Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Emergency room visits UP by 40% -- another Barrycare talking point is wrong

who's talking here?

sunshine1881 7
SoupIsGoodFood 9
Perfection 6
Laurabeth 12
It is I WhyWhyWhy 4
SwimSwim 1
Emperor of Kingwood 4
Snake Plissken 3
Prolix Raconteur 1
Sweet Cherub 9

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

Another Barrycare lie...


New Findings Contradict Major Arguments from Medicaid Expansion Supporters

MacIver News Service | January 6, 2014

[Madison, Wisc...] A common argument to expand Medicaid nationwide was squashed late last week when newly released data found that people on Medicaid actually go to the emergency room more often than those without insurance.

The results were released by Amy Finkelstein, Ph.D., and Katherine Baicker, Ph.D., the principal investigators of The Oregon Health Insurance Experiment. Finkelstein is the Ford Professor of Economics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Baicker is a Professor of Health Economics at the Harvard School for Public Health.

The Oregon study is one of the first experiments that can accurately measure the outcomes of health insurance and Medicaid with the use of a control group. According to the website, the study, "uses a randomized controlled design - the gold standard for medical evidence - to evaluate the effects of insurance."

This was all possible because Oregon expanded Medicaid by the use of a lottery system in 2008, which created the perfect opportunity to study the outcomes.

The information released last Thursday said individuals on Medicaid were 20 percent more likely to use the emergency department. Actual visits were measured over an 18-month period and Medicaid enrollees visited the emergency room 40 percent more than the uninsured.

The study found that individuals on Medicaid were more likely to go to the emergency room for cases that did not require a hospital stay, what they deem "outpatient emergency department visits." Medicaid enrollees were also more likely to visit the emergency room with cases that were classified as, "non-emergent," "primary care treatable," and "emergent, preventable."



This group of individuals on Medicaid is more likely to go to the emergency department because they know the bill will be paid for. Previously, when uninsured, these individuals would have stayed home until they truly felt it was necessary to get medical care. Instead of changing their behavior once they were covered by Medicaid to use a primary care doctor for non-emergency cases, many still just go to the emergency room because they know they will be admitted and the bill will be paid.

Results released in October revealed that Medicaid did not improve health outcomes, as well. Individuals reported they were healthier, but clinical tests showed no statistically significant effect on blood pressure, cholesterol, diabetes blood sugar control, or diagnosis of or medication for blood pressure or cholesterol.

The only health outcome that saw a significant change was levels of depression. Medicaid reduced observed rates of depression by 30 percent, according to the study. However, there was no statistical increase in the use of medication for depression.

This study refutes the claims of many that support the Affordable Care Act and the expansion of Medicaid. A common argument to expand Medicaid is that individuals would no longer have to rely on uncompensated care at the emergency room. The Oregon experiment shows that they are more likely to rely on the emergency room and there is no statistical change in health outcomes.

Supporters may have to ask themselves if expanding a $415 billion a year program that doesn't improve health is really the best decision. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Supporters may have to ask themselves if expanding a $415 billion a year program that doesn't improve health is really the best decision.


That question was asked over and over and ignored by the likes of Obama, Reid and Pelosi. Now, its come home to roost and we get to pay for it. 

Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

Rick Perry has refused to expand Medicaid.

When asked why, the liberal KU'ers stated Perry's reasons for refusing Federal money to expand Medicaid were that he enjoys being mean to the poor and because Obama is black. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

When asked why, the liberal KU'ers stated Perry's reasons for refusing Federal money to expand Medicaid were that he enjoys being mean to the poor and because Obama is black.

You don't get a logical fact based discussion with them. You get hyperbole and bombastic platitudes. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Emergency room visits are ridiculous. Emergency room cost need to be high enough that people won't go when going to their regular doctor would be acceptable. Emergency rooms also need to send people to after hours urgent care facilities when its not truly an emergency room issue.

A lot of people are now going to the emergency room instead of their doctors even when they have insurance. Its bullshi$. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

People go to ER's with the sniffles and minor stuff because they can't pay and the ER can't turn away. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

People go to ER's with the sniffles and minor stuff because they can't pay and the ER can't turn away. 


That needs to change too. 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

People go to ER's with the sniffles and minor stuff because they can't pay and the ER can't turn away.

Does Medicaid charge co-pays for going to the ER? Are there any kind of co-pays with Medicaid?

I get why people without insurance would go so they didn't have to pay, but why sit there for hours when you could wait until the next morning and see your doctor. I know I haven't been to an ER in years and years. We use the minor emergency clinics if absolutely necessary because the co-pays are lower, and 99.9% of the time we just wait and make a doctor's appointment.

If there are no Medicaid co-pays at all, maybe there should be, and maybe that would help address the problem. Maybe a $20 copay for the minor emergency clinic and $50 for the ER.

If it's not life-threatening, the ER should be able to turn you away if you can't/won't pay the co-pay. There are other options. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

If it's not life-threatening, the ER should be able to turn you away if you can't/won't pay the co-pay. There are other options. 


Totally agree 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

The lawsuits would sky rocket beyond control if ER's were allowed to turn people away. Most care facilities would shut down in a matter of months due to the lawsuits or the hefty rise in liabilty insurance.

But yes, I agree....it needs to change. But turning away patients that have been fully evaluated is not the answer. Too much liability, and even though it sucks....that's the reality of it. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

But yes, I agree....it needs to change. But turning away patients that have been fully evaluated is not the answer. Too much liability, and even though it sucks....that's the reality of it. 


Then they need to go back to free hospitals and paying hospitals. As much as that sounds bad the current situation is just causing more issues. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Then they need to go back to free hospitals and paying hospitals. As much as that sounds bad the current situation is just causing more issues.

Thats Ben Taub downtown. You pay if you can. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

You don't get a logical fact based discussion with them. You get hyperbole and bombastic platitudes.

Winner, winner........... chicken dinner. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

That needs to change too.

According to you liberals, Obamacare was supposed to change this.

Was that also a lie? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

If it's not life-threatening, the ER should be able to turn you away if you can't/won't pay the co-pay

Sounds like you're turning into one of those heartless conservatives you frequently post about. 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

Thats Ben Taub downtown. You pay if you can.


Ben Taub and LJ are still both county emergency facilities. They are trying their very best to transform into paid hospitals with the AHA changes, but I don't really see it happening successfully. When AHA finally bottoms out, it is going to be horrible for both the people relying on AHA and for the hospitals and other facilities that banked on the changes. The money is going to run out........ 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

The lawsuits would sky rocket beyond control if ER's were allowed to turn people away. Most care facilities would shut down in a matter of months due to the lawsuits or the hefty rise in liabilty insurance.


If a hospital decided that a patient who could not pay should be sent away because it was not a 'true emergency' and something happened to that person as a result, can you even imagine the law suit on that one! Hospitals won't take that chance. 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

If it's not life-threatening, the ER should be able to turn you away if you can't/won't pay the co-pay

Sounds like you're turning into one of those heartless conservatives you frequently post about.


Please note, I also said there are other options.

And, it sounds like those baseless assumptions you like to make about you think liberals think about various things are proving to be false. Many of us are able to think for ourselves and form our own opinions on various topics. No party talking points needed. 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

OK, so you can't turn people away from the Emergency Room. What do you do to get the message across that there are other and better options for treatment?

I've always thought that Medicaid should have a 24-hour nurse line. I know those have been lifesavers for me when we were in the military and when we had a pediatrician's office that provided one. That might help deter people from just going to the ER for every minor thing. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Many of us are able to think for ourselves and form our own opinions on various topics. No party talking points needed.

If so, you're far and few between. 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

Many of us are able to think for ourselves and form our own opinions on various topics. No party talking points needed.

If so, you're far and few between.


There was a decent conversation going on here, and you had to bust in with your childish political pot shots.

This is why the whole process is so screwed up, because idiots like you can't see past a stupid label you decided to stick on someone. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

This is why the whole process is so screwed up, because idiots like you can't see past a stupid label you decided to stick on someone.

LOL.......... you give way too much credit to the "power" of a obscure message board.

My posts haven't screwed up the ER situation.

Besides, if you want to see "stupid labels" applied. Just visit any of the religious, gay marriage, or social equality threads. Every label imagined has been placed on conservatives in those threads by liberals like yourself.

Chill out....... this message board isn't going to affect anything. 

SwimSwim --- 12 years ago -

Under EMTALA, emergency rooms can turn patients away if their illness is not considered to be emergent or life-threatening. Has nothing to do with the ability to pay. Doctors don't use it very often, but I have seen it done.

I work in an ER and first hand I can tell you the number of people we are seeing is going up, could be because of the changes demanded by AHA or it could be because its cold and flu season. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Sunshine......... what is your solution to the increased traffic at the ER's?

I've suggested in the past to start turning people away. Especially the illegal alien population that swarms the county ER's. Also turning away those who had no insurance and absolutely no way of paying.

(Note: I was called a heartless conservative for saying this, too) 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -


LOL.......... you give way too much credit to the "power" of a obscure message board.

My posts haven't screwed up the ER situation.


I was speaking in more general terms of the overall way things are happening in our current society. You can't have a constructive conversation with someone if all they see is a label they've stuck on you instead of actually listening and exchanging ideas. You and several other individuals (on this board, in society and in government) are clearly guilty of this.

Every label imagined has been placed on conservatives in those threads by liberals like yourself.

And here it is. Have I placed any of those labels on anyone on those threads?

No.

Then why lump me into the group that has just because I share some similar opinions with them on some topics? I am responsible for my own actions, not anyone else's and if you're going to form an opinion about me, form it based on my actions, no one else's. 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

I've always thought that Medicaid should have a 24-hour nurse line.


There are some.....each is set up by their respective states. Texas has one through the STAR program for medicaid users. It would be great if it were used more often.

Please remember that a great deal of the general population does not have a basic education, much less be able to decifer medical symptoms. Sorry, but that's true, they would rather rely on the professionals to help them. Which is understandable, but causing major issues. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Then why lump me into the group that has just because I share some similar opinions with them on some topics?

Because that's how the game is played. The same thing gets done to Tea Party people. One kook in the crowd there, and liberals like yourself label the entire group as extremists.

Don't act like you're not guilty of this type of action. We all are. 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

What about the illegal alien population using our hospitals for their medical needs? What can be done about that? 

Prolix Raconteur --- 12 years ago -

deportation 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

I agree. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Does Medicaid charge co-pays for going to the ER? Are there any kind of co-pays with Medicaid?


No 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

What about the illegal alien population using our hospitals for their medical needs? What can be done about that?


It is incredibly frustrating when you show up with a child who has a broken arm, and walk into a waiting room full of people who are using the hospital as if it were a doctors visit. The waiting times are atrocious. Something has to be done. 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

Sunshine......... what is your solution to the increased traffic at the ER's?

I've suggested in the past to start turning people away. Especially the illegal alien population that swarms the county ER's. Also turning away those who had no insurance and absolutely no way of paying.

(Note: I was called a heartless conservative for saying this, too)


I agree with you on the illegal immigrant issue. That needs addressed. It's a sticky situation though because you end up with children involved, and I don't think you should deny care to children because of the choices their parents made. We need a tougher stance on illegals. Period. For many reasons.

Addressing adults, ultimately, some of the responsibility for healthcare needs to be pushed back on the individual. But with that, some of the freedom needs to be given to the individual.

A few things I would suggest:

1. 24-hour nurse lines provided as part of Medicaid, CHIPS, etc. Give people the ability to ask questions about symptoms, receive feedback and possible home treatments, along with information as to exactly when treatment should be sought. ie Treat with Tylenol for the fever tonight and make an appointment with your PCP in the morning. If even with Tylenol, the fever reaches xxx degrees and/or this happens, go to the emergency room.

2. Make some antibiotics over the counter. Why if I know that every winter I'm going to get a sinus infection, and I know exactly what the symptoms are, and I know a Z-Pack works every time, do I still have to go to the doctor every time to get a prescription? I should just be able to go to the pharmacy, pick up a Z-Pack and if it doesn't work in a couple days, then I'll go see my doctor.

3. Put co-pays on Medicaid (if this isn't done already), CHIPS, and all health coverage. Tier them just like they are for private insurance. Cheaper for your PCP, a bit more for a minor emergency clinic, a bit more for the emergency. With hold care unless the condition is clearly life threatening if the co-pay isn't paid up front. Make them affordable for Medicaid (maybe $50 for an emergency room visit), but do require them. I'm sorry, but anyone can keep $50 stashed away just in case -- maybe even make it a requirement for Medicaid enrollment that you put $50 into an account to cover that co-pay and it has to be replenished if used or services can be denied. Don't deny services for children, but put binding legal/financial consequences on parents for failure to pay co-pays.

4. Take away the ability to sue legislatively if services are denied for lack of payment of co-pay.

I don't know, those are just a few ideas. I think the ultimate problem is people not taking responsibility for themselves and there are just certain people who will do that if not forced to. I think we need to force it, at least to some degree. 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

Make some antibiotics over the counter. Why if I know that every winter I'm going to get a sinus infection, and I know exactly what the symptoms are, and I know a Z-Pack works every time, do I still have to go to the doctor every time to get a prescription? I should just be able to go to the pharmacy, pick up a Z-Pack and if it doesn't work in a couple days, then I'll go see my doctor.


Oh my gosh...I totally agree with this! It really would help during this time of year when so many have sinus/upper resp. issues. Doctors would hate it though cause they would miss out on the $ for the required office visit for the script for antibiotics. 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

1. 24-hour nurse lines provided as part of Medicaid, CHIPS, etc. Give people the ability to ask questions about symptoms, receive feedback and possible home treatments, along with information as to exactly when treatment should be sought. ie Treat with Tylenol for the fever tonight and make an appointment with your PCP in the morning. If even with Tylenol, the fever reaches xxx degrees and/or this happens, go to the emergency room.


That is already in place. Now if folks would just use it. But remember....there is liabilty involved if a nurse or Doc helps to treat at home as you suggested without a medical evaluation. yes, it might just be a fever.....but then again it could be meningitis........

Make some antibiotics over the counter.


Seems simple enough, until you understand the science behind antibiotics, how they work, and how too many antibiotics in circulation actually can harm society.

Put co-pays on Medicaid (if this isn't done already), CHIPS, and all health coverage.
I'm sorry, but anyone can keep $50 stashed away just in case --


Not a good understanding of the mindset of a great number of people actually on medicaid. Most really don't have a spare 50.00 and for others....if they did, they would use it for other things that they think they "need".

4. Take away the ability to sue legislatively if services are denied for lack of payment of co-pay.


Then every ER or medical facility across the country would just kick out every non paying patient and many would die, but the hospitals wounldn't care....because aferall....hey it's not illegal and I won't get sued. Sorry, but that wouldn't work either. 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

Oh my gosh...I totally agree with this! It really would help during this time of year when so many have sinus/upper resp. issues. Doctors would hate it though cause they would miss out on the $ for the required office visit for the script for antibiotics



I wouldn't mind getting my antibiotics OTC as well, easier and quicker.....but not good for the general public. Not good at all...... 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

Seems simple enough, until you understand the science behind antibiotics, how they work, and how too many antibiotics in circulation actually can harm society.


Laurabeth, this already happens anyway. Way too many antibiotics are written by doctors as it is. That being the case, you should be able to treat your yearly sinus infection with antibiotics on your own. 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

Sorry, SC, I don't agree with you. 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

Not a good understanding of the mindset of a great number of people actually on medicaid.

My point exactly, though. The mindset needs to be changed in order for anything to be fixed.

Ultimately, we need a system where everyone can have some sort of affordable healthcare coverage -- and we're moving toward that. If that's in place, then it is the responsibility of the individual (adult) to have that coverage and fulfill the requirements of it. If you don't, the consequences are on you. I'm sorry, but we really have babied people too much.

People don't respond unless they have some skin in the game. 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

Ok, so my husband got a sinus infection a couple of weeks ago. We have a fantastic doctor. My husband called up the doctor, described his symptoms, the doc called in a Zpack rx, hubby picked it up at the local HEB with a $5.00 co-pay...bada bing, no charge from the doctor, no office visit, no waiting in a lobby full of sick folks.

I love our doctor! :) 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground