Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The Experiance Machine

who's talking here?

Holling Vincoeur 2
BuiltinTX70 3
AMDG 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

This is a classic mind experiment - Thought it might be fun to see what folks think here.

The Experience Machine

Let's say they is a real machine. You climb into a tank, and they hook you up with feeding tubes. Neuropsychologists also hook up your mind to a machine that stimulates your brain to believe anything you want is actually happening. You are Tom Brady winning the super bowl, climbing mount Everest, writing moby dick, eating the best food, drinking the best wine, laying on the beach bora bora - whatever you want - anything can become real to you, but it is not real.

But there is one caveat - you have to sign up for life. Once you hook up - you can never unhook.

Remember - to you this is all real - the minute they hook you up - the machine will wipe your memory that this is not real - every thing to you is as real as what we perceive to be real now.

So would anyone hook up ?? 

Holling Vincoeur --- 9 years ago -

Nope, life is too good... 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Nope, life is too good...

Ok Offlimits - let me turn it around - Since you think that what you perceive as real life now is too good - let me tell you - you are already hooked up to the machine - Do you want to unplug ??? 

BuiltinTX70 --- 9 years ago -

Sounds like a ripoff of The Matrix :)

Ok, I'll play along, but here's a question. When I am hooked up and experiencing this other world, do I know that I really exist? 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

yea - very much the Matix without all the cool martial arts.

Ok, I'll play along, but here's a question. When I am hooked up and experiencing this other world, do I know that I really exist?

Answer is yes, just as much as you know you really exist now. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Should have added - this new reality will seem just as real to you as does this reality - 

BuiltinTX70 --- 9 years ago -

My initial answer is to say, then, definitely yes. That's because I could live a life that is essentially better than I have now.

But...after pondering that, I would be cheating myself and who I really am.

So my final answer is no.

However, I could see people certainly saying yes to this proposition. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

yea - the original purpose of the experiment was a test of the hedonist philosophy - that people should do what maximizes their pleasure. The belief was, given the choice- if you would forgo pleasure for reality - the theory was false.

I threw in the brain in vat scenario - the how do we know that what we perceive is real - Is actually real. Or, like in the matrix, are we just brains in a vat - being stimulated.

The classic - I think therefore I am 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

The other fun thing about this question, is how sure can you be that you can actually answer it truthfully ??

Since in your current reality, this is just a hypothetical - and since most would perceive the leaving of your current perceived life, the people you perceive in it, your responsibilities to run to this make believe eden - would be a less moral, weaker, more selfish choice. And since it is just hypothetical, and not real - it is too easy to say you wouldn't do it.

However if it was a real choice ... and since you would never know you made that choice - it would be without guilt - without any moral implications. Who knows 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Anyway - something to think about other than politics -

Have to go back to real life now, whatever that is 

BuiltinTX70 --- 9 years ago -

However if it was a real choice ... and since you would never know you made that choice - it would be without guilt - without any moral implications. Who knows

I would know right up till the last second what I am doing.....certainly would be scary!!!! 

Holling Vincoeur --- 9 years ago -

Do you want to unplug ????


Nah...


0 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground