Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Should a 17 year old be allowed to make this decision?

who's talking here?

Perfection 1
FANCY PANTS 4
SueRDH 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 3
*LOL* 1
Work in Progress 1
needsleep 1
sheddy 1
FabFive 1
witchywoman 2
ThisLady 1
a889324uu 1
EarthyBrie 2
Not KU 1
Slider152 6
Butterbean 7
Leila 1
mutton 1
jacobson 2
Wicked 5
Nurse3 1
YourMomsOutside 1
Porterican 1
XpressUrself 1
Detonator 1
lawa 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

A court will determine whether a 17-year-old girl, under something called the "mature minor doctrine," can be forced to undergo chemotherapy after she refused treatment for her cancer.
The case will go to the Connecticut Supreme court this week to determine whether the teen, identified in court papers as Cassandra, has "the fundamental right to have a say about what goes on with your [her] body," attorney Michael Taylor, who represents the teen's mother, told ABC News. Taylor was appointed by the public defender's office, and Cassandra has her own court-appointed lawyer, but they've filed joint appeals.
Cassandra was diagnosed with Hodgkin's lymphoma in September, but decided she didn't want to complete the prescribed treatment, according to a court summary. Her mother supported this decision, but the Department of Children and Families stepped in and ordered her mother to comply with the doctor's treatment recommendation.
"It's really for all the reasons you might imagine," said Taylor, adding that he couldn't go into more detail.
Although chemotherapy is a drug that destroys cancer cells, its side effects include hair loss, nausea, pain and fertility changes, according to the National Cancer Institute.
Cassandra underwent two chemotherapy treatments in November and then ran away from home and refused to continue treatments, according to the court summary.
A court hearing ensued in which Cassandra's doctors testified, and she was removed from her mother's home and placed in state custody so that the state could make medical decisions for her.
She has been has been living at Connecticut Children's Medical Center and forced to undergo chemotherapy for about three weeks.
The Hartford Courant reported that Cassandra has an 80 to 85 percent chance of surviving her cancer if she continues with her chemotherapy.
The state Department of Children and Families issued the following statement:
"When experts -- such as the several physicians involved in this case -- tell us with certainty that a child will die as a result of leaving a decision up to a parent, then the Department has a responsibility to take action. Even if the decision might result in criticism, we have an obligation to protect the life of the child when there is consensus among the medical experts that action is required. Much of the improvements in Connecticut's child welfare system have come from working with families voluntarily to realize solutions to family challenges. Unfortunately that can't happen in every situation, especially when the life of a child is at stake."
"No one is disputing that it's very serious," Taylor said. He said there's "a good chance" Cassandra could survive her cancer with treatment, and "there's a good chance she could die if she doesn't. None of us disagree about that."
Taylor said they're trying to argue that because Cassandra is competent, she should be allowed to make this decision for herself through something called the "mature minor doctrine," which has been adopted in Illinois and a few other states but rejected in Texas. The doctrine holds that some children are mature enough to make key life decisions for themselves. 

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

What do you all think of this? As a mom, I cannot imagine allowing my child to make this decision at that age. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

As a mother of a 17 year old, I've done a good job raising him - he's articulate, confident, and capable of making decisions. Even those I may not agree with. 

Leila --- 11 years ago -

It would be very, very hard. But if a 17 year old can be treated like an adult in the eyes of the law if they commit a crime, then I guess I would have to rationalize and say she should be able to make the decision an adult would be allowed to make. But if she were my child, I would be getting her every kind of support to influence her to not make that choice. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

People, including minors, make decisions frequently that directly affect their lives, and are not what I would recommend or approve of.

Let her make the decision without interference. 

Perfection --- 11 years ago -

They can make decisions to get abortions at that age.

If they can make a decision to kill a baby why not themselves? 

FabFive --- 11 years ago -

I would like to think that if my child felt so strongly about it I'd respect their decision. 

FANCY PANTS --- 11 years ago -

Because a 17 year old is old enough to get an abortion without the consent of their parents, then yes, the state should keep their noise out of her business about her treatment of Hodgkin's lymphoma. It seems that the government only wants to control kids when the kid does not want to do something like chemo. If she wanted an abortion they would be all for it.

On the other hand, Hodgkin's lymphoma is very treatable. If she is treated she has an 85% chance of survival. If I were the parent I would want my child to have the treatment. In this case the mom seems to want to let the girl go without treatment. If it means life or death for my child, I would push for life. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

They can make decisions to get abortions at that age.

Yes, they can. Thankfully. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

Indeed- 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

Not thankfully, two very sad comments. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

Hey Jake. Welcome back from the land of ice.

Now you'll have to take a chill pill to get the same effect.

Try it. You'll like it. 

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

The state of Texas actually rejected that doctrine.

What is interesting is that many of you are not ok with killing an unborn baby, but you are ok with a 17 year old killing herself. This is a curable cancer. She is not terminal unless she does not get the treatment. So, is this suicide by cancer? 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

What is interesting is that many of you are not ok with killing an unborn baby, but you are ok with a 17 year old killing herself. This is a curable cancer. She is not terminal unless she does not get the treatment. So, is this suicide by cancer?

You actually know none of that. It's pure speculation on your part. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

Choosing not to treat an existing disease is not suicide. Good grief! 

EarthyBrie --- 11 years ago -

Does it freak anyone else out that a state agency took custody of this girl over medical treatments? That is shocking to me. Perhaps this is paranoid, but where will the line be drawn in other instances? At what point is it okay for the state to decide that they are going to take custody because you aren't making proper decisions for the child?

Didn't vaccinate your kids? Didn't feed them the government recommended diet? Child rides their bike without a helmet. Maybe your kids don't get enough sleep at night. You have now lost custody!

Obviously I'm being overly paranoid here (am I?), but really... If the mom and the daughter both agreed no treatments, then it is very scary to me that they took custody of her. As a mother myself, the thought of the state coming in, taking custody, and making medical decisions for my daughter is very frightening indeed. 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

Has been done before, but with much younger children. This is a hard one, at 17 you hope they make wise choices. As a parent I would have a very difficult time with this choice if there is 80% chance of survival. I have no answer. If not in those shoes too hard to know how I would react... 

YourMomsOutside --- 11 years ago -

The HUMAN BRAIN does not finish MATURING until mid to late twenties. The choices I made at 17 are certainly not the choices I would make today. 

FANCY PANTS --- 11 years ago -

Does it freak anyone else out that a state agency took custody of this girl over medical treatments?

Yes, it does freak me out! The state should not take custody of a 17 year old who has decided that she does not want treatment. She is not even a full year from being an adult. I do not agree with the fact that she does not want the treatment but feel it should be her choice, not the states. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

The HUMAN BRAIN does not finish MATURING until mid to late twenties.

A MATURE brain doesn't automatically make good decisions. For example, some of the comments being made concerning abortion. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

A MATURE brain doesn't automatically make good decisions. For example, some of the comments being made concerning abortion.

Absolutely correct, Jake. You must have taken the chill pill. 

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

Earthie your 17 y/o daughter is diagnosed with a curable form of cancer. Your response. Oh just let nature take its course? Really? Do you find this a bit abnormal? 

needsleep --- 11 years ago -

Yes she should have the right to make her own decision in this. As a parent I would think some of her decision will be influenced by her parents. 17 yr olds can join the military with a written consent from their parents, 17 year Olds are tried as adults all the time and there is emancipation of minors it shouldn't even be a question. Now if she gets worse and decides to do the treatment does her insurance have to pay for chemo later because she did not follow doctors orders? 

sheddy --- 11 years ago -

I hope she lives and has a long, long life. Years from now, I hope she is thanking all the people who fought for her survival and I hope she can forgive her mother for thinking a 17 has enough life experiences to make that kind of decision. 

FANCY PANTS --- 11 years ago -

curable form of cancer.
Oh just let nature take its course? Really? Do you find this a bit abnormal??


Yes, It is very abnormal of the mother to want her daughter to with hold treatment for a cancer that is so treatable. I find it very odd. But, I still think at the age of 17 the girl is old enough to make her own decision. If the girl were already 18, we would not be having this conversation, or would we? Would the hospital, doctors, or government think it was their business? 

EarthyBrie --- 11 years ago -

Wicked- If it happened to my daughter, I would personally make her do the treatment. But that's not the point I was discussing. I was trying to point out that the family agreed on what they wanted to do, and the state came in and took custody. That is what frightens me. Whether or not I agree with the moms decision is not relevant. Was just trying to discuss where does the state draw the line? Could you lose custody if you choose not to vaccinate and your kid gets a life threatening illness? At what point can the state back off and let families make their own decision. 

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

Not vaccinating does not make you terminally ill. This is a life threatening illness. There is a difference. And yes, if your child gets a life threatening illness from not vaccinating, you should be held accountable. Some families are not capable of making good decisions. Some people should not be parents at all. I saw that many times over the years. Still see it today. It is too bad that we have to have any government organization overseeing parts of our lives but until we, as Americans are 100 percent, law abiding citizens, we will have to deal with a few rules. 

*LOL* --- 11 years ago -

UPDATE on this story:


A 17-year-old Connecticut girl who was forced to have chemotherapy for her cancer is finally being released from the hospital today after she was removed from her home almost four months ago.

Cassandra Fortin, from Hartford, has finished the treatment a court decided she must undergo at Connecticut Children's Medical Center after being diagnosed with Hodgkin's lymphoma in September.

The teenager, whose cancer is now in remission, made national headlines after she and her mother initially refused the treatment and said they wanted to explore natural alternatives.

But in January a court ruled that Cassandra could not make the decision because she was not legally mature enough and the state's Department of Children and Families gained temporary custody of her.

Cassandra announced in a Facebook post on Saturday that she had 'less than 48 hours left in the hospital' and 'couldn't be happier', according to the Associated Press.

The teen was reunited with her mother just weeks ago on Easter Sunday for the first time in three months.

Cassandra's mother Jackie revealed details about the reunion on the 'FreeCassandra' Facebook page.

What a feeling to hold her and tell her I love her! She greeted me by running down the hallway yelling mom with her arms wide open!'

'This is a very special Easter Sunday.'

In March Cassandra told NBC she had not been allowed to see or speak to her mother since the New Year.

Cassandra gave a list of people who were allowed to visit her to the Connecticut Department of Children and Families (DCF), but said she had yet to see her mother or her boyfriend.

'For the most part I don't get many visitors,' she wrote in an interview conducted over Facebook chat.

Cassandra told NBC that the guard who stood outside her door had been removed, but that she was still only allowed to visit the cafeteria when escorted by a nurse, patient care assistant or child-welfare official.

The teenager insisted that she was prepared to try chemotherapy, but only after exploring other 'alternative' methods first.

Cassandra's mother Jackie told NBC Connecticut that her daughter has long held the belief that she does not want 'poison' in her body.

Doctors said the six rounds of chemotherapy treatment would give Cassandra an 85 per cent chance of survival, but without it there was a near-certainty of death within two years.

The teen said she was informed by doctors in early March that her cancer was now in remission.

Cassandra wrote on Facebook that she never wanted to die and that she was grateful she had responded well to the drugs.

The teenager added that she did not regret challenging her doctor's orders.

'I stood up and fought for my rights,' she wrote.

Several states recognize the 'mature minor doctrine', but the Connecticut court said the teen did not understand the severity of her condition.

The state Supreme Court ruled in January that Connecticut wasn't violating Cassandra's rights by forcing her to undergo treatment.

In January Cassandra called the experience a 'continuous nightmare'.

'It's disgusting that I'm fighting for a right that I and anyone in my situation should already have,' she wrote in the Hartford Courant.

'This is my life and my body, not DCF's and not the state's. I am a human ? I should be able to decide if I do or don't want chemotherapy.

'Whether I live 17 years or 100 years should not be anyone's choice but mine.' 

Detonator --- 11 years ago -

Her body

Her decision

She has enough to worry about

F**k the courts. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

I think its a states right to make that call. Not that long ago there was a woman from Oregon that terminated her life after a terminal diagnosis. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

I remember being 17. I remember thinking I knew what was best for me when I was 17 (I was pretty mature at 17). And I was wrong. I didn't have enough life experience to know what was best for me at that point in my life. I know people in their mid-twenties who still don't know what's best for them.
Sure, there are some mature 17 year-olds, but that doesn't mean they know what's best for them. And who says it's all about them. What about the care-givers, why must anyone suffer through the agony of caring for someone due to an uninformed decision.
Those of you who say she has the right to make this decision have obviously never personally provided care for someone who is totally bed-ridden. It takes a toll on your body, your emotions, your family, your finances (you can't provide care 24/7 for someone and have a job). And a nursing home will divide the family and cost a great deal.
It's no different that me being in the same situation and telling my wife I've decided against treatment and that she'll eventually have to care for me 24/7. That would be extremely selfish to put her through that. And it's something I shouldn't be allowed to do if I have people who depend on me.
Im sorry, 17 year-olds are not emotionally or mentally equipped to make an informed decision of this magnitude.
Now if the treatment would only prolong her life for a few months, then she has the right to make that decision, but for something that can most likely save her, nope.
Who else agrees with me on the poor decision making of 17 year-olds?
The insurance industry.
The tobacco industry.
The alcohol industry.
Rental car agencies.
Voting board.
Gun dealers.
Bar tending.
Driving with a car full of other teenagers.
Clubs.
The list keeps going...
The vast majority of teenagers are not capable of making the right choice on pretty much anything.
On an episode of "The Biggest Loser" once, I saw a father who didn't agree with his 18 year-old son's decision to change trainers. When asked what he thought about it... The father said, "he's an idiot... He a teenager, all teenagers are idiots".
That pretty much summed it up right there. 

Porterican --- 11 years ago -

And we think the government will make the right decision for her? Sure.... 

FANCY PANTS --- 11 years ago -

I would not want my 17 year old to make that decision. I would want them to get medical treatment and I would encourage them to. I do not feel the mother in this case wanted her daughter to get treatment and I disagree with her. But, I do not think the government has the right to make the decision for her. Would they step in when she was 18, 22, or 26 years old? Will the government decide they should step in and control all of our medical decisions no matter how old we are? When does it stop. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

I think that "We the people" have decided (through our elected officials) to do two things...
1. Define a child as anyone under the age of 18 (this includes 17).
2. Create laws to protect and defend children (see #1 for definition of a child). In some cases, child protection means taking the decision away from the short-sighted or inept parents.

I don't see any difference between this and taking the decision away from a 17 year old to stay with an abusive parent or a sex offender. 

SueRDH --- 11 years ago -

I moved out of my parents' house when I was 17. I had my own job and paid my own bills. Some 17 years olds are mature enough to make that decision. Others are not. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

My Great-grandfather left home at 15 to help the family out by driving trucks, my grandfather left home at 16, lied about his age and joined the army during WW2. My father left home at 17 to start working on the railroad. I left home at 19 for college, briefly home again after college, then out for good at 22.
See the pattern here...
The current generation is barely capable of changing their clothes without help. If it doesn't have a keypad for texting... They're lost.
When the current generation reaches the age of 25-27, they'll be ready to make educated and informed decisions.
You can make your own decisions when you're an adult... You're not an adult until you can pay your mortgage or rent, and ALL of your bills. Until then, you rely on other people to make decisions for you. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

You can make your own decisions when you're an adult... You're not an adult until you can pay your mortgage or rent, and ALL of your bills. Until then, you rely on other people to make decisions for you.

I don't believe that's a legal definition. 

XpressUrself --- 11 years ago -

18 is of legal age not 17. They should still be under they should still be under the care of the parents until the age of 18. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

Not a legal definition, but it's what motivates children to become adults in every sense of the word. Age doesn't give anyone say over my house rules. Nothing changes from the last day you were 17 to the morning you turn 18. I still make the decisions in my house and you have to live with my decisions and because your life affects mine while you live at my house, I make make decisions for your life as well. If you don't like my decisions, then maybe that motivates you to become more responsible and plan something for your life. You won't be treated like an adult until you are no longer dependant on me for anything.
An example...
At 22, I was married and had bought my first house. I was not only an adult by age, but also by behavior and actions.
At 27, my sister is a single mom living with my parents. Though she is an adult by age, she is not an adult by behavior or actions. She has very little say in what goes on in her life because she's dependant on someone else's charity. She's obviously incapable of making the right decisions in her life and by proxy has had a negative affect on everyone around her. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

Just found this and like it a lot...
In fact, I would concede that this would constitute an adult at any age. You're 16 and fully understand and can demonstrate what's in this passage, I'd say you were an adult. You're 30 and still don't get it... Not an adult.

How can one classify a true adult? Many people directly attribute age to adulthood. The problem with this methodology becomes evident when you discuss the topic with various people of different cultural backgrounds. If you ask each of them what age they believe constitutes the point at which a person progresses from childhood into adulthood, their answers will always be different. Why? Because every one of the answers are based on subjective opinion. Adulthood is not based age; it?s based strictly on emotional maturity.

So what constitutes emotional maturity, and thus adulthood? Here are 20 defining characteristics of a true adult:

Realizing that maturity is an ongoing process, not a state, and continuously striving for self improvement.
Able to manage personal jealousy and feelings of envy.
Has the ability to listen to and evaluate the viewpoints of others.
Maintains patience and flexibility on a daily basis.
Accepts the fact that you can?t always win, and learns from mistakes instead of whining about the outcome.
Does not overanalyze negative points, but instead looks for the positive points in the subject being analyzed.
Is able to differentiate between rational decision making and emotional impulse.
Understands that no skill or talent can overshadow the act of preparation.
Capable of managing temper and anger.
Keeps other people?s feeling in mind and limits selfishness.
Being able to distinguish between ?needs? and ?wants?.
Shows confidence without being overly arrogant.
Handles pressure with self composure.
Takes ownership and responsibility of personal actions.
Manages personal fears.
Able to see the various shades of grey between the extremes of black and white in every situation.
Accepts negative feedback as a tool for self improvement.
Aware of personal insecurities and self-esteem.
Able to separate true love from transitory infatuation.
Understanding that open communication is the key to progression.

Above all, true adults do what they have to do when it is required of them, and they do what they want when they can. They are able to distinguish between the two and manage their time and efforts accordingly.

Now show me a 17 year old that demonstrates thus... And I'll show you an adult. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground