Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Should people be charged for the cost to rescue them?

who's talking here?

Perfection 2
I_won't_tell 1
andreweggplant 2
LitlJay 3
sheddy 1
Three Greens and a Red 1
Edgar Po Wong 1
MissPris 1
TexasCajun 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

What about cost associated if a rescuer is injured? What about if they were then charged with a crime?

Under Marsy's Law, the California Victims Bill of Rights championed by county Supervisor Todd Spitzer, the Orange County Fire Authority wants $55,000 spent to rescue teenage hikers who got lost in Trabuco Canyon Easter Sunday.

A legal brief to that end the OCFA filed Wednesday contains this bombshell: Nicolas Cendoya, 19, and Kyndall Jack, 18, allegedly admitted taking hallucinogenic drugs before and during their hike.

It's worth noting that both teens, from their respective hospitals, talked of visions they saw while lost, parched and separated. Heck, the fact they were lost for days in a relatively easy area to hike caused much speculation in the Navel Gazing peanut gallery that they must've been on something.

It's also worth nothing that Spitzer came down hard on the Costa Mesa pair immediately after their ordeal--and before it was disclosed publicly that the rescue cost government agencies $160,000 and that sheriff's deputies had allegedly found methamphetamine in Cendoya's car while he was still lost.

A law that would have allowed recovery of the full $160,000 expired in 1999, but the Orange County Board of Supervisors Spitzer sits on approved a draft of a bill they want Assemblyman Don Wagner (R-Irvine) to sponsor so counties can once again receive that kind of compensation.

The OCFA maintains it is entitled to recover its chunk of costs from the rescue operation because of a law that is already on the books. Under Marsy's Law, the agency's lawyers contend, it is a victim of the crime Cendoya has been charged with: possession of 497 milligrams of meth.

"People have got to be careful," OCFA Division Chief Kris Concepcion tells City News Service. "It is not a victimless crime as some people might think, because it caused a great deal of not just cost, but as you know, it resulted in injuries to a couple of people while they were out looking for Nic Cendoya. If it weren't for his criminal activity we wouldn't be doing that."

Nick Papageorge's, a 20-year-old volunteer who helped in the search, is also using Marsy's Law to seek financial compensation for his back surgery and a week in the hospital he says cost about $350,000. He had titanium screws put in his back after he fell about 110 feet from a cliff.

The judge could consider the Marsy's Law claims at Cendoya's scheduled July 12 arraignment. 

andreweggplant --- 13 years ago -

Definitely, people should have tp pay the costs just like they would if it was a car accident etc. emergency responders put their life on the line for hikers, climbers etc and they get paid "peanuts" for doing their job very well in rescues 

Three Greens and a Red --- 13 years ago -

I can just see a Coast Guard rescue swimmer explaining to someone on a sinking boat in a storm that he has to first sign a consent form and a waiver absolving the Coast Guard of any wrongdoing should the rescue go horribly awry. Then he explains the list of available services and the price for each one. For a hundred bucks they'll snatch him from his sinking boat and deposit him curtly on the nearest land. For a thousand bucks they'll fly him to the Coast Guard Air Station and call him a cab. If he can afford it they'll fly him home, give him a clean bathrobe, some cognac and a warm bath and they'll even sprinkle some powder on his backside before they tuck him in. 

andreweggplant --- 13 years ago -

That's a bit excessive... I should be common knowledge that you be expected to pay for services just like you have to pay if you are taken to a hospital in an emergency for example. They will treat you even if you cannnot sign but it is not free. You should be required to be resposible for the services, even more so if you have to be rescued for doing something stupid! 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

The Coast Guard does bill for the costs of rescues. You can read news accounts of cruise lines trying to avoid paying for rescues. 

LitlJay --- 13 years ago -

If someone falls asleep in bed or in a recliner with a lit cigarette and they have to be rescued from the resulting fire, you bet they should pay for the fire department's services.

Same goes if someone puts dinner on the stove and then goes out for a beer.

If it's a genuine accident like someone else's irresponsible use of fireworks or a previously undetectable electrical fault, then they should not be on the hook. 

I_won't_tell --- 13 years ago -

What about heart attacks?
Strokes
Electrical fires
Falls
....... 

LitlJay --- 13 years ago -

What about heart attacks?
Strokes


of course not.

Electrical fires

Depends on if it was owner negligence (cutting the ends off of an extension cord to wire up a new light switch, overloading a cord with cube taps)or a fault that they couldn't have been aware of (defective breaker or improper install by an inept electrician).

Falls

that obviously depends on the circumstances of the fall, but unless it was due to a case of outright and extreme stupidity (belt/drapes superman costume) I doubt that most falls would not be accidental and therefore no liability. 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

Many people put themselves in danger. When things go wrong, their actions put other peoples lives in danger. I do believe that people should be responsible for the bill. You have a heart attack, stroke or fall, you will pay for the ambulance and the hospital. 

LitlJay --- 13 years ago -

You have a heart attack, stroke or fall, you will pay for the ambulance and the hospital.


I thought that part went without saying.

I thought the question was extra effort as a result of the illness, above the ambulance ride, such as having a heart attack while hiking. 

TexasCajun --- 13 years ago -

I have to admit that I was a little miffed at the effort and expense afforded those people in Galveston who were told to evacuate before a recent hurricane. They went door to door for crying out loud! 

Edgar Po Wong --- 13 years ago -

Yes, they should be billed by weight. 

TexasCajun --- 13 years ago -

Lol @ Edgar. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

In the article referenced, they are charging them because the people needing rescued were needing it because they chose to do drugs and became disoriented.

Is that personal choice grounds to not provide a free service? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground