Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Household Effective Federal Tax Burden: for Cook'n Queen

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 1
Perfection 3
Hiro Protagonist 3
Warren Peace 3
jtcitrus 4
evolved 2
allday 2
20yrtexan 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

jtcitrus --- 15 years ago -

Household Effective Federal Tax Rate 2007:
Top 5% 27.9
Top 10% 26.7
Middle Quintile 14.3
Bottom 20% 4

Household Effective Federal Tax Rate 2007 (as total Percent Change Since 1979):
Top 5% -12.3
Top 10% -9.8
Middle Quintile -23.1
Bottom 20% -50.0
*calculations mine

Source: Congressional Budget Office

Effective Federal Tax Rates measure the tax burden on households. These
rates are calculated by dividing taxes paid by or imputed to households
by their comprehensive household income.

Federal taxes include individual income, corporate income, payroll and
excise taxes. Individual income taxes are generally distributed directly
to households paying those taxes. Social insurance, or payroll, taxes are
distributed to households paying those taxes directly or paying them
indirectly through their employers. Corporate income taxes are distributed
to households according to their share of capital income. Federal excise
taxes are distributed to them according to their consumption of the taxed
good or service.

The income measure, comprehensive household income, comprises pretax cash
income plus income from other sources. Pretax cash income is the sum of
wages, salaries, self-employment income, rents, taxable and nontaxable
interest, dividends, realized capital gains, cash transfer payments, and
retirement benefits plus taxes paid by businesses & employee contributions
to 401(k) retirement plans. Other sources of income include all in-kind
benefits (Medicare, Medicaid, employer-paid health insurance premiums,
food stamps, school lunches/breakfasts, and housing & energy assistance).





CQ, Don't know if this answers the question you posed, but I thought I'd share. It's CBO data, but everything looks pretty standard from a labor econ stand point. again, don't have the time/data to go more recent or back in time. 

allday --- 15 years ago -

Interesting for sure. Let's see if this even gets a nibble.

Let me call the confederates.

Dog whistle!!!!!!!! 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

They are staying away from this one like the plague it is. FACTS

The anathema to a teabagger. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

Those can't be right! All these people(who don't even really have money) all act like they're paying 80%! 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

All these people(who don't even really have money) all act like they're paying 80%!

Yeah, the bootlickers of the rich. It's so damned funny that they have NO IDEA about tax rates much less EFFECTIVE tax rates.

My 7th grader can walk them through it if they can get them off Fox long enough. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Household Effective Federal Tax Rate 2007:
Top 5% 27.9
Top 10% 26.7
Middle Quintile 14.3
Bottom 20% 4



So you are pointing out the unfairness of the tax schedules. Thanks for being honest enough to demonstrate the inequities in the system.

Fair tax for ALL

Tax purchases not work.

Redistribution fails every time. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

Yeah, the bootlickers of the rich. It's so damned funny that they have NO IDEA about tax rates much less EFFECTIVE tax rates.


My favorite is when they say that the U.S. has the 2nd highest corp. tax rate, when in reality the effective corp. tax rate is around 15%. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

How many rich liberals pay additional taxes and/or do not apply exemptions or deductions to their tax returns?

They could easily send in additional money to help with the issues. But they choose not to do that, I wonder why that is? 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -


They could easily send in additional money to help with the issues. But they choose not to do that, I wonder why that is?




And how many of them are acting like they're paying all their money in taxes????? 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Seems like this is classiasm being displayed by some.

If you are rich and you don't pay additional taxes voluntarily but talk about others paying higher taxes you are a hypocrite.

If you are not rich and want the rich to pay more taxes you are a jealous.

If you are the recipient of redistribution and want more taxes on the rich you are jealous.

There is never a reason a democrat who is rich cannot give more money to the government but heck, you don't even see leading democrats paying their taxes as they should. Has Sec. Geithner ever paid his taxes? Rep Rangel? Former Senator and former Secretary of HHSC nominee Daschle, did he ever pay his?

All are very rich yet not only do they not pay additional money to the government they don't even pay what they owed.

Shameful. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

They'll only break this class warfare argument down into smaller pieces now.

It's no longer going to be the rich. It will be rich conservatives. Rich people who support Obama are exempt. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

Don't effective tax rates conceal the economic benefits that government knowingly incentivizes?

The government has an interest in many charitable contributions. So rather than use tax revenue, they allow deductions so that citizens can donate to organizations to minimize special interest expenditures by the government.

When the government has an interest in small business owners ( over 70% of the tax payers in that upper bracket are small business owners according to a 2007 Treasury report) carrying the operating expense of funding health plans, they create a deduction for these upper income earners. Yet that gets concealed in effective tax rates (which don't count this deduction).

When the government has an interest in various green initiatives, they offer tax deductioms rather than provide direct funding. This also is concealed by effective tax rates.

We could continue to list such deductions. But the point I'm making is that folks who try to rely on effective tax rates to make the point that the rich don't pay enough are relying on keeping a significantly higher list of expenditures that would otherwise come as taxes - out of the conversation.

When you knowingly conceal facts that are relevant to the conversation, most folks call that dishonesty. 

jtcitrus --- 15 years ago -

When you knowingly conceal facts that are relevant to the conversation, most folks call that dishonesty.

I wasn't being dishonest or deliberately hiding anything. Do you have a low opinion of me to assume that?

I was asked if I could find out how the financial tax burden had evolved over time by percentile. I provided the best answer I could. there's a ton of different ways the data could be altered, accounting for this or that. I gave the most honest answer that I could given the resources I had.

rather than use tax revenue, they allow deductions so that citizens can donate to organizations to minimize special interest expenditures by the government.

I don't know what the net effect on federal expenditures is from the increase in total charitable donations due to income tax incentives, and it's not clear to me at the moment how one would go about estimating the counter-factual to determine that effect.

Conditional on the intensity of the tax incentives in place, it's not clear that the net effect would have evolved in such a way over that period of time that it would have significantly changed the course of relative tax burdens (as depicted by the percent change in the effective tax rates).


the point I'm making is that folks who try to rely on effective tax rates to make the point that the rich don't pay enough are relying on keeping a significantly higher list of expenditures that would otherwise come as taxes - out of the conversation.

As it can be inferred that you're accusing me of making that argument, I'll respond that the data I posted doesn't state any such thing, and I certainly don't hold to the notion that the wealthy pay far to little in taxes.

Without further research, I wouldn't want to make claims about the elasticity of substitution between tax incentive induced charitable donations and public expenditures.

You bring up an important topic and I hope the silent majority will google it to do some of their own research.

To more succinctly reiterate my answer to your comment Warren: I'm not persuaded that the change in effective tax burdens over the last 30 years would be significantly altered by accounting for things you commented on, even though at any point in time the level of the effective tax burden might be. 

jtcitrus --- 15 years ago -

in reality the effective corp. tax rate is around 15%.

which is still way too high in my opinion. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

I wasn't being dishonest or deliberately hiding anything. Do you have a low opinion of me to assume that?

My apologies. I intended for my comments to be directed to anyone who tries to use effective tax rates to make the case that the rich don't pay enough. Folks often cite Warren Buffet's observation that he pays a lower effective tax rate than his secretary. The folks that use his observation tend to leave out his economic contributions that result in his lower effective rate.

I didn't intend my use of the word "you" to refer to jcitrus. I did use it a bit wrecklessly, but I mistakenly believed that my previous reference to "folks" would infer a broader use of the word "you" 

jtcitrus --- 15 years ago -

I didn't intend my use of the word "you" to refer to jcitrus.

I figured that later, but... it was midnight when I typed that.
:) 

20yrtexan --- 15 years ago -

Seems like this is classiasm being displayed by some. TRUTH! 

allday --- 15 years ago -

The government has an interest in many charitable contributions. So rather than use tax revenue, they allow deductions so that citizens can donate to organizations to minimize special interest expenditures by the government.

Say whaaaatttt??

Please show how you you derive REAL numbers out of that?

I showed that to the CEO of a small energy firm this morning and he howled. HE said it was purely speculative as far as a quantifiable $$ achievment is concerned by tying fed expenditure totals to effect of charitable donations via the tax incentives.

Lack of ability to produce a real number out of that renders it noise.

To be so certain of things that have no certitude is dishonest, no?

You make a great point my only contention is I believe it's not knowable. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

Please show how you you derive REAL numbers out of that?

How about doing a better job of explaining what you're looking for?

You do know that the government allows charitable deductions, right? What do you think is the purpose of it? Why else do you think an agency has to qualify with a government entity in order to be classified as a charitable organization under 501(c)(3). The government absolutely sees an economic benefit by allowing it. Otherwise it would not happen. If the small energy CEO howled over that, you may either want to check his agenda or get him an IQ test before he ruins that energy company.

To be so certain of things that have no certitude is dishonest, no?

Um no. There are tiers of certainty. If you limit yourself to 100% certainty, you're doomed to a life of inaction. Even your small ceo acquaintance knows that.

I'll put it in financial terms so your ceo pal can understand. Was it knowable that the housing market would collapse before it did? Yes it was. Many predicted it. Knowing when was not knowable. Many folks (myself included) moved all money out of the stock market before the collapse and into government treasuries. I didn't know with 100% certainty that it would collapse (because we didn't know if there would be attempts to correct it). But my "Heads I win, tails I don't lose much" philosophy triggered action on my part when talk of banks collapses began occurring with greater frequency. You can't say there was a level of certitude where it was absolutely knowable, because many financial experts lost a lot. All I knew was that there were folks whose opinions I valued but never met in real life that were signaling problems, so I acted.

The same thing occurred in the latest stock market drop. I moved every dime of my retirement fund from Dow indexed and S&P indexed funds to a bond fund on June 9th of this year to save my retirement from what seemed to be yet another inevitable collapse. It wasn't the optimal time since a minor loss had already occurred and a minor recovery still followed. But while many Americans were again losing their portfolios this week (again, including many financial experts), Warren Peace's finances were sound and secure (other than some Apple stock that took a hit).

So what's the difference between Warren Peace's certainty of knowing and everyone else who lost portfolio value? The difference is I do not require 100% certainty to know. Many folks who lose their ASSets during such crisis do require that level of certainty. They lose because they insist they don't and can't know. The truth is they are delusional. They CAN know, they just turn a blind eye because they are fearful of being wrong (that's why they utter such things about certitude).

If your CEO pal lost any money this week, tell him I'm howling. If anyone else reading this lost money, my sympathies go out to you. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground