Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

vacation for the 'elitists' in the room

who's talking here?

smartypants 2
Fallon 10
planemom 1
traveller 5
maverick 1
ukchristine 1
movedagain 1
wayward1 1
AuthorMan 2
Zionist NightOwl 3
Mabbers 2
txdaddy 2
~sassy~ 20
ExLady In Blue 1
Perfection 2
Laurabeth 1
voice of reason 7
ladyjane 2
pumpkinsmom2 1
james osterberg 1
TexasOma 5
autumnlover 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 5
~ MARY C ~ 5
In AbsentiaW 9
a_non 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

August 9, 2010
Slumdog Tourism
By KENNEDY ODEDE
Nairobi, Kenya

SLUM tourism has a long history — during the late 1800s, lines of wealthy New Yorkers snaked along the Bowery and through the Lower East Side to see “how the other half lives.”

But with urban populations in the developing world expanding rapidly, the opportunity and demand to observe poverty firsthand have never been greater. The hot spots are Rio de Janeiro, Mumbai — thanks to “Slumdog Millionaire,” the film that started a thousand tours — and my home, Kibera, a Nairobi slum that is perhaps the largest in Africa.

Slum tourism has its advocates, who say it promotes social awareness. And it’s good money, which helps the local economy.

But it’s not worth it. Slum tourism turns poverty into entertainment, something that can be momentarily experienced and then escaped from. People think they’ve really “seen” something — and then go back to their lives and leave me, my family and my community right where we were before.

I was 16 when I first saw a slum tour. I was outside my 100-square-foot house washing dishes, looking at the utensils with longing because I hadn’t eaten in two days. Suddenly a white woman was taking my picture. I felt like a tiger in a cage. Before I could say anything, she had moved on.

When I was 18, I founded an organization that provides education, health and economic services for Kibera residents. A documentary filmmaker from Greece was interviewing me about my work. As we made our way through the streets, we passed an old man defecating in public. The woman took out her video camera and said to her assistant, “Oh, look at that.”

For a moment I saw my home through her eyes: feces, rats, starvation, houses so close together that no one can breathe. I realized I didn’t want her to see it, didn’t want to give her the opportunity to judge my community for its poverty — a condition that few tourists, no matter how well intentioned, could ever understand.

Other Kibera residents have taken a different path. A former schoolmate of mine started a tourism business. I once saw him take a group into the home of a young woman giving birth. They stood and watched as she screamed. Eventually the group continued on its tour, cameras loaded with images of a woman in pain. What did they learn? And did the woman gain anything from the experience?

To be fair, many foreigners come to the slums wanting to understand poverty, and they leave with what they believe is a better grasp of our desperately poor conditions. The expectation, among the visitors and the tour organizers, is that the experience may lead the tourists to action once they get home.

But it’s just as likely that a tour will come to nothing. After all, looking at conditions like those in Kibera is overwhelming, and I imagine many visitors think that merely bearing witness to such poverty is enough.

Nor do the visitors really interact with us. Aside from the occasional comment, there is no dialogue established, no conversation begun. Slum tourism is a one-way street: They get photos; we lose a piece of our dignity.

Slums will not go away because a few dozen Americans or Europeans spent a morning walking around them. There are solutions to our problems — but they won’t come about through tours.

Kennedy Odede, the executive director of Shining Hope for Communities, a social services organization, is a junior at Wesleyan University. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

Slum tourism turns poverty into entertainment



this is why i thought it might appeal to some here especially those who like to go after the impoverished on a daily basis. 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

How would that be entertaining? 

traveller --- 16 years ago -

The elitist seems to be you as your obviously think you are morally superior to everyone else on KU. Don't speak for me in the future. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

Ditto Trav.

Ditto, ditto, ditto.

No one here goes after the impoverished. They go after people cheating the system. They go after people who never, ever, make any efforts to get out of that lifestyle. And the ones who talk about that lifestyle, are the ones who lived it. And are now out. And know you can get out. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

Interesting article. I didn't know people even did that. In my travels, I prefer doing all my exploring on my own. However, occasionally it is best to tour one piece of an itinerary with a group, for one reason or another (like a remote, dangerous-to-travel-to locale). So I have found myself on vans, traveling through a countryside, looking out the window at communities with far less than I have. It makes me very grateful for the luxury we are bathed in. But I can't imagine taking a photo of someone, or even just walking around their community, where they were aware that I was gawking at them. 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

Only a complete fool would think you could get a "feel" for the way the truly impoverished live by walking through the area they live in. Unless you live there day after day with no hope of leaving, you would have no idea what these people live through on a daily basis.

The "impoverished" in the USA are a bit different. Many impoverished in this country choose to live in poverty collecting money from the government and not trying to better themselves.

As many ku'ers have suggested......tying that government assisstance to an education would help. Anything that would demand that these people take steps to help themselves would be of great benefit. Hand outs will never solve the problem. At some point people on welfare have to want something better for themselves and their families.

The way we are doing it now is not working at all. 

In AbsentiaW --- 16 years ago -

Voice of Reason?
Hardly a voice for the majority of KU posters.

I've seen a lot of poverty in my travels but I never have taken any pictures....how crass can you get? 

maverick --- 16 years ago -

Never heard anyone "going after the impoverished" on here. But some people imagine all types of conspiracies and attacks.

The elitist I am aware of is vacationing in Spain with 40 of her closest friends on your dime. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

you are right. i was wrong it wording it that they go after the impoverished. how about they bash daily those who are not as fortunate as themselves. we all know who they are.

now in regards to this from above.
Ditto Trav.

Ditto, ditto, ditto.


don't mess with me, ditto head.
let me remind: fallon apparently just another ku hypocrite writes just in one thread alone:
small minded people
What a stupid comment
You need a measurable IQ.
You are both judgmental, and quick to call names. I have no problem
letting stupid people know they are stupid. And I have no problem
judging people. Find a human that doesn't.
You are an idiot.
You both are morons. On your best day.
Really you are both pathetic


and then ends it with this humdinger:
Oh, but that's right, you as liberals are allowed to name call. And be
hateful, and insulting


what entertainment! 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

laurabeth, referring to the slumdog vacationing:
How would that be entertaining?


you are right. it is completely unfeeling. an atrocity. a shame! 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

Fallon was merely stating facts!!! 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

mary c that is what we call hypocrisy at its finest hour! speaking of which, there are some pics floating around of sassy trashed. makes illegals look like royalty. lolol wonder if they will ever see the ku light of day. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

There was an interesting article about something similar today on CNN regarding celebrities who go for the photo-ops in under-developed or poor areas.

Is it helpful they go? Not really but it does get the name out there so free advertising never hurts........ but at the same time, the free advertising is also for the "celebrity".

Sometimes I wonder why they think it is more valuable to give their time and not their money to charity. Perhaps the best is to give both.

Just an interesting article that seemed to go with this theme. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

Sometimes I wonder why they think it is more valuable to give their time and not their money to charity. Perhaps the best is to give both.

Just an interesting article that seemed to go with this theme.



yes i found it interesting also, as a study of humanity and i am not referring to a study of the poor but a study of those who would go infiltrate them. i would venture to guess most celebs give their money and some give their time as well. i don't agree in the case of jolie. i don't think she does it for a photo op at all and i never have. 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

along the Bowery and through the Lower East Side

Hey,I lived there and the only tourists I ever saw were at CBGB's and Some people shopping at a place called Trash & Vaudville 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

voice of reason, I agree that there are some who are very monetarily generous, both on the right and left. They do it because it is the right thing to do.

But there are just as many who only give in-kind donations and not their money. 

In AbsentiaW --- 16 years ago -

Mary C. I find it hard to believe that you [who appears to be a nice person] can agree with Fallon's snide comments.

"Fallon was merely stating facts!!!"

Any attempt to be clever and cute does not need to be downright insulting to anyone.

If she is backed into a corner she attacks with junk like that.

She called me a liar when I posted the same things that were posted above.

If insults don't work she turns to some type of political insult.

At the very least it can be entertaining I guess. 

ukchristine --- 16 years ago -

That article is interesting timing as I just arrived home this morning from Buenos Aires, Iguassu Falls and before that Rio de Janeiro. I (after much reluctance due to the "gawking" feeling) did drive to a favela with a local taxi driver who speaks really good English. He himself lives in a favela and was not in any way ashamed of that fact and urged us to see for ourselves. We visited Rocinha the largest favela in Rio (300K). I can't say it was "entertaining".......but it was certainly interesting. With more than a million people living in favelas a lot of "regular" working people live there......families like our taxi driver & his wife. They are self contained cities with banks, shops etc. I guess that was my biggest surprise....that there is some "normalcy" to life in a favela. BUT........a lot of the areas are def a no go zone due to the drug lords and gangs staking their claims. The problems of very substandard housing are overwhelming. The way electricity is supplied is seriously scary. And mud slides I am sure are a very big threat. I did see a store selling big screen TV's....most odd. BA has it's share of these kinds of slums.....very visible on the drive to the airport. But it's not like RIO where the favelas are built on the side of all the beautiful hills. We learned a lot about their history from our taxi driver. I do not in any way sugar coat the lives of many of the people. Brazil is very concerned about the growing child prostitution business which has overtaken Thailand (so the TV there reported)…..especially with the upcoming Federation Cup in 2013, World cup in 2014 and Olympic in 2016.

I guess I am going to be labled one of the elites now. 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

Mary C. I find it hard to believe that you [who appears to be a nice person] can agree with Fallon's snide comments.

First of all, AGIT8R......Fallon is a very pretty, very knowledgeable, very articulate woman. She is one of the fairest minded individuals on KU.

However, if you are silly enough to refer to Fallon as a racist, you can prepare to get your nose bloodied. No way this woman is racist and she will not tolerate someone spewing that kind of ignorance at her.

She may talk like a pothole and have this wonderfully soft southern voice, but she will kick your butt if you want to act stupid! 

ladyjane --- 16 years ago -

this is why i thought it might appeal to some here especially those who like to go after the impoverished on a daily basis. 


Who goes after the impoverished on here? And on a daily basis? Glad I missed that, but if I encountered it, I would totally be as disgusted, too. I'm sure you don't really picture KUers going through poor neighborhoods to gawk and feel superior, do you?

Maybe I'm pollyanna-ish....well, okay, I am....but I have the impression most people on here, regardless of their politics, would give of their time and resources to someone in need. Without judging. Maybe a strong pep talk, but I just don't picture this group, as a whole, as going after people when they're down. 

a_non --- 16 years ago -

Who goes after the impoverished on here? And on a daily basis? Glad I missed that, but if I encountered it, I would totally be as disgusted, too. I'm sure you don't really picture KUers going through poor neighborhoods to gawk and feel superior, do you?


I don't think anyone does it intentionally, but I certainly do think they get caught in the crossfire sometimes when discussing things like welfare from time to time here. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

Interesting post, ukchristine. Thanks for sharing it. The timing is pretty funny. I can't imagine you being insensitive or having the wrong attitude about seeing how other people live. It's what anthropologically minded folks do. I think it's the mindset of people viewing their experience as "tourism" that seems so crass, and seeing others doing it as a "tour group" seems to fit in with that perspective. I dunno. That's just how I see it. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

Fallon is a very pretty, very knowledgeable, very articulate woman. She is one of the fairest minded individuals on KU.

I agree with this. Fallon is awesome! And I adore her southern drawl. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

i don't agree in the case of jolie. i don't think she does it for a photo op at all and i never have.

Angelina??? No, she just gives away free tickets to a Russian spy thrown out of the US to attend her 'Russian spy thriller' premiere thereby excusing such pesky business. Pfft. Jolie is just...another...celebrity. Always has been. Always will be. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

this is why i thought it might appeal to some here especially those who like to go after the impoverished on a daily basis.


Name one person who goes after poor people.

Some of us have issues with those who abuse the system but no one I know has issues with use of the system.

Learn the difference before you go shooting off your mouth about things you ONLY think you know. 

TexasOma --- 16 years ago -

The difference in the 'tourist attraction Bowery' and the poof of America is opportunity or lack thereof.

In the countries where these so-called tours are taking place, people do not have the opportunities that we in America have. People that CHOOSE to live in poverty have CHOSEN to pass on the opportunities provided to them. In the 'tourist Bowery' countries, most have to pay for their children to be educated, the government keeps them in a subservient situation by the politicians and people of power living high off the hog and passing favors onto their friends rather than giving back to the community - such as a free education.

People here choose to live off the backs of other Americans who are hard working people being taxed to death. Professional welfare recipients find ways to collect welfare under many names and find ways to skirt the system to get more than their fair share so they can continue the cycle of poverty onto their kids. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

no one I know has issues with use of the system.

That is not at all clear when the "socialist" war-cry is sounded almost any time funding of social services is discussed is here. 

a_non --- 16 years ago -

That is not at all clear when the "socialist" war-cry is sounded almost any time funding of social services is discussed is here. 


THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT A SOCIALIST WOULD SAY. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

lol 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

I only called you a liar AGIT, because you did lie. Stop telling fibs and I will not call you a liar. But when you repeat lies I will EVERY single time call you on it.

vor, you are a vile small minded piece of garbage. And as long as you act like you do, you can bet I'll call you on it.

Do you want me to quote the hate you spew on every religious thread? My quotes were facts, you want to see some of yours? 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -


vor, you are a vile small minded piece of garbage. And as long as you act like you do, you can bet I'll call you on it.



I adore you Fallon! 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

That is not at all clear when the "socialist" war-cry is sounded almost any time funding of social services is discussed is here.


Just because someone is poor doesn't mean others should be expected to provide their basic needs from cradle to grave. That's not reality, that's utopia....and Utopia doesn't exist. I take that back, for generational welfare bums perfectly content living off another's dime as evidenced, I suppose it exists.


No one has a problem in giving someone a hand up - NO ONE, but there's a limit to what society is willing to bear.

If you can't afford insurance, you find yourself a free clinic and stand in line. Insurance isn't a right, it's a responsibility. YOUR responsibility - not MINE...... YOURS.

If you can't afford rent, you find yourself a tiny apartment that you CAN afford. You don't squat yourself in section 8 housing for years and years on anothers dime and expect people to be ok with that.

This has nothing to so with an unwillingness to help those in need of a hand up, it has to do with those who seek to mooch off hard working Americans from cradle to grave.

It has to do with supporting millions and millions and millions of illegal invaders stealing services for THEIR poor that belong to OUR poor.

Has NOTHING to do with helping deserving Americans down on their luck.

I hope this clears up future confusion next time the socialist war cry is sounded. It helps to understand exactly what we're pissed at. Now you know. 

pumpkinsmom2 --- 16 years ago -

James Osterberg...in my 20's I shopped at Trash and Vaudeville and went to CBGB's, lol. I guess you know about Phinnean's Rainbow (sp)in the village, too? The courtyard with the wrecked plane in it? Had a lot of fun there! Sorry everyone, I was having a flashback to my youth. Good times, lol. 

ladyjane --- 16 years ago -

Well, at least VOR is either clever enough (or off his game enough) not to add the usual diatribe about Christians being so bad. I'd like to give him credit for figuring the truth - that lots and lots of us have spent time on mission trips in the poorest of poor areas in our countries and others. And these people don't appear with fancy cameras. They come with rakes, shovels, paintbrushes, food, and, yes, prayer. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

No one has a problem in giving someone a hand up

It's extremely frustrating when your related to those with their hands out. No money to pay for lights/water but always plenty for beer and cigarettes. GRRR.... 

traveller --- 16 years ago -

vor: it seems that through your calling out of these nameless people on KU, you have become what you supposedly despise. Get off your podium. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

It's extremely frustrating when your related to those with their hands out. No money to pay for lights/water but always plenty for beer and cigarettes. GRRR....


right? Reminds me of those Katrina "Victims" who showed up at the Dome with with no diapers or baby food but by golly they had their cigarettes. Priorities, right? 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

that lots and lots of us have spent time on mission trips in the poorest of poor areas in our countries and others.

Oh wow. Flashback. You just got me remembering a mission trip to central Mexico where the only place to stay did not have running water or electricity. LOL. The people there lived in mud houses with dirt floors, but boy oh boy, those were the cleanest little huts I've ever seen in my life. Those women had their floors packed down so tight and smooth it was incredible. I sat on a cot in a corner and watched her mill around while her kids went and got me their 'treasures' to give me along with a coveted ice pop. That was the very first time I had pig cooked in the ground. Damn, it was GUUD. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

It's extremely frustrating when your related to those with their hands out. No money to pay for lights/water but always plenty for beer and cigarettes. GRRR....

Oh and you forgot plenty of money for their tattoo's when they want one to. ugh 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

recommendations


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground