Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

KMS 6th grade punishment...

who's talking here?

june 1
cmi 1
planemom 4
FishinKim 1
lizandmike 1
qpc 1
gumbeauxgirl 1
porterswimmom 4
Mom's Taxi Service 2
Mabbers 17
AIL 1
goldfishdust 1
~sassy~ 1
Diamom 3
Princess 1
Perfection 2
Jrzygrl 1
Edith Mazure 2
POTUS 1
PHSMOMOF2 1
JusticeForAll 9
quiettype 4
crazymama87 4
mommie21g1b 6
Jack's Mom 2
elle 1
ebegirl 2
Puppydoglover 4
*Goatlady* 4
rachelakarachel 1
Hardshell- 1
cookie mom 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

crazymama87 --- 16 years ago -

Is anyone having problems with the discipline action taken on all 6th graders? I am having trouble understanding why they all are getting punished even if my child didn't do anything. I am not the kind of Mom who never thinks my kid does anything wrongbut I know she is a good kid and is very angry for getting in trouble for doing nothing. I already talked to AP and not much help. Not sure if anyone else was upset by this. Thanks! 

june --- 16 years ago -

I, too, used to get upset about this but then realized their theory behind the punishing everyone. At that age, kids respect peers more than adults, authority and if they are the reason all their friends have to do without priveleges they will more likely learn and not want to repeat the behavior. They would feel awful knowing their friends were punished because of them. 

rachelakarachel --- 16 years ago -

The entire sixth grade is being punished for what one child did? or a whole group of them? Things like this I would take on a case by case basis...I am curious to know what happened. 

elle --- 16 years ago -

Wait, what happened? 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Unless it was a majority of the class then I don't like this type of punishment. It bothered me as a child and it still does. Peer pressure never worked on the trouble makers in my class. To me it's a lazy ineffective way to discipline. 

FishinKim --- 16 years ago -

What happened? 

crazymama87 --- 16 years ago -

well from what I was told a few rowdy 6th graders were not keeping their lunch areas clean and they were lingering in the hallways and acting overall disrespectful. Not sure if they know who they are that were doing it or not. So they decided to have assigned seats at lunch. Some people were not really affected by this because they still sit near friends but my dd didn't get to be near her friends! So she is feeling like WTH? The schools solution was to give her a privledge card. Which allows her on FRIDAYS only on nice weather days she and a friend can eat out on the patio. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Yup. It's a pisser ain't it? Dh and I actually laughed though...assigned lunch seats? Bwahahahaha. Poor kids. NOT. Ds didn't do anything, but sometimes I enjoy someone else getting on their arses just because, ya know? Better get used to disappointments now. LOL. 

crazymama87 --- 16 years ago -

Well the problem we are having is that my dd wants to know what is the point of her behaving well if she gets punished anyway. Same thing happens in her classes Drama, P.E., Art etc. How do I tell her she should behave anyway when she gets punished anyway? I feel like this causes good kids to act up it doesn't discourage bad kids from doing anything they just feel like ha ha look what I did! I got the whole class in trouble! Not: CRAP I got in trouble! 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

I hear ya. Ds has had a few problems with some teachers. This zero tolerance thing can get WAY blown out of proportion. 

Diamom --- 16 years ago -

Heck- I wouldn't want to eat lunch w/o my friends 

Princess --- 16 years ago -

I have a 6th grader there too... he mentioned that the other day but didn't seem to be bothered by it so I didn't think anything else about it. 

Mom's Taxi Service --- 16 years ago -

KMS doesn't do a very good job of enforcing the whole "zero tolerance" thing - just ask the parents of the kids that are being threatened and bullied. (I know of FOUR, just in my daughter's grade that have gone to Counselors, Assistant Principals, etc. and NOTHING has been done). I agree that punishing the WHOLE 6th grade really isn't fair - but maybe it's a situation where it really got out of control and they're trying to send a message. I hope for your daughter, it is only temporary! I remember this happening to my daughter when she was in 5th grade - they kept it that way for about two weeks, then let them go back to normal. They were much more behaved after that and made A LOT less of a mess. I have a daughter at KMS as well (not in the 6th grade) and have seen far too many things go on there the last two years that just makes me want to scream! I just hope they can come up with a way to be strict and fair and actually resolve problems instead of ignoring them. (sorry for the rant on your thread) 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

And forget about asking questions in honors classes. They're told, "YOU SHOULD KNOW!" Lmao. Dh and I think some of these teachers shouldn't be teaching 6th grade as they think they're on a college campus. 

Jack's Mom --- 16 years ago -

I dont think it is all that bad of a thing. It goes back to the whole "life is not fair" thing that we grew up with. Sometimes Sh** happens and you have to move on. For some reason we have forgotten that school is for learning and that is what the rules are all about. I bet that once things calm down a bit they will be able to ease up and go back to normal but for now the powers that be have made a rule and I think as parents, we need to let our children know that we stand behind the authority figures who are over them. If people in this country did not feel so entitled I think we would be a lot better off. Sometimes we need to step back and say "it is what it is" to our kids and go on. They need to know that sometimes things do suck, they are not always fair, and we will get through it. JMO 

Puppydoglover --- 16 years ago -

some of these teachers shouldn't be teaching 6th grade as they think they're on a college campus I don't see anything wrong with pushing kids. They're usually capable if they apply themselves. I think it's great if they push them academically to exceed, it gives them confidence and should make their parents very proud. It can't hurt them. They are the future of this country, after all. JMO :) 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Absolutely Puppy, which is why I listen to him complain and then nicely say, "It's HER classroom. Do as you're told." LOL. We're huge proponents of a life-isn't-fair mentality. Suck it up bucko. Haha. 

Hardshell- --- 16 years ago -

Our daughter is a 6th grader at KMS and we've heard all about it...especially assigned seating at lunch....and her entire PE class being punished for the actions of a few.... But now she's sitting next to this little kid at lunch who keeps asking her to the dance on Saturday and she's totally annoyed....apparently when he first tried to ask her, he was nervous and kept stuttering.... and was interrupted by the bell....LOL... 

goldfishdust --- 16 years ago -

Assigned seating is a punishment? Aren't there some schools where no talking is allowed at lunch? 

Jack's Mom --- 16 years ago -

Assigned seating is a punishment? Aren't there some schools where no talking is allowed at lunch? I know I would LOVE to make it through a meal and I did not have to talk at all. LOL 

Jrzygrl --- 16 years ago -

I think it is a fair punishment. Life is not fair and that is just the way life goes. yes it sucks that a few kids mess it up, but that is how life is. It will happen the rest of their lives why not learn how to deal with it know. 

Puppydoglover --- 16 years ago -

You know, I don't think assigned seating is a bad thing. It breaks up cliques and gangs. Might cause two people to become friends who might not have before. I cannot see a bad thing about it. It's odd at first for the kids, but I think it gives them a chance to "mingle" so to speak. It's good for them. Maybe they should change the seating arrangements every month. They get a chance to meet new people. I think we are not in schools anymore, we all should know school is NOT the way it was when we were in school. The schools have these rules for a reason and I think parents should support them for trying to do the right thing. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

What happens down the road when your boss assigns you to a team with people you detest? LOL. We're constantly bombarded with daily struggles which our kids need to be prepared for. Period. We've all had teachers we've despised...even in college. It never ends and the sooner they can deal with dilemmas, the better for all of us. 

Diamom --- 16 years ago -

This bothers me b/c lunch is these kids only break during the day. Every adult worker gets a break, state law. Even when you work with people you hate you are able to go to your desk or office away from them & you are not required to eat lunch with them every day. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 16 years ago -

some of these teachers shouldn't be teaching 6th grade as they think they're on a college campus Stop complaining.. Start now to enforce rules on these kids and maybe they will learn something. Life isnt not fair and they need to know that. Stop trying to baby them. The schools have these rules for a reason and I think parents should support them for trying to do the right thing.  

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Hell I wish they'd bring back corporal punishment and simply beat the bullies back down. Bring some FEAR back to the campus. LOL. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Stop complaining.. Start now to enforce rules on these kids and maybe they will learn something. Eh, hash up. If you read my other posts, you'd see that's exactly what I do. LOL. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

lmao..."hash up".... I think punishing everyone at lunch is a bummer, but at the same time, maybe sitting by kids you don't know is an opportunity to meet new people and make new friends! I'd tell my child to make the best of it and try to see the positive side. :) 

quiettype --- 16 years ago -

Every adult worker gets a break, state law. Sorry to burst your bubble but there is no law in Texas that requires employers to provide breaks to employees unless they are under a certain age. Same for Federal laws. There are some states that do this but Texas is not one of them...yet. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Call the news. I can't believe they are forcing children to talk to other people and not sit with their friends. How dare they try to teach children to open up to others. I'm SHOCKED 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Every adult worker gets a break, state law. What State? 

cmi --- 16 years ago -

Seating charts are not a form of punishment. They are a form of control that is sometimes necessary in schools. Do you all consider seating charts in the classroom discipline.....because they are often automatic from the first day of school. They tried lunches the free way and had issues. The solution (not punishment) was a seating chart. 

quiettype --- 16 years ago -

I know Tennesee and California for sure, I'm sure there are others. 

quiettype --- 16 years ago -

One of my favorite sayings to my girls...mama never told you life was fair! 

Diamom --- 16 years ago -

State law mandates a break for persons working a certain number of hours in the day. The amount of time alloted for the break is based on the number of hours working in a day. This was Texas state law when I was a hourly employee in college. 

crazymama87 --- 16 years ago -

Life isn't fair and I tell that to my kids all the time. I understand needing to have control of the situation but like diamom said lunch is the only time they have free time to talk to their friends, she needs that outlet. She doesn't talk in class she will sit and read quietly and respectfully until the other kids finish working in class if she finishes her work early. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

In middle school lunch is the social outlet of the day. For some kids this is the only time during the day they see their friends. It is a big deal when they can't sit by them. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Beat the bullies down so the kids can have lunch back.  

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

I'm surprised so many adults are upset by this! Yes, it is "social" time, but, what's wrong with making new friends? I know when I've been in situations alone or a different schedule than my friends were on at work or a convention or whatever, I just made the best of it and struck up a conversation with whomever I was seated with...I've never had a problem doing that, and I certainly would encourage my child to do the same! Try to look at it from a POSITIVE perspective instead of feeling like the school is being unfair... Do you think they should change the policy because some of the kids are having a hard time with this? What do you think is a better solution to the problem of unorderly lunch time? 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

What do you think is a better solution to the problem of unorderly lunch time? I'm telling ya...swats. LOL. BIG, FAT, OUCHIE WAH WAH'S. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground