Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Does husband have a right to withhold life support for unborn child?

who's talking here?

smartypants 3
sunshine1881 1
Tylers Journey 4
Polly Ester 1
Perfection 8
RiteWingKing 1
FANCY PANTS 3
Laurabeth 4
Hiro Protagonist 1
jtcitrus 3
AwesomeTattooedDragon 9
JohnLynch 12
Gigix4 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 3
Dorothy Parker 3
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
WatchOut 7
Nightshade 1
TONISFRIEND 1
JAMS 2
witchywoman 1
Ogre13 2
MissPris 4
Beachbum 1
Prolix Raconteur 1
You can call me Michelle 4
Sweet Cherub 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

what a horrible situation all around

FORT WORTH -- Erick Munoz sat quietly as he thumbed through several photos of his family.

They are reminders of good times, like the birth of their son, Mateo. It's a light moment during what has been a very trying and dark time for the Munoz family.

"As the days have gone by, the images are becoming more permanent in my head," Erick said.

Erick is talking about the moment he saw his wife, Marlise, unconscious on the living room floor at around 2 a.m. Nov. 26. As a paramedic, Erick rushed in to do CPR and later called 911.

Marlise Munoz, who was 14 weeks pregnant at the time, was taken to JPS in Fort Worth. Family members say doctors suspected she suffered a pulmonary embolism, but didn't know with complete certainty.

"You just never think it's going to be you," Erick said.

Marlise has been on life support since that day in November. Erick tells News 8 she has not regained consciousness and is "simply a shell." Tests are done daily on the fetus, and results show a normal heart beat.

Both Marlise and Erick are paramedics in the Tarrant County area, and both have had serious conversations about what to do if the worst happens. Marlise's mother told News 8 that conversation started when Marlise lost her brother tragically four years ago.

"We knew what her wishes were," Erick said. His wife told him she never wanted to be kept alive by machine.

Marlise was taken to the emergency room at JPS in the early morning of Nov. 26. Later in the day, the family was informed by doctors that they would provide any life-saving measures because she was pregnant. The family was told the hospital was taking that measure because of state law in Texas' Health and Safety Code.

"Section 166.049 Pregnant Patients. A person may not withdraw or withhold life-sustaining treatment under this subchapter from a pregnant patient," the code reads.

Even more, in a health directive form found under the Health and Safety Code, it reads, "I understand under Texas law this directive has no effect if I have been diagnosed as pregnant."

Erick said he did not officially sign a Do Not Resuscitate (DNR) form, but said it was a topic that was "talked about" and mutually agreed upon. However, even with a signed DNR form, the statute to protect the pregnancy would take priority.

Officials at JPS could not speak directly to the Munoz' case, but did respond in a broad sense.

"We have families every day that face really difficult decisions when it comes to the care of their loved ones and we would have the same response. We follow the law," said J.R. Labbe with JPS.

"I don't agree with this law... I don't," Erick said.

He said this law keeps him from honoring his promise to Marlise.

"It's hard to reach the point where you wish your wife's body would stop," he said.

Attorneys said Marlise’s family could try to go to court to get an injunction or restraining order to allow her wishes to be carried out. But most say it would be difficult to find a Texas judge to grant it. They say it’s unlikely a mother’s wishes would be allowed to override a child’s potential.

Erick said the testing of the fetus is so limited it's hard to tell if the fetus is viable. He said he does not expect a lot of people to side with him on this.

He also said he doesn't want to get into a long, drawn-out fight over pro-life and pro-choice.

"They don't know how long the baby was without nutrients and oxygen," Erick said. "But I'm aware what challenges I might face ahead."

The next series of tests of the fetus will be at 24 weeks, which is mid-February. Family members tell News 8 doctors may know then when the fetus can be removed.

Erick said doctors have even discussed taking the fetus to full term. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

My question is - IF the wife made it known to him she did not want life support or measures to save her life, why did he do CPR when he found her unresponsive? 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

His wife expressed that she did not want to be on "machines" to stay alive. Not all cardiac arrests pateints require "machines" after a full arrest. Unlikely that she would survive, but he was a Paramedic afterall......and that's what a paramedic does.

She also had nothing in writing for her wishes, no DNR, no out of hospital directives; or in hospital either.....so he did....what he had to do, not only morally, but by law. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

She also had nothing in writing for her wishes, no DNR, no out of hospital directives; or in hospital either.....so he did....what he had to do, not only morally, but by law.


And that's just one of the problems, they didn't have it in writing.

However even if they had, the law about the fetus trumps that and the mother would still be on life support.

I wonder if there have been other cases where the mom was on life support for so many weeks of the pregnancy and the condition of the child then.

Such a weird situation. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Awful situation very sad 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

Such a weird situation.


It's a sad situation......but hopefully something beautiful will come from it. She is just so early in the pregnancy that I would think the viability of the baby would be slim, much less the medical issues that would come later.

It's just terrible. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

She is just so early in the pregnancy that I would think the viability of the baby would be slim, much less the medical issues that would come later.


Agreed, I struggled not wanting to use the word viable when discussing the baby, but that's the exact word. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

her feelings, as told to her husband, should trump- what are they going to do down the line? once on life support, it'snot easy to take her off- before she got to the hospital, she wasn't getting oxygen to the fetus-this man's misery is only just starting- 

Tylers Journey --- 12 years ago -

This one is hard would the child be better off dieing or living a life in a hospital/home with no life. I would let the father keep her or take her off since he would have to take care of her/him. 

Laurabeth --- 12 years ago -

I personally think that they should do anything possible to preserve the life of that baby. It is most certainly going to be a difficult road for the family, but the life of the baby, to me, is more important than the mothers wishes. 

TONISFRIEND --- 12 years ago -

what a terrible decision. Prayer. 

Tylers Journey --- 12 years ago -

A child stuck in bed with hardly any life is not a life I would want for my child. 

FANCY PANTS --- 12 years ago -

Erick said. "But I'm aware what challenges I might face ahead."

It is selfish of him to be worried about what he might be facing. He would rather his wife and his baby die instead of letting the baby live. The best way to have a healthy baby is to keep the mom on life support. He might just be facing a healthy little baby. Yes, maybe he will have a baby that needs lots of care but I think they would know it if there were problems with the baby. It is the law in Texas and I think it is a good law. If he does not want the baby he can always give it up for adoption. 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

I'll post it again, National Advocates for Pregnant Women have an extensive list of the issues regarding personhood laws.

I wonder if the people who pushed for this law have funded programs to help this man offset the enormous hospital bills that will incur over months of life support? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

adoption? if the baby has been deprived of oxygen, and has no quality of life, who's going to adopt him/her? 

FANCY PANTS --- 12 years ago -

adoption? if the baby has been deprived of oxygen, and has no quality of life, who's going to adopt him/her?

You do not know what the condition of the baby will be. Even the best tests can be wrong and they did not state anything was wrong with the baby, did they? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

they said they didn't know how long the fetus was w/o oxygen-if it was me, I wouldn't want to take that chance- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

this is one of the reasons I'm for keeping Roe vs Wade- for the first 3 months- 

You can call me Michelle --- 12 years ago -

They have no idea what condition the baby is in. (S)he could be horribly handicapped or absolutely physically perfect. Only time will tell that. 

You can call me Michelle --- 12 years ago -

She's already past 3 months pregnant though. She is 17-18 weeks pregnant now. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

I can't believe this law is in effect for someone who was only 14 weeks pregnant. What hell for the family to keep her on life support not knowing the effect on the fetus and going against her wishes. :( 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

that's the thing- I'd stretch the 3 months a couple of weeks for this situation.... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

now it's so far along... that poor man- 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

they said they didn't know how long the fetus was w/o oxygen-if it was me, I wouldn't want to take that chance- 

that should be left to God... 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

I personally think that they should do anything possible to preserve the life of that baby


I agree Laurabeth. They have been blessed with a child. For whatever reason, this child is supposed to be here. The odds may be against this child being 'normal' in our eyes, but stranger things have happened. 

You can call me Michelle --- 12 years ago -

The only test spoken of showed no abnormalities.

Obviously, this child is alive for a reason. Handicapped or perfectly formed, this child deserves a chance to live. 

Beachbum --- 12 years ago -

I hope he doesn't view the child as the reason his wife is gone and resent it. 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

Does it concern anyone that the state has usurped the medical decision making rights of this family? For those that are horrified by the government mandating the purchase of insurance, are you ok with losing your right to make your own medical decisions? 

Tylers Journey --- 12 years ago -

They could harvest the moms eggs for later. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

MissPriss it does not bother me the state is protecting the baby. I expect them to value life.


This is however hypocritical since they allow the killing of babies by choice. I hope they correct that. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Remember the woman did not have her wishes written. That's a reminder for all. 

You can call me Michelle --- 12 years ago -

This is however hypocritical since they allow the killing of babies by choice. I hope they correct that.

That's the truth 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

I wonder if the people who pushed for this law have funded programs to help this man offset the enormous hospital bills that will incur over months of life support?


Is insurance covering this since the law is mandating it? Or is the state picking up the tab? 

Hiro Protagonist --- 12 years ago -

that should be left to God... 



If it was left to god, they'd be both dead. The only thing keeping them alive is human intervention. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

If it was left to god, they'd be both dead.

LOL...you are so confused...every breath you take is because God allows it... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

john, how can say that? what Randle said is exactly the truth-human intervention by the government! 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

No first was human intervention by doing cpr which allowed the baby to live. Had the husband not done that the baby would have died as well. The government now is enforcing the law due to his action. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

he said he did CPR- he didn't say it worked- what a horrible situation- 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

john, how can say that? what Randle said is exactly the truth

nope...what randle said isn't exactly the truth 

FANCY PANTS --- 12 years ago -

Does it concern anyone that the state has usurped the medical decision making rights of this family?

That is what the govt. is doing with ocare isn't it? They will be making all your medical decisions for you. Do you only want that when it's pregnant, old, fat, or unhealthy people? It's ok with you that the women did not have it in writing? Maybe the hubby just said that she did not want to be on life support. Maybe he is just being selfish.

Is it ok with you that ocare takes away all your medical making decisions for yourself and your kids. The govt. will decide everything for you and your family. Not you. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground