Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Does having a degree make you smarter than someone without it?

who's talking here?

GCan 2
JDB2 1
Fallon 1
planemom 1
Sandyr9111 1
ukchristine 1
Deltadawn 1
Going off air 1
KWPlanner 1
Mr Mark 1
Donkey Hodie 2
Katie 1
Perfection 1
justcat 1
Exile 1
drop1216 1
POTUS 1
zapper007 2
quiettype 1
Squareduck 1
voice of reason 1
ladyjane 1
curtis 2
evolved 3
mommie21g1b 3
SighFiGurl 1
franfran 1
Q The Rain in 5 4 3 2 1
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
Puss In Boots 1
midland 1
StepDad 2
Trashy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Does having a degree make you smarter than someone without it?

Does having a degree make you smarter than someone without it?

Yes Vote
 
 23.5% (19)
No Vote
 
 76.5% (62)
Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Does having a degree make you smarter than someone without it? 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

I know quite a few college educated idiots! lol 

justcat --- 16 years ago -

Define smarter..(yes,I said that)
It would in most cases make you "smarter" or more knowledgeable in certain fields,such as a medical degree, engineering,and well you get the picture.

But it does not necessarily make you smarter,in general. 

JDB2 --- 16 years ago -

not necessarily...exceptions on both sides to be sure! 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Having a degree has nothing to do with your IQ, but it does provide one with a canon of knowledge to pull from.

I've known non-college educated people who had much more common sense than those with a degree, but a degree does show a certain level of responsibility to see a long term plan through. 

franfran --- 16 years ago -

No, but it makes you more marketable, in this economy that's what counts. 

StepDad --- 16 years ago -

Anyone who gets through college has learned a process of thought that should position them well in their careers, but it doesnt make them smarter than someone who doesnt. The school of hard knocks teaches the same processes, but isnt nearly as fun.

But....

Physics, chemistry and other sciences are not concepts that are simple to understand. In fact, most of them are counter to "common sense". That's why pedegree does matter in these fields. 

Katie --- 16 years ago -

A degree shows how hard you have worked for it. Takes more than brains to get the degree. Also takes perseverance 

Squareduck --- 16 years ago -

My SIL is college educated. But in real world reality, she missed out on those lessons. My FIL and my own father are not college educated. But they have done very well for themselves and have been educated by being well read and learning on the job. Having a paper that said you earned a degree is just that a piece of paper. It's what you do with it that determines if you actually learned anything. Most people don't need a paper for sucess. They need drive and ambition. If you don't have that no diploma in the world will do anything for you! :) 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

No, but it makes you more marketable, in this economy that's what counts.

Not necessarily, I get lots of resumes from people with degrees who can seem to hold a job for more than a few years. Job hoppers are not more marketable in this economy. Who wants to pay to train someone only to have them leave in 8-15 months later?

They need to teach that in college too. 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

Define smarter..(yes,I said that)
Good thinking - If you lack a degree of any kind and are defensive about it and go around trying to prove you are just as "smart" as anyone with one, you are going to look like a fool and if you feel you have superior intelligence than others (degree or not)and go around acting that way and trying to prove it to them over and over, that just makes you look like a fool as well. To me it seems we all have our area of expertise, and if we allow that we can and should learn new things all the time, than we have no problems with others knowing something we don't, nor with the idea we know something they don't and the polite thing to do is to share information in a civilized fashion. 

Exile --- 16 years ago -

Does having a degree make you smarter than someone without it?

Does being a mod lying in the grasses asking inane questions make you smarter than those that answer the questions? 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

*removed by mod* 

SighFiGurl --- 16 years ago -

What StepDad said. 

drop1216 --- 16 years ago -

SighFiGurl ---
What StepDad said



Same for me! 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

I'd rather see a doc with a degree than one without:) 

StepDad --- 16 years ago -

You know what they call the guy who finished last in his medical school class??

Doctor. 

ukchristine --- 16 years ago -

Maybe...maybe not....But having a degree shows somebody who saw something through to the end. Shows focus and coimmitment. 

Mr Mark --- 16 years ago -

You have to have an I.Q. to have a degree.
But you don't have to have a degree to have an I.Q.

Rule No.2 

mommie21g1b --- 16 years ago -

No- there are many kinds of intelligence and a degree only measures a few of them.

I have met people who are book smart, but socially stupid. I have met people with PhDs in a load of debt (not smart in my mind).

A degree simply measures your determination and motivation. Having a degree will not bring you automatic success. You still have to work hard. The degree is just a stepping stone. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

Funny. I bet the majority disparaging those with degrees are without one.

For the record, most who don't have one couldn't earn one anyway. 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

Funny. I bet the majority disparaging those with degrees are without one.

I agree. You rarely hear someone with a degree saying that it wasn't worth it. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

I agree. You rarely hear someone with a degree saying that it wasn't worth it.

It's worth a couple of million over the course of a 30 plus year career. So yeah, on the balance they are smarter. Just because trailer park idiots in Porter/Kingwood have player envy means little. 

GCan --- 16 years ago -

I'm sure Bill Gates is having a good laugh of some of the comments.

Peter Jennings, John D. Rockefeller, Michael Dell, Mary Kay Ash and Henry Ford too. 

Trashy --- 16 years ago -

 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

I'm sure Bill Gates is having a good laugh of some of the comments.

Bill Gates went to a private high school, and he probably walked out of there better educated than some people with a BA. (He also dropped out of Harvard, not Kingwood College. Big difference.)

Also, for every Bill Gates there are millions of dropouts working dead-end minimum-wage jobs. If Bill Gates was the norm instead of a huge outlier, you might have a point. 

midland --- 16 years ago -

Not "smarter", but it does show that someone is disciplined enough to stick it out in school - show's drive an dedication. Plus, once you have that degree you will have more options through out life. 

GCan --- 16 years ago -

There are plenty of people with degrees that are without jobs or working beneath their "sheepskin". My point is no less valid than yours. It's a generalization to state that a college diploma makes you smarter and that being without one makes you an idiot. Especially when there are lots of degrees that are mostly of an esoteric nature. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

doesn't make you smarter and you know that. does give you more knowledge. 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

I've only met about 15-20 people who were smarter than me, and only three of them had a degree. 

quiettype --- 16 years ago -

For the record, most who don't have one couldn't earn one anyway.
Just because trailer park idiots in Porter/Kingwood have player envy means little.

Evolved I am surprised at you. Are you a degreed snob?

I, for many reasons, have not had the opportunity to complete my degree. I own my own home in KW (SWH) and have raised two children as a single mom. I was able to put both of them in cars when it was time to drive which was just as much a help to me as it was nice for them.

I was fortunate to work for a man for 10 years who understood that lack of degree does not equate with lack of knowledge, skills, abilities or drive. I earn a very nice base salary plus bonus incentive eligible at the Director level.

I have known a lot of college educated idiots who couldn't find their butt with two hands and a road map and can say the same for non-college educated idiots. I am smart enough to know when I need to use the tools at hand, including someone who has different or better knowledge, skills, and abilities than what I do.

And yes, having a degree does make you more marketable in this economy and as you go further up the management chain. Right now I am putting my kids through college so once again completion of my degree is on hold but some day I will finish it. What I will not be is a degree snob. 

zapper007 --- 16 years ago -

One thang's fur sur - it don't impruv ur spellin' er grammer...lol 

zapper007 --- 16 years ago -

I've only met about 15-20 people who were smarter than me, and only three of them had a degree.


Wow, you sure are 1 smart dude!!!!...lol 

mommie21g1b --- 16 years ago -

You rarely hear someone with a degree saying that it wasn't worth it

I have an M.S. and a specialized certification (with several research projects published in peer reviewed journals) and have never worked since the day I graduated. Sometimes I wonder if the degree was worth it since I am happy in my role as a wife and mother. Once my kids are grown I will probably be the only one willing to take caring of our aging parents so I don't ever see myself having a true career.

So in terms of money, I doubt it will end up being "worth" it. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

An intelligent person, with a plan and drive to succeed doesn't need a piece of paper to be successful. A degree doesn't make you smarter. It is an easy way for an employer to determine your level of knowledge. Does having a masters degree make you a better teacher? Does it make you a better social worker? It doesn't, but based on job requirements it's almost a necessity. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

Evolved I am surprised at you. Are you a degreed snob?

No. Just surprised at the PC nonsense people post. Of course it doesn't mean you're smarter for certain, just likely.

And my sarcasm was intended for a couple of morons who know who they are. No offense to any others intended. 

ladyjane --- 16 years ago -

Mr. Mark, you said it best:

[i]"You have to have an I.Q. to have a degree.
But you don't have to have a degree to have an I.Q"[/i

There are lots of smart people out there without degrees, and lots of not so smart ones, but it's pretty hard to complete a degree without at least some level of intelligence. Those with degrees are, ahem, a more homogenous group than those without. 

mommie21g1b --- 16 years ago -

You have to have an I.Q. to have a degree

or be a good athlete :) 

curtis --- 16 years ago -

In my opinion, yes and no.

As an example, my undergrad degree is in theology. My in-progress master’s degree is in public administration. Basically, I'm skilled in the things you don't talk about at parties :-)

In many respects, I do consider myself better educated than the average church member on matters of theology, history of religion, biblical languages, etc. The better-educated thing, though in my view, does not mean I have a heightened sense of faith, as we know that does not guarantee one's faithfulness to God. (I am a protestant Christian). It’s the same case with my master’s degree. I would consider myself better educated about taxation, public organizations, government processes, etc than the average American.

While I feel like the knowledge I gained in my classes was invaluable, what I believe mentally made me "smarter" was not anything I did, but rather sitting under men and women who continually challenged my assumptions and thought processes. I didn't agree with all of them, all of the time, but they taught me to "think" and not "how to think."

Aside from sort of specializing in those fields, completing those degrees has given me the foresight to challenge statements, research, develop arguments, look at different perspectives, etc. Someone can easily gain this outside the classroom, but I think it is less likely. They will have to work much harder and possibly wait longer for that opportunity.

I think that if you have a non-degreed person who continually seeks out personal intellectual growth, either through reading or associating with people different from them, they will be just as capable as someone who has had that level of challenge from professors. My experience is obviously not the case in all situations, as some kids never show up to class, take a test, pass, and then get their paper.

I once had a professor who said, “There are no ignorant people, only ignore-ant.” 

Q The Rain in 5 4 3 2 --- 16 years ago -

A college degree shows you have dedication, stick-to-it-iveness, goal-oriented and will not guarantee you a job in this day and age. Some very, very smart people do not have degrees. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground