Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Would you lie to save your child's life?

who's talking here?

Empty Nest 1
ghostpost 11
Perfection 4
justcat 3
Nightstorm 2
quiettype 2
SueRDH 1
RedMulch 12
Gigix4 1
Cs Land Escapes 1
Eyes Of Green 1
Butterfly Kisses 2
Puss In Boots 1
Mabs 4
Clock 9
Dorothy Parker 9
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
needsleep 1
rednecktek 2
Invisiblewings 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

Watching the Casey Anthony trial and suspecting that her parents (especially her mother Cindy) are not being truthful on the stand has me asking myself some questions.


Her child is on trial for her life. I like to think that I am an honest and ethical person..sometimes to a fault. But what if was my child on trial? Would I lie if it meant the difference in her getting the needle or not?

What if the crime she was accused of was as horrible as this one..murder of my grandchild? Would I still lie to protect her? Would I be unable to face the loss of my daughter after losing my grandchild...even if it were at my child's own hands?

I think I know what I would do, and I hope to God I never find myself in a similar situation..but do we ever really know what we would do in a situation like this? As mad as I am at her mother there is a part of me that still has sympathy for the terrible situation her parents are in.

Like I said on the other thread.."You reap what you sow"..there is no way they could have ever thought their daughter was capable of murdering her child, but certainly they looked the other way when the seeds were sown for this horrible act...and yes, i do believe she is guilty. 

Invisiblewings --- 15 years ago -

That's a really good and tough question. I don't know what I would do if I were in her position, and hope to never be in that position. Wow....really makes you think. I'm going to be pondering this for awhile now. 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

I'd be worried about what i did to cause my child to be so evil that she would kill her child?? And yes, the absence of God in their lives probably had alot to do with it......... 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I'd be worried about what i did to cause my child to be so evil that she would kill her child?? And yes, the absence of God in their lives probably had alot to do with it......... 


Wow...what a broad statement. Andrea Yates was very active in church...think it was absence of God that caused her mental illness, too?

I'm not defending Casey Anthony, I know nothing about this case, but to make a statement like 'absence of God in their lives' causes someone to turn evil and kill their own children, is absolutely asinine. 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -


I'm not defending Casey Anthony, I know nothing about this case, but to make a statement like 'absence of God in their lives' causes someone to turn evil and kill their own children, is absolutely asinine.



Being active in Church does not mean having God in your life. and Andrea Yates had a mental illness..........something Casey Anthony does not have........

And as far as Yates goes.....i think her husband should be put on trial. He was warned by doctors this could happen. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

Well, the Anthony family say they are Christians. Casey asked for a bible and claims to be reading it in jail. No one ever really knows what is in someones heart, but I think saying there was an absence of God in her life is way too simplistic.

Can you not be a sociopath or have narcissistic personality disorder or have another mental illness and still have God in your life? 

quiettype --- 15 years ago -

Very thought provoking ghostpost. When I first saw the title I was thinking of my girls as little and thought in a New York minute. But I feel there would come a point in their lives, that both of mine have reached as adults, that I might have to say no, you made your mess and you have to account for it. Please dear God do not ever put me in the position to have to answer this question for real. 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

Can you not be a sociopath or have narcissistic personality disorder or have another mental illness and still have God in your life?

Saying you are a Christian and being one are different. I did not mean to start this debate.........sorry. Locking the thread. 

Cs Land Escapes --- 15 years ago -

QT, I thought the same thing when I read the thread, of course I would. But then as they get older they will be on their own. I do agree with the point above that as a parent I would be asking myself over and over where in the world did I go wrong to even be that position. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Being active in Church does not mean having God in your life.


Says who? You? Who are you to judge "what level" someone has God in their life? And especially to make a broad statement like this:

And yes, the absence of God in their lives probably had alot to do with it......... 



give me a break. The BTK killer was a DEACON in his church! Active in boy scouts and community service, a real family man...and yet, he was a serial killer.

Whether or not you have "god in your life" has nothing to do with whether or not you turn out to be a sociopath. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Locking the thread.


You didn't start this thread! LOL! How can you lock it? 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -



give me a break. The BTK killer was a DEACON in his church! Active in boy scouts and community service, a real family man...and yet, he was a serial killer.

Being active in Church does not mean having God in your life.
\

does this not prove my point?? 

SueRDH --- 15 years ago -

Can you not be a sociopath or have narcissistic personality disorder or have another mental illness and still have God in your life?

Very good question! 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

Sorry i can't lock this topic...........carry on 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

does this not prove my point?? 


What point? That you have no way to know whether or not someone has God in their life?

By all outward appearances, BTK was a good guy...a lot of his fellow church members said he seemed every bit a good Christian.

there is no way to judge whether or not someone has God in their life or to say lack thereof caused them to become a murderer.

AND....

I bet if you took a poll of prisoners in our own system, and asked them if they had God in their lives, most would say YES. 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

I think you can have a mental illness and and be close to God. I think Andrea Yates has a better shot at Heaven than Anthony cause she knew what she was doing.......but she still can confess and get there herself.........

And i really did not mean for this to turn out this way........... 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

MO5...do you beleive that there are some good people in this world? Seems you don't trust anyone. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

MO5...do you beleive that there are some good people in this world? Seems you don't trust anyone. 


What??? LOL! What are you talking about?

Because I questioned your post about people becoming evil if they don't have God in their lives? How does that translate to me not trusting in people or believing in good people?


Are you actually reading my posts? 

justcat --- 15 years ago -

I just don't understand why a thread like this has to go this way..Just let people post their opinion, and don't attack them for it...Heck, it doesnt even have to be questioned. This same topic is on WS has gone about 10 pages, with nothing but folks commenting on what they would do...
This one was gone in 10 seconds. 

Clock --- 15 years ago -

Just let people post their opinion, and don't attack them for it..

That doesn't happen here anymore .

This one was gone in 10 seconds.

Hmmmm....I wonder what made this thread go south? 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

This same topic on WS has gone about 10 pages, with nothing but folks commenting on what they would do...
This one was gone in 10 seconds.


Exactly, justcat.

Lol..I didn't even see the thread on WS when I started this one..just now went and looked. (edited to add..very interesting responses on that forum...some of them are surprising me .)

I guess there are a lot of people asking themselves that question after today's testimony. 

Gigix4 --- 15 years ago -

Hmmmm....I wonder what made this thread go south?

Hmmmm ... good question. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I just don't understand why a thread like this has to go this way..


Really?


I found her post extremely insulting. I said as much...she can't handle the fact that I'm disagreeing with her.

Should I not be able to express my opinion because it may differ from the majority?

If you only want threads where people ^5 one another, that doesn't leave much room for any real conversation/debate. Message boards need opposing views to thrive. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

Hmmmm....I wonder what made this thread go south?

Well, I think when you start bring God or Godlessness (is that a word? lol ) into it you are going to stir up a lot of controversy right off the bat.

Also, respectfully disagreeing is not that difficult. 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -


Hmmmm....I wonder what made this thread go south?



I know...but now i am afraid to say............. 

Clock --- 15 years ago -

I know...but now i am afraid to say.............

You should be able to voice your opinion like anyone else here. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

Okay..would you all please get this thread back to the original question? And no locking from the rest of you, lol....

I really think it is a question makes us all take a step back and do some searching.

It is easy to judge others..like the Anthonys for example..but if you were in their shoes, would you lie to save her life...no matter how terrible she is and how horrific the crime she is accused of was? 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

Depends on what I was lying about. Playing hooky from school or transporting my dead grandbaby in the trunk of a car. It'd be kind of foolish to administer a lethal injection to someone I'd already killed. 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

I found her post extremely insulting. I said as much...she can't handle the fact that I'm disagreeing with her.


I can handle anything.......... 

justcat --- 15 years ago -

My gut instinct is that no, I would not lie. Not saying I would not be tempted to. But, lying just opens up a whole new can of worms.
I would try to just not even have to answer, and would rather be held in contempt,than be the one that helped send my child to their death. 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

Depends on what I was lying about. Playing hooky from school or transporting my dead grandbaby in the trunk of a car. It'd be kind of foolish to administer a lethal injection to someone I'd already killed.


Great insight Mabbers 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

Great insight Mabbers 

Pfft, you jest. LOL. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

Depends on what I was lying about. Playing hooky from school or transporting my dead grandbaby in the trunk of a car. It'd be kind of foolish to administer a lethal injection to someone I'd already killed.


Okay...would you lie about internet searches that your child made, when you know that they would be very damaging to your child in their defense? Such as searches for chloroform when it is suspected that is how a murder was committed by your child.

Would you lie and say those searches on the internet were yours and not your child's to help keep them from being convicted and receiving the DP? 

justcat --- 15 years ago -

K..yeah. I am basing my answer on the CA case lol, not hooky...I aint going to jail for hooky. 

Clock --- 15 years ago -

It seems to me that there were deep-seated demons in that family long before the death of that child. I mean, the lies, deceit, lack of moral fiber, etc., let's not forget about the MURDER of a little baby with parents helping cover it up. Lying on trial seems minute at this point. 

Eyes Of Green --- 15 years ago -

I don't think the parents know how to tell the truth anymore. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

Okay...would you lie about internet searches that your child made, but you know that they would be very damaging to your child. Such as searches for chloroform when it is suspected that is how a murder was committed by your child.

Would you lie and say those searches on the internet were yours and not your child's to help keep them from being convicted and receiving the DP? 


Nope. Because imo, it all relates to the charges. I can't think of something I WOULD lie about on the stand. I'm a terrible liar to begin with...I'd either turn beet red, bust out laughing or crying. You pick the emotion; I'd have it. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I found her post extremely insulting. I said as much...she can't handle the fact that I'm disagreeing with her.


I can handle anything.......... 



Yet, you locked your other thread when I asked you some basic questions regarding the details around this sign change in New York and now you're playing a martyr on this thread...you wanted to lock it, but couldn't....lol.

thread topic:

If my child killed my grandchild, I don't think we'd have much to talk about let alone lying for her on the stand.

You reap what you sow....when you're an adult, you have to live with the consequences of your actions, regardless of your upbringing. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

It seems to me that there were deep-seated demons in that family long before the death of that child. I mean, the lies, deceit, lack of moral fiber, etc., let's not forget about the MURDER of a little baby with parents helping cover it up

Oh, no doubt about that. I have been pretty hard on them and judgmental. I guess I just really started thinking about the impact of a parent's testimony being the key to a lethal injection..not talking about life in prison.

It almost seems to me that a parent should not be asked to testify in a death penalty case involving their child. It is a horrible position for a parent to be in. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

In addition, if anyone confiscated my computer this very second, I'd be considered suspicious. Because every damn time I hear something, I google it. My google history is beyond bizarre. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground