

Passing judgment on the mother's concern for her child isn't just crossing a line, it's bulldozing a line.

If you have a kid who has cerebral palsy or any gross motor challenges, you know just what sort of efforts and prayers go into your child's ability to take steps, let alone walk. I will never forget the sight of Max in our living room taking his first steps in his walker, the same kind LaKay uses (a Kaye Posterior Walker). They're the steps I never thought I'd see after doctors had pretty much knocked the hope out of me.

The walker enabled Max to learn to walk independently, just as it is enabling LaKay to move on her own and strengthen her muscles. That child has every right to use a walker in school to get around, same as any kid has a right to put one foot in front of the other and go.

Kristi Roberts doesn't have the money to sue but I can almost guarantee that as the story gets attention, some lawyer (if not many) will offer to take the case.

Here's where you can send the superintendent of the school district an email, urging him to reconsider.

I wish this mama strength and power to fight for her child.

It is a shame this is a battle that has to be fought.

Update: Caught up in this story, I neglected to mention that today is Cerebral Palsy Awareness Day—and obviously, there is much awareness still to be raised. If you're new here, check out my CP Awareness Day post on why my son is not a tragedy. Meanwhile, after reading this Kristina Chew at Care2 set up a petition asking the district to let LaKay use her walker. You can sign it here. 

Jennygirl --- 14 years ago -

I am sorry to hear that, however the school acted the way it should. This is a damned if you do, damned if you don’t situation. The staff witnessed the girl falling in the parking lot. Had she done it under the supervision of the school and hurt herself, they would be held liable. With the countless frivolous law suits out there, the school is doing what they feel is a necessary precaution.
It sucks for the little girl; however comparing her to a normal child that falls down is not the same. If you want the little girl to receive special needs treatment, then you need to place her in an appropriate school. 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

bs!
what a crock.
let the poor child use her walker! 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

LaKay had fallen in the parking lot when her walker collapsed, while she was with her mom.]


Up until this part of the video, I was thinking the special ed director was being a blockheaded bureaucrat, perhaps concerned that the district could get sued if LaKay hurt herself on the premises. Obviously, if LaKay's walker is collapsing it needs to be fixed, although barring it seems excessive (and hel-lo, discrimination).


lololol
serves them right that now they WILL get sued and the girl WILL win this suit. what a bunch of idiots.


If you have a kid who has cerebral palsy or any gross motor challenges, you know just what sort of efforts and prayers go into your child's ability to take steps, let alone walk.



THAT POOR CHILD!!! 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

NCISD rots! 

Jennygirl --- 14 years ago -

Like I said damned if you do, damned if you don't situation. 

ghostpost --- 14 years ago -

the other thread on this topic :) 

ghostpost --- 14 years ago -

I am sorry to hear that, however the school acted the way it should. This is a damned if you do, damned if you don’t situation. The staff witnessed the girl falling in the parking lot. Had she done it under the supervision of the school and hurt herself, they would be held liable. With the countless frivolous law suits out there, the school is doing what they feel is a necessary precaution.

I don't think the fall she had with her mother has any relevance. Kids fall. My kids fell. I know many children that have had falls when first learning to use adaptive equipment. As a Polio survivor I walk today because I was allowed to fall and not told I had to use a wheelchair.

The school would not be any more negligent when a child with a disability fell than they would with any other child..if she was appropriately supervised and a normal expectation of care was taken then there would not be negligence.

The determination regarding appropriate equipment and her adaptive needs to be made by the team of professionals including her therapists and physicians in an ARD meeting. Her parents have the opportunity to agree or go to due process if an agreement can not be met.

However, I have seen children with limitations that are more involved than hers appear to be successfully learn to use a walker.

None of this excuses the lack of professionalism that I heard on the recording. Even when dealing with an emotional parent, professionals, especially directors of programs, are trained to deal with that level of emotionalism without losing their cool. Hearing that was sad. 

ghostpost --- 14 years ago -

If you want the little girl to receive special needs treatment, then you need to place her in an appropriate school.

You have got to be kidding me. Have you heard that our schools are the appropriate place to educate the majority of our children with special needs? Have you heard that a free and appropriate education is a legal right for every child? Her school has special education programming for children with special needs just like other schools do.

On the other thread her mother mentions that she is enrolled in a Preschool program for children with disabilities. Every school my children attended has special needs children in programs on their campuses and they learned to co-exist with these wonderful children who will one day be their neighbors, co-workers and friendly employees in their community. Sometimes they were in their class for an inclusion activity and sometimes they were in a specialized setting, but they were always a highly visible art of their schools and my children gain valuable experiences from being in school with these inspiring children. 

Jen --- 14 years ago -

I worked in NCISD Special Ed for a couple of years as a sub at various elementaries. They were all wonderful. I feel bad for the family however I do feel...there is more to this story than we know. NCISD has its side of their story too and I will wait to hear it, before I form my overall opinion. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

How do they get away with this crap!?!?
What happened to the Americans with disabilities Act???? 

ghostpost --- 14 years ago -

nevermind..my screwup. 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -

Ghostpost --- There is a Jen and and Jennygirl......I think Jennygirl made the comments you are referring to. 

ghostpost --- 14 years ago -

Ghostpost --- There is a Jen and and Jennygirl......I think Jennygirl made the comments you are referring to.

Thanks, Oma. My old eyes didn't distinguish between the two similar IDs.

I apologize Jen, I mixed up your post with Jennygirl's. 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -

Wanna borrow my glasses? :-) They don't seem to do much good for me --- going for a check up on Friday. Need to get new fingers also - these keep having to retype what I start writing. 

Good Ole USA --- 14 years ago -

I can't imagine what NCISD's version could be. Possibly, the child was hurt before and a lawsuit was rbreatened, there are many documented falls we are not aware of, etc. I have worked in Special Ed at many schools, but the great work those teachers do has nothing to do with the unprofessionalism of one person. I believe he has resigned, and I can't comprehend why NC would violate Federal Law because of one fall. 

Blinker --- 14 years ago -

Kings Manor Elementary School in Kingwood, near Houston.

Sorry to say this is not in Kingwood. I feel sorry for the Mom and child though. 

kidsfan3 --- 14 years ago -

This story is airing on the Today show right now. 

kidsfan3 --- 14 years ago -

I'm not sure how to post a link on here but this is from the Today show this morning.

http://video.today.msnbc.msn.com/today/46890363#46890363 

ghostpost --- 14 years ago -

I wonder what the hold up is with getting Dr authorization for the use of the walker? That should be a quick fix if that is true.

I am glad they are addressing the manner in which the administrator conducted himself in the meeting. I think had he acted differently this could have been mediated within the district privately.

I hope for this adorable child's sake everyone can keep the focus on her and her educational needs..and leave the other crap out of it. 

kidsfan3 --- 14 years ago -

Yes, I would think getting the doctor's authorization should be a quick fix. However, I have had a school district fight my doctor's orders before for my special need's child. :( Sad, but true! 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Montgomery county police reporter has the full story including moms role in this occurring.

Seems she agreed, had been sending child to school without required safety equipment which could potentially cause further damage to child and is blocking the school from getting required information from physicians.

Hmmm a liberal media in NBC again only shows partial information. 

Winning --- 14 years ago -

Here is the whole story from NCISD.

New Caney ISD is a Texas Education Agency "Recognized" school district that has as its foremost priority the safe and quality education of all students enrolled in the District. Each day, the District provides individualized, quality instruction to 1,090 students with physical, emotional, and learning disabilities who are eligible for special education programs.

On March 26, 2012, Ms. Kristi Roberts provided for the first time a release that would allow District representatives to speak to the media regarding this story. Previously, the District was precluded from comment due to the strict federal and state laws that protect student privacy. We thank Ms. Roberts for the opportunity to share publicly how the District is helping LaKay and working with her family toward meeting her individual educational needs.

In sharp contrast to earlier reports, New Caney ISD did not “take away” LaKay’s walker, nor did the District unilaterally determine that LaKay could no longer use her walker at school. The decision was a collaborative effort in which the mother agreed.

Earlier this year, specialists working with LaKay at school voiced strong concern that LaKay was becoming alarmingly fatigued when using her walker. Although LaKay’s physicians previously endorsed the use of the walker, LaKay also had been prescribed ankle foot orthotics (AFOs) by her doctors to wear during her use of the walker. LaKay began arriving at school without the AFOs, and at times, without shoes. Without the AFOs, LaKay demonstrates improper placement of her feet when walking and when fatigued, walks on the tops of her feet (with the soles of her feet facing up). Professional specialists, including the District’s physical therapy team, are extremely concerned that allowing LaKay to walk in this manner could result in permanent injury to the child — at worst, damaging LaKay’s chance of walking for the rest of her life. They also are concerned that the model of LaKay’s walker has no protection to prevent her from falling frontward during use. This is significant, given the nature of LaKay’s disabilities, which include both cerebral palsy and a life threatening seizure disorder.

New Caney ISD works in partnership with parents and routinely uses adapted devices with children and has done so in LaKay’s case. District personnel have met extensively with LaKay’s mother, and at a meeting on February 21, 2012, LaKay’s mother agreed with the school’s proposal to seek guidance from LaKay’s physicians regarding LaKay’s use of the walker. To date, the District has made more than eight attempts to get information from LaKay’s treating physicians without success, in part because of limitations placed by LaKay’s mother on the manner in which the school is allowed to communicate with the doctors. While LaKay’s doctors have endorsed the use of the walker,

walker, the District has not been able to get much needed clarification from them regarding the previously prescribed AFOs and to ensure that LaKay is safe when using her walker.

In the interim, Ms. Roberts signed an agreement with New Caney ISD on March 1, 2012 that LaKay would not use her walker until the much needed medical information could be obtained. A copy of that agreement is attached to this statement.

On March 29, 2012, LaKay’s story was told by NBC on The Today Show. New Caney ISD feels that the story was incomplete and therefore did not paint an accurate picture. The District spent more than an hour with NBC explaining several points that were not revealed to the public in the story aired by NBC. NBC was made aware that the District did not unilaterally take away LaKay’s walker. In fact, the District gave NBC a copy of the March 1, 2012 agreement that Ms. Roberts signed, which would have confirmed that she agreed with the District and that LaKay would not use her walker until additional medical information was provided. Despite this information, NBC ran a story that likely led viewers to conclude that the District had taken the walker away from LaKay, and without Ms. Roberts’ agreement. NBC also glossed over the legitimate concerns that the District has regarding the safety and health issues presented by LaKay using the walker without her previously prescribed AFOs. NBC also did not adequately explain the limitations Ms. Roberts has placed on its ability to communicate with LaKay’s doctors regarding these concerns.

The District remains committed to LaKay’s safety and to working with LaKay’s parent in the educational process. To that end, the school has arranged with LaKay’s parent to conduct a meeting of the child’s special education planning team (known as an “ARD committee” in Texas) to again discuss LaKay’s program, including the use of the walker. The District is confident that the school and the parent can work together to reach agreement, resulting in a safe and favorable outcome that will — most importantly — benefit LaKay.


In the interim, Ms. Roberts signed an agreement with New Caney ISD on March 1, 2012 that LaKay would not use her walker until the much needed medical information could be obtained. 

kidsfan3 --- 14 years ago -

I am not this child's doctor, but I would have to agree with the child needing to wear her AFO's when walking. Regardless of everything, there is no excuse for the way Mr. Lemley conducted himself in their meeting! 

Winning --- 14 years ago -

Regardless of everything, there is no excuse for the way Mr. Lemley conducted himself in their meeting!

AGREE 100%.

I do wonder why the mom would not send the AFOs and why the kid was even sent without shoes a few times? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children
kingwood
parenting
rant


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground