Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Houston area hospital surgery ratings (incl Kingwood)

who's talking here?

RoseSr 2
Donkey Hodie 1
Perfection 2
AngieKaye 2
Warren Peace 7
RedMulch 1
Four of Us 1
K.T. 4
TinktheSprite 2
Its Mygirl01 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

The Sept 2013 issue of Consumer Reports provides ratings on hospitals that perform surgeries. They worked with MPA, a healthcare consulting firm to obtain the data and develop these ratings.

They looked at the percentage of a hospital's surgery patients who died in the hospital or stayed longer than expected for their procedure. The sample was limited to the percentage of Medicare patients who experienced these complications among all Medicare patients admitted during the data period. This would normalize the comparison when certain hospitals were more likely to have Medicare patients than others.

Ratings were the CR standard 5 tier rating scale. From best to worst:

5 - Houston Orthopedic and Spine Hospital (Bellaire)
5 - St Lukes Lakeside Hospital (The Woodlands)
5 - TOPS Surgical Specialty Hospital (Houston)
4 - Sugar Land Surgical Hospital
4 - Texas Orthopedic Hospital (Houston)
3 - Bayshore Medical Center (Pasadena)
3 - First Street Hospital (Bellaire)
3 - Houston Northwest Medical Center (Houston)
3 - Kingwood Medical Center
3 - Memorial Hermann Katy
3 - Memorial Hermann Northeast (Humble)
3 - Memorial Hermann Northwest Hospital (Houston)
3 - Memorial Hermann Sugar Land Hospital
3 - Methodist Sugar Land Hospital
3 - Methodist Willowbrook Hospital
3 - North Cypress Medical Center
3 - St Joseph Medical Center
3 - St Luke's Patients Medical Center (Pasadena)
3 - St Luke's Sugar Land Hospital
3 - St Luke's The Woodlands Hospital
3 - The Woman's Hospital of Texas (Houston)
3 - Tomball Regional Medical Center
3 - University General Hospital (Houston)
3 - University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center (Houston)
3 - University of Texas Medical Branch Hospitals (Galveston)
3 - West Houston Medical Center
2 - Christus St Catherine Hospital (Katy)
2 - Conroe Regional Medical Center
2 - Memorial Hermann Texas Medical Center (Houston)
2 - Park Plaza Hospital (Houston)
2 - San Jacinto Methodist Hospital (Baytown)
1 - Memorial Hermann Memorial City Medical Center (Houston)
1 - St Luke's Episcopal Hospital (Houston)
1 - The Methodist Hospital (Houston)

They also looked at certain hospitals for specific categories of procedures. The only notable Houston area hospital was The Methodist Hospital which ranked among the 5 worst for back surgeries.

Any surprises? 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

I think those rankings may be skewed a bit. I think the TMC hospitals are probably better, but they have lower rankings if it's based on survival or length of stay, since maybe the worst cases get sent there. If all the really serious cases at Kingwood get sent downtown, that both inflates Kingwood's rankings and lowers TMC's. 

TinktheSprite --- 13 years ago -

I am quite surprised. But then I haven't watched the ratings over the years. Some of those on top were at the very bottom years ago. How can you compare the Community Hospital to a Medical Center hospital when they take higher level, more complicated cases on a daily basis? 

RedMulch --- 13 years ago -

kingwood Medical Center did a fine heart surgery on me......but I think they have the finest surgeons to thank for that rating. 

K.T. --- 13 years ago -

This Scale is misleading in presentation... Methodist is #1 and should be at the TOP of the list, not at the bottom of the list presented. Statistics and numbers can always be skewed. 

K.T. --- 13 years ago -

This Scale is misleading in presentation... Methodist is #1 and should be at the TOP of the list, not at the bottom of the list presented. Statistics and numbers can always be skewed. 

TinktheSprite --- 13 years ago -

or stayed longer than expected for their procedure.

This part is interesting. I think patients stay a shorter time than ever before. Used to be, you would go in the day before for all your pre-op tests etc and surgery would be early the next morning. Now Pre-op testing is done a few weeks before and you have to come in before dawn for your surgery. Further, patients are sent home with IV's, a long list of post op instructions which include a follow up visit as soon as the next day. Many patients go home to Home Health Care. IMO patients have been sent home sooner than they should. 

RoseSr --- 13 years ago -

Many patients go home to Home Health Care. I patients have been sent home sooner than they should.

Or they go to a rehab hospital or skilled nursing facility - neither of which do I recognize as in the list. Methodist will always be top of the list for me. 

Its Mygirl01 --- 13 years ago -

From the article: they only used a small percentage of patients, only ones that were using Medicare.

Our Ratings for the first time make public a measure that some hospitals now use to track quality—the percentage of Medicare patients undergoing surgery who die in the hospital or stay longer than expected.

We looked at results for 27 kinds of scheduled surgeries, which we combined into an overall surgery Rating, and also developed Ratings for five of those procedures: back surgery, replacements of the hip or knee, and procedures to remove blockages in arteries in the heart (angioplasty) or neck (carotid artery surgery).

To develop the Ratings, we worked with MPA, a health care consulting firm with expertise in analyzing medical claims and clinical records. This project uses billing claims that hospitals submitted to Medicare for patients 65 and older, from 2009 through 2011, and covers 2,463 hospitals in all 50 states plus Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico. 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

since maybe the worst cases get sent there. If all the really serious cases at Kingwood get sent downtown, that both inflates Kingwood's rankings and lowers TMC's. 

You make a good point. But the article also states that the rates are risk adjusted based on patient characteristics such as age, gender, other health conditions such as high blood pressure, and diabetes. The paper version does not have the typical methodology section that most research studies have. But it does say that on-line subscribers will have access to such specifics. I'd be curious as to how they controlled for those variables. 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

How can you compare the Community Hospital to a Medical Center hospital when they take higher level, more complicated cases on a daily basis? 

The article states they controlled for that. 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

This Scale is misleading in presentation... Methodist is #1 and should be at the TOP of the list, not at the bottom of the list presented. Statistics and numbers can always be skewed. 

Methodist is actually rated as among the worst. I guess the numbers I chose to identify the 5 categories may have misled some to think that the number 1 implies the highest ranked rather than the lowest rated. I was thinking a 10 point scale would have 10 as the highest. So on a 5 point scale, 5 would be the highest. That part may be misleading. But it doesn't change that Methodist is in the category were a higher percentage of Medicare patients died or had extended stays beyond the norm than other hospitals.


Methodist will always be top of the list for me.

So are you surprised that a higher percentage of Medicare patients died or had an unusually longer stay at Methodist than Medicare patients at other hospitals? 

K.T. --- 13 years ago -

As I stated before, you can skew statistics. When you work inside the community you know the truth... How you can rank MD Anderson,St. Luke's or MD Anderson at the bottom???? Are you serious? Seriously???? As someone stated before, if you are seriously ill you go downtown to the research hospitals. Unfortunatey the situations are the most severe, it cannot even come close to what the satellite hospitals are dealing with... They send all the severe cases downtown to the med center. 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

I dont care what this says Methodist is one of the best in the world. Their education and study of the human heart led to many today still alive. They gave my dad only months to live after his first heart attack. Said there was an aneurysm that covered the entire heart. Half the heart muscle was dead.

But with Dr Debekay and Dr Noon they saved my father and he lived for 15 years more. They used his case to create the stint that they use today.

I also had brain surgery there, got the best treatment in every way.

With that said, my dad was on medicare. I although had Blue cross. My dads' hospital stays were very long, mine was only a couple of days. 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

To add if the med center is that bad why then do so many from all over the world come here for treatment? Heck Dr Debakey even was flown to perform on the POPE! 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

Surely someone on KU is an online subscriber with access to the methodology. I'm starting to get curious enough to subscribe simply to access it for this study.

Obviously statistics can be skewed. But it's pure supposition to suggest they are without reviewing the methodology. 

K.T. --- 13 years ago -

Warren, all studies can be weighted to favor one aspect against another. My best advice, find friends who work in the hospitals in the area. They know who the wonderful physicians and facilities are to handle the perplexing cases. The articles in the paper, magazines... well personally, I would rather know someone who works with the folks on a day to day basis. 

Four of Us --- 13 years ago -

Warren,

I am confused on how you got this information. I looked at report on CR and I get different information.

Safety Ratings (out of 100):

Methodist - 46
St. Luke's - 42
Kingwood - 39
Mem. Hermann NE - 38
St. Joseph's - 27 

RoseSr --- 13 years ago -

So are you surprised that a higher percentage of Medicare patients died or had an unusually longer stay at Methodist than Medicare patients at other hospitals?
My husband (a Medicare patient) had heart valve replacement surgery last year and was hospitalized after that for over 11 days. From there he went to a rehab hospital. That was much longer than I expected but I was relieved that they kept him as long as they did. He has other medical problems and I could not have dealt with them (at my age) by myself at home. To answer your question - no, I was not surprised. Methodist takes very good care of their patients and if that means keeping them longer, so be it. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Ratings similar to these are what will be determining Medicare and therefore all apr-drg based hospitals. Thats a major part of the ACA also known as obamacare.

Taking these numbers will mean that hospitals that treat the elderly will now be getting less in payments than others.

These hospitals are now having to rethink their missions 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

I am confused on how you got this information. I looked at report on CR and I get different information.

Safety Ratings (out of 100):


CR states that the Safety Ratings are a summary of five categories that relate to hospital safety: avoiding infections, avoiding readmissions, communicating about medications and discharge, appropriate use of chest and abdominal scanning, and avoiding serious complications.

That's not the same thing as their surgery ratings. 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

Methodist takes very good care of their patients and if that means keeping them longer, so be it. 

All hospitals take very good care of their patients in my opinion. This study is not contradicting that. It is simply showing the differences in outcomes among some hospitals. Health research data shows that indicators such as the percentage of a hospital's patients who died in the hospital or stayed longer than expected for their procedure are indicators that are strongly correlated with complications. Many hospitals use these same factors to assess their own quality control. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Outcomes are worse at inner city charity hospitals and the new payment methodology is going to have a major adverse affect on those hospitals.

In the past couple of weeks the listing of payment reductions was made public and most lower income not-for-profit hospitals in the area were reduced on their APR-DRG SDA by the maximum whereas the for profit hospitals were either not reduced at all or by less than half the non profits.

The difference in them is the type of patient which affects their outcomes measures. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

health
kingwood


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground