Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should you be fired for having personal financial issues?

who's talking here?

planemom 1
Sandyr9111 2
steinhoister 1
lizandmike 2
AuthorMan 1
Deltadawn 1
txdaddy 1
~sassy~ 4
Setta 1
Perfection 6
Atasca Mom 1
POTUS 1
JusticeForAll 2
Ogre1 8
evolved 1
mommie21g1b 1
alreadygone~~ 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should you be fired for having personal financial issues?

[url=http://www.federalnewsradio.com/?nid=35&sid=1995749]Employees fired after routine periodic background checks showed money issues[/url] All things being equal, once you get hired and you are doing a good job, should you be fired for your personal finances?

Yes it is a way to protect everyone Vote
 
 22.0% (11)
No it is an invasion of personal freedom Vote
 
 78.0% (39)
Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Employees fired after routine periodic background checks showed money issues

All things being equal, once you get hired and you are doing a good job, should you be fired for your personal finances? 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

If they have access to my sensitive information, then yes. It might seem over kill but when money problems hit how tempting would it be to skim a little here and there to help out. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I don't think so, but poor money management DOES show a lack of discipline.

It's not THAT you're in debt, it's WHY. 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

I went and read the article, and for these employees they have to be able to pass the security clearance whenever it is checked, it is part of the job. 

lizandmike --- 16 years ago -

My dh is subject to this kind of check. One of the reasons is that with a security clearance, you are privy to certain info. If you are having financial difficulties, you are more vulnerable to being bribed out of that info.
In addition, these were DFAS employees. They have access to federal employees personal and banking info. Where again, financial difficulties increases the temptation to skim a little or sell this info.
The employees knew about this when they were hired. The paperwork to be hired is unbelievable. They request several years of financial info before you're even hired.
Simple solution... if you can't pay cash, don't buy it. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

If you are having financial difficulties, you are more vulnerable to being bribed out of that info.

Did yall know Allstate and Farmers and most other insurance companies now base their fees on your credit history?

And doesn't this infer if you're in debt that you're more likely to cheat the system? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

I am under periodic background checks where I work too. We all knew this when we hired on and every couple of years we hold meetings to remind people that if they have something they need to tell us about, they better tell us and not let us find it in the background checks.

If we know about it, we are willing to work with them to find something, if we discover it, then bye bye.

Yeah it stinks but you have to protect information. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

should you be fired for your personal finances?

Depends on the job.

Bus driver? No.

Undercover Drug Gang Investigator? Yeah,probably.

Spie? (I'm sorry, the current euphemism is "Professional Trainee") - Definitely.

President, Senator, Congressman, or any politician at a higher level than dog catcher? - Absolutely. 

alreadygone~~ --- 16 years ago -

no 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

I would say it depends on the job. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Ogre1 --- 17 min ago - quote - flag comment

should you be fired for your personal finances?

Depends on the job.

Bus driver? No.


why not a bus driver? You don't think they could become so distressed they intentionally wreck the bus? 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

You don't think they could become so distressed they intentionally wreck the bus?

To what end? If that's your standard then we need perfect robots driving the bus.

He11 Chunks, we know ALL bus drivers are crazy anyway, so you can't really base the job on a psychological profile.

You don't think they could become so distressed they intentionally wreck the bus?

Isn't that true with EVERYBODY, but since it is rare it can't be a legitimate benchmark.

No the financial limitation must be related to financial circumstances. People who are in a position to be bribed, to be enticed into abrogating their duties with money,drugs,sex, etc. should be the one's subject to credit restrictions. Not just the general populace, (up to 40% of which have a score of less than 600). 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Not just the general populace, (up to 40% of which have a score of less than 600).

Really?

Wow I didn't realize we sucked so bad. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Wow I didn't realize we sucked so bad.

It's pretty heinous out there. Over 1,000,000 personal bankruptcies were filed last year alone. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

It's pretty heinous out there. Over 1,000,000 personal bankruptcies were filed last year alon


Didn't the rules just change a few years ago too to make it harder? 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Didn't the rules just change a few years ago too to make it harder?

Yep. But not impossible. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

And I said Last year, I meant 2008..sorry..brain damage this morning. Dunno about last year yet. 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

We should also fire people for the thoughts in their heads. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Yep, that's what I thought. 1.4m in 2009

One report
 

Setta --- 16 years ago -

I would say that no one should lose a job if they do their job honestly and are devoted to great job performance...their personal life finances or not should not interfere. No one knows why someone is struggling...that's their business. Maybe they had to help a child elsewhere or elderly parent and they had no choice?...as long as they are honest they should keep their job. To fire them would make their life even harder..so why hurt them more? IF there should be a money shortage and they are aware of that person's situation...at "that" time..."then"...question and possibly fire if they aren't willing to take a polygraph or prove they are innocent...but until then they should be able to keep their job. Personally I would be furious if my employer were looking into my personal life...what goes on in my life, bank etc. has nothing to do with them "until" my job performance begins to suffer from it! 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

I don't think anyone should be fired based on "what ifs". Unless someone has proven to not be trustworthy, they are owed the benefit of the doubt. Especially a long time employee.

As Potus said, are we going to start prosecuting on "thought crime" next?

Just stick to tangible reasons for terminating employees. 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -


We should also fire people for the thoughts in their heads. 




0 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Just stick to tangible reasons for terminating employees.

So what happens when the financial adviser starts embezzling funds from client's accounts when the company knew he was having financial difficulties?

They have a duty to protect their client's assetts and as such are liable under the master/servant rule for all loses.

Should they just eat that?

How about, the special agent, who is working an undercover drug case who has overdrafted his credit cards, taken out several mortgages, and can't control his spending.

Should he/she/it be allowed to continue doing their job? How trustworthy are they? And what is a defense attorney going to do to their reputation if they ever have to take the stand?

The vast majority of people should not be subject to this sort of thing, yes. But in the REAL WORLD there are jobs out there where people control other people's assets, where people are in a position where they must be scrupulous about their personal life as well as the business life.

I don't see this any different than drug testing. There are people who you don't want high when they go to work. There are people who you don't want tempted by "creative solutions" to their financial woes as well. 

Atasca Mom --- 16 years ago -

I dont know if it is right or wrong but "it is what it is"... I am subject to the same thing with my employer. They checked my credit when I started and the expectations were set...same with my last employer (same field).. Personally, I dont have a problem with it. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Just stick to tangible reasons for terminating employees.

So what happens when the financial adviser starts embezzling funds from client's accounts when the company knew he was having financial difficulties?


They fire him once he's proven to be untrustworthy.

Are you saying someone's credit score is directly correlated to their job performance?

As I said before, fire someone when they've proven to be untrustworthy, I think it's a poor practice to fire someone without provocation based on "what ifs".

I don't care WHAT field you're in. If they found you competent to hire you, they should give you the benefit of the doubt until proven otherwise.

Just because someone has hit hard times financially, it doesn't make them a crook. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

should? hmmmmmm, that's a tough one. if i owned a business and wanted to hire someone in a treasury/cash management position whereby they would have access to the company's cash...i could see using how they have handled their personal funds as a means to making the decision to hire or not.

it may not 'seem' right or fair but if i disclose this during the hiring process and/or in the employee handbook, it's known and i feel like i would have done my part to inform them that their personal finances do play a part in their continued employment. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

They fire him once he's proven to be untrustworthy.

And when the company is sued?

There are certain jobs, for which, allowing your credit to get bad, PROVES you are untrustworthy. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

We have an ex exec who has gone through a bankruptcy after losing everything in a 401K collapse. The misinformation he received from his beloved company caused his loss. It's his fault for trusting them and he can't get on with a big company due to background and the company he worked for.

I've found less reliable folks with spotless pasts, just sneakier. If you've done nothing, risked nothing, you are probably not dynamic enough for much. Most highly successful folks have enjoyed as much pain as pleasure. If not, you missed half the ride. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

There are certain jobs, for which, allowing your credit to get bad, PROVES you are untrustworthy.


And like I said, it's not so much THAT you're in debt, but WHY.

Some times things happen beyond your doing, but that's the exception, not the rule. Poor credit generally DOES speak to character. Lack of discipline and priorities specifically. 

mommie21g1b --- 16 years ago -

They fire him once he's proven to be untrustworthy

So wait until they steal to fire them. Obviously you have never owned a business or had a job where YOUR finacial future could be impacted by an employee.

I didn't read the article, but in Texas and many states a person can be fired for any reason no questions asked. In addition, if these were terms of employment there shouldn't be an issue. 

lizandmike --- 16 years ago -

What about people, employed by the government, who deal with intellegence? Regardless of your view on it, we are at war and have things that are issues of national security. People who want those secrets will stop at nothing to get them. should we trust people who have financial difficulties with those secrets?
Personally, I am grateful that those with financial issues aren't trusted with national security secrets.
Financial stability is not too hard to achieve. Buy a home that costs less than you can afford. Buy a car that is less than you can afford. Save money instead of starbucks and sonic. Then you have $ in case you fall on hard times. Spend less than you make. Don't use credit cards. Make a budget and live by it. Then it wouldn't be an issue. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Financial stability is not too hard to achieve. Buy a home that costs less than you can afford. Buy a car that is less than you can afford. Save money instead of starbucks and sonic. Then you have $ in case you fall on hard times. Spend less than you make. Don't use credit cards. Make a budget and live by it. Then it wouldn't be an issue.


excellent post 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

Save money instead of starbucks and sonic.

No! 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

I am sitting here right now looking at my desk. Two starbucks iced coffees and a passion iced tea lemonade....

I think I need some more caffeine!!! 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

Are you saying someone's credit score is directly correlated to their job performance?

I cant agree considering up till a few years ago mine was junk. Now even though Ive worked my azz off @ 660 its now still junk because of all the bank BS. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground