Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Should physicians be required to accept Medicare/Medicaid

who's talking here?

ToidBoid 1
ladybeachbum 2
SoupIsGoodFood 1
Perfection 9
FANCY PANTS 1
Aah Grasshoppa 1
WatchOut 1
sheddy 4
Mayberry 1
freebyrdll 1
Emperor of Kingwood 7
MissPris 11
Leila 1
Tempted 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

That is the question being asked nationwide now as more and more physicians are opting out of the Medicare and Medicaid systems.

One State legislator is even floating a bill to require physicians in that state accept government payment for services even though those payments are less than the cost of doing business.

What do you think? Should all physicians be required to accept medicare and medicaid regardless if the payments are less than the operational cost of staying open?

How would you feel if accessibility to your provider or specialist is limited because they are mandated to accept all patients? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Nope, iff the Doc doesn't want to accept he shouldn't have to. 

freebyrdll --- 13 years ago -

No 

Tempted --- 13 years ago -

Yes, at least a percentage however small. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Yes, at least a percentage however small.

Why? is Apple Computer required to give discounts and take less money if they sell their products to senior citizens or the poor? 

Tempted --- 13 years ago -

Why? is Apple Computer required to give discounts and take less money if they sell their products to senior citizens or the poor? 


Not sure but they do sell at a discount to schools and students. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Not sure but they do sell at a discount to schools and students.

Does the govt require them to? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Not sure but they do sell at a discount to schools and students.

That is NOT required by law. Is any compnay or service provider required by the government to provide their services for less than they charge to a select group of individuals? Let me help you with this. The answer is no. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

I agree with you Bob in Texas but then the question of access arises.

In Texas less than 26% of physicians accept some form of Medicaid and not all of that 26% accept all Medicaid plans. So kids on Medicaid are limited in who they can see and what specialists they have access to.

In some States now the largest hospital chains and largest pediatric hospitals are opting out of the exchange plans and in other states they have had to mandate forced acceptance.

Big problem 

Tempted --- 13 years ago -

That is NOT required by law. Is any compnay or service provider required by the government to provide their services for less than they charge to a select group of individuals? Let me help you with this. The answer is no. 


It may not be required by law but it may be required by mutual agreement via government contracts. They also sell at a discount to military and government employees at a discount.

Health benefits are much more important than computers and I would not be surprised to learn that taking a percentage of government funded clients is required to hold a medical licenses. If it is not true now I bet it will be in the future if doctors start exiting the markets. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Health benefits are much more important than computers and I would not be surprised to learn that taking a percentage of government funded clients is required to hold a medical licenses. If it is not true now I bet it will be in the future if doctors start exiting the markets.

That would be unconstitutional under the commerce clause of the Constitution.

Contract sales and forced by legislation are two very different issues. No company is forced to enter into a contract with the Government. 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

They better watch what they require people to do or before long there will be no doctors. Ask yourself this, how many hours a week would you work for free. How long can any business stay open if they are required to work for less money than it costs to operate the business? Businesses aren't like the government, they don't have limitless funds to keep running at a loss. 

ToidBoid --- 13 years ago -

As the baby boomers retire, there are going to be more and more on Medicare...what is that demographic group supposed to do if no doctor will see them? Even though most carry supplemental insurance, since Medicare is the primary, and if they won't pay, neither will the secondary supplemental policy. . .

So we will be hanging our seniors out to dry. . . 

Leila --- 13 years ago -

I am not old enough yet to have researched it, but how hard is it to get physicians to accept you when you are on Medicare? Someone told me that if you are already seeing a physician that they can't drop you when you become medicare eligible. Can anyone verify that? 

WatchOut --- 13 years ago -

Yes. 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

As it stands today, only publicly funded medical institutions are required to accept Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE and any other publicly funded insurance programs.

I know many doctors who don't accept any insurance at all.

I haven't heard any reason why that should change. 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

I know that my mother's doctor is not taking any more. He has said he loses money, but won't drop anyone he has been seeing for years. He has started changing for things that he used to do for free. My daughters allergy doctor told me a year ago, that she still keeps patients that cost her money every time she sees them, but she has seen them for 15 years and is not going to drop them. I think more doctors will go to a cash only plan. 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

I also don't feel that, if mandated, that accessibility would necessarily suffer. I know many doctors with closed practices, as in they don't accept new clients. Doctors determine how many patients they want to see and if they are mandated to accept all insurance policies, that doesn't mean that they have to accept unlimited number of patients. That isn't how private practice works. 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

And doctors can choose who they want to see as patients and what services they want to perform and what services they want to refer out to.

The Original post makes assumptions and connections that are unrelated to the idea of mandating insurance acceptance. 

ladybeachbum --- 13 years ago -

I believe they should to an extent especially if the patient has been theirs for a period of time. All this said, I would be screwed because I never go to the doctor. Becoming a senior shouldn't come with lots of problems. Everyone should remember they will be one someday if they are lucky. My nephew is a doctor in a small town and I think he would say they take an oath of responsibility first and money next. 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

Well, that oath of responsibility won't feed your family. So many of these doctors come out of school up to their ears in debt. They are in the hole before they start their practice. Older doctors can take less in fees, but they still have to pay their staff, pay for the building, utilities and insurance, etc. You can't keep going in the hole every day and keep your doors open. 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

That is so true Sheddy. I think that when health care reform legislation was being put together, they missed an opportunity to strengthen our system by incentivizing doctors to stay in general practice with tax breaks or loan forgiveness programs for doctors to stay in family practice in underrepresented areas for a certain length of time. Even before Obamacare we had a serious shortage of general practitioners since there isn't any money in it, at least not to the extent that there is money in certain specialized fields.
Doctors aren't going to go into family practice when they can make significantly more money as specialists. That is where the accessibility part of the argument comes in to play. If there aren't enough primary care doctors around to begin with, insurance coverage is pretty moot. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

And fewer and fewer residents are taking up primary care as their area. It is anticipated there will be 90,000 fewer PCPs in just a few years than their are now. 

ladybeachbum --- 13 years ago -

My nephew was primary care in an office and was offered a position in the local hospital. He works one week of crazy hours and is off the next. He's a great doctor but now is going to manage the hospital. I don't think he has done bad with three kids and living a small town life without the doctor attitude of wealth. He is involved in all the activities and volunteers. I'm pretty proud of him. 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

Perfection, you are right. That's why it was so disappointing that the ACA didn't incentivize new doctors to stay in primary care. This isn't a new or unforeseen problem. It should have been addressed.

Ladybeachbum, that is great for your nephew. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

MissPris --- 8 sec ago - quote - hide comments
Perfection, you are right. That's why it was so disappointing that the ACA didn't incentivize new doctors to stay in primary care. This isn't a new or unforeseen problem. It should have been addressed.



MissPris, the limit on med school slots is a driver of this as well. The medical schools only take so many students regardless of the demand for physicians.

This is one of the reasons (besides the tough entry requirements) that students go to other countries for their education. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

When you look at the cost of Med school, the crazy admissions policies (affirmitive action), the debt upon graduating, Government interference in your practice, the risk of law suits, why would anyone want to be a Dr. when they can be a piece of Hollywood trash and make more money. 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

Perfection, the school's have a reputation to uphold for quality education. That's not a bad thing. The fact is, there is significantly, ridiculously more money to be made in certain specialties rather than primary care. That is why hardly anyone sticks with primary care. Not when there are huge bills to pay and you can make so much more money being a specialist. It's been that way for quite a while. The trend is well established. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

I expect Primary care will go to Physicians assitants and/or nurses first. Lets face it, most visits to your PCP are routine aren't they? 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

Here is an article with the average pay different types of doctors earn. It's not difficult to see the difference.  

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

Bob, state laws vary in how much care PAs and DNPs can legally provide. In most cases, their hands are tied despite being well qualified to give primary care. Another issue that might have been resolved by ACA but wasn't. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

One of the many things that should happen is a change in State laws to allow PA's and nurses to handle certan things. 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

I see a nurse practitioner when I go to my doctor and I prefer her to the doctor. The problem I have with states making things a little more flexible, is that PA's or NP's will end up doing more than they should, without the oversight that they need. Of course, i'm sure the 90% of the time when you go to the doctor, you know what is wrong, you just can't write yourself a prescription. 

Mayberry --- 13 years ago -

Back to the original question..,,absolutely not...NO!!!... 

Aah Grasshoppa --- 13 years ago -

No. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

So if no one takes it and hospitals won't accept it (other than emergency) what good is it? 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

Perfection, every medical facility that receives public funds is required to accept it so that scenario will never happen. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Really?

Check out Iowa where the pediatric hospital in the State isn't accepting it.

They opted out of the contracts.

They do have a choice. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

And since the hospitals have lost their incentive payments for disproportionate share (DSH payments) they are opting to leave public business.

They can stay non-profit status and not accept public insurance.

The DSH payments gave them a payment increase annually to accept government funded and charity care. Those were removed and it costs hospitals tens if not hundreds of millions of dollars annually. 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

Private hospitals have always had a choice. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground