Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should the electoral college and the House of Representatives be dismantled

who's talking here?

wayward1 8
d:-] 1
Perfection 3
FabFive 1
Charli 1
JAMS 1
Emperor of Kingwood 10
Biggun 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should the electoral college and the House of Representatives be dismantled

Currently our government is designed to give each person the same approximate weight in the voting process. US House of Representatives are determined by the number of people on the latest census and the 435 seats are apportioned equally with some minor tweaking such very small States in terms of population are guaranteed 1 seat even if their population would not otherwise qualify. Doing it this way allows for each geographic area to have some represenation of the citizens living in that area and the more heavily populated areas then have the same weight as other less populated ones. Is it perfect, NO but it is what we have. So should we change it to something more like the Senate where there are 2 votes per State and that's it. Or even making the electoral college obsolete entirely and moving to a popular vote only. The downside of a popular vote is that the areas of the country that currently are under populated would not have a say in the general election of President as the more urban areas of high population density would control the outcome. In this scenario a Presidential candidate could focus on NYC, Chicago, California and Florida and win the election while not concerning themselves with the rest of the country - but they would win the popular vote. So the question becomes. What is more important in a general election - representing the majority of the people or representing the majority of the country by area?

Popular vote Vote
 
 23.5% (4)
Leave as is Vote
 
 76.5% (13)
Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Currently our government is designed to give each person the same approximate weight in the voting process.

US House of Representatives are determined by the number of people on the latest census and the 435 seats are apportioned equally with some minor tweaking such very small States in terms of population are guaranteed 1 seat even if their population would not otherwise qualify.

Doing it this way allows for each geographic area to have some represenation of the citizens living in that area and the more heavily populated areas then have the same weight as other less populated ones.

Is it perfect, NO but it is what we have.


So should we change it to something more like the Senate where there are 2 votes per State and that's it.

Or even making the electoral college obsolete entirely and moving to a popular vote only. The downside of a popular vote is that the areas of the country that currently are under populated would not have a say in the general election of President as the more urban areas of high population density would control the outcome. In this scenario a Presidential candidate could focus on NYC, Chicago, California and Florida and win the election while not concerning themselves with the rest of the country - but they would win the popular vote.

So the question becomes.

What is more important in a general election - representing the majority of the people or representing the majority of the country by area? 

wayward1 --- 13 years ago -

I don't see how changing the way we vote would lead to dismantling the HoR. They give us a representative voice in the creation of legislation. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Do we need that? 

wayward1 --- 13 years ago -

You need it if you want to create legislation. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

But if everyone was elected across the country by popular vote only wouldn't that be more representative of the people of the country?

Have we allowed regionalism to suplant nationalism? 

wayward1 --- 13 years ago -

But if everyone was elected across the country by popular vote

Elected to what? If we get rid of the HoR, you just eliminated most of the jobs we would be voting for across the country. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Its a silly premise because of where the population centers are located. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

The electoral college needs to go. Antiquated and not a true representation. We are advanced enough to count the popular vote. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

The electoral college needs to go. Antiquated and not a true representation. We are advanced enough to count the popular vote.

That was never the purpose of the electoral college. The Electoral College was created for two reasons. The first purpose was to create a buffer between population and the selection of a President. The second as part of the structure of the government that gave extra power to the smaller states. 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Hmmmmm....I wonder how many people supported the electoral college when Bush lost the popular vote.

I'd be interested to see who has suddenly changed their views. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

It would take a constituitional amendment ratified by 3/4 of states to change the system. It is hard to imagine the smaller states agreeing. 

wayward1 --- 13 years ago -

Let the electoral college retire. If you don't agree with that then every time you hear Ohio, Florida and Pennsylvania mentioned during the next presidential election, know that we all hate you. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Let the electoral college retire

Retire? It takes a constitutional ammendment to make it go away. 

wayward1 --- 13 years ago -

Retire? It takes a constitutional ammendment to make it go away. 

Ok, Let the electoral college "go away."

As in, I would support an up and down vote to change the constitution to make the electoral college go away. 

Charli --- 13 years ago -

Getting rid of the electoral college? No.

Allow population centers, like New York City, elect presidents?

We have enough voter apathy. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

It still has a very valid reason to exist. 

wayward1 --- 13 years ago -

Allow population centers, like New York City, elect presidents?

Like population centers don't elect presidents now. No one fights for Montana. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Actually the system affords small state voters more vote impact than large state voters, and that was intentional. What should change is the winner take all practice that is NOT in the constitution. 

wayward1 --- 13 years ago -

What should change is the winner take all practice that is NOT in the constitution.

If you take that away, you have a straight up popular vote. By getting all or nothing, you vote by state as a whole. In this age of mass transit and communications, we're all equally affected by presidents and voting by state is dated to me.
We used to have Senators appointed by governors instead of voted for. We can update these things as time passes. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

If you take that away, you have a straight up popular vote

You would have each electoral college delegate voting who won the district. 

Biggun --- 13 years ago -

Yes, it is the "winner take all" practice that causes so many states to be ignored during the campaigns.

The campaigns now only focus on the "swing" states.... ie. Ohio, Florida and Pennsylvania.

If you look at the results of the last election, it is basically the urban areas of those three states the decided the election.

Pubs carried most areas of those states, geographically speaking. But Dems took the urban areas (densely populated - more votes) in those states which swung the overall state vote their way, giving them the electoral votes needed to win. 

wayward1 --- 13 years ago -

You would have each electoral college delegate voting who won the district. 

That would be a compromise I hadn't thought of. Including D.C. and PR, you'd have what 437 or so combined district popular votes to determine the president? Might be a mess to track. And not many people are fighting for district rights compared to state's rights. 

Biggun --- 13 years ago -

currently, there are 538 electoral votes

100 - the size of the Senate
435 - the size of the House
3 - Washington DC

PR gets no votes 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

In the last election, without winner take all, Romeny would have lost the city of Houston and a couple other areas in Texas. But, Obama would have lost a few areas of PA, NY Ohio, and others. I wonder if it would have been a trade off and the results the same. 

d:-] --- 13 years ago -

Senators are elected by the popular vote in their respective states. The president needs to be elected in the same way - popular vote of the entire country. The current system puts the presidental election in the hands of the swing states and northeast States. It's completely unbalanced. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

The current system puts the presidental election in the hands of the swing states and northeast States. It's completely unbalanced.

No, thats not true. The current electoral college system gives more electoral weight to smaller states. 

Biggun --- 13 years ago -

The current system puts the presidental election in the hands of the swing states and northeast States.

Actually, it is the "winner take all" practice that puts the presidential election in the hands of the swing states.

Since CA and NY are strong Dem states, there is no reason for a Pub to spend effort there. Same for a state like Texas - not much incentive for a Dem to spend much effort here.

Most of the states fall one way or the other. Few are right in the middle. The ones that are in the middle are called swing states and those states is where most of the focus is directed. It makes many voters in non-swing states feel like they don't matter.

Another issue is that voting is not done at the same time across the country. Many Pacific time voters do not vote at all if they believe the election is already over based on early returns from Eastern/Central time zones. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Hamiltons writing in the Federalist Papers also revealed that the framers of the Constitution wanted a buffer between the election of the POTUS and the people for fear that the people may elect an idiot based of the idiots ability to raise momentary passions in the people. I'm not so sure that didnt happen anyway. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground