Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Interesting point on illegal workers

who's talking here?

sunshine1881 3
SoupIsGoodFood 1
Perfection 4
I_won't_tell 1
Ender 13
Emperor of Kingwood 5
jacobson 1
AMDG 15
FireWife 1
Big D 1
thesweetness 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ender --- 12 years ago -

I did not create this, I just picked it out of the comments section from this article.

http://news.yahoo.com/mexico-california-texas-border-troop-plan-030034338.html

"Subject: John Legal vs. Juan Illegal


You have two families: "John Legal" and "Juan Illegal". Both families have two parents, two children, and live in Arizona ..

John Legal works in construction, has a Social Security Number and makes $25.00 per hour with taxes deducted.

Juan Illegal also works in construction, has NO Social Security Number, and gets paid $15.00 in cash "under the table".

Ready? Now pay attention....

John Legal: $25.00 per hour x 40 hours = $1000.00 per week, or $52,000.00 per year. Now take 30% away for state and federal tax; John Legal now has $31,231.00.

Juan Illegal: $15.00 per hour x 40 hours = $600.00 per week, or $31,200 per year.Juan Illegal pays no taxes. Juan Illegal now has $31,200.00.

John Legal pays medical and dental insurance with limited coverage for his family at $600.00 per month, or $7,200.00 per year. John Legal now has $24,031.00.

Juan Illegal has full medical and dental coverage through the state and local clinics and emergency hospitals at a cost of $0.00 per year. Juan Illegal still has $31,200.00.

John Legal makes too much money and is not eligible for food stamps or welfare. John Legal pays $500.00 per month for food, or $6,000..00 per year. John Legal now has $18,031.00.

Juan Illegal has no documented income and is eligible for food stamps, WIC and welfare. Juan Illegal still has $31,200.00.

John Legal pays rent of $1,200.00 per month, or $14,400.00 per year. John Legal now has 9,631.00.

Juan Illegal receives a $500.00 per month Federal Rent Subsidy. Juan Illegal pays out that $500.00 per month, or $6,000.00 per year. Juan Illegal still has $ 31,200.00.

John Legal pays $200.00 per month, or $2,400.00 for car insurance. Some of that is uninsured motorist insurance. John Legal now has $7,231.00.

Juan Illegal says, "We don't need no stinkin' insurance!" and still has $31,200.00.

John Legal has to make his $7,231.00 stretch to pay utilities, gasoline, etc..

Juan Illegal has to make his $31,200.00 stretch to pay utilities, gasoline, and what he sends out of the country every month..

John Legal now works overtime on Saturdays or gets a part time job after work.

Juan Illegal has nights and weekends off to enjoy with his family.

John Legal's and Juan Illegal's children both attend the same elementary school. John Legal pays for his children's lunches, while Juan Illegal's children get a government sponsored lunch. Juan Illegal's children have an after school ESL program. John Legal's children go home.

Now, when they reach college age, John Legal's kids may not get into a State School and may not qualify for scholarships, grants or other tuition help, even though John has been paying for state schools through his taxes, while Juan Illegal's kids "go to the head of the class" because they are a minority.

John Legal and Juan Illegal both enjoy the same police and fire services, but John paid for them and Juan did not pay.

If you vote for or support any politician that supports illegal aliens... You are part of the problem! Go to numbers usa on the web to make your voice heard today!" 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

What should we do with the guy who hired Juan, under the table, to save $10/hr and increase his profits ?? 

I_won't_tell --- 12 years ago -

GREAT post and message! 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

What should we do with the guy who hired Juan, under the table, to save $10/hr and increase his profits ??

Penalize him.

I am not a business law guru by any stretch, but it doesn't take one to see that the consequences for using illegal labor are not harsh enough.

Just like every issue we face, this one does not exist in a vacuum separate from the rest. If the guy who hired Juan did so because his business is being starved by over-regulation, those issues need to be addressed as well. 

Big D --- 12 years ago -

Change the name to Tyrone Williams or Billy Ray and keep the cash under the table job and you see that this is a class warfare post. It is more about anti-welfare than it is about immigration. The character of Juan Illegal was used just to make class warfare and welfare be about an immigration problem. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Penalize him.

yea, if we really want to make a significant dent in the use of illegal labor we need to investigate, take to trail, and if guilty - severely punish the people who utilize this labor force simply to increase their profits.

This will be much more cost effective than trying to completely secure the border.

If you limit the opportunities for employment, by making the penalties and enforcement of punitive enough to have a real impact. Less and less will come.

We need to save some of our anger for the people supplying the demand for this illegal work force. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

How many of you here in Kingwood pay your housekeepers cash?

How many of you pay your lawn people cash?

Aren't you doing the same? 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

How many of you here in Kingwood pay your housekeepers cash?

How many of you pay your lawn people cash?

Aren't you doing the same?


Yes, you are. They come here to work, they can't work legally, there are people on the other side of that transaction. I never see the outrage on this board for them. Not exactly sure why.

Is employing someone illegally less of a crime than working illegally ?? 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

I think that is a fair question AMDG.

It is easy to point fingers at others but not realize each one is doing the same thing.

Most people think it only matters if others are violating laws but when they do it it is acceptable for a variety of reasons. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

Change the name to Tyrone Williams or Billy Ray and keep the cash under the table job and you see that this is a class warfare post. It is more about anti-welfare than it is about immigration.


I don't agree with you, but you have a valid point for the most part. The only thing I would point out that doesn't translate into "class warfare" with Jethro is the minority specific benefits that illegal children get. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

How many of you here in Kingwood pay your housekeepers cash?

How many of you pay your lawn people cash?

Aren't you doing the same?



I would venture to say that paying someone for a transactional service such as cleaning or lawn care is NOT the same thing as employing them on a permanent basis.

You do not provide healthcare for your landscaper either, do you? 

FireWife --- 12 years ago -

Good post Ender 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

I would venture to say that paying someone for a transactional service such as cleaning or lawn care is NOT the same thing as employing them on a permanent basis.

Agree, to a point.

If you hire a lawn service, and they in turn hire workers, I think for the most part you are removed. If however, you wish to pay by check, and they will not accept it, well you are close to the line. If they offer you some significant discount for cash, and you take it, you are over the line. You know why there is a discount for cash, but you take it anyway and justify it to yourselves, however makes you feel good.

But you just voted with your pocketbook.

On the other hand, if you hire a cleaning person, and don't do any real due diligence to see if he or she is legal. And if you pay them in cash, you are once again voting with your pocketbook.

In general, many of the folks screaming about the problem of illegal immigration, vote everyday with their pocketbook to support it. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -


In general, many of the folks screaming about the problem of illegal immigration, vote everyday with their pocketbook to support it.



And that's the bottom line.

Everyone can make an excuse that paying someone cash and them not declaring it isn't like really employing them but that's not true and logically they know it.

You are employing them by paying for the service, that is the definition of employment, money for goods or services.

It doesn't matter if the person in this scenario is legal or illegal you are helping them break the law and possibly collecting benefits they are not otherwise entitled to 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

It doesn't matter if the person in this scenario is legal or illegal you are helping them break the law and possibly collecting benefits they are not otherwise entitled to

That's the key, and addressing that would go a long way toward curing a lot of the problems people are complaining about.

Working under the table and misusing public benefits are not a illegal immigrant issue. They are simply a widespread issue. There are plenty of whites, blacks, Hispanics, etc. doing it. The only way to address it is good enforcement and harsh penalties on the employers and business owners who use under the table labor. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

The only way to address it is good enforcement and harsh penalties on the employers and business owners who use under the table labor.

How about REAL enforcement and harsh penalties for those who abuse the system? 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Soup - not 100% sure your point. Do you not think that people who profit off illegal employment are not abusing the system? 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

How about REAL enforcement and harsh penalties for those who abuse the system?

What is the most cost-effective and efficient way to address the problem? Go after the employers who employ multiple people "under-the-table"? Or go after each individual "under-the-table" worker?

My cost-benefit analysis on that would definitely say go after the employers, make it unprofitable for them to hire workers illegally, and make a substantial dent in the problem. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Agree sunshine - also, I have much less sympathy for an upper middle class business owner offering illegal employment to enrich himself further, than a poor person accepting illegal employment to work for significantly less pay due solely to their illegal status. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

My cost-benefit analysis on that would definitely say go after the employers, make it unprofitable for them to hire workers illegally, and make a substantial dent in the problem.


ding ding, we have a winner 

thesweetness --- 12 years ago -

How about REAL enforcement and harsh penalties for those who abuse the system?

Tyson Foods, Koch Foods, Pilgrims Pride? Ohh, you didn't mean them did you? Please correct me if I'm wrong. 

thesweetness --- 12 years ago -

How about REAL enforcement and harsh penalties for those who abuse the system?

Tyson Foods, Koch Foods, Pilgrims Pride? Ohh, you didn't mean them did you? Please correct me if I'm wrong.


?? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

What should we do with the guy who hired Juan, under the table, to save $10/hr and increase his profits ??

Its a violation of the law to hire illegal workers. Aprehend and prosecute. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

The character of Juan Illegal was used just to make class warfare and welfare be about an immigration problem.

Wouldn't one reduce if the other did? 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Its a violation of the law to hire illegal workers. Aprehend and prosecute.

Agree - don't hear much of that happening though. May just not be news, but don't seem to hear of it all
that often. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

If you hire someone to mow the lawn, you are hiring a contractor on a contract basis, not an employee. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

If you hire someone to mow the lawn, you are hiring a contractor on a contract basis, not an employee.

Not sure I understand the point.

Is it OK to hire illegal contractors?

Is it OK if you really don't know for sure ?

Is it OK if it saves you a few buck ??

But think this may appy -

In general, many of the folks screaming about the problem of illegal immigration, vote everyday with their pocketbook to support it. 

thesweetness --- 12 years ago -

Is it OK to hire illegal contractors?

Sounds like it. It's the manipulators that created the mess as evidenced by the answer you got AMDG. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Not sure I understand the point.

Its a fee for service arrangement or in other words, independant contractor. ICE says its not incumbent on me or anyone to validate citizenship or right to work. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

Its a fee for service arrangement or in other words, independant contractor. ICE says its not incumbent on me or anyone to validate citizenship or right to work.


In other words: Its not my job to verify the citizenship status of the guy who mows my lawn, its my governments job to make sure anybody asking for that job is legal. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Its a fee for service arrangement or in other words, independant contractor. ICE says its not incumbent on me or anyone to validate citizenship or right to work.

Understand - kind of like don't ask don't tell. I get it. And I once again repeat:

In general, many of the folks screaming about the problem of illegal immigration, vote everyday with their pocketbook to support it. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -


In general, many of the folks screaming about the problem of illegal immigration, vote everyday with their pocketbook to support it.



I understand what you are saying, but do you have a proposed solution to the wrongdoing you keep bringing up?

Should I ask any Hispanic looking person for their papers to verify that they are legal before i give them $25 to mow my yard?

I am sure that there are plenty here that would say that is racist. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Ender - sorry have to dash - will answer when I have a sec - mea culpa 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

I love how people are trying to justify both their hiring people breaking the law and those breaking the law

Look I agree go after businesses who are doing it, go after the people who are doing it and go after the illegals.

All three legs of the stool.

And if you are part of the problem, then that's on you and there is NO justification you can give that makes it right. 

thesweetness --- 12 years ago -

And if you are part of the problem, then that's on you and there is NO justification you can give that makes it right.

exactly. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

I understand what you are saying, but do you have a proposed solution to the wrongdoing you keep bringing up?

Should I ask any Hispanic looking person for their papers to verify that they are legal before i give them $25 to mow my yard?

I am sure that there are plenty here that would say that is racist.


Sorry the delay -

On a personal basis - If you deal with a reputable business (lawn service, contractor, restaurant, etc) it is their responsibility to not hire illegal labor.

If you hire an individual, cut your grass, cleaning lady, quick tile job, etc, it is your responsibility not to hire illegal labor.

That said - If you don't want to ask, and you are enjoying the benefit of the cheap labor. Fine, just stop complaining about the illegal immigration problem. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

If you hire an individual, cut your grass, cleaning lady, quick tile job, etc, it is your responsibility not to hire illegal labor.



I agree with what you are saying here, I am just trying to get into the nitty-gritty details of what you are proposing.

Should civilians be responsible for checking the legal status of anyone that they "suspect" may be illegal?

Of course employers need to do this for tax purposes, but do private citizens need to do this?

can private citizens even do this? Is there some resource that I have access to right now that will allow me to check the citizenship status of my cleaning lady? If so, I am not aware of it.

I know that I could ask to see someones ID, but is that really enough verification?

As an aside: My landscaping guy is someone I met in college who does fantastic work. My only problem with him is that he is an Oakie 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

I love how people are trying to justify both their hiring people breaking the law and those breaking the law

Look I agree go after businesses who are doing it, go after the people who are doing it and go after the illegals.

All three legs of the stool.

And if you are part of the problem, then that's on you and there is NO justification you can give that makes it right.



I am genuinely interested in seeing some numbers on how many illegals work for large employers -vs- individual contract work like we are discussing here.

I would venture to say that a LARGE majority of illegal immigrants are employed by corporations, not people getting their lawns mowed. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

I would venture to say that a LARGE majority of illegal immigrants are employed by corporations, not people getting their lawns mowed.

I think not. I think most of them work in the construction, landscaping and domestic services industries where no I9 form is ever completed. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

I think not. I think most of them work in the construction, landscaping and domestic services industries where no I9 form is ever completed.

I see an awful lot of them being bussed around east Houston where I work. Usually the illegals are hired through "temp agencies" which completely removes the I9 requirement from the Business itself. The temp agencies themselves are basically throw away, so if they get busted they just disappear and come back with a different name.

That's the story that I hear from our newly legal friends that we hire out here. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground