Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

!0 year old Lung Transplant patient receives 2nd set of donor lungs

who's talking here?

smartypants 3
Perfection 4
lucky dog 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 3
needsleep 1
sheddy 2
photophanatic 2
JAMS 1
witchywoman 1
BiteMe 1
Anna Conda 2
Polka Dot Duck 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

photophanatic --- 13 years ago -

PHILADELPHIA (AP) — A 10-year-old Pennsylvania girl whose parents sued to challenge national lung transplant rules received a second set of lungs after the first failed, and her family said she has taken some breaths on her own.

However, she faces another operation because of complications from previous procedures.

The mother of Sarah Murnaghan said Friday that the first set of lungs failed within hours of the June 12 transplant at Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, and her daughter was placed on machines. She was placed back on the lung transplant list the night after her surgery and received a second set of lungs on June 15.

"We were told ... that she was going to die," Janet Murnaghan said Friday as she explained why Sarah's second transplant was not publicly disclosed. "We weren't prepared to live out her dying in public."

Sarah's mother said the second transplant was a success and the girl was able to take a few breaths on her own.

But, Sarah was placed back on a ventilator due to partial paralysis of her diaphragm, a complication of surgery that is not allowing her lungs to expand, her mother said.

She is scheduled for surgery on Monday in an effort to repair her diaphragm.

"There's still a lot in front of us," Murnaghan said, but then added: "Sarah's a fighter. She's always been a fighter."

The suburban Philadelphia girl initially received lungs from an adult donor after her parents sued over national rules that place children behind adolescents and adults on the priority list for adult lungs — even if the children are sicker and are capable of accepting adult organs.

The action spurred a national debate over the organ allocation process.

The Murnaghans and the family of 11-year-old Javier Acosta of New York City challenged the policy making children under 12 wait for pediatric lungs to become available or be offered adult lungs only after adolescents and adults on the waiting list had been considered. Both children have end-stage cystic fibrosis.

A federal judge ruled they should be eligible for adult lungs after U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius declined to intervene.

Janet Murnaghan said Sarah's condition began to "spiral out of control" shortly after the first surgery. A second set of lungs was found and transplanted even though the donor once had pneumonia, making the surgery extra risky. The second set was also from an adult donor.

The failure of the first transplant is not uncommon. A 2005 University of Pennsylvania study found nearly 12 percent of lung transplants experienced what's called primary graft failure, where the organ almost immediately begins to fail.

But the timing — she received a second set of lungs just three days after her first — was narrow.

Of 5,081 lung transplants performed between 2010 and 2012, there were only seven retransplants within a week of the initial operation, according to the United Network for Organ Sharing, the private nonprofit group contracted by the government to manage the transplant list.

"I think this very clearly illustrates that the decision needs to be scientific and medical, rather than judicial," said Lawrence O. Gostin, a health law professor at Georgetown University who questioned the legal basis of the rulings. "UNOS was under pressure from the publicity surrounding this case and the court's decision. It is highly unusual to get two transplants within days."

According to UNOS, a graft failure does not automatically propel someone to the top of the waiting list of potential recipients, who have been assigned scores based on need. But Sarah's new score made her eligible for the second set of lungs.

Earlier this month, the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network, which is overseen by UNOS, resisted making rule changes for children under 12 seeking lung transplants, but created a special appeal and review system to hear such cases. The special review option will expire on July 1, 2014, unless the full board of directors votes to keep it in place.

Of the 1,663 people currently seeking a lung transplant in the U.S., 12 are between the ages of 6 and 10.

____ 

photophanatic --- 13 years ago -

Interesting..... 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Very 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Wow.

Yes the decision should have been medical all along. The court overstepped their area here 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

any word on the lungs she got the second time, were they adult too? 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

I believe that they were. 

smartypants --- 13 years ago -

I wonder, if everything goes well, what is her prognosis? The new lungs do not make this terrible illness stop progressing.

What would you do if you were a carrier of the mutation for CF? Would you have the fetus tested? What if an amnio revealed the fetus had it? 

Polka Dot Duck --- 13 years ago -

***oops*** deleted by me for redundant info. 

witchywoman --- 13 years ago -

I agree with Chunky that the decision should have been medical. I don't know much about CF but smarty, are you saying these lungs will end up affected by the disease as well? If that's the case I'd think anyone with CF shouldn't even be considered for a transplant.


any word on the lungs she got the second time, were they adult too?

That's what the above article stated. 

smartypants --- 13 years ago -

are you saying these lungs will end up affected by the disease as well?

Here's what I read:

The major cause of death in lung transplant is rejection.

Survival rates for people with CF after lung
transplantation are approximately 91 per cent (for
persons without Burkholderia cepacia complex)
and 64 per cent (for persons with B. cepacia
complex), one year after transplantation.

Survival
rates five years after transplantation are 68 per
cent (for persons without B. cepacia complex) and
34 per cent (for persons with B. cepacia complex).


CF affects other organs besides the lungs:

"A pancreatic or liver transplant may be performed at the same time in order to alleviate liver disease and/or diabetes".

"Immunosuppressive drugs, also called antirejection drugs, must be taken daily for the rest of a recipient’s life to reduce the immune system’s ability to attack reject the new organs. These
drugs will cause a life-long reduction in the ability to fight infection."

"Currently, about 17 percent of all lung transplant patients survive 10 years or longer." 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

I think you don't give healthy organs to terminally ill patients unless otherwise healthy patients are either not a match or there are enough for everyone.

Those who are not terminally ill should come after those who are not. Sounds cold but using organs that could extend ones life by a year and having someone die who could have lived 40 is just bad use of the organs. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Those who are not terminally ill should come after those who are not. Sounds cold but using organs that could extend ones life by a year and having someone die who could have lived 40 is just bad use of the organs.


I totally agree with this. Plus have the people she jumped in line received life saving treatment yet? 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

I don't think someone with a disease should get a transplant. If it were my child I would want to do anything I could to prolong their life, but at what cost. I don't think I could bear seeing the suffering. Can you imagine what the parents of this girl have gone through this past month? I'm sure it has been awful for the child, At what point does she say, enough is enough. I also have a problem with an alcoholic receiving a liver. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

I also have a problem with an alcoholic receiving a liver.


yup 

smartypants --- 13 years ago -

The new lungs do not make this terrible illness stop progressing.



Correction: Witchywoman, I should have said, lung transplant is often necessary when patient survival is threatened, but then you are dealing with the serious problem of rejection, which is often fatal.

If it were my child I would want to do anything I could to prolong their life, but at what cost. I don't think I could bear seeing the suffering.

Thanks for your honesty. 

lucky dog --- 13 years ago -

Get the gov out of the organ business. It's time for open buying and selling.
Enforced 'fairness' is an oxymoron. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Get the gov out of the organ business. It's time for open buying and selling.
Enforced 'fairness' is an oxymoron. 



Where are these unregulated organ dealers going to be getting their organs from? I guess if he walks someone could just follow George Zimmerman around for a fresh supply. 

BiteMe --- 13 years ago -

You can't expect the parents to be thinking logically in this situation, I feel for them. They will do and are doing whatever it takes to try and save their little girl. You can't expect them to sit her down and be like "Listen, honey, we're giving up and you're doing to die." I can't imagine the helplessness they feel and however misguided they are I still feel so horrible for them. It's easy to say what we would do in the situation, but you just don't know unless you're in it. The problem lies with the courts. They are supposed to take emotion out of it and be the voice of reason in this emotionally charged situation, and it looks like they failed. 

Anna Conda --- 13 years ago -

Get the gov out of the organ business. It's time for open buying and selling.
Enforced 'fairness' is an oxymoron. 


Yes. If we can sign do not resuscitate orders, if we can grant power of attorney to someone else, if we're ok with children giving their lives to the military at age 18, if we're ok with aborting babies through the first trimester because "it's a woman's right to do with her own body"...then why can't all people be permitted to sell their organs?

I guess because out of "fairness" this will be unfair to the poor. But there should be a way around it - let the government buy a % of organs that matches a % of people living in poverty. Since we already pay for healthcare for the poor, why not pay for what it costs to encourage more organ donation? 

Anna Conda --- 13 years ago -

Where are these unregulated organ dealers going to be getting their organs from?

All healthcare seems to be regulated. Why wouldn't organ selling? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

You can't expect the parents to be thinking logically in this situation, I feel for them. They will do and are doing whatever it takes to try and save their little girl. You can't expect them to sit her down and be like "Listen, honey, we're giving up and you're doing to die." I can't imagine the helplessness they feel and however misguided they are I still feel so horrible for them. It's easy to say what we would do in the situation, but you just don't know unless you're in it. The problem lies with the courts. They are supposed to take emotion out of it and be the voice of reason in this emotionally charged situation, and it looks like they failed. 


I agree with you. Just because its the right thing doesn't make it easy for anyone but at some point the suffering has to stop. I hope I'm never in their situation. :( 

needsleep --- 13 years ago -

I have not read enough to know she stepped in front of others to receive the lungs now 2nd set. From reading the article I do agree the courts should have considered the medical evidence as Perfection already stated. It all sounds death panel no matter what angle you look at it. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground