Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

is the school blaming the victim?

who's talking here?

smartypants 9
sunshine1881 1
Perfection 5
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
I_won't_tell 2
It is I WhyWhyWhy 7
Dorothy Parker 11
sheddy 1
Loveday 1
Nurse Ratched 2
Semper 3
MissPris 6
mutton 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

tells child to not bring backpack to keep bullying down

A North Carolina mom said her 9-year-old son's school asked him to leave his "My Little Pony" bag at home after school officials said it was ?a situation that had created a disruption in the classroom.?

Grayson Bruce said he was teased about his blue backpack, which depicts a character named Rainbow Dash.

?The first day I brought it to school, people smirked, you know, laughed. The usual, ?That?s hilarious. Why would you bring that??? he told HLN.

Grayson told HLN the next day he was teased and punched to the ground by another student. He said the alleged bully had to walk three or four laps as punishment.


When Noreen Bruce, Grayson?s mother, told school officials about the incident, she said she got a call back from an official.

?He said I could get in touch with the social worker at the school and I asked him what he thought about banning the lunch box and he said it was a trigger for bullying, which I have relayed in a previous interview, if a lunchbox is a trigger for bullying, we might as well say a short skirt is a trigger for rape," Noreen told HLN. "It's flawed logic. There?s no sense in it.?

Noreen told HLN affiliate WLOS said she still stands by her son's favorite cartoon show: "It's promoting friendship, there's no bad words, there's no violence -- it's hard to find that, even in cartoons now."

Read more: Do girls really need pink Legos?

Grayson said he recently decided he wanted to be home-schooled.

?I really can?t take much more. People would call me horrible names even when I didn?t have it,? he told HLN.

"Grayson's hurt. He feels he's not safe going to school, and he should feel safe going to school," Noreen told HLN.

HLN reached out to Buncombe County Schools but has yet to get a response. WLOS was sent the following statement: "An initial step was taken to immediately address a situation that had created a disruption in the classroom. Buncombe County Schools takes bullying very seriously, and we will continue to take steps to resolve this issue." 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

Most 9 year old boys aren't into My Little Pony as they are toys/cartoons aimed at girls. It would be equivalent to him bringing a Barbie backpack.

While that's no excuse for the boys' behavior, I can see why the school would suggest a different backpack to cut down on the teasing. This kid admits he was bullied before, so, I think the school is trying to help him be less of a target. 

smartypants --- 12 years ago -

Buncombe County Schools takes bullying very seriously, and we will continue to take steps to resolve this issue.

Anything other than addressing the aggression of other students towards the boy is blaming the victim. 3 or 4 laps is not adequate retribution for assault. No wonder we still have problems with bullies in schools. 

Loveday --- 12 years ago -

If this child was truly a victim of bullying - truly felt fearful and powerless - would he have taken the lunch box to school a second day? 

smartypants --- 12 years ago -

If this child was truly a victim of bullying - truly felt fearful and powerless - would he have taken the lunch box to school a second day??

According to the OP, he was laughed at the first day. The 2nd day he was beat up. 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

Dorothy you must not be current on MLP culture. The new show, Friendship is Magic is very popular among guys. They even have their own fandom and call themselves Bronies 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

I have heard of Bronies...not normally amongst the elementary age group. 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

It's pretty common when the elementary kid has older brother or father that is into it. Usually entire families embrace a fandom. 

I_won't_tell --- 12 years ago -

In schools today there is way too much acceptance of the brats doing the bullying. "Boys will be boys" "Mean girls" are all too common.

Too little is being done by the school teachers and administrators.

Innocent children are being abused.

Period.

There should be absolutely ZERO tolerance for this crap.

Instead the bullies get away being bullies because teachers/administrators are either unwilling or not capable of dealing with their responsibility.

If a bully punched - repercussions would be huge. Not so when it comes to emotional bullying.

Clear lines - No grey lines.

Zero tolerance for bullying needs to be enforced. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

Bullying has always existed and will never completely go away, no matter what they enforce.

However, you can take some personal steps to be less of a victim. I wouldn't send my 9 year old son to school with a girlie backpack. Even if he loved it, I would explain why it's better to carry a regular backpack.

That's not blaming the victim, that's taking steps to be less of one. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Too bad a child can't express their individuality and are being programmed to be like everyone else.

Personally I like individuality.

Groupthink is never a good thing. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

To each their own.

A 9 year old isn't mature enough to handle the backlash of extreme individuality like carrying a girls backpack to school.

A 15 year old is a different story. 

Nurse Ratched --- 12 years ago -

I have to disagree with you on this one DP. I firmly believe a student should feel safe at school no matter what he/she is wearing. The problem is not the backpack. The problem is kids who have not been raised to treat others with kindness and educators who would rather blame the victim than look at their own possible biases. If my son wanted to take a My Little Pony backpack to school, I'd let him. I would definitely have a talk with him beforehand about what to do if he's teased about it, but I'm not going to force my children into arbitrary gender roles because it's what's expected. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

If I have to explain to my child why they would be teased, they aren't old enough to handle it.

I don't think it's choosing a gender role to avoid my child being a target of bullying which carrying a girls backpack as a 9 year old boy will definitely attract.

But, that's me. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

It will only attract it if others have not been taught to respect each other.

That is their problem - these parents who won't confront bullying and allow children to be kids.

Bullying is a learned behavior, no one is born a bully. Since it is a learned behavior it can be changed - it is up to us to change it. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

Since we don't live in a Utopian world, I would take steps to protect my kids from unnecessary negative attention.

Not everyone feels the same way, and that's fine. 

Nurse Ratched --- 12 years ago -

Bullying is a learned behavior, no one is born a bully. Since it is a learned behavior it can be changed - it is up to us to change it.

I agree. Of course, it's much harder if the school district isn't on board. The district my kids are in takes a very strong anti-bullying stance and bullying is dealt with immediately. Some school districts take a lot more activism on the part of the parents to get the ball rolling. Obviously schools can't do anything about how kids are being raised at home, but they can send a clear message that students are to treat one another with kindness and respect at school. 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

It is choosing a gender role when you do that DP. It's America, it's your choice to raise your children along rigid gender roles and stereotypes but it's not OK to impose those roles on others. That's bullying.
Boys need to be allowed to like more than just dinosaurs, machines and military without society beating them up for it. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

Lol...wow. So because I wouldn't send my 9 year old son to school with a girls backpack, I'm stereotyping and choosing a strict gender role?

See, I realize I'm only raising my children and not everyone in the world. I cannot control how they treat others. Therefore, at 9 years old, I think it's better for my son to not be subjected to teasing and ridicule.

If he was older and was better prepared for dealing with people, wear whatever you want and wear it proudly.

9 isn't old enough, imo. 

smartypants --- 12 years ago -

So because I wouldn't send my 9 year old son to school with a girls backpack, I'm stereotyping and choosing a strict gender role?


Maybe you are, and that's your prerogative, but that's not the point. The point is that the way to stop bullying isn't to try and change the victim. To put a stop to bullying the school needs to promote an atmosphere of kindness and inclusion so that the kids get along and can concentrate on their job of learning. 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

I don't understand why they aren't trying to stop the bullying. If he felt like he was a girl trapped in a boys body and wore dresses to school everyday, would they still let the kids bully him. Some of these schools are insisting on bathrooms for kids who are confused about gender and this school is giving him a hard time about a bag. I am glad my kids are grown. 

smartypants --- 12 years ago -

I found this story at another online site, and liked one of the comments:

"Jennifer Stoudt
I suspect there is a lot more to this story. A lot of school districts require mesh backpacks - mainly for security - so any character backpacks are banned. 6:48am

Ginger Mann Pierce ? Top Commenter ? Asheville, North Carolina
Nope. No mesh backpacks are required in Buncombe County. It's a clear case of punishing the victim. I am a registered volunteer in the county schools and I am considering volunteering at this particular school and arriving in all my Pony regalia."

Good for her! The kids could start carrying MLP in support of Grayson, too! 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

Bullying is a learned behavior, no one is born a bully. Since it is a learned behavior it can be changed - it is up to us to change it.

Love that Perfection! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

of course, in a perfect world, y'all are right- but realistically, I'd do what DP said- if I could take his place, I'd go there swinging, but I couldn't put myself in my son's body- if the kids continued that behavior, that's another story- 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

Exactly, Tat.

I'm not excusing the bullies' behavior. Here's an analogy for you.:

In a perfect world, we wouldn't have to lock our doors or cars for fear of theft. But, we don't live in a perfect world so, we lock our doors because it's better to take precautions.

I see this situation in the same light. In a perfect world, children aren't teased or bullied for being different, but we don't live in a perfect world. So, when they're little, it's better to minimize the potential for being teased or bullied. A nine year old boy carrying a girls backpack is fodder for ridicule. If you think otherwise, you aren't being realistic. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

that about sums it up for me, too- 

smartypants --- 12 years ago -

What parents do in their role as protectors and caregivers is separate from the school and school policy. 

I_won't_tell --- 12 years ago -

Draw a line - If the line is crossed - administer significant consequences.

When consequences are not delivered the message it that it is ok to bully.

Bullying is tolerated in the schools by teachers and administrators.

I am not sure why. I am guessing it is just easier for them.

Bullying should not be tolerated.

But undeniably bullying is allowed in the schools by teachers and administrators.

Take a stand
Stand for those that are not strong enough to stand up for themselves.

Stand For The Silent




. 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

It's obvious that you have never had to experience caring for someone who is "non-conforming" to your traditional gender roles.
Locking doors would only be a relevant comparison if your house was a living human being.
SMH 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

Do we truly value those who Think Different or do we just give it lip service?

Every time you tell a child, male or female, to give up something they love for fear of what others might think, say, or do, you are breaking that child's potential. It's a sad thing. 

smartypants --- 12 years ago -

Every time you tell a child, male or female, to give up something they love for fear of what others might think, say, or do, you are breaking that child's potential.

If the school doesn't have a clear policy , what are they going to do when it's the child who is overweight, or disabled, or speech impaired, or considered unattractive in some arbitrary way, who is picked on? Those kids can't just leave their condition "at home", or buy something from the store so they are considered more acceptable by the bullies among their peers. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

It's obvious that you have never had to experience caring for someone who is "non-conforming" to your traditional gender roles.?Locking doors would only be a relevant comparison if your house was a living human being.?SMH?


You really are missing the point.

You seem to think that everyone is coming from the same point of view you have and are taught the same manners and acceptance of others that you teach your children.

Guess what? Reality is such that no matter how many anti bullying campaigns you have, no matter how much punishment there is, bullying will always exist.

Knowing this is the case, you do what you can to minimize its effects on your own children. Gender roles are great discussion for adults...not so much for 9 year old children. Therefore, explaining to your child that while he may love toys and clothing traditionally for girls, the kids at school may not understand and until everyone is older and able to handle themselves with empathy and maturity, it might be better to leave the backpack at home.

If carrying this backpack is the whole entirety of this kid's being and self esteem, something is wrong. There's more than one way to express yourself and your individuality. Why limit it to carrying a backpack?

You guys are taking this situation to extremes. This kid is not Rosa Parks.... 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Since we don't live in a Utopian world, I would take steps to protect my kids from unnecessary negative attention.




Bingo. Why make your kid a target to get punished everyday and humiliated so you can demand the school do something about it.

Not being able to carry his my little pony backpack is not going to scar the kid. Having his arse beat on a daily basis just might.

Someone needs to be the adult and protect THEIR child and let them know that the real world isn't fair so suck it up buttercup and you can see your pony after school. It fact you'll probably have a better visual of it without two black eyes. smh for sure. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

0 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Y'all do understand that by 9 a lot of boys have been playing football, baseball, soccer and other sports on teams for a much as 4 years already. Most boys at 9 would see My Little Pony as something for babies. Gender roles and other crap aside. Hell I don't even think my daughter were into stuff like that by 9. They were already over barbie by that point any way. 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

How about teach your kids NOT to be arseholes. Or is that too hard?
It's past time to shift that tired paradigm y'all cling to so fervently.

Do you advocate women dress in burqas to avoid harassment from men as well? 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

My kids aren't arseholes...quite the opposite actually. My oldest especially. But, it wasn't ever my kids I was worried about...I know how they're being raised. It's the kids that aren't raised with empathy and tolerance toward others that I would protect my kids from.

Hence not encouraging a 9 year old to be a target for ridicule. Again..there are many ways for a boy to express himself that do not include carrying a girls backpack in the 4th grade.


Or can you not see that?

A woman is not a 9 year old child. A woman can dress however she wants and has the maturity to handle it, as will most of the adults she encounters. The situation discussed on this thread pertains to elementary aged children. There is a difference. 

smartypants --- 12 years ago -

People would call me horrible names even when I didn't have it,


This part of the OP is being glossed over. This is why I don't see the problem as being the backpack, or a parenting style some don't agree with. imo the problem is that the school has blamed the victim and asked him to change his behavior, while not addressing the problem of bullying at all. They slapped a band aid on the situation and are hoping that's the end of it, without addressing the root cause.

Thinking this is going to be the only incident of kids being cruel, for whatever reason, is completely naive. It's the school's place, or I think, duty, to at least try and prevent bullying while students are under their supervision. I don't see an iota of try, from this school. I don't consider that it's an extreme viewpoint to insist that schools have no bullying policies. They are greatly needed, need to start when children are young, and go all the way through high school. 

Semper --- 12 years ago -

I was in 6th grade and into rainbows and unicorns both which were on my purple backpack. First week of school the most popular kids in school started giving me grief about my bag. They even took it and tossed it around when the teacher wasn't looking. They never were able to make me cry nor rat on them so eventually they got bored and moved on. I did try being less "smart" because it seemed they would harass whoever they thought were teacher's pet. Then it dawned on me that these kids also had friends who were smart so this wasn't about my being this or that. After that I just stopped caring about what they or anyone else thought. I just did my own thing. Middle school sucks. It is sad that elementary sucks these days as well. 

Semper --- 12 years ago -

 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground