Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

All workers entitled to a fair wage - documented or not - just call the government

who's talking here?

~sassy~ 6
rEVOLution 2
Perfection 2
Betty 1
Ogre1 6
Crusty Undies Revenge! 1
allday 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

We can help!

Hmmm, so will they turn in the undocumented worker too?

Hey, I am all for going after the employer, but get the employee too for breaking the law and send them out. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

Obama Labor Chief: Illegals Have a Right to Fair Wages

IMO they have the right to remain silent and get their as* back to that hole they call a country and fix it. 

Crusty Undies Revenge! --- 16 years ago -

What is the problem? Way I see it is if they have to pay 7.25 to a illegal then they are more likely to hire an American at 7.25 that can read, write, and speak English 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

The problem is that if they turn them in (which I do NOT have a problem with) then they too should be held accountable for being here illegally. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

The problem is that if they turn them in (which I do NOT have a problem with) then they too should be held accountable for being here illegally.

Absolutely! 

allday --- 16 years ago -

Powerful arguments. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

hmmmm, Here's the problem.

First, don't get me wrong. I think that people who want to live here SHOULD go through the process. I also think that process can be made a LOT better than it is today.

HOWEVER, this is a different issue. This isn't an immigration issue, this is an issue of AMERICAN EMPLOYERS breaking laws.

And I don't think you guys have thought through all the consequences.

For instance;

IF an undocumented worker knows that by turning an employer in for paying them below minimum wages they will get deported, then they will most likely NOT turn that employer in (except maybe in the most egregious cases - and even then, maybe not).

That leaves that employer with the option of hiring more illegals at the reduced rate.

THUS creating an expanded, essentially government created, underground market for illegals.

As everyone here should know, if there is a demand, there will be a supply.

SO, by tying this reporting apparatus together with a check for immigration status, you COULD actually cause MORE illegal aliens to come into the country.

You could also create a defacto slave system wherein illegals have no means of reporting abuse. where in, employers hold power over people to get them deported as punishment for whatever slights they may commit. This of course, could (would!) escalate and eventually you would have a class of people who were essentially slaves to criminals.

Additionally, the federal government would incur much greater expense in seeking out and investigating this type of abuse. AND since paying someone less than the legally prescribed minimum wage is a crime, the government would have to attempt to prosecute it without any reliable witnesses as they would be to afraid to come forward for fear of being deported.

There are about 310,000,000 people in this country. High end estimates put Illegals at about 20,000,000. That's about 6.45~% of the population.

I find the arguments that they're taking all our stuff to be ludicrous.

And if they are, then I think there is something deadly wrong with what we're doing. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Let's take this a step further.

Let's say that the government decides it is too difficult, without witnesses to prosecute cases involving underpayment of wages.

THIS weakens the laws that are designed to prevent it.

Eventually, since this law is not being enforced universally, it is put aside and then CITIZENS no longer have the protection they should have against unscrupulous employers.

That's the other 93.55~% of the population. Now, because all some people can think about is "Them brownies ain't got no right to have rights", NO ONE is protected and there is no minimum wage and your employer is no longer afraid that the government will take him to court if he doesn't pay you. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I still say if illegals weren't allowed to tap into our social service programs, they wouldn't come. The billions of dollars sent to Mexico is earned from these wages while the illegals, in part, live off social services. If this were not true, they could simply not afford to live here. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

I still say if illegals weren't allowed to tap into our social service programs,

Which social services? Legally, they are not allowed to do so.

Welfare, medicaide, medicare and all federal services are not available (LEGALLY) to undocumented immigrants.

Even legal immigrants don't have access to them for ten years.

There are, of course ways around that. But the ways around it are as often used by legal residents as they are by illegal.

People don't come here to get on the dole, they come here to find work that pays more than .25c a day.

In fact, according to the Social Security Administration, illegals pay into the system something akin to $9bn a year that they never take out.

And the vast majority of illegals pay proportionate taxes just like you and me. In fact,the IRS has been issuing "individual taxpayer identification numbers" (ITIN) for about 15 years now. MOST of those go to undocumented workers!

The IRS estimates that about 3/4 of all illegal pay taxes and social security. And will never see a benefit. (And that's fine with me, call it the cost of playing the game).

IF Illegals are a drain, it is because our systems are messed up. I can't find stats that I trust on it, numbers range for $30bn a year to $100bn a year...BOTH may be valid, but no one actually lists what they're counting.

I have to wonder if illegal immigration is akin to the war on drugs... do we spend more to prevent it than it would cost if we just let it go?

Some Articles:

NY Times

USA Today

There's a statement at the bottom of the USA Today article that is interesting:

"He [Ford, an economist] calculates that illegal immigrants contributed $428 billion dollars to the nation's $13.6 trillion gross domestic product in 2006. That number assumes illegal immigrants are 30% less productive than other workers.

"If anything we need more immigrants coming into the country, not less, especially with the baby boomers retiring," he said."


$428bn and 30% LESS productive.. if his numbers are true, imagine what these WORKING and self-sufficient people could do as citizens! Try $600bn in income for the government.

Seems to me that maybe some of these people should be offered citizenship, just like we did for the illegal Irish back in the 80's. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Welfare, medicaide, medicare and all federal services are not available (LEGALLY) to undocumented immigrants.


Someone posted the stats on fake ID's not long ago - If you want one, you can get one.

E-verify is here - why isn't it being used? 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

If you want one, you can get one.

That's true. Like the article say, on any particular street corner you can get a complete package deal for about $150.00 And they're used.

BUT, using your fake ID to get through the vetting that the social services do versus using one to just get a job washing dishes or picking fruit are NOT the same animal.

But do you really want Social Security to lose $9bn?

How about that $428bn to the GDP? 

Betty --- 16 years ago -

We have too many people here allready we are busting at the seems. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -


IF Illegals are a drain, it is because our systems are messed up. I can't find stats that I trust on it, numbers range for $30bn a year to $100bn a year...BOTH may be valid, but no one actually lists what they're counting.



Yeah, there are many opposing stats out there. Some say they're a benefit - sorry, ain't buyin' it.

Take into account the cost of birthing their babies. Then medical care for those babies..... and momma and papa and brothers & sisters to boot. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

But do you really want Social Security to lose $9bn?

I recently read an article about that too, but it showed less benefit than believed. I'll see if I can find it, but point being, at the end of the day they walk away receiving more than they bring to the table. A lot more.

My concern isn't so much for those already here. Well, it is, but I don't advocate rounding them up and busing them back.

I advocate using e-verify to weed out all those fake ID's and denying them services on ALL levels. It's the ONLY way to stem the future influx. I think we all agree we can't continue as we are. There is just no way. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

She also said that we all should get a fair wage and keep every penny we earn. Really? The government takes about half of every penny I make. How much of the undocumented workers money does the government take? 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

How much of the undocumented workers money does the government take?

That would depend on their income, refer to the tax tables.

It's the ONLY way to stem the future influx.


I dunno Sassy, I think that one way to actually stem the influx of illegals would be to have an effective legal immigration system. A LOT of people come here illegally because they are frustrated in dealing with INS. Some people have waited TEN YEARS for their paperwork to be processed.. that's insane.

E-Verify will only do so much though and there will be ways around it as well.

I'm not convinced of the costs. Not at all. Again, we're talking a little over 6% of the population, and 3/4 of those are paying in.

Again, if these people are costing us more, it's because we haven't come up with creative solutions and are instead beating our heads against the wall with old-school "keep them all out" thinking.

The reason we're "continuing as we are" is because people just don't come up with creative solutions to this sort of problem.

As far as Betty's assessment that we're "Bursting at the seams"... hogwash. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

A LOT of people come here illegally because they are frustrated in dealing with INS. Some people have waited TEN YEARS for their paperwork to be processed.. that's insane.


I agree, something needs to be changed on this front, but one reason we have immigration laws is because there's a limit. Otherwise, just open the flood gates and allow all who wish to come (and who doesn't wish to live in America?) do so - no questions asked.

I honestly doubt that America as a whole realizes the extent of the burden taking in Mexico's poor places on us. Our resources are limited. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Our resources are limited.


The next fight for resources will be water. Sounds insane it's going to happen. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

but one reason we have immigration laws is because there's a limit.

The trick is to actually balance that limit and not make it arbitrary. We don't do that now.

The next fight for resources will be water.

That's going to happen no matter what. It's not a function of OUR population, but population over all. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground