Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is your doctor part of a 'concierge' practice?

who's talking here?

napoleon 1
planemom 1
ukchristine 5
Spunkin 1
Perfection 6
Cookin' Queen 1
Dorothy Parker 1
TinktheSprite 4
sheddy 3
Charli 1
tennismommy 1
Sweet Cherub 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

We got a letter from our doctor this week telling us that because of the health care changes, in order for her to be able to afford to stay in practice and provide quality healthcare, she is going to become a concierge physician. I was just curious if anyone else has heard this from their doctor, or if anyone else already has a concierge physician? 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

That's awesome, it is a great way to insure you get timely care and more personal attention. 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

In theory it sounds great Perfection. I am just not sure how the whole thing works yet. We are going to an informational meeting soon to find out all the details. I don't really understand how insurance fits into all of this. I very much like the idea that I would or my family members would be able to get in to see her the same day, as that NEVER happens how, and also that we will have access to her cell phone and fax and have answers immediately to health questions or prescription refills. Also, she will have a lot more time to spend with you when you are in her office, as opposed to rushing in and out because she is so busy. I just have to weigh whether it will be worth an additional $2500. per year for all of this. We already pay $1600 per month in health insurance and about $500 per month in prescriptions. Also, I wonder if this would qualify under medical expenses on our taxes...could we possibly write it off? Lots of questions... 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

concierge practices have been around for a while now. Many of the people who use them love them which is why the Texas AMA has all the standard letters on their website and educates physicians in Texas on how to convert from an insurance paid office to concierge office.

As for this as a medical expense, no, under IRS rules it does not qualify.

THis works because what they do is reserve a certain number of appointments for concierge members and non-concierge patients are bumped out of their appointments so the paying patients can get in.

Your insurance is still billed and they pay, you pay your copay like normal. The fee you are paying is for access.

This is a way the offices are finding they can raise revenue so they can stay open while dealing with the costs associated with electronic medical records (those systems can cost a small office 100K or more and the grants to help pay for them are drying up), staff re-education for ICD 10 (even though it is now delayed another year that will cost them another $60k), new technology for testing in the office and other costs associated with being in business.

It's a way to get more money since insurance payments are being capped. 

napoleon --- 12 years ago -

So you pay $2500 a year plus your insurance co-pays for each visit? $2500 seems high but it sounds like you would get good service. Tough decision. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Yes that's pretty normal amount napoleon.

I know of some physicians locally who even have seperate waiting areas for paying vs non-paying patients.

One is MUCH nicer than the other. 

planemom --- 12 years ago -

We may have the same doctor. I'm going to try it out. If I thought I'd stay healthy for the next 20 years I'd skip the extra cost. However, there is a good chance I'll end up with a long term illness that will require many doctor visits. Having one doctor overseeing and even helping with specialists will be worth the money. 

tennismommy --- 12 years ago -

Already happened to us last month. 

TinktheSprite --- 12 years ago -

Concierge practices are few and vary greatly especially the membership fees. Some do not accept insurance but rather have a "menu" of procedures they do and what you can claim for on your own. This is an important part that I need to know about.

I don't like class separation and it seems bad business practice to do it. "The more money you make the more you get"?? Including a nicer waiting room?? Should this apply to healthcare?? 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

People keep forgetting that some doctors do this as a way to keep the doors open. Next time you go to the doctor look around and see their overhead. It cost a fortune to open the door and they don't see most of the money until the insurance pays up. I heard a woman about ten years ago on the radio. She said her husband had gone to strictly cash. HIs fees were cheaper and patients filed their own insurance. He got his money up front and he didn't have to have all the office help. Our doctor started charging fees for all kinds of stuff that used to be free, but he has to pay people do call in prescriptions, lab orders, etc for people who don't to make an office appointment. 

Charli --- 12 years ago -

My endo went concierge in January. He also sees patients on a cash basis. No insurance. We opted for appointments and paying cash and not concierge services this year.

I love the idea!! Paid $70 for a 40 minute appointment. I can file that $70 with my insurance as an out of network expense to meet deductible. Can also file it with IRS stuff. 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

Well, it is all kind of confusing, but we are just going to wait until we go to the informational meeting and get all of our questions answered. We don't want to switch doctors. We have been with her for a long time and she is a good doctor and a no-nonsense person, which I really appreciate. She tells it like it is. As far as the concierge patients getting preferential treatment, that is the way it is in most other businesses. You get what you pay for. If we can afford to do this, and she is the doctor we want, why not? Too many doctors these days just want to write you a prescription and get you in and out quickly. You feel like you are just a number. Our doctor doesn't do that. She knows us. And I really appreciate that. If there is any possible way for us to stay with her, we will. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

I spoke to a doctor recently that switched to a concierge practice and lost a ton of patients.

Not sure if it's a good business move or not.

With the way Urgent Care clinics are popping up everywhere, general/family practitioners in private practice are becoming obsolete. 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

We have used Rediclinic plenty of times. It is great to have a place to go in the evening or weekends. I don't want to go to the doctor's office and never know who will walk in the door. I like seeing the same doctor. 

Cookin' Queen --- 12 years ago -

I use Dr Google a lot! I get more info there than from a doctor. Got me thru passing kidney stones twice which would have cost $$$$ if I had gone to the ER.

Hoping that someday we can have Dr Skype. Why can't I just go get lab work 3 or 4 times a year for my thyroid and glucose numbers and Skype a PA for results and I can tell them what my BP and temp is. That is all my doc does 3 or 4 times a year for $200 a pop. Between waiting time in the office and exam room it is a waste of almost 2 hours. Not mention sitting around with sick people and getting a cold or the flu. 

ukchristine --- 12 years ago -

I just heard that info from my doc. She's going fro 4000 patients to 500. I don't recall the caveat re keeping you doc costing an extra $1500. Or that your doc won't keep you. Thou right from the get go that's what I envisaged. I also entirely understand the docs rationale . 

TinktheSprite --- 12 years ago -

My BIL doctor is not in favor of Concierge Plan for his practic but understands how lower-paid practices could benefit. Patient benefit? Not really, says he. 

ukchristine --- 12 years ago -

I do think the 3500 patients will find it hard to find a doc. Which docs are taking on new patients? 

ukchristine --- 12 years ago -

Lower paid practices??? 

TinktheSprite --- 12 years ago -

He said for example surgeons or specialsts won't be doing this but more family practice doctors who do not benefit from charging for surgeries will get on board. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Please understand that some of this is also being driven by quality standards being measured by CMS and therefore by the insurance companies.

CMS requires insurance companies measure a physician's performance on a wide variety of measures - everything from % of kids getting their well visits (typically less than 50% do), to % of women getting cervical screenings, to diabetics getting their bloodwork measured timely to number of patients who go to the ER instead of the PCP and so on. These measures then are used to determine the payment rate for the physician as well as other things (such as being put on corrective action plans).

These are cumbersome to offices and many physicians don't want to deal with these rules so they are finding a way to not have to deal with insurance and the oversight they have to do.

It's all changing and more and more practices are going this route 

TinktheSprite --- 12 years ago -

many physicians don't want to deal with these rules so they are finding a way to not have to deal with insurance and the oversight they have to do.


....And so they get the patients to pay $1000's of dollars per year instead? I never liked a Doctor whining about not enough money. 

ukchristine --- 12 years ago -

My doc is taking 500 patients at $1500 a pop. 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

This is all the governments doing. We are going to have to pay for the deadbeats and then pay a fortune to get into see a decent doctor. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

It is free market sheddy.

There isn't a government requirement that physicians, primary care, see everyone therefore the physicians are free to sell their services for whatever the market will pay.

So why do you say this is the governments doing? This is actually BECAUSE there isn't government involvement in the free market capital society.

If there is a market for physicians who sell their services for the higher prices then why shouldn't they sell them for what the market will pay?

there are other physicians who don't want to participate in the free market capitalistic society and they will see those patients who choose to use government coverage without paying additional fees.

It's just business. 

ukchristine --- 12 years ago -

I didn't notice such a reaction to the free market BEFORE the implementation of the ACA. Now the irony is many people WITH insurance will have to find a new doctor. As have others for different reasons. It already feel like healthcare is starting to be rationed. The stated purpose of healthcare reform was to help the 46 million with no access. Not sure why a much larger number is not clambering to participate. The upside of reform was to alleviate the misuse of emergency room visits. Not sure that's going to work as hoped by the proponents of the ACA. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

well the ACA was never designed to be healthcare reform. It is insurance reform. 

Spunkin --- 12 years ago -

Sweet Cherub - How did your informational meeting go? I am considering changing to a Concierge type physician. I can't ever seem to get in to the my doctor herself, I always see a Physician Assistant at my doctor's office. I am tempted to go to a concierge situation so I can call and talk to the doctor about my results, as it is I have to wait until Thursday to see the PA to get my MRI results from last week. 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

Spunkin, we decided not to go with concierge service. It was going to cost us 300 dollars a month to do so, and after weighing everything, we decided it just wasn't worth it. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground