Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

No mammos until 50? Really? wow, cutbacks starting....

who's talking here?

marthas attic 3
freshhell 1
Carla 4
randyjet 12
planemom 1
mamadog53 1
lizandmike 3
funmom 4
LAXmom 1
R.E.B. 7
hummer 1
justforfun 6
~sassy~ 4
Perfection 2
Jpgirl 2
ladybughomeschool 7
PHSMOMOF2 3
TakeTheGlovesOff 1
jtcitrus 5
ladyjane 1
mommie21g1b 5
Wynter 4
One to go:) 7
Izzy'sMommy 2
magic70 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

And so it begins.... it saves lives, just not enough of them In a major change from past guidelines, a federal task force is recommending women not undergo routine breast cancer screening until they turn 50 and then only every other year. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force cited concerns about false-positive test results and unnecessary treatment in delivering its announcement today. The controversial recommendation comes after 25 years of calls for women to get a yearly mammogram beginning at 40, policy widely credited with a significant decline in breast cancer deaths over that period of time. The task force said the latest clinical data doesn't support that policy. “These guidelines represent a better way of maintaining the benefit of screening while reducing the harm,” said Dr. Diane Petitti, vice-chair of the task force, which was established by Congress to make recommendations about preventive care for healthy people. “They don't say women 40 to 49 should never be screened but that the decision should follow a conversation with their doctor, not be routine.” The new guidelines, published in Tuesday's Annals of Internal Medicine, say the latest data show mammography does save lives but that the false positives and spotting of cancers that wouldn't have needed treatment is greater in women in their forties. They say the data shows there is almost no difference in benefit at any age if mammography is undergone every two years instead of annually. The task force also recommends against teaching breast self-examination because no data exists to show it reduces deaths. That recommendation is not expected to be controversial. But the recommendation against routine mammography drew immediate criticism nationally from the American Cancer Society and locally from the University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center and Baylor College of Medicine's Cancer Center. All said they had no intention of following the task force's guidelines. “As someone who has long been a critic of those overstating the benefits of screening, I used these word advisedly: This is one screening test that I recommend unequivocally, and would recommend to any woman 40 and over, be she a patient, a stranger, or a family member,” Dr. Otis Brawley, the American Cancer Society's chief medical officer, said in a statement. “Surveys of women show that they are aware of (mammography's) limitations and also place high value on detecting breast cancer early.” Dr. Therese Bevers, medical director of M.D. Anderson's Cancer Prevention Center, dismissed the new guidelines, saying questions about routine mammography come up on a regular basis even though the data shows it results in fewer deaths. And Dr. Kent Osborne, director of Baylor's Cancer Center and Breast Center, noted that screening women in their forties is important because breast cancer that strikes when a woman is that age tends to be more aggressive. It is unclear what effect the task force guidelines will have on insurance company policies on women under 50 getting mammograms. Osborne said it's possible doctors would have to document that a patient is high risk in order for insurance to cover it. What is clear is that the task force's new guidelines reflect a debate now raging over the value of routine screening of many types of cancer. Increasingly, some experts are arguing that the benefits have been exaggerated and that the potential harm — both physical and psychological — needs to receive greater consideration. The debate has been loudest for prostate cancer's PSA test, which the task force last year recommended against for men over 75. The debate has been less public over mammography, though a study in the British Medical Journal this summer stirred discussion when it found that as many as one in every three breast cancers diagnosed by routine screening would never have become life-threatening. The study came on the heels of other research that found some breast cancers would naturally have regressed on their own. Petitti said the driving force for the task force's new guidelines was more mammography's false-positive results than the unnecessary treatment in which it sometimes results, though she acknowledged that was a factor too. She said statistical models show that about 60 percent more false-positive results occur for every 1,000 exams than if screening began at age 40 than had it started at 50; and that a lifetime of screening 1,000 women every year beginning at 40 results in 1,250 false positives, compared to 780 if they were screened every other year beginning at 50. In his statement, Brawley said the statistics suggest the task force is “essentially telling women that mammography at age 40 to 49 saves lives; just not enough of them.” He added that the task force is saying screening 1,339 women in their 50s to save one life makes it worthwhile in that age group but that screening 1,904 women in their 40s to save one life isn't. The American Cancer Society, he said, believes the benefit outweighs the harm in both cases.  

One to go:) --- 17 years ago -

My onocologist father would agree wholeheartedly, unless family history is profound. There are too many false positives and too much radiation. 

funmom --- 17 years ago -

that stinks.. i already had to get special permission to get mine through my ins.. since i was under 40.. but my mom had breast cancer so i had to get a letter from my dr.. i know a mammogram saved my moms life.. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Let the rationing begin. Lets not test for anything any longer, dang sick people just get in the way and cost money. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

My onocologist father would agree wholeheartedly, unless family history is profound. There are too many false positives and too much radiation. I was 38 years old with absolutely no family history and diagnosed with a Stage 3. Good thing I did not listen to your father. I was 38 years old with no family history. I guess I do not matter. 

One to go:) --- 17 years ago -

well, it's definitely good to get that baseline at a young age. But, my father suggests to definitely stay with the SAME radiologist to read your xrays, because the false diagnosis comes often from too many different people reading your results. Do you understand? Take care and good luck. 

One to go:) --- 17 years ago -

Good grief, of course you matter. Your case is rare, which I'm sure you were told. But, there have been very many surgeries, biopsies, and treatment for false positives because radiology is not always accurate. 

funmom --- 17 years ago -

all i know is that if the dr wouldnt have been persistant with my mom she would not be here with me today.. i will go every year even if i have to take out a loan and pay for it myself.. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

Your case is rare, which I'm sure you were told In the big picture I am rare but to me and my family that statistic was 100 %. 

One to go:) --- 17 years ago -

You're absolutely right, that in the big picture it's 100%. I am personally scared to have too much radiation in a yearly. But, I do not have a family history and do a thorough manual check frequently. This isn't an issue where everyone will agree, but I'm happy for you that you're a survivor 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

I can think of about 8 people just off the top of my head who have had breast cancer in their 20s and 30s. It is strange that while they are recommending less screening they are not recommending women give up things linked to breast cancer such as birth control pills and chemicals in our food?????? No wonder so many of us don't trust modern medicine! 

LAXmom --- 17 years ago -

The task force also recommends against teaching breast self-exams for all women and said evidence was insufficient to recommend mammograms for women older than 74. This is the line that literally blows my mind. They don't even want women to do self breast exams. 

One to go:) --- 17 years ago -

That's so true. In fact, another point that my oncologist father makes often is that preservatives are the most serious contribution to cancer. That is just his educated opinion, but it makes sense to me. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

You're absolutely right, that in the big picture it's 100%. I am personally scared to have too much radiation in a yearly. There are many more things to be concerned about than the low radiation levels of mammograms. I feed my dd organic whenever possible and never give her milk from cows treated with hormones. 95 % of the time she gets hormone free meat also. 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

Me too, anything unnatural "added" to the body has to have side effects whether is it a hormone, MSG, trans fat etc. The first line of defense should be a healthy lifestyle but at least a baseline mg should be done well before 50 IMO 

magic70 --- 17 years ago -

Aren't MRIs supposed to be better? 

funmom --- 17 years ago -

well i know this is one thing i would and will fight.. i am very passionate about testing for this.. at any age.. there was no breast cancer history in my family.. cancer yes but.. it has to start somewhere.. watching and helping my mom through her double mastectomy was a true eye opener.. seeing the strongest woman i know get upset about having her daughter change her dressings was very hard for me .. i gladly take the test.. i also had a scare myself 5 yrs ago at 34.. again i dont get mad about much but if someone tries to do this you will see one very very mad woman.. 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

I feed my dd organic whenever possible and never give her milk from cows treated with hormones. 95 % of the time she gets hormone free meat also. I am the same way, even our chocolate, crackers, and peanut butter are organic. Take any nonorganic label and compare it to an organic counterpart and you will see just how much extra crap goes into nonorganic food. 

Izzy'sMommy --- 17 years ago -

My mom was diagnosed at age 37 and died at 42; with no family history of breast cancer. Since they don't reccomend mammograms in your 30's, it was caught too late. I am 27 and will start getting them yearly at age 30 and will pay out of pocket. I don't care what the cost. 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

I don't blame you. I am going to get one at 30, no family history of bc, but have some lung cancer history (smokers) in the family. I will probably have to pay out of pocket but I don't care, I want a baseline. 

Wynter --- 17 years ago -

Let the rationing begin. Lets not test for anything any longer, dang sick people just get in the way and cost money. Is it difficult being such a--holes on a regular basis? 

freshhell --- 17 years ago -

I for one am glad. I am tired of getting my tits smashed for my birthday. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Let the rationing begin. Lets not test for anything any longer, dang sick people just get in the way and cost money. Is it difficult being such a--holes on a regular basis? You would know, you do it often enough. 

One to go:) --- 17 years ago -

I for one am glad. I am tired of getting my tits smashed for my birthday. lol! 

Wynter --- 17 years ago -

You would know, you do it often enough. What a comeback. lol 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I wonder if they will limit prostate exams for men or if they are only limiting womens services 

One to go:) --- 17 years ago -

Aren't prostate exams less expensive. Aren't they doing this because of the supposed great cost of the service? 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

I think they have already changed the age for prostate exams. Preventative medicine is expensive. It only makes sense to administer it based on a cost/benefit basis. It is probably why healthcare costs keep escalating. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

You would know, you do it often enough. What a comeback. lol I'm practicing being like you. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I wonder if they will limit prostate exams for men or if they are only limiting womens services NOBODY is limiting anything! If any thing will come out of this, it will be a bonanza for the insurance companies. All the study said was that they did NOT find a good basis for ROUTINE mammograms for many women under 50. They did NOT say it was prohibited, or not recommended for those most at risk. I see why you are Republican. I sure hope that you don't do that kind of a job reading on your job. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

I for one am glad. I am tired of getting my tits smashed for my birthday. No one is holding a gun to your head making you get the test. If you do not want it and do not feel you need it then do not get it. Easy enough. If the recommendations change then women who are dependent on insurance, Medicaid or our future National Healthcare will be unable to make an informed decision. It is no joke when young mothers die and leave kids to be raised by single Dad's because their cancer was not caught in time. Maybe if you had been in my shoes and rocked a 13 month old baby well into the night every night hoping that she would remember you because the drs gave you a 20 percent chance of survival it would not be so funny. Maybe if you spent the night on the bathroom floor throwing up you would take it more seriously. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Yep! 

Wynter --- 17 years ago -

You would know, you do it often enough. I'm practicing being like you. GTFU 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

You would know, you do it often enough. I'm practicing being like you. GTFU Are you a little testy? lol 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Is it difficult being such a--holes on a regular basis? Not when there are people like you around to piss off. Makes it worth the effort. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Is it difficult being such a--holes on a regular basis? Not when there are people like you around to piss off. Makes it worth the effort. Oh you see it too. lol 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Are you a little testy? lol Oh those testy lefty's. rolf 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Oh you see it too. lol Such tools. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

I was wondering what h/she's problem was but maybe they are just angry all the time. 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

NOBODY is limiting anything Guess again. Insurance companies do not pay for them unless there is an obvious problem or the woman is at the recommended age. Over half the people I know with a diagnosis never had symptoms and the cancer was caught by a routine mg. Think before you type. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground