Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: If your child were going to die without care should the govt stay out of it??

who's talking here?

ToidBoid 1
JDB2 2
Tylers Journey 1
SoupIsGoodFood 7
rEVOLution 8
Perfection 3
Hiro Protagonist 1
oneyedman 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 9
TexasOma 3
jessemyles 6
Dr Aborto 2
Work in Progress 6
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
LiveFreeOrDie 1
Dorothy Parker 1
Koka 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
Feeling Blue 1
Kyobungee 1
Its Mygirl01 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: If your child were going to die without care should the govt stay out of it??

As most here in this area feel that healthcare is not a right then what should happen?

1) let the child die Vote
 
 90.0% (9)
2) wait for donations Vote
 
 10.0% (1)
jessemyles --- 15 years ago -

As most here in this area feel that healthcare is not a right then what should happen?

keep in mind you couldn't get insurance with a pre-existing condition. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

I think you caught what Kyobungee has. 

jessemyles --- 15 years ago -

I think you caught what Kyobungee has.

if you dont' have a substantive response that's your MO but I'm serious. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

We've seen this happen. A religious family believes praying the Child's illness away instead if taking them to the hospital for basic care. Parents get arrested and care is given to the child. Most cases it's too late for the child.

Your poll is flawed (snickers). Don't children qualify for Medicaid? 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

Don't children qualify for Medicaid?



Yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 

Its Mygirl01 --- 15 years ago -

Don't children qualify for Medicaid

Not if the family's income is above a certain amount. 

Koka --- 15 years ago -

Why would you even make ANOTHER thread about the same subject? What's the point? You can't judge what someone's answer to this poll would be from their response in the other thread?

PULL ON THEM HEART STRINGS! 

jessemyles --- 15 years ago -

There are many cases where the family can't get medicaid plus the ideology of some is that healthcare is not a right and given their way this could be the future so their answer would be appreciated.

I doubt they'll answer though. Ideology flies fast down the rabbit hole when reality hits. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

If your child were going to die without care should the govt stay out of it??

I didn't vote because the options are not reality.

The same thing that happened before people found the government cash cow. Call it heartless or what ever you want but there are people who pay taxes in America who can hardly feed their own families much less care for others. It's not the government's place to pick and choose who gets health insurance or who gets care. Before this nation started being run by greedy people, the people actually took care of their own communities. Churches and Colleges, Grandma's and Doctors who cared, took care of those in need in the communities. But the problem today is that we have tens of millions in our nation who are in need, WHY IS THAT? And today we are at a place where government is literally the life line for tens of millions of people. And that money is taken from who have and given to those who do not have. That's not freedom. With Freedom comes consequences. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

And hospitals have some very steep discounts for people who qualify for their assistance programs.

No kid should go without care. They won't turn you down if you are sick. You may have bills to pay but they work with you on payment plans as well. Ben Taub has sevices that, according to what I've heard, are next to free for those who are uninsured or qualify as low income.. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

I can't vote on either choice, because they're both awful-I do know, though, Jesse, that if you're refused coverage due to pre existing conditions, you can still get them through BCBS-I'm sure it's more expensive, though, and not everyone can afford it- if you're not the unfortunate bottom,economically,who can get Medicaid, you're the REALLY unfortunate middle, who can't qualify for medicaid, and may not be able to afford BCBS-(that would be a small business owner like you, probably)I have no idea what to tell you, honey- 

Koka --- 15 years ago -

Not if the family's income is above a certain amount.
I'll just leave this here.

0 

Its Mygirl01 --- 15 years ago -

Any family can apply for CHIP (Children's Health Insurance Program) which is based on income and set up for those families that make too much to qualify to medicaid but can't afford private insurance. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

So. How have we survived as a nation up to this point without healthcare being a "right"?

Silly poll.
Silly question.
Silly silliness. 

jessemyles --- 15 years ago -

The same thing that happened before people found the government cash cow. Call it heartless or what ever you want but there are people who pay taxes in America who can hardly feed their own families much less care for others. It's not the government's place to pick and choose who gets health insurance or who gets care. Before this nation started being run by greedy people, the people actually took care of their own communities. Churches and Colleges, Grandma's and Doctors who cared, took care of those in need in the communities. But the problem today is that we have tens of millions in our nation who are in need, WHY IS THAT? And today we are at a place where government is literally the life line for tens of millions of people. And that money is taken from who have and given to those who do not have. That's not freedom. With Freedom comes consequences.

You didn't answer but YES you did.

This is the model for America if we look at what folks like Paul say and if we move away from models that made America what it is. You say it's not reality but it is if the social safety net is stripped away.

If that's what you want I applaud your honesty, if you don't then get involved.

The notion that the poor and middle are killing this country is as old as the queen and king. It's also flawed. Nobody gets rich for free. They get rich because of this country, not in spite of it.

Now the wingnuts will drag out all the govt programs that prove me wrong. HILARIOUS!! You hate those and want them dismantled. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

You really have a hair up you azz today 

ToidBoid --- 15 years ago -

NOBODY goes without medical "care" - I've never seen anybody on the street curb in need. . . you go the ER, you get seen and treated. . .

It's that a lot of people have NO INSURANCE -

That's entirely two separate issues.

We don't have a lack of health care - we have a lack of insurance coverage. 

jessemyles --- 15 years ago -

you go the ER, you get seen and treated. . .

for cancer...sure 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

Idiocy!! Pure IDIOCY!! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

I just want to say this-if you look at the chart for Chip, for 3 people the chances are jesse makes more than that amount-there's a large portion of people caught in this problem- 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

We don't have a lack of health care - we have a lack of insurance coverage. 

Not only that. But people WITH insurance need help. If I live my life with insurance, have the occasional illness and maybe a broken bone, I'll be fine and think my insurance is GREAT! If I'm healthy and insured, then at around 39 my liver isn't working so well, I need a few procedures, I'll find out quick how much my insurance company DOENS'T do. 

jessemyles --- 15 years ago -

Idiocy!! Pure IDIOCY!!

There it is.

The rebuttal. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

you go the ER, you get seen and treated. . .

for cancer...sure



Nope --- for anything.

When I worked at MHTW, I had several patients that were indigent and we gave those patients the same care we gave the very wealthy. As medical people we do not discriminate. I even had a homeless lady who was hit by a car.....she stayed several weeks on our floor. People get the care they need.

Currently I'm doing home care and I have a person who only makes $690.00 per month, plus $100.00 in food stamps. She gets the same medical care that the people I see in Kingwood. In fact, she gets better because all of her medications are paid for and no co-pay for her MD visits.


Now --- tell me another whopper. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

The rebuttal.

Even that was too much of a rebuttal for this thread. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

The problem could be GREATLY helped if we all paid out of pocket for medical expenses (via a health savings acct, tax free!), and only carried catastrophic coverage.

It IS hard getting used to paying for everything, we've done it the last couple of years, but it definitely makes you question the tests the doctors order, and the amount of care that you need.

For instance, during my pregnancy, the doctor ordered my 4th blood typing test. Why in the world would my blood type change? I know what it is, it's on my records from the SAME clinic. However, because it's something that the clinic can bill the insurance for, they test again!

And the system is rife with similar problems. Fix the problems and you don't have to throw the tax payer out with the bath water! 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

This is the model for America if we look at what folks like Paul

Wrong. The man has delivered a couple thousand babies, he knows very well the importance of life, specially with children. Anyone who believes that Ron Paul's views are to simply let people die, they are flat out ignorant on the topic and know nothing more than corporate run media hysteria.

This nation would FAR more generous in helping others if they weren't being raped financially at nearly every turn. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

a BIG problem not mentioned- the cost of insurance, now, and more importantly, the cost of medical care in the hospital w/o insurance has skyrocketed- no one can save enough to cover medical expenses in the hospital-they're so out of line with reality-set up to rape the insurance companies, but the same for an uninsured person, that only a millionaire could possibly save enough for surgery, doctors, (there are many who bill you after) and the hospital stay-I don't have an answer-if we could find a way to lower insurance, and hospital, it would probably work to have a medical savings account- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

So no answers, a lot of name calling, dis the poll for no good reason.

I guess TP is saying what, we should go back to the 1800's version of life?

When you could go to the doctor and pay him in chickens?

Society progresses, and if you don't believe that, time to get a horse, give up your air conditioning and grow your own food. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

Kyo, i thought I actually made some sense with no name calling or judging other people's posts- 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

a BIG problem not mentioned- the cost of insurance, now, and more importantly, the cost of medical care in the hospital w/o insurance has skyrocketed- no one can save enough to cover medical expenses in the hospital-they're so out of line with reality-set up to rape the insurance companies, but the same for an uninsured person, that only a millionaire could possibly save enough for surgery, doctors, (there are many who bill you after) and the hospital stay-I don't have an answer-if we could find a way to lower insurance, and hospital, it would probably work to have a medical savings account-

We CAN. It's called catastrophic only! Then you bargain shop for the rest of your medical, the same way that you do for everything else. Prices would reflect the market, instead of what they "rape" the insurance companies out of.

Right now, the people with very little choice are the doctors and the patients, due to the agreements between the billing of the hospitals, and the insurance companies.

Cut them out in all but catastrophic, and vio la! Affordable healthcare for all. 

Tylers Journey --- 15 years ago -

I had seen a documentary a few weeks back about a boy here in Houston. The boys parents refused to do chemotherapy and wanted to do alternative care so CPS took the kid away from them and did chemotherapy. When the Chemotherapy and radiation didn't work they gave the child back almost dead so the parents started the alternative treatment. They took him to Dr. Burzynski downtown and within a few weeks the tumor had shrunk but it was too late at that point and they had a few months left with there son. So don't worry the child will be taken and treated the way the state wants to do it. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

Cruella, what does catastrophic cover? What about a a bleeding ulcer, or a herniated disc, etc? I was under the impression it was only something like cancer, heart attack, a life threatening disease, or attack- 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

It's basically a high deductible plan. So catastrophic would be anything that costs more than your deductible.

But the premise is that if you get a cold, you pay to see the doc out of pocket. It cuts down on abuse, fraud, hypochondriacs, etc.

We had a very high deductible during my last pregnancy, so I questioned EVERYTHING that was done to me. It was exhausting, but I got a good understanding of where most of the costs come from. They are built in! If more people questioned them, they would be forced to price based on the free market.

But of course, nobody but Bill Gates could afford cancer, so things like that are covered at a percentage. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

o.k., I get it that, but would someone in the category that jessmyles is in, be able to get catastrophic? I guess that would be where the high premium BCBS would come in-high deductible, but if he only used the "catastrophic insurance" affordable- 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Jesse can get catastrophic if he pays for catastrophic. It's a lot less expensive/month than most plans.

And if we got a significant number of people QUESTIONING their healthcare, then the prices would go down.

People could shop around for the best price on pediatricians, OBGYNs, etc. You could choose how many bells and whistles you want for the price. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

a BIG problem not mentioned- the cost of insurance, now, and more importantly, the cost of medical care in the hospital w/o insurance has skyrocketed-

That goes right back to what I was saying about the government being in bed with the insurance and pharmaceutical lobbyists.

This was their dang plan all along. The government said OK, let's get rich working with the lobbyists and we'll let their corporations run prices us, we'll even compete with their prices to drive them up even higher and then when we elect the next Democrat, we'll push Nationalized healthcare because by then no one will be able to afford healthcare.

If I were going to do it, that's exactly how I would have done it. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

If your child were going to die without care should the govt stay out of it??

Even with today's current Government Lobbied health care system there is the possibility that Greed would allow people to die. It's what we have allowed our system to become. Living in a free country we have all had the right to protest these costs, to protest government working with them in driving up prices. But all some of you want to do is demonize the only man who wants to fix it all.

 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Limited resources equal limited services.

To spend extra resources on a non-viable child may seem compassionate to that family however to the family from which resources were taken it is cold and impersonal.

So to save or attempt to save one life how many others must sacrifice?

The pie is only so big. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Great answer Chunky 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground