Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Analysis of election factors points to Romney win, University of Colorado study says

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
maverick 2
wayward1 2
AuthorMan 1
ladybeachbum 1
SoupIsGoodFood 2
Perfection 1
AngieKaye 1
RiteWingKing 20
Agent of Change 2
Hiro Protagonist 1
voice of reason 3
AwesomeTattooedDragon 3
JohnLynch 8
TexasOma 1
RedMulch 2
truthmiser 2
Dr Aborto 2
Work in Progress 4
SlateRiver 1
Dorothy Parker 1
IrvingShwartz 3
justforfun1 2
Nightshade 8
txsassy 3
SmoochieAndTheBean 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

August 22, 2012 •

A University of Colorado analysis of state-by-state factors leading to the Electoral College selection of every U.S. president since 1980 forecasts that the 2012 winner will be Mitt Romney.

The key is the economy, say political science professors Kenneth Bickers of CU-Boulder and Michael Berry of CU Denver. Their prediction model stresses economic data from the 50 states and the District of Columbia, including both state and national unemployment figures as well as changes in real per capita income, among other factors.

“Based on our forecasting model, it becomes clear that the president is in electoral trouble,” said Bickers, also director of the CU in DC Internship Program.

According to their analysis, President Barack Obama will win 218 votes in the Electoral College, short of the 270 he needs. And though they chiefly focus on the Electoral College, the political scientists predict Romney will win 52.9 percent of the popular vote to Obama’s 47.1 percent, when considering only the two major political parties.

“For the last eight presidential elections, this model has correctly predicted the winner,” said Berry. “The economy has seen some improvement since President Obama took office. What remains to be seen is whether voters will consider the economy in relative or absolute terms. If it’s the former, the president may receive credit for the economy’s trajectory and win a second term. In the latter case, Romney should pick up a number of states Obama won in 2008.”

Their model correctly predicted all elections since 1980, including two years when independent candidates ran strongly, 1980 and 1992. It also correctly predicted the outcome in 2000, when Al Gore received the most popular vote but George W. Bush won the election.

The study will be published this month in PS: Political Science & Politics, a peer-reviewed journal of the American Political Science Association. It will be among about a dozen election prediction models, but one of only two to focus on the Electoral College.

While many forecast models are based on the popular vote, the Electoral College model developed by Bickers and Berry is the only one of its type to include more than one state-level measure of economic conditions.

In addition to state and national unemployment rates, the authors looked at per capita income, which indicates the extent to which people have more or less disposable income. Research shows that these two factors affect the major parties differently: Voters hold Democrats more responsible for unemployment rates while Republicans are held more responsible for per capita income.

Accordingly -- and depending largely on which party is in the White House at the time -- each factor can either help or hurt the major parties disproportionately.

Their results show that “the apparent advantage of being a Democratic candidate and holding the White House disappears when the national unemployment rate hits 5.6 percent,” Berry said. The results indicate, according to Bickers, “that the incumbency advantage enjoyed by President Obama, though statistically significant, is not great enough to offset high rates of unemployment currently experienced in many of the states.”

In an examination of other factors, the authors found that none of the following had any statistically significant effect on whether a state ultimately went for a particular candidate: The location of a party’s national convention; the home state of the vice president; or the partisanship of state governors.

In 2012, “What is striking about our state-level economic indicator forecast is the expectation that Obama will lose almost all of the states currently considered as swing states, including North Carolina, Virginia, New Hampshire, Colorado, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Pennsylvania, Ohio and Florida,” Bickers said.

In Colorado, which went for Obama in 2008, the model predicts that Romney will receive 51.9 percent of the vote to Obama’s 48.1 percent, again with only the two major parties considered.

The authors also provided caveats. Factors they said may affect their prediction include the timeframe of the economic data used in the study and close tallies in certain states. The current data was taken five months in advance of the Nov. 6 election and they plan to update it with more current economic data in September. A second factor is that states very close to a 50-50 split may fall an unexpected direction.

“As scholars and pundits well know, each election has unique elements that could lead one or more states to behave in ways in a particular election that the model is unable to correctly predict,” Berry said.

Election prediction models “suggest that presidential elections are about big things and the stewardship of the national economy,” Bickers said. “It’s not about gaffes, political commercials or day-to-day campaign tactics. I find that heartening for our democracy.” 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

Bo had his chance and screwed up so now it's time for someone else who will actually do something. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

I've been saying he's going to win all along. The pubs hate Obama way beyond the will of the dems to support him. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

I have been to the polls and pulled the lever at the last minute for someone else. I think when people get to the polls they will have one opinion but when it comes down to it they will vote for the best person. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

It's clear that Romney is ahead. You can tell that the media doesn't really even have the heart for Obama anymore. The love affair is over.

I think the only thing that would cause an Obama win now is a huge scandal to break with the pubs in late September. And I'm sure that the dems are combing through every bit of life history on Romney and Ryan in an attempt to either find one, or fabricate one. 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

(secretly whispering, rubbing my rubbing my palms while reading these posts)
he he he. November is gonna be even sweeter than I thought. he he he. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

lol, what nefarious plan do you have to get Obama voted in?

Or will he just be proclaiming himself dictator around that time? 

wayward1 --- 14 years ago -

Or will he just be proclaiming himself dictator around that time? 

It could happen! Luckily we a brave judge in Lubbock ready to stand in front of the UN armored personnel carriers if it happens. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Luckily we a brave judge in Lubbock ready to stand in front of the UN armored personnel carriers if it happens.

I'm not familiar with this reference. . .what's the story? 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

ol, what nefarious plan do you have to get Obama voted in?

Nothing. He's gonna win fair and square. I just think you guys are in this far right bubble that isn't really the way most of America really thinks. If the poll numbers were swapped, I would be nervous but they're not. 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

Do you who say it's over for Obama not believe the polls in the battleground states?

When Obama is actually leading and you guys make these statementsIt's clear that Romney is ahead. You can tell that the media doesn't really even have the heart for Obama anymore. The love affair is over.and you wonder why many think you guys fell on your head? 

wayward1 --- 14 years ago -

I'm not familiar with this reference. . .what's the story? 

It was in the news yesterday about a judge who actually thinks Obama will become a dictator. 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

It was in the news yesterday about a judge who actually thinks Obama will become a dictator.

And guess where the nutjob is from? You'd never guess.

I'll give you a clue....

unscramble this- escesions 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

and you wonder why many think you guys fell on your head?

I didn't fall on my head. I just have more faith in the American people not to be stupid enough to vote for Obama again. 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

I just have more faith in the American people not to be stupid enough

So when Obama is elected would you agree that faith is valueless? 

maverick --- 14 years ago -

A scientific model that has been proven since 1980 - that would be 7 out of 7 elections. Sounds fairly reliable. Yet the the libs cant believe it - guess they hate science. 

maverick --- 14 years ago -

Polls have been proven wrong time and time again, mostly because they are skewed one way or another. This study has been proven accurate for 28 years. I'll go with this study. 

AuthorMan --- 14 years ago -

Check the only reliable, thorough source:

Vegas! 

RedMulch --- 14 years ago -

I can't wait for KU on election night.....i'm taking the next day off so i can stay up til we have a victory. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

I'm worried that Obama will win...and it would be because of the women's votes- 

RedMulch --- 14 years ago -

I'm worried that Obama will win...and it would be because of the women's votes-

Don't put women down like that..... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

Mulchie, if Romney wins, we have a date to buy some expensive champagne, and celebrate!!! 

Agent of Change --- 14 years ago -

A scientific model that has been proven since 1980 - that would be 7 out of 7 elections. Sounds fairly reliable. Yet the the libs cant believe it - guess they hate science.


Nate Silver who is the gold standard so far as election polling/statistics go, tweeted this last night regarding these professors predictions:

--A Denver Post reporter asked me (bit.ly/MNOF1C) about this U. of Colorado election model (bit.ly/O7pN4I). (1/5)

---It's late, so I'll be blunt: I saw their paper and I think there are glaring problems with their methodology. (2/5)

---The U. of Colo. model fits the equivalent of 7 unknowns to 8 elections. That's not a good idea. (3/5)

----The Colo. model also assumes huge effects from unemployment if incumbent is a Dem., but none if he's GOP. Hard claim to defend. (4/5)

---If you want a "fundamentals" model that shows Romney winning, the Hibbs model is a lot more sensible. bit.ly/SqgfnH (5/5)

---Also, it's false advertising to claim CU model has predicted the last 8 elections right. It's a new model. Hasn't predicted anything yet. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Also, it's false advertising to claim CU model has predicted the last 8 elections right. It's a new model. Hasn't predicted anything yet. 

false statement...not a new model 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

I'm worried that Obama will win...and it would be because of the women's votes-


the doofus remarks the pubies have been coming out with lately regarding rape are not going to get the intelligent women's vote. face facts mulch. 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

false statement...not a new model


actually you are WRONG. it is a new model. was just reading that berry admits it himself: 'Our model was developed after the 2008 election. The only election that we forecast is the 2012 election.' 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

I just think you guys are in this far right bubble

Speak up. I can't hear you from inside your far left bubble. 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

no new material yet tickets? yawny yawn yawn stretch 

SmoochieAndTheBean --- 14 years ago -

I'm worried that Obama will win...and it would be because of the women's votes-

Not from this woman!! I would NEVER vote for Obama. I'd rather saw off my own foot. 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -

Not from this woman!! I would NEVER vote for Obama. I'd rather saw off my own foot.



Same here and for all the women I know. I cannot think of a single person in my circle of friends who would even consider voting for Obama. One couple voted for him in 08, but even they are disappointed in what he has done to our country. 

whatchamacallit --- 14 years ago -

Part of me wishes they would not spread all this info. I wonder if it won't make some people let their guard down and they won't be as adamant about reminding like minded people to vote and even that they may just think it will be ok without them having to go to the polls on election day! 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Hasn't predicted anything yet.

so now a forecast isn't a prediction?...i think someone needs to visit with a dictionary


actually you are WRONG.

nope...YOU are wrong 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

Same here and for all the women I know. I cannot think of a single person in my circle of friends who would even consider voting for Obama. One couple voted for him in 08, but even they are disappointed in what he has done to our country.


Of course no one in your circle of friends. We live in a red state and a red area. sheesh. It's like 90% republican here.

As for you, JohnLynch, I used the google on 'Our model was developed after the 2008 election. The only election that we forecast is the 2012 election.' Lo and behold, looky what I found.

But everyone here already knows that you can never admit when you are wrong. Your loss. 

AngieKaye --- 14 years ago -

Of course no one in your circle of friends. We live in a red state and a red area. sheesh. It's like 90% republican here.


if this is correct then why does Houston always vote democratic for mayor and most offices of harris county???? Just asking.. can't be a total red state if we have liberals voting more than republicans. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

But everyone here already knows that you can never admit when you are wrong.

so i guess that you consider something developed in 2009 to be new?...then i've got a 2010 car that i'll sell to you at the "new" car price 

SlateRiver --- 14 years ago -

Electoral College Model Predicts Romney Will Win Big in 2012 (And It’s Been Right Since 1980)

0 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

If you really want a Romney/Ryan win then we need to help in the swing states. Make calls, donate to those areas, help those areas spread the education.

This election is coming down to a relatively small number of people in swing states and withing those states swing counties. That's where help is needed. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

The plus side to Romney winning: Conservative blowhards talking out of both sides of their face when they realize nothing will change under Romney's watch.

The plus side of Obama winning: Womens rights being taken into consideration and not going backwards in time to 1890.

Honestly, I don't think it really matters who wins, nothing will change. We'll have the same division in Congress and the same division amongst the US citizens.

No real winners either way. 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

so i guess that you consider something developed in 2009 to be new?...then i've got a 2010 car that i'll sell to you at the "new" car price


It is a product that pertains to a presidential election which is every four years.

We weren't debating if it was brand spanking new in that sense but, rather, in relation to the number of presidential election cycles it's been used on.

Common sense. 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

The plus side of Obama winning: Womens rights being taken into consideration and not going backwards in time to 1890.


The conservatives may then screw around with women's rights but at least Roe v Wade won't ever get reversed. NFW. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground