Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The Politics Behind New Voter ID Laws

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
Justwatching72 1
SoupIsGoodFood 5
justforfun 4
rEVOLution 1
genxer 1
lucky dog 5
james osterberg 2
allday 5
Toss 2
Work in Progress 6
It is I WhyWhyWhy 4
In AbsentiaW 1
crazypinetrees 1
rednecktek 1
Kyobungee 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

The Politics Behind New Voter ID Laws
by PAM FESSLER

July 18, 2011
Voters going to the polls next year — and even some this year — will encounter lots of new rules. Photo ID requirements and fewer options for early voting are among the biggest changes.


Dinesh Ramde/ASSOCIATED PRESS

A voter casts a ballot in a Democratic primary on
July 12, 2011 in Wisconsin, one of seven states to enact voter ID laws this year.

They're part of a wave of new laws enacted by Republican-controlled legislatures this year. Supporters say the rules are needed to ensure honest elections.

But Democrats say it's part of a concerted GOP campaign to suppress the vote. They say minorities, students, the poor and disabled — those most likely to vote Democratic — will be hurt the most.

Seven states so far this year have enacted news laws requiring voters to show photo ID at the polls. Ohio and Pennsylvania are considering similar requirements, and several other states already have them on the books.

Other states have placed restrictions on voter registration drives, imposed new requirements for voters to show proof of citizenship, or reduced the amount of time for early voting.

"This is about putting up obstacles to legal voters being able to exercise the franchise," says Scot Ross, executive director of One Wisconsin Now, an advocacy group that opposes the changes. "That is the scheme that the Republicans have concocted on this."

Ross says tens of thousands of Wisconsin voters lack the photo ID that will now be required in that state. He says many of them will also have difficulty traveling to motor vehicle offices to get free ID cards available under the law.

For more on changes to voting laws this year, visit National Conference Of State Legislatures. The Brennan Center for Justice at New York University Law School, which opposes many of the changes, also has a detailed list.

National Conference Of State Legislatures
Brennan Center for Justice
All this, he adds, was created to solve a problem that doesn't exist.

"The bottom line is, in Wisconsin, there is no evidence of widespread voter impropriety happening at any point in time," says Ross.

But supporters say, in effect, that's beside the point and that the changes won't hurt legitimate voters. They argue that any voter fraud — even the possibility of fraud — is a concern.

"Whether it's one case, a hundred cases, or a hundred thousand cases, making sure we have legislation that protects the integrity for an open, fair and honest election in every single case is important," said Wisconsin's Republican governor, Scott Walker, when he signed the new law this spring.

And Republicans appear to be winning over public opinion. Polls shows that an overwhelming majority of voters back ID requirements.

In Tennessee, the Republican secretary of state, Tre Hargett, is preparing plans and public service announcements to make sure voters in his state adjust smoothly to the new rules. They'll be required to show photo ID at the polls and to provide proof of citizenship when they register to vote.

Hargett rejects opponents' claims that the changes will discourage voter turnout.

I think that nothing could disenfranchise an eligible voter more than finding out that ineligible voters are voting.
- Tre Hargett, Tennessee secretary of state
"I think that nothing could disenfranchise an eligible voter more than finding out that ineligible voters are voting," he says.

Hargett cited a 2005 special election in Memphis, in which poll workers admitted faking at least three votes. But opponents of the new restrictions say a photo ID requirement won't stop that kind of fraud.

Doug Chapin, an election expert with the Humphrey School of Public Affairs at the University of Minnesota, says one problem with the current debate is that there's little data to back up either side.

Chapin says there's not only no evidence of widespread fraud, but "you really haven't seen, despite the rhetoric to the contrary, a whole lot of evidence that there are large numbers of people who are registered to vote, or want to register to vote, and don't have the kind of ID that would be required."

That's one reason Democrats and voting rights activists will be on high alert over the coming year, as they try to gather examples of harmed voters for potential legal challenges to many of the new state laws.

One civil rights group, the Advancement Project, has already filed suit against a voter ID initiative in Missouri. The ACLU is fighting new voter restrictions in Florida, and there's likely much more to come.


Are they serious votes are too poor or unable to get a ride to the DMV to get a FREE photo ID but they have no problem getting someone to take them to vote with no proof of who they are.

This is the kind of stupid reasoning that is the DNC. People need to have a photo id or not vote period. 

Toss --- 15 years ago -

yep it has nothing to do with the fact that in some places obama got 10 times more votes than there were registered voters. It has nothing to do with the fact the amount of dead people were able to somehow get out and vote, or the fact the amount of people that should not even be in the country are able to somehow cast their vote either. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

You are suppressing the rights of illegal aliens and wanted criminals to vote!

That's racist!

I like how they KNOW that wanted criminals and illegal aliens wouldn't vote for a Republican. Isn't that kinda all you need to know? 

genxer --- 15 years ago -

They are exactly right this suppresses the vote of the dead, illegals and convicted felons.

To receive their welfare checks, and food stamps they have to present a govt issued state id. So this BS about the poor is nonsense.

To get into a bar or college you have to present a state issued govt id. So this is BS about students

To get into a doctor or hospital and be on medicare, you have to present a state issued govt id. So this is BS about old people

I can never understand how anyone can support the democrat party with all their blatant disregard of the law. 

In AbsentiaW --- 15 years ago -

How many people are just going to say "The hell with it! I just won't bother to vote. It's not worth the hassle to go jump through the hoops to get the damn ID card."

Voter apathy? I think so.

As far as the votes Obama received, what makes you think Georgie didn't get he same thing?

How soon we forget the Florida tab thing in his last election.

Get it? Politics is a crooked thing! 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

If they are that apathetic about voting. . .should we care? No pun intended, but truly, how informed on the issues are they if they can't even find the energy to get an ID card? 

Toss --- 15 years ago -

If they are that apathetic about voting. . .should we care? No pun intended, but truly, how informed on the issues are they if they can't even find the energy to get an ID card?

Makes sense to me. now if we can just put a stop to the buses of "Get on the bus and come place your vote for the democrat, and on the way back we are going to take everyone to Luby's"

how is this not voter fraud, or exploiting the old and the poor? 

allday --- 15 years ago -

I like how they KNOW that wanted criminals and illegal aliens wouldn't vote for a Republican.

Felons and illegals can vote now?

WOW 

james osterberg --- 15 years ago -

They are exactly right this suppresses the vote of the dead, illegals and convicted felons.

No cases ever reported resulting any conviction.
Let's just call it what it is. Preaching fear, enacting laws to protect against a myth. Same as the need for sharia laws.
GOP-hate,fear& lies
nothing new to report here 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

Well, if it changes nothing other than to make people sure that their legal vote is not canceled out by an illegal one then it is still a good law. EVERYONE should know that the process is proteced from fraud. Shouldn't bother anyone unless they want illegal votes counted! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

It looks like it ruffled the right feathers. 

james osterberg --- 15 years ago -

In your usual caned answer list you need something else in place of that.

As long a you are pounding the keyboard in chimplike fashon,I thing you should use "correct" in place of "right" . Right indicates we buy into your illogical parroting 

justforfun --- 15 years ago -

I have always thought picture ID and other forms of ID should be used. Yes it will cut down on voter fraud but only in certain areas. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Felons and illegals can vote now?

WOW


Yes, but only for democrats. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

But Democrats say it's part of a concerted GOP campaign to suppress the vote. They say minorities, students, the poor and disabled — those most likely to vote Democratic — will be hurt the most.



Hmmm, I thought the liberals on here said that the poor vote Republican? 

allday --- 15 years ago -

PLEASE EDUCATE YOURSELVES;

Here's a primer:

One of the favorite lines used by the get-tough-on-immigrants crowd is to claim that people who don't share their views "confuse legal with illegal immigration." This is the wall-builders' way of arguing that when it comes to legal immigration, they love the Statue of Liberty and all it stand for, their own ancestors were immigrants -legal ones, mind you-- and, in fact, some of their best friends are legal immigrants.

Now it seems that confusing legal and illegal immigrants with immigrants who are naturalized U.S. citizens is a deliberate part of the campaign strategy of some folks who sent a letter to 14,000 Orange County Hispanics claiming that they could be arrested and deported if they vote in November's election. Presumably, the strategy was aimed at discouraging naturalized citizens and U.S.-born Hispanic voters from turning out at the polls to re-elect U.S. Representative Loretta Sanchez, a Democrat.

"You are advised that if your residence in this country is illegal or you are an immigrant, voting in a federal election is a crime that could result in jail time," said the letter, which was written in Spanish.

The letter is disturbing for so many reasons. It implies that anyone with a Hispanic surname is suspected of being here illegally and intent on voting fraudulently -- a confusion of legal with illegal if I've ever heard one. It bends the truth in its implicit assertion that even naturalized citizens could be arrested for voting. It smacks of racketeering in its clear intent to intimidate potential voters. It's hard not to read the letter as a response to last spring's "Today We March, Tomorrow We Vote," proclamations.

Unfortunately, it also reflects an ugly trend that threatens to disenfranchise many native-born U.S. citizens as well as naturalized ones. Arizona's infamous Proposition 200, passed in 2004, requires voters to prove their citizenship Despite the state elections chief stating that there had been precisely zero reports of illegal immigrants attempting to vote The Oregon House of Representatives passed a copy-cat proposal this year, though it did not become law. Colorado legislators discussed the issue in a special legislative session on illegal immigration. Georgia passed a similar law, which was then overturned in early October as a form of poll tax.

In September, the U.S. House of Representatives joined in the fray with a bill, HR 4844 that would, require government-issued photo identification. The Senate did not immediately follow suit.

Law-abiding American citizens are naturally horrified at the prospect of fraud by foreigners who might try to influence U.S. policy, elect a president who would throw the borders wide open, and not only force bilingual education on the schools but go even farther to make Spanish the official language.

But anyone who thinks of such a scenario as a real possibility would be getting upset over a problem that does not exist and is not likely to. Election officials are hard-pressed to come up with any evidence that widespread voting by non-citizens is a serious problem.

In one of the hearings on immigration that took place across the country last summer -one that stood out from the others in that both sides of the debate were represented instead of just the hard-line view--Maricopa (Arizona) County District Attorney Andrew Thomas testified that a total of four non-citizens actually voted in 2005. Under the provisions of Proposition 200, all of ten non-citizens were charged with registering to vote. That's out of a total of roughly 1.5 million registered voters in the county. Some big problem, right?

By contrast, more than 10,000 citizens in Maricopa County were rejected as voters in the 2005 election because they could not prove their citizenship -in some cases because married names did not match birth certificates. Though some eventually were able to clear up the problem, about 1,000 citizens were prevented from casting ballots in the 2005 election despite being registered voters. That does not count the impossible-to-know number of people who simply did not register or vote for fear of being challenged.

The Arizona case illustrates dramatically how U.S. citizens are suffering collateral damage from policies intended to punish undocumented immigrants instead of fixing our laws so that the hard-working, law-abiding people we need can come in through the front door and we can focus on catching the real law-breakers. But it also is a warning of the way that bad ideas can come cloaked in seemingly reasonable guise. After all, who isn't in favor of the integrity of the ballot box? (The answer to that question may be the very people who are trying to paint non-citizens as the biggest threat to.)

The illegal-immigrants-voting straw man is far from the biggest problem at the ballot box. Blaming illegal immigrants, in fact, is a cynical ploy that ultimately would make it easier to keep Americans away from the polls -people like those in, say, Ohio, or in neighborhoods across the country where poor public transportation is as much an obstacle to getting an ID as it is to getting out the vote.

When will Americans learn that whenever the politicians holler loudest about illegal immigrant invasions, it's because they're trying to distract us from their own corruption and failure to do right by their constituents? Undocumented immigrants are perhaps 4 percent of the population. If every single immigrant here illegally were to disappear tomorrow, would every American really get a decent education and health care? Would our roads and public transport systems no longer be inadequate and ill-maintained? Would our election system be without fraud?

The saddest part of such immigration scare tactics is the message we're sending to those who have arrived recently and are learning first-hand what America is about. That brings me to the final thing that is so disturbing about the letter sent out to discourage people with Hispanic surnames from voting: the letter campaign has been linked to a Vietnamese immigrant, Tan Nguyen, running for office as a Republican challenger. Though he denies direct knowledge of the letter (and six other Vietnamese-American political candidates in Orange County quickly denounced it), the fact that such a letter could go out from his campaign is a sad commentary on just how quickly some immigrants are absorbing the messages being sent by a wrong-headed but vocal minority about what America means: that it's okay to judge people and harass them based on their race, skin color, or nationality. Immigrants may want to take a cue from those who complain (though mistakenly) about "confusing legal and illegal immigrants," and stand up to make sure that nobody confuses "real" Americans with the kind --whether naturalized or native born-- who would send such a letter. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

If they were ONLY asking hispanics for ID at the polls, then you might have a point Allday. But they ask EVERYONE.

Welcome to blind justice. Try it, you'll like it. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

As long a you are pounding the keyboard in chimplike fashon,I thing you should use "correct" in place of "right" . Right indicates we buy into your illogical parroting

Does it even matter now? Either way, the correct/right feathers got ruffled. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

If they were ONLY asking hispanics for ID at the polls, then you might have a point Allday. But they ask EVERYONE.



Bingo, again some will choose to make it about race, they are usually the most racist of all. 

lucky dog --- 15 years ago -

IMO; It's simpler to cast fraudulent votes by mail ballot than in person (simple logistics) so why the rush for govt issued pic id at the poll? In Texas there was no demonstration of large numbers of bogus in person votes cast but now I'll have to demand pic id from my wife/gf/neighbor/cousin/kid before letting them sign the book and vote. Do not explain to me that I am required to show such at the bank, to travel (a soviet style travel permit?), or even to get in to city hall, I object vigorously to all of this show time theater nonsense. 

justforfun --- 15 years ago -

I carry ID on me, why doesn't everyone? 

allday --- 15 years ago -

Bingo, again some will choose to make it about race

I sure didn't say it's about race. I say it's the tried and true frightened right playing fear games and look at the most fearful here.

Sad and weak. 

lucky dog --- 15 years ago -

Embrace your national id cards folks, for that's the end game wrapped in the pic to vote deal. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Bingo, again some will choose to make it about race, they are usually the most racist of all.

Finding a race issue in everything they debate seems to be their "goto" lately.

It really shows how weak their argument is. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

I sure didn't say it's about race.

Do you not read what you copy and paste? 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Embrace your national id cards folks, for that's the end game wrapped in the pic to vote deal.

I agree with your wariness on this. We should always be wary. But certainly, we should be able to prove that we are able to vote legally, no? Why would we want to make it easier to vote illegally? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

The bottom line is everyone needs to show proof of identification to vote. It is the only thing that makes sense. 

allday --- 15 years ago -

Do you not read what you copy and paste?

It's one side of the argument. Do you think I wrote the article, colonel? 

lucky dog --- 15 years ago -

CDV, we prove our eligibility when we register...if the registrar is doing a proper job there is no further reason to show additional bonafides. I believe Texas will now demand second id in addition to a voter reg card. The honey hole of bogus votes is the mail ballot where you can generate significant numbers without having to get bogus bodies to actually show up at a poll. I don't subscribe to the sob stories about folks who are too poor or too stupid to get an official id, my objections come from my firmly held position that we are being acclimated to proving some arbitrary qualification in every dealing in commerce and with govt. Hell, I recently walked in to my bank, was greeted by name and then asked for my damned id to do a transaction. Recall that every one of those Sept 11 killers had official govt issued photo id...how'd that work out? 

Justwatching72 --- 15 years ago -

The bottom line is everyone needs to show proof of identification to vote. It is the only thing that makes sense.

Then how are we to stop the GOP from creating faux democrat candidates in order to slow down and muck up an election? 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

CDV, we prove our eligibility when we register...if the registrar is doing a proper job there is no further reason to show additional bonafides. I believe Texas will now demand second id in addition to a voter reg card. The honey hole of bogus votes is the mail ballot where you can generate significant numbers without having to get bogus bodies to actually show up at a poll. I don't subscribe to the sob stories about folks who are too poor or too stupid to get an official id, my objections come from my firmly held position that we are being acclimated to proving some arbitrary qualification in every dealing in commerce and with govt. Hell, I recently walked in to my bank, was greeted by name and then asked for my damned id to do a transaction. Recall that every one of those Sept 11 killers had official govt issued photo id...how'd that work out?

Good points. Well argued. I'll have to think about that. 

lucky dog --- 15 years ago -

Ah, you're not so cruel :) 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

It's one side of the argument. Do you think I wrote the article, colonel?

Nope. That's way too many words for you. 

justforfun --- 15 years ago -

Recall that every one of those Sept 11 killers had official govt issued photo id...how'd that work out?



The government only made them show ID.Those guys weren't registered as killers, were they? Had that been on their ID I doubt very seriously they would have gotten on board the plane. 

lucky dog --- 15 years ago -

Right jff, our id doesn't yet show our occupations...and your point is? 

justforfun --- 15 years ago -

Right jff, our id doesn't yet show our occupations...and your point is?



The point is about Voter fraud. If people prove who they are then Voter fraud goes why down. I do not see a problem with this. We should have always done it. 

allday --- 15 years ago -

Right jff, our id doesn't yet show our occupations...and your point is?

You'll truly be a tired dog trying to pierce a brick with logic... 

crazypinetrees --- 15 years ago -

Seriously, how many people walk our streets with no valid ID if they arent illegal? Thats ridiculous. To cash a check you need an ID, get any kind of assistance you need ID, to drive you need an ID, to get a job you need an ID. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

So the less government, less interference side now wants ID's to vote. Next thing you know they are going to want the government to interfere in in our private lives, like say abortions, or our phone calls or, no, wait.....

Smaller Gov. less interference, except where WE think it needs to be.,
So hypocritical. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground