Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

She said I make "too much" money. On what planet?

who's talking here?

Donkey Hodie 2
Polly Ester 1
Perfection 15
Warren Peace 1
I_won't_tell 1
Bornanraisedkw 1
CrazyDiamond 1
Walker Bait 2
sheddy 1
photophanatic 3
Ender 10
Four Pinocchios 1
MissPris 1
Beaner 1
lt767 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

lt767 --- 13 years ago -

Please forgive me for this rant. I know people are struggling with far greater problems. I'm simply feeling overwhelmed.

I am a single mother with two children. A family of three is required to lease a minimum of 2 bedrooms. My plan was to give each of the kids their own room and get a hide-a-bed for the living room for me. The first property we went to had a 3 bedroom available! We were SO excited even though it would be hard to meet the rent. It was clean, well-kept, friendly staff, an attractive property with a pool and good location. Then the leasing agent told me my income was TOO HIGH. We are not eligible as tenants because they participate in a government program. I don't know which one. We were told the same thing at a different property later today. It was only one block from the lake, had a pretty club house, even a business center!

We were welcome to lease at a complex in another part of town. A much older, less maintained location, where safety is a concern and the apartment itself made our stomachs churn from the smell of smoke and urine.

Driving home I'm trying to keep the sense of panic to myself. Could I approach it another way? Paycheck deductions reduce my monthly income to $2,600. My paycheck gets smaller every year, literally, because of health insurance costs. If there was a way to lower our medical care expenses my take home pay would increase. I could afford a clean apartment in a safe location, right? I begin to research online and see that if I made $10,000 less we could get medical AND dental coverage for $50 a year. I pay $546 a month.

Can this really be true? We would have a higher standard of living if I quit my job and found something with a lower salary? A nicer place to live? Better health care? How can this be real? The whole day felt like I had landed in the twilight zone...and what did this teach my children? Work hard and always do your best? Go to college? Earn a degree? All so you can find a good job? A job where you earn "too much" to live in the nice apartments but can't afford decent housing and medical care?

I'll stop here as I am on the verge of letting loose with a string of profanities. And have apparently morphed into my conservative father.

I'm sorry. My frustration is bringing me to tears. 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

A woman on tv a couple of months ago said that she couldn't afford to make more money, since she would lose her benefits. She figured she would have to make over $80,000 to be able to pay for the benefits herself. Here the government thinks they are helping someone, but she will never know her true worth, because she will lose so much by trying to better herself. Who knows how far she could go, if she wasn't afraid of failure. 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

I'm not surprised to read that, but I couldn't be more disappointed that anyone has to experience that in a system that could easily be designed with a more graduated scale of income eligibility rather than this.

For what it's worth, I've heard that the threshold for qualifying is based on the county where the property is located. So Harris County properties may have a different disqualifying income than Montgomery County properties. 

I_won't_tell --- 13 years ago -

Our country is going to
____ in a hand basket!

Too many takers! 

Bornanraisedkw --- 13 years ago -

If you take home 2600 why are you looking at income based rent apartments? 

CrazyDiamond --- 13 years ago -

$2600 goes by very quickly, especially with children. 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

$10,000 less we could get medical AND dental coverage for $50 a year.

That is insane.

http://www.aei-ideas.org/2012/07/julias-mother-why-a-single-mom-is-better-off-on-welfare-than-taking-a-69000-a-year-job/

This article has some interesting data

"The single mom is better off earning gross income (sic) of $29,000 with $57,327 In net income & benefits than to earn gross income of $69,000 with net income & benefits of $57,045"

0undefined

*edit* I am not implying anything about your situation. I am merely trying to illustrate the issue that you seem to be running into. I wish you the best with your home search.. I was laid off for a year and some change back in 2009, and i struggled to keep my family in a good place. I know how it feels.. 

Walker Bait --- 13 years ago -

I bring home 2200 and have 1 kid and 7 pets and own a home, not bragging or anything . Anyway maybe you need a financial adviser or who ever helps with budgeting. Granted I never go out or buy anything for myself my DD ,the pets and the house are takin care of first.Luckily the truck is paid for and the company covers the other stuff on it. 

Four Pinocchios --- 13 years ago -

Bornanraisedkw --- 7 hours ago - quote - hide comments
If you take home 2600 why are you looking at income based rent apartments?



Did you even read what she wrote?

herp freakin derp 

Walker Bait --- 13 years ago -

Oh but my DD is on chips and I don't have insurance. Other than that I don't get any government help. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

0311Patriot, your graph needs better explanation.

Benefits are not just based on income but also household size so you need to factor that in as well. Your source document fails there.

Also, the graph is making assumptions that all States are the same and they are not. What qualifies in one State may not in another. For example, in Texas the maximum for Medicaid assistance is 100% of FPL for kids above the age of newborn (133% for them)(federal poverty level), in Pennsylvannia it is 250% of FPL and up to 400% in certain circumstances.

To qualify for CHIP is 200% of FPL in Texas and up to 400% in other States.

Your graphic is using the State data from those States with more generous benefit levels and you are attempting to qualify that for Texas.

A little education would be beneficial as this is a rather complex issue.

Your heart may be in the right place but don't grab a pretty chart without understanding it, I will call that out every time. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

By the way for the OP, CHIP is not just given based on income, while that is the primary reason for most, there are exceptions. For example, if the cost of insuring your children is more than 10% of your income then they qualify for CHIP coverage that will only cost you $50 a year plus copays up to a maximum out of pocket of a few hundred dollars.

You may want to check on that which will help your cash flow. 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

There is a program where property managers get federal grant money to spruce up their rental properties. Usually it entails getting older buildings up to code and then cleaning it up. What the government requires of these companies after they get the grant and update their properties is that they must rent to low-income families for a certain number of years before opening the properties to the general public. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Thanks for that MissPris, I didn't know that. 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

I will call that out every time.
As you should Perfection

I concede to your point that that graph is not a precise representation of what is available in our area. I meant it to be a general overview of the problem

@it767

Feel free to ignore this question, as it is really none of my business:

What is your professional background/education?

Maybe someone reading this thread would be able to point you in the direction of a better job if you gave us some details on this matter.

I mentioned earlier that I was laid off and had to live in a "less than optimal place" until i got back on my feet.

One aspect of that was that my wife could not get a job with her degree (Child life studies) so she was working at a daycare making peanuts while i was working at a furniture store making equally small peanuts.

One of my friends recommended that we look into http://www.texasteachers.org/ and we took the advice. Now my wife has been teaching for a little over 3 years.


Hang in there, as long as you work hard and think outside of the box, you will get through it. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

I meant it to be a general overview of the problem

Only the problem in Pennsylvania which is where your data is from. They have some of the most generous benefits in the entire Country so they are not representative of anyone but themselves. No other State comes close to them, including NY who also has some pretty generous standards. 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

not representative of anyone but themselves.

Correct again

I do not have time to find Texas equivalents for ALL of the benefits in the chart, but here are a couple:

(All based on single parent w/two children)

Max TANF: $235/mo ($2820 annually)

http://www.hhsc.state.tx.us/help/financial/temporary-assistance.shtml

Max SNAP: $526/mo ($6312 annually)

http://www.hhsc.state.tx.us/help/Food/snap.shtml

0

Hopefully this is more informative than my poor example i posted last night 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

If you go to the link I have above it will give you the qualifications for all the assistance available in the State.

Also there is alot of other info available on the HHSC website and via emails of hearings in the Legislature that would give you additional information.

If you need other resources I can give you those. Just ask. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

0311Patriot, did the numbers you post surprise you any?

The fact that to get TANF (temporary assistance for needy families) requires a maximum income of $2820 annually. Most families in this area bring that home every week or biweekly. Most people don't get TANF but do qualify for foodstamps and Medicaid or CHIP. In fact there are hundreds of thousands of kids who are qualifiable for Medicaid or CHIP with many of those in this area who are not on the programs. Now why that is, no one knows. Maybe it is because the parents don't want to fill out the paperwork, maybe it is because they don't know but for whatever reason, there are those who qualify who aren't getting it.

Texas is one of the most stringent on the criteria for assistance. That is not to say or imply there isn't waste and fraud for there is. The system can always be better. 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

Yes i was surprised.

I would like to apologize to IT767 for derailing her thread with an irrelevant correlation and thank you for correcting my inaccurate perception of Texas' welfare program.

I do not know the "details" about Louisiana's welfare system, or how it compares to Texas/Pennsylvania ect.
However, I do remember vividly the rampant abuse of that states system growing up.

I worked at a grocery store in high school and i would regularly watch customers pay for hundreds of dollars of whatever food they wanted with food stamps. Then i had the privilege of bringing their groceries out to a new Cadillac Escalade with 20" rims.. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

As I said there is fraud and abuse and ways to get around it. For example owning/buying a car counts and there is a limit on value however if you lease it does not count as an asset and there is no limit on value. So in your example the vehicle was most likely a lease. 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

You may not be considering another factor: unreported income 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

You may not be considering another factor: unreported income

One cannot consider that which isn't reported. Hence the statement there is fraud, waste and abuse.

Yes changes need to occur. I don't think anyone disagrees with that.

So if someone doesn't report income, how do you know it is theirs?


Also, did you report the people you speak of for a fraud review and investigation? Or if you didn't don't in hindsight you feel you should have? 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

did you report the people you speak of for a fraud review and investigation?

no, i was a 16 year old kid. All i did was get mad every time i had to make a truck/insurance payment.

And i am specifically talking about rampant fraud/abuse, not necessarily about "legitimate welfare recipients"

You can go to pretty much any ghetto and see $60,000 vehicles in front of shacks.

That is what you get when you have an "entitlement society" 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

You can go to pretty much any ghetto and see $60,000 vehicles in front of shacks.

I am in "the ghetto" often, you don't see a lot of those vehicles. Yes you do see some and yes, there is a lot of cash transactions occuring for illegal substances and yes there is a lot of bartering and unreported transactions.

You speak with broad general statements and they aren't always accurate.

You don't like some within the system and truly they are the minority of those receiving assistance. The vast majority are playing by the rules.

The issue is to identify those not playing by the rules and remove them. But then what about the kids? who takes responsibility for them?

Granted, the dysfunctional homes they are in now aren't the best, but what happens if those are gone? 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

The entire system can be fixed by immediately applying the following changes:

1. Mandatory monthly drug testing for ALL welfare/unemployment/disability recipients. There are extremely cheap tests that we use all the time at work that can give immediate results, so the money spent on testing would be dwarfed by the amount saved from weeding out scammers. Is there a way to get around drug testing? Sure, but at least it is better than nothing.

2. All welfare/LONG term unemployment recipients must enroll in some sort of trade school. NOT COLLEGE, trade school. IF they qualify for welfare, then they will qualify for grants. They must also report their academic progress to the government (I have to do so with my GI bill)If they fail to make progress or fail out, they do not get assistance.

People in this country do not know what the word "freedom" means. Freedom means that the framework of our society allows you to achieve as much or little as you choose in your lifetime. You should succeed or fail based on your own efforts.

Freedom does not mean that you should be able to survive at the US poverty line without working/benefiting society in any way.

I also think that SNAP/foodstamps should be run like the WIC program: families receiving them should only be allowed to get bare necessities for survival. Bread, cheese, milk, ect..

There is no excuse for foodstamps to work like a debit card for these people. what is the motivation to improve your situation if you can go buy whatever you want at the grocery store for free? IF they were eating beans and rice every day that would change. It might also help the obesity epidemic among impoverished Americans.

If you think that a "beans and rice" policy is harsh or "inhumane" I leave you with this thought:

I was good friends with one of our Somali interpreters when i was in Djbouti (Africa). One thing he said jokingly has stuck with me through all of these years. "The USA is the only place in the world where the poor people are FAT" 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Those are reasonable 0311Patriot 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

I think there needs to be a phase in approach as well. Let someone keep some benefits when they start back to work not a quick cut off 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

The entire system can be fixed by immediately applying the following changes:

1. Mandatory monthly drug testing for ALL welfare/unemployment/disability recipients. There are extremely cheap tests that we use all the time at work that can give immediate results, so the money spent on testing would be dwarfed by the amount saved from weeding out scammers. Is there a way to get around drug testing? Sure, but at least it is better than nothing.


False. It is not cost-effective to test for drug use. A study of the Florida program determined that the cost of drug tests far exceeded the amount that would be denied to welfare recipients that are using drugs.

http://www.aclu.org/blog/criminal-law-reform-racial-justice/just-we-suspected-florida-saved-nothing-drug-testing-welfare 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

I think perhaps a more reasonable solution is what Texas just implemented, if there is a history or specific conditions then yes, testing can be ordered but only for some services, not all.

A little more reasonable than all the way around. 

lt767 --- 13 years ago -

No apology necessary. I appreciate a thoughtful discussion. The chance to vent helped. It's time for me to suck it up and move on but I will share a few specifics.

1. Income

My gross income is $47,000. I am a special education teacher (don't get me started on the education system, ha ha). The irony is I went back to school to do so. I wanted to "help people". I knew it would be a cut in pay but you don't decide to be a special ed teacher for the money. I promised myself I would never complain about the salary. I made the choice. What I didn't realize was how much the benefits would impact us. The position I left had fully paid health insurance. Can you imagine that now? I was naive and had no idea what I was really giving up. Speaking of naive, I was married when I made this decision. ;-)

2. Housing

The property with income limits is one block from Lake Houston, on the Huffman side of the bridge. Here is a link: http://www.greater-coastal.com/fairlake_apartments.htm

The apartment without income limits is behind the Humble Ford dealership, near the bowling alley. I couldn't find an official website but if you google "Meadowbrook" in Humble it will come up through apartment search sites.

It's difficult to tell from the pictures but I assure you, they are not comparable.

3. Health Insurance

I will pay about $6,500 this year in premiums only. I deduct an additional $150 month for co-pays, prescriptions, etc. All together, that is $8,300. This does not include coverage for dental nor vision. CHIP appears to be $50 a year (or less) to register a family and then an income based structure for co-pays and prescriptions. It also includes dental.

4. Food

Did you know there is a summer "feeding" program? Anyway, reduced lunch is .40 and reduced breakfast is .30. On this program you pay $1.40/day for two children to eat breakfast and lunch. Over 180 days it totals $252. I, on the other hand, would pay $6.95/day or $1251/180 days.

From what I can tell, the "magic number" to qualify for many programs seems to be around $36,000 to $39,000 gross income.

Please forgive me for any errors, typos, etc. I'm getting worked up again and can't bring myself to review this post.

Thank you for listening to me whine. :-) 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

False. It is not cost-effective to test for drug use

Linking an ACLU article in a debate on welfare is like linking an NRA article in a gun control debate.

This is not just a "cost effective" issue, its is a matter of principle.

Drug testing kits can cost as little as $7.45 a piece
http://drugtestsinbulk.com/nine-panel-drug-check-oral-fluid-drug-test-p-498.html

Probably cheaper than that when you buy them in bulk.


I would rather pay an extra $7 to make sure someone is not taking my tax money to live like a bum when they have enough money to blow on drugs.

I want to be clear: As long as someone lives a productive life and doesn't bother anyone, i could care less whether or not they do drugs.

BUT, if you have proved for whatever reason that you are unable to provide a living for yourself and your family, then you give up that luxury.

Just imagine what the results would be if we drug tested EVERY adult that lives at a property that received benefits. Just because grandma goes up to the welfare office and pees in the cup doesn't mean that her benefits aren't supporting the bums that leech off of her. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

3. Health Insurance

I will pay about $6,500 this year in premiums only. I deduct an additional $150 month for co-pays, prescriptions, etc. All together, that is $8,300. This does not include coverage for dental nor vision. CHIP appears to be $50 a year (or less) to register a family and then an income based structure for co-pays and prescriptions. It also includes dental.



As I stated above, if the cost of your insurance is more than 10% of your pay, then your kids qualify for CHIP. You need to apply and include that information, you may be denied on the first pass but will be approved on appeal. 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

I am a special education teacher

That pretty much sums it up. As i mentioned before, my wife is a Humble ISD teacher. I couldn't believe my eyes when she showed me the "benefits" package. The health insurance premiums are astronomical!!

I pay around $250 a month for Blue Cross/Blue shield for my family (wife & daughter)

If memory serves, HISD's lowest plan was in the range of $700 a month..

I will have to put on the old thinking cap to try and think of something. 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

This is not just a "cost effective" issue, its is a matter of principle.

Drug testing kits can cost as little as $7.45 a piece
http://drugtestsinbulk.com/nine-panel-drug-check-oral-fluid-drug-test-p-498.html

Probably cheaper than that when you buy them in bulk.


I would rather pay an extra $7 to make sure someone is not taking my tax money to live like a bum when they have enough money to blow on drugs.

I want to be clear: As long as someone lives a productive life and doesn't bother anyone, i could care less whether or not they do drugs.

BUT, if you have proved for whatever reason that you are unable to provide a living for yourself and your family, then you give up that luxury.




If you want to base your argument on some kind of "morality" that it's not right to help someone with welfare who also uses drugs, fine. But your original argument was that it would save money to test for drug use, and the facts prove that it does not save money - it's more expensive to do so.

As far as dismissing the ACLU, that's ridiculous. The ACLU, whether you agree with their stances or not, (and I don't agree with everything they do) is one of the most ethical organizations out there. If you dispute the facts they present, I'd love to see the proof. Otherwise, don't base your argument that denying welfare to drug users is a cost savings mechanism, because it's clearly not. 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

it's clearly not.
The first line that you quoted from me says that it is a matter of principle.

We all know that drug testing is easy to circumvent, especially government run testing. (bear with me)

My question is this: IF there are so few drug users on welfare, then why is there such an uproar from them whenever the issue is brought up. We all remember the protests and anger over the florida law.

As for my "morality" you mentioned, i guess i am guilty as charged.

If you have enough money for drugs, then you do not need money for food. 

photophanatic --- 13 years ago -

$47,00 a year is nothing to sneeze at....It is way above poverty level. That being said, it does not afford for a lot of extras. I have a friend that lives in Kingwood, owns her home and the mortage is about $1300. She does get child support for her 2 kids and the ex carries insurance but she has to pay all co pays etc b/c he bails on that part. Look into Harris County Hospital District Gold Card. Totally based on income and every Harris County resident qualifies. Look into 1st time buyers programs for home ownership. It is a great way to buy a home and get a better interest rate and assistance with closing etc. The housing program has homes in Kingwood. Just make sure the taxes are within reach. Good Luck. 

photophanatic --- 13 years ago -

Also pack your kids lunch. Way cheaper and healthier for them, and you control what they eat.
Do you have cable, internet, cell phones for you and the kids? A home phone?
I am not trying to belittle you or your predicament. Just trying to offer some assistance because there are limited resources and you are probably a step or two above working poor. It will just take excellent financial management on your part. I have worked with families that make way lees than you and get by without welfare assistance. Go to the local pantries, there are 3 you can access in the Kingwood area and you can get assistance 1x per month at each. Thye give about 1-2 weeks of food for a family of 4. There is no time limit except for the 1X per month. 

photophanatic --- 13 years ago -

What about the lodge in the front of KIngwood. Last I checked their rent was about $1200. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground