Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Can we have a real conversation about LGBT? If so, AMA (Ask Me Anything)

who's talking here?

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 1
wayward1 5
SoupIsGoodFood 3
Red Heifer 1
Holling Vincoeur 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
RedMulch 3
*LOL* 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
Dorothy Parker 3
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
Joe Blow 3
Froggie 1
sheddy 5
DatBoyHooD 5
Hot Dog Diarrhea 1
Four Pinocchios 1
Emperor of Kingwood 14
Judas 2
a889324uu 9
Prolix Raconteur 1
Leila 1
mutton 7
AMDG 5
them 1
Barnstormer 1
ugly yapper dog 1
Zapper009 1
JuanSequin 2
fuzz81 13
Pixtor 1
Karras 10
AprilMayNovember 20

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AprilMayNovember --- 10 years ago -

I don't see any trans or generally other LGB people on here. I do see some arguing, sprinkled with some community gossip and some truly helpful neighbors every once in a while. So, for anyone that's interested in a real conversation on the topic, I am an open book.

Let's try to not spew useless banter about hell etc, because that's between me and my higher power, should I choose to believe anyway (I do, by choice). Please respect my personal choices, as I respect yours. If asked, I am willing to discuss that topic in a friendly manner, and how it pertains to my life.

I am a trans woman, which means I was assigned male at birth (referred to as AMAB in the trans community). I am 40, educated at A&M, a jack of all trades, master of none. I can weld, I know the biologies, I know technology very well. I can assemble anything, and make half of the parts myself. I am a true tomboy.

I started my journey 2 years ago, consciously. In actuality, if I wasn't being beaten and even choked over feminine qualities as a child/teenager, I probably would have grown up a woman. Instead, I hid within myself and became an alpha-male type to survive.

I am officially diagnosed as trans, and on hormone replacement therapy. I have two kids. I am divorced, and we are still friends and a team for our children.

Please try to understand that I am not Caitlyn Jenner and do not wish to be compared to a filthy-rich trans woman who seemingly came out overnight. Our typical lives are not nearly as glamorous.

Trans women are not escorts. Sometimes it seems that most men assume we are. Not to say that doesn't exist, but that also exists in every other category of gender or race. To be honest, when we go on hormone replacement therapy (HRT), our libidos typically take a serious dive. I know mine did. I prefer it, though. There is much less distraction in my life without that internal nagging. I sleep better. I am able to concentrate. A naked woman could be dancing in front of me and I can simply ignore it.

..this brings me to orientation. This is a biggie for some. When a trans woman is attracted to women, she is a lesbian. If she is attracted to men, she is straight. Please try to understand, beyond biology and genetics, that despite the equipment below the belt, a woman is a woman and a man is a man.

I already know that is going to bring up all kinds of irritation and misunderstanding. So, to the horror of someone I am sure, I have used women's restrooms. Ladies, do YOU want to stand next to some random dude taking a pee? Me either. Nor do I want to stand. Or splash all over the toilet. I just want to pee in peace, and maybe touch up my makeup and fix my hair. This all goes over so well in the men's room, of course.

I would really prefer not to talk politics. Really.

So, that is my start. I am not an internet troll or weirdo. If you are curious, ask me anything. I am not sure what to expect, so please try to keep the anger to a minimum, or I'll be forced to come back under a new account and remain in hiding, which is actually pretty lame, in my opinion. 

them --- 10 years ago -

How do you know there are no trans people here? 

AprilMayNovember --- 10 years ago -

I don't. There probably are, but I don't see them being vocal. I just figured maybe I could answer some questions on the topic, and I'm feeling brave tonight. :D 

mutton --- 10 years ago -

I have no issues either way. Pretty sure have shared bathrooms with one who is, but never knew, lol. At the end of the day, i never knew it was such a problem once I understood the true argument. Be true April, if you are for real. 

AprilMayNovember --- 10 years ago -

Thank you mutton. I am real, very real.

I "pass" as a woman mostly when I present as female (I'm still in that awkward stage between). When presenting as male, I often get looks as people size me up, but once they hit my eyes they usually back off. I am not afraid of people, I am afraid of ridicule. I shouldn't be, but those years of teasing before I took charge have taken a small toll on me. 

AprilMayNovember --- 10 years ago -

The hard part is for women who don't "pass". They are the ones that must endure the crap the world has to offer them. 

AprilMayNovember --- 10 years ago -

Heading to bed. Will pick this up in the morning if I have time, otherwise after work. Night folks. 

Leila --- 10 years ago -

I don't see the need for a conversation. People are just people. If your character is good, I am not interested in where or how you go to the bathroom. People that have strong feeling about the issue are probably not going to be influenced by someone on the internet anyway.

Perhaps if they had a family member or a friend with a child dealing with this they might view things differently but it isn't really up to me to try to convince someone that my views are right and theirs are wrong unless they were harassing or mistreating someone.

I think most people are just too busy keeping up with their own lives and families to spend much energy on someone else's. But that is just my view based on my experiences and those of my friends. 

Froggie --- 10 years ago -

April, my heart breaks for you and the struggle you have and will have to endure. I wish you peace, love, and serenity. That had to take some major jewels to post your struggles here. 

AprilMayNovember --- 10 years ago -

Leila, I decided to do this topic when I hit the "disgusting LGBT monument" thread. I believe you are correct, if people had someone close to them that found out they were trans, they would be confronted with the same issues all LGBT people deal with on a daily basis. It shattered my world, but I am glad now that it happened. I experience so much peace, just simple peace, now. I miss my kids terribly and I'm not going to say I haven't fallen into walls in tears, but I do get to see them every week. There are people that work offshore etc that don't get to do that, so perspective helps.

Froggie, thank you. I am a strong woman, fortunately, so I will survive and thrive eventually. I feel like I'm just existing right now, because I'm still recovering from the move, the divorce, child support, etc. I have 85 dollars in my checking account until next Friday. I had some debts to pay off, one of which was my ex's, but since it was on my card, I got to keep it (sarcastic smile :)).

Since I'm getting ready for work, I'll mention this: I am between names. I go by April when I can, but I have a birth name I go by as well, due to familiarity at work, etc. I do not hate my name, but psychologically I do not really associate with that name any more, so when people call me that, or "dude", "sir" etc, I flinch a bit. I take it like one would suck air through their teeth and shake it off if they got popped with a rubber band on their wrist. It's not an insult (yet) as I am aware that while everyone at work knows of my status, I do not look female completely. I deal with it. It's like having a childhood nickname that you absolutely hated, and having some old school bully from years ago still calling you that at work. Yeah, kinda like that. A coworker and friend asked me what I prefer, and after some thought I realized that actually, when I am at work, and sometimes not, I associate myself as literally nameless. As in, I don't even have a name right now. It's that fundamental.

Alright, got to finish getting dressed. I'll check in after work. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

You are still male. You can't change your DNA. Just because you've had some surgery and taken hormones doesn't make you female. 

Red Heifer --- 10 years ago -

Good for you, AMN. Peace. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

AMN - my 2 cents - probably worth exactly that.

There is a major difference between ridicule, discrimination, and acceptance. No one should personally ridicule anyone for these kind of choices. No one should have to face ridicule in any kind over this life choice.

No one should be denied any kind of civil liberty over this lifestyle choice, and a secular government should protect your rights. The bathroom issue, which is a tad ridiculous in my opinion, is an issue of competing rights. The other people who will be using the bathroom with you, also have rights. It is an equally valid right not to want to share the rest room with someone biologically different than you. Competing rights are always sticky issues. To me the right answer is don't ask, don't tell. Done discreetly, no one would probably know the difference, or care.

However, I can not accept your path as a life choice. For some who think like me it would be tantamount to denying some very deeply held beliefs. I feel the same exact way about divorce, adultery, and all kind of other sinful choices. This is not in anyway a judgment on the person, just on the actions. I also make no distinction between your life choice which I feel is sinful, and the bunch of sinful life choices I have made, and will make in the future.

My job, as I see it, is to not judge, to love as I would love myself, and as my Jesuit friends would say, to proceed along with you. My job is also to speak my truth, that your choice is wrong, and acceptance of it would be a denial of who I am, and what I believe to be true. 

wayward1 --- 10 years ago -

This is not in anyway a judgment on the person, just on the actions.

If AMN (and those like him/her) took NO actions, they would still be gay.

They would be single, celibate gay people and still probably not accepted into society.

Unless of course, they were wearing holy orders ;) 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Wayward - it is about what you do. ( some of my protestant friends may disagree with that). We all have sinful tendencies and desires, it is what you do about that counts.

Someone who struggles with fidelity is not unfaithful unless they act on it. People with tendencies of dishonesty are not dishonest until they act on it. People with desires to harm others to advance themselves are not sinners until they act on it.

The desires are not sinful by themselves, they are an evil that exists in the world, it is what we do that matters.

There is no judgment here - we are all sinners and we all have out temptations. And we have all succumbed to them. 

wayward1 --- 10 years ago -

The desires are not sinful by themselves, they are an evil that exists in the world, it is what we do that matters.

I totally agree and understand this point.
Gay people who don't act on it. Who take no actions. Who don't give into the sinful desires of the world - are still gay. And will still be viewed as outsiders. If someone says, "I'm gay, but don't worry, I don't act upon it," most people are going to judge them. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

. And will still be viewed as outsiders. If someone says, "I'm gay, but don't worry, I don't act upon it," most people are going to judge them.

Then, those who view them as outsiders and judge them are giving into an evil temptation as well. Their actions, IMO, are sinful. 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

Sorry that you are trans. Society has let you and thousands others down by not helping you with your mental disorder.

Here is a story about a boy who thinks he's a girl and he and his parents are demanding, through title IX, that he be allowed to shower with girls at the high school. As you can imagine, these girls do not want a biological boy to shower with them. Shouldn't those girls, some as young as 14, allowed to have their privacy?

In my opinion, you can go into the bathroom when you have went all the way with the surgeries.

"A group of 50 families whose children attend a high school in Illinois filed a federal lawsuit Wednesday, attempting to reverse a policy that allows a transgender student to use girls? bathrooms, locker rooms, and other sex-specific facilities.

The families are challenging a policy at Township High School District 211 that was mandated by the U.S. Department of Education to accommodate the transgender student, who was born male but identifies as a female.

?It?s an organic group of parents and students who came together and said, ?We have to do something about this?we can?t just roll over and allow the federal government to force our school to commingle the sexes in locker rooms,?? said Jeremy Tedesco, a lawyer representing the families.

The suit, which challenges the Education Department?s authority to redefine the term sex in Title IX of U.S. law to include gender identity and to enforce it against schools, is the first of its kind, Tedesco told The Daily Signal.

The president of the group filing the lawsuit, Students and Parents for Privacy, said she and other Cook County parents with children in the school district decided legal action ?was the only thing we could do at this point.?

?We tried,? she said, adding:

We did everything we could to work with the school district, and we were really hoping they would do the right thing and protect the privacy of all students, but when they chose not to, we felt we had no choice in order to protect the girls in the locker room.

The group?s president asked that her name not be published because of the sensitive nature of the case.

The issue began in December 2013, when Student A filed a complaint with the Education Department against Township High School District 211, based in the village of Palatine, Ill.

The complaint alleged that District 211 had discriminated against the transgender student on the basis of sex.

After completing an extensive investigation, the Education Department?s Office of Civil Rights said on Dec. 2 that Township High School District 211 was in violation of federal law for refusing to grant Student A full access to the girls? locker room.

The school had granted Student A some accommodations, including changing the student?s name on official records, allowing the student on the girls sports teams, and granting the student access to the girls? bathrooms. But District 211 drew the line at providing Student A unrestrained access to the girls? locker rooms because of the privacy concerns of other girls using them. Instead, the school offered a private facility to Student A.

Daniel Cates, superintendent of District 211, said in an October newsletter:

The goal of the district in this matter is to protect the privacy rights of all students when changing clothes or showering before or after physical education and after-school activities, while also providing reasonable accommodations to meet the unique needs of individual students. Our responsibility is to provide an environment conducive to learning for all its 12,000+ students.

According to the Education Department?s investigation, the student felt ?crushed? by the school district?s decision not to allow access to the locker rooms, ?which she said indicated that the school did not accept her as a female.?

After the Education Department had completed its investigation, it ordered District 211 to grant Student A full access to the girls? locker rooms and install privacy curtains inside those locker rooms, or else be at risk of losing federal financial assistance.

Thomas Petersen, director of community relations at Township High School District 211, said the school ?could potentially lose up to $6 million in federal funding.?

Now, the 130 parents and students who are members of the group Students and Parents for Privacy are suing, arguing the Education Department lacks the authority to redefine sex in Title IX of U.S. law to include gender identity.

The parents and students also are asking for an injunction against the Justice Department, which has enforcement authority under Title IX, and an injunction against Township School District 211 from carrying out the Education Department?s demands.

The Christian legal aid group Alliance Defending Freedom is representing the parents and students, along with local support from lawyers at the Thomas More Society.

?What we?re attempting to do in this case is stop the Department of Education from redefining sex in Title IX to include gender identity,? Tedesco, senior counsel for Alliance Defending Freedom, told The Daily Signal. ?It has no authority whatsoever to do that.?

Debate Over Title IX

Title IX is the federal law that bans discrimination on the basis of sex in any federally funded education program. Whether or not Title IX applies to transgender students is an issue that has been vigorously debated, with courts ruling on both sides.

Most recently, a federal appeals court in Richmond, Va., ruled that a transgender high school student who was born female but identifies as a male has the right to pursue discrimination charges against a school district for blocking access to the boys? bathrooms.

The judges of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit cited the Obama administration?s interpretation of Title IX in issuing their 2-1 decision.

The Obama administration stated in a 2014 document that ?Title IX?s sex discrimination prohibition extends to claims of discrimination.?

Tedesco called the ruling in Virginia a ?complete outlier,? arguing that other courts have ruled the opposite way:

There?s been several courts that have addressed the question of whether Title IX applies to and protects against gender identity discrimination, and all those courts up to the 4th Circuit?s decision have said it does not.

If Americans want to add additional protections for gender identity, Tedesco said, it?s the job of Congress?not the Education Department?to make those changes. He said:

If Congress wants to redefine sex to include gender identity?if they want to add gender identity as a protected class under Title IX?they can do that through the regular lawmaking process. But Congress has rejected it several times, so the Department of Education just comes in and makes it up and adds it to the law. That?s something they have no authority whatsoever to do. And now they?re running around the country and forcing essentially what is a new Department of Education rule against schools across the country.

Since 2010, Sen. Al Franken, D-Minn., has proposed that Congress pass a measure that would provide protections for students from discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and gender identity. Thus far, that legislation has failed.

Township High School District 211 is the first school in the nation that the Education Department found in violation of Title IX over transgender issues. Now, it?s the first school in the country to face a lawsuit of this kind.

The Path Forward

In December, six female students attempted to explain to the District 211 school board why they were uncomfortable with allowing Student A into their locker room.

?Although we will never fully understand your personal struggle,? the girls said, addressing the transgender student, ?please understand that we, too, all are experiencing personal struggles that need to be respected.?

>>> Why These High School Girls Don?t Want a Transgender Student in Their Locker Room

The president of Students and Parents for Privacy said she supports accommodations for Student A that balance the student?s interests with the rest of the student body.

?We understand why Student A doesn?t want to be in the boys? locker room,? she said. ?We get it. But the girls? locker room isn?t the answer either. We believe in accommodation, but we don?t believe in an accommodation that hurts other students.?

Student A, who is represented by the American Civil Liberties Union, said in an earlier press release that using a separate locker room ?stigmatized me, often making me feel like I was not a ?normal person.??

At the December school board meeting, one speaker called the old policy ?institutionalized segregation.? Others brought up the high rates of suicide and depression for transgender men and women.

The head of the privacy group, who has children in the school district, said the group cares about Student A but is asking for fairness. She said:


We truly do care about these children who struggle with gender identity, and these children are welcome in my home. All I ask is that the respect go both ways. That?s what we?re not seeing. We?re just seeing demands.

20150504_Ds_quote_ARTICLE_parents-for-privacy-1

The lawsuit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, hinges on the idea that the school can and should make accommodations for Student A, but those accommodations shouldn?t violate the privacy and safety rights of other students.

Absent the lawsuit, Tedesco suggested, there?s little chance of finding middle ground.

?The reality is, the folks driving this agenda on the other side from us won?t accept anything other than full access to the opposite-sex restroom and locker room as the solution,? the families? lawyer said, adding:


And what happened at District 211 is proof positive of that. They gave Student A accommodation after accommodation after accommodation, and ultimately the [Education Department] said no, full access is the only thing that?s going to solve the issue. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Rage on karass. How compassionate and big of you. Someone tries to have an actual convo about the subject, and you just copy/paste some garbage. pathetic. 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 10 years ago -

Good for you, April. It took a lot of guts to get on here and say what you did. I'm sorry some of the responses are less than kind.

If you are happy in your skin, that's all that matters. No one's opinions of you count aside from your own. You seem to be happy and confident. Keep up the good work. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

Society has let you and thousands others down by not helping you with your mental disorder.


^^^^ THAT ^^^^ 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Good for you, April. It took a lot of guts to get on here and say what you did. I'm sorry some of the responses are less than kind.

If you are happy in your skin, that's all that matters. No one's opinions of you count aside from your own. You seem to be happy and confident. Keep up the good work.?


^^^ that ^^^ 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

Rage on karass. How compassionate and big of you. Someone tries to have an actual convo about the subject, and you just copy/paste some garbage. pathetic.

He said to ask him anything, so I did. Sometimes the left have no idea the damage they are doing to society by taking the side of the gender identity crowd. This article points out the harm to the children (remember them or is it only convenient to talk about the children when they are hopping the border or for school funding) 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Society has let you and thousands others down by not helping you with your mental disorder.


^^^^ THAT ^^^^?


Is this a call for help soup? The first step is admitting your problems. We can find someone for you to call if you need help. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

He said to ask him anything, so I did. Sometimes the left have no idea the damage they are doing to society by taking the side of the gender identity crowd. This article points out the harm to the children (remember them or is it only convenient to talk about the children when they are hopping the border or for school funding)?

You didn't ask him anything. You told him he has a mental disorder, and pasted something from your right wing nut job sites that feeds your fear and shapes your stupidity.

How about an apology? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

Is this a call for help soup?

Is your response to my post a call for help, fuzzy? 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Good one bro 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

Apologize for what?

Here is my question:
Here is a story about a boy who thinks he's a girl and he and his parents are demanding, through title IX, that he be allowed to shower with girls at the high school. As you can imagine, these girls do not want a biological boy to shower with them. Shouldn't those girls, some as young as 14, allowed to have their privacy?

Yes, it is a mental disorder. It would be the same if he thought he was a monkey. But I suppose you think transpecies is normal. 

Judas --- 10 years ago -

Emperor, Soup for Brains, Karras, you are the bigots here who can't accept anything or anyone who doesn't think exactly as you do. People like you make this world a sad place.

I hope you rot. 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

Fuzz why do you use three different alts? Fuzz in the morning, then Judas or Joe Blow in the afternoon? 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

who can't accept anything or anyone who doesn't think exactly as you do

Actually, you are describing yourself and all libs. I don't see conservatives trying to stop Hillary or Bernie from speaking at rally's. 

Judas --- 10 years ago -

Sorry that you are trans. Society has let you and thousands others down by not helping you with your mental disorder. -Karras showing their true, bigoted self for the world to see 

Hot Dog Diarrhea --- 10 years ago -

You can be what ever you want but you will forever be biologically male. It'll be hard to change those XY chromosomes to XX chromosomes 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

you are the bigots here who can't accept anything or anyone who doesn't think exactly as you do.

How does not being able to change your DNA make anyone a bigot? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

You can be what ever you want but you will forever be biologically male. It'll be hard to change those XY chromosomes to XX chromosomes

Exactly. A man that surgically removes his penis isn't a woman, he's a man that removed his penis. 

wayward1 --- 10 years ago -

Dwight: I don't need them. Superior genes. I'm a Schrute. And superior brain power. Through concentration, I can raise and lower my cholesterol at will.

Pam: Why would you want to raise your cholesterol?

Dwight: So I can lower it. 

RedMulch --- 10 years ago -

I recently heard some advice that put an end to my struggle on this subject.

"Don't judge anyone because they sin differently than you do"

I take that to heart and have been at peace with the LGBT issue ever since. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Fuzz why do you use three different alts? Fuzz in the morning, then Judas or Joe Blow in the afternoon

I have zero alts. Nada. None.

Get a clue karass. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

"Don't judge anyone because they sin differently than you do"

But I have a right to my opinion, the right to articulate it and the right to try and shape my government and its laws as I see fit. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

the right to try and shape my government and its laws as I see fit

How's that working out? Lol 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground