Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Persecution of Jesus' Followers Goes On in Israel

who's talking here?

Red Heifer 4
Lillabeth 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 15
JohnLynch 4
hard shell 1
JimBecka 22
RayofHope 7
The Master 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

Recent criticism of Messianic Jews hosting a speech by George W. Bush brought back some memories of my time in Israel. I jotted some down. Perhaps my thoughts will help you understand the problems many Messianic Jews in Israel (and the United States) experience.
------------------------------------------------------

The Mindset of an Orthodox Jew

I have not spoken a great deal about the things I experienced in Israel because Israel receives too much criticism from the world. Anyone believing the Bible has an obligation to support Israel.

But, supporting Israel should not include turning a blind eye to the things going on there. Yeshua (Jesus) was quite disappointed with the Jews at times, as were many of the great prophets.

Christians have faced their own problems sharing their faith in Israel. But, the anger evangelicals face is nothing compared to the rage directed at Messianic Jews.

"Is this your first trip to Israel?" asked a young Jewish girl sitting next to me on a flight to Israel in the summer of 1973.

I felt a little intimidated. She was from a fine New York family and I was raised in Southeast Texas, though my dad's family were immigrants from (what was then) Czechoslovakia.

I later found many Israeli Jews were Czechoslovakian expatriates, and before the founding of the state of Israel, Czechoslovia had the largest concentration of Jews in the world. My skin color, hair, and facial features were carbon copies of all the Czechoslovakian Jews walking the streets of Jerusalem. But, though I looked like them, I could not understand their language or mannerisms. My mother was Catholic and I was raised Catholic.

My dad's family had been Kohen (Temple priests), though the Becka's were forced to accept Catholicism at the close of the 30 year War (The first Becka appears in Catholic birth records eight years after the war ended). My DNA still identifies me as a Kohen and my family name is derived from a unit of measure used to determine how much Jews must pay to the Temple each year. In spite of my family background, I probably could not become an Israeli citizen. While atheist and Buddhists are welcome, any Jew accepting Jesus is not.

The girl on the plane wanted to know everything about me, and asked questions about Texas, my family, and why I was coming to Israel. She assumed I was Jewish. "Tell me abut your synagogue?" she asked.

I was a little startled by the question. She had been very friendly and I knew her mood would soon change.

"We have a great fellowship," I began. "We have a bunch of dedicated people who love Jesus."

She had been treating me like a family member, but now she was threatening. "You know you can get into a lot of trouble talking about Jesus in Israel," she said, after a long pause. "You can be arrested and deported from the country."

Messianic Jews are in the same situation Reformed Jews faced many years ago from the Orthodox. The informality and acceptance of goyim were things the Orthodox felt would pass, and Reform Judaism would die out. Now, both Reform and Orthodox both look at Messianics (Jews who accept Yeshua 'Jesus' ) and say it is a fad. But, the number of Jews accepting Yeshua as their Messiah is phenomenal and will not stop.

Some of the anger directed at Christians is valid, because Jews suffered at the hands of Christians for centuries. Christian theology has also created problems for Jews. Corrie ten Boom, author of the Hiding Place, a book about her families experiences hiding Jews during the Holocaust, felt Dutch Christian churches helped fuel the Holocaust by teaching Replacement Theology. It is the idea that Judaism has been replaced by Christianity, and Jews are no longer needed in the world.

Within one day of reaching Jerusalem a young Arab took me to a small congregation of Jews and gentiles on Prophet street. I sang and played guitar at night to large rousing mix of people. We were on a busy street and many Jews were curious. They had never seen Jews worship Jesus, someone many were taught was a gentile.

In spite of attempts by such violent Jewish organization as the Jewish Defense Leage (JDL) to close our fellowship, many Jews were very friendly and wanted to know more about Yeshua. The JDL even tried to burn down our building one night, but everyone kept coming.

Alex was a Brooklyn Jew and we spent much time together and became close friends. He explained that Christians are converts to Judaism, though both Jews and Christians go out of their way to hide that fact.

Christians and Jews both seem to overlook that the Bible was written primarily by Jews, about a Jewish Messiah, that fulfilled many Jewish prophecies. Also, the First Century followers of Yeshua were considered a Jewish sect.

It's only logical that Jews would want to know more about Jesus. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

Orthodox Jews in Israel have been at odds with secular Jews, since Israel became a state they also believe Hebrew should only be spoken in prayers, and speak Yiddish conversationally- in my opinion,they're extremists, and you're post is misleading- secular Jews are in the vast majority, and couldn't careless what you believe- the idea that people are arrested for being Christians or messianics is laughable- they don't arrest Arabs,either-in fact the Knesset has Arabs, too-I would imagine most Jews that read this would find it offensive- I've also never heard of a Jew being forced to become Catholic,except during the Spanish Inquisition- 

Lillabeth --- 12 years ago -

It's only logical that Jews would want to know more about Jesus.

I thought those that are Jewish are still waiting for the Messiah? They don't believe Jesus is the son of God. Am I wrong? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

no, you're right, Lillabeth- only the Messianics believe Jesus was the Messiah- ZNO taught me all about this subject, and everything about Israel- 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

secular Jews are in the vast majority

and secular Jews aren't really Jews...they don't believe the Torah is the literal word of God 

hard shell --- 12 years ago -

0undefined 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

you don't have to be a believer to be Jewish, john-if you don't believe me, read up on Hitler- 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

you don't have to be a believer to be Jewish

you have to believe God to be a real Jew...

lol...you're using hitler as an expert on Jews? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

if you can't figure out what I my point was, I'm sorry for you- 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

if you can't figure out what I my point was, I'm sorry for you- 

lol...you hardly ever make your points clear... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

poor john- no one but you has that problem- 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

poor john- no one but you has that problem- 

LOL...yea right... 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

I thought those that are Jewish are still waiting for the Messiah? They don't believe Jesus is the son of God. Am I wrong? 

Good question. I'll try and keep it short.

You have to understand the Second Temple period was a time of several Jewish sects. Some were religious and some were not religious (I.E., Sadducees did not accept Oral law or believe in an afterlife and Pharasees were very religious (Like the Orthodox of today).

Christianity (and mainstream Judaism) both teach that the Jews did not accept Jesus. In reality, Jesus (Yeshua) was very popular (Think about it, if Jewish society thought he was a crackpot why would they feel threatened by him and ignore Jewish laws to crucify him?). Jesus was undoubtedly a Pharisee and was accepted by many Pharisees.

Jesus rode into Jerusalem on a donkey (In fulfillment of prophecy) and was welcomed by a crowd (Does that sound like the Jews were rejecting him).

Then a short time later, he went through a trial and crucifixion (During a time when religious Jews are not suppose to conduct business.......It violates Jewish law). The groups behind the crucifixion were not religious and had no problem ignoring laws.

After the crucifixionresurrection Jesus was still very popular with many "religious" Jews. Christianity continued as a sect of Judaism until around 380AD/CE, when the Catholic Church forced Christians to split with Judaism. A Catholic bishop found many Christians still worshiping in Jewish synagogues and began speaking out against the practice.

Today, mainstream Judaism is still waiting for the Messiah. But, remember there is a growing segment of Jews that believe the Messiah (Jesus) has already come. 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

since Israel became a state they also believe Hebrew should only be spoken in prayers, and speak Yiddish conversationally-

It is true that Yiddish is making a comeback (My dad taught me a little). But, Hebrew is the language of Israel.

Dr. Libermann, Jewish UH professor and former resident of Israel, once told me that he once asked a young boy how he knew people were getting older. The boy answered: "Well, you can tell when someone is getting older when they start speaking Yiddish."

The point is, the boy only saw elderly Jews speaking Yiddish. When I lived in Israel in the 70's very few could speak it.......Only very old. 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

you're post is misleading- secular Jews are in the vast majority, and couldn't careless what you believe- the idea that people are arrested for being Christians or messianics is laughable-

I think you are reading things into my post. Also, I'll post a few Israel TV news programs devoted to the issue. It will help if you can see the issue through Israeli television.

You are correct in that much of Jewish society is secular, but secular jews are not the ones causing problems for Messianic Jews.

If you read the title to my post it reads: The Mindset of Orthodox Jews (I was not talking about secular Jews)

Orthodox Jews are gaining more and more power in Israel. They are working their ways into government positions and secular Jews are being pressured to work with them.

There was recently a television interview over the abduction of a Messianic Jewish blind girl by an Orthodox Jewish group. The secular Jewish TV news man was quite upset that Orthodox Jews were not being held accountable for their actions.

The direction Israel is heading in is not good for Christians living in Israel of Messianic Jews living in Israel.

I'll look for a couple of the news programs.

Also, you might talk to some of the Messianics you know. they can explain it better than me. 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

the idea that people are arrested for being Christians or messianics is laughable-

Again, you are readling things into my post. The words were spoken as a threat against me......and I was not evangelizing. The girl asked me about my religious beliefs and I answered......Then she threatened me.

I don't believe there has been a single person arrested in Israel for talking about Jesus. But:

1) It is a popular threat used by Orthodox, because there are laws against evengelization in Israel. I will post a few for you to look at.

2) Though the Orthodox have been not able to stop Messianics from evangelization, the police and government have looked the other way while the Orthodox have delivered letter bombs to Messianics, kidnapped Messianics, and stood outside Messianic homes with loud speakers in the middle of the night.

I'll post some of those also. Again, it helps if you can see it through Israeli news channels. 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

hard shell - Your post is commonly referred to as replacement theology, one of the causes of the Holocaust.

Ask yourself, when G-d makes an "eternal" covenant with a nation of people, how long is the covenant for?

Or, how long is an eternal covenant? 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

I've also never heard of a Jew being forced to become Catholic,except during the Spanish Inquisition- 

Didn't intend to make this a history lesson. But, I'll find the post with the history of the 30 Year War.

It's interesting reading. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

you didn't read what I said very carefully- I said only the Orthodox believed Hebrew shouldn't be spoken conversationally- the secular Jews spoke Hebrew- and I'm not surprised if you were threatened- the orthodox are as extremist as any other extremist group- and just as scary- 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

Issue: Evangelization in Israel

Israeli News Story About Evangelization Controversy. 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

Issue: Evangelization in Israel

Israeli News Story About Evangelization Controversy. 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

never mind.

I don't feel like getting into a debate about messianic "Jews". 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

Issue: Orthodox Increasing Power in Israel

Article about increasing power of Orthodox in Israel. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

you agree with me, then- Israel is a democracy- and although I'm sure that proselytizing is not appreciated, it isn't illegal- 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

Correct that Spain expelled this Jews, but the English expelled their Jews. This is from an article about what happened to Bohemian Jews (Where my dad's family is from.....during the Habsburg rule).

While Jewish life flourished under the rule of Rudolf II and Mathias, successive Habsburg rulers were not as kind. As the counterreformation made its way through Europe, anti-Semitism became increasingly vicious and widespread in Bohemia, Moravia, and Silesia, leading to an increase in pogroms and the return of the Jews to their original status as “outsiders.” In 1726 a ceiling was placed on the Jewish population and a decree unveiled allowing only one son per Jewish family to marry. When Maria Theresa became queen in 1745 she immediately expelled the Jews of Prague. Though three years later Theresa did allow the Jews to return to Prague, they were required to pay exorbitant taxes approximately ten times the normal amount. 

Red Heifer --- 12 years ago -

Right Tatt. One thing. Orthodox is the mainstream among the "religious" as opposed to the secular. It is the far right Haredi and others out of the mainstream Orthodox who take the extreme positions you describe. And you are correct: we Jews tend to respect others' beliefs but are not particularly interested in hearing about Jesus except at most as a historical figure and a significant figure in someone else's religion. I am reasonably confident that Israel doesn't "persecute" Christians, but Israel is a Jewish state, not a secular one, so that non-Jews may feel second class because much of society--even for the secular--revolves around Jewish observance. 

Red Heifer --- 12 years ago -

Having said that, I encourage everyone to visit Israel...it is inspiring for people of all faiths. it is safe (despite what it looks like on TV sometimes) and feels very western. There are some great interfaith trips sponsored by community organizations. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

quite right, and I apologize if I overstepped- 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

you didn't read what I said very carefully- I said only the Orthodox believed Hebrew shouldn't be spoken conversationally-

I think you are confusing Orthodox and Ultra-Orthodox. Most orthodox jews are NOT fluent in Yiddish. However, most chassidic/haredi jews (ultra-orthodox) are, and speak it as a first language. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I was thinking about the Hasidim- 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

you agree with me, then- Israel is a democracy- and although I'm sure that proselytizing is not appreciated, it isn't illegal- 

I think you description is close. I'm not 100% sure it is correct though. Have to do more research.

But, I heard the words repeated many times by everyone. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

you can do that, but I'd be shocked if it's true- 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

DearestTatooedDragon - We can debate history and the finer points of Jewish society, but we are really not focusing on the real issue.

This is a video produced by an Israeli high school student from Arad. She is a Messianic and talks about everything the Messianics are forced to endure.

Story From a Messianic Jewish Girl About the Persecution of Messianic Jews. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

that's nothing but a video some girl made-you're saying it's illegal- a law- 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

This is one of the best Israeli News stories done on the subject. It's very touching. It's very popular and (I believe) was even shown on Israeli "national" television.

Story of the problems facing a Messianic Jewish Family. 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

that's nothing but a video some girl made-you're saying it's illegal- a law- 


Still missing the point. 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

This is from the Beckfords. I have communicated with them about what they have gone through. The have gone through years of persecution in Israel because they have accepted Jesus.

Another group of Jews facing persecution in Israel. Watch the video. 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

that's nothing but a video some girl made


Actually I really was impressed by the video from the high school student about the persecution her family faced in Israel for accepting Jesus.

But, if you want something more professionally done. This is from Israeli National Television.

NATIONAL ISRAELI TELEVISION BROADCAST OF THE PERSECUTION OF JEWS IN ISRAEL WHO ACCEPT JESUS. 

JimBecka --- 12 years ago -

Enjoyed chatting with you guys.

Not sure if my original post made the point. Some of it may have been confusing.

But, if you watch the videos you will see that Israel, a country I love and respect, has some obvious problems they need to deal with. Messianic Jews (who accept Jesus) are going through intense persecution.

They need our prayer and support. Watch the videos and try and understand the problem. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

before I watch it, Red is Jewish, and what she said made me think- Jews have been 2nd class citizens for thousands of years- since they've had their own state, they're allowed and should be able to have their faith as Jews- what other faiths have taken for granted, forever- they have never proselytized and don't want others to do it- 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground