Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

ADHD/ADD French vs American children

who's talking here?

Donkey Hodie 1
SoupIsGoodFood 1
Perfection 3
Jpgirl 1
Warren Peace 2
jtcitrus 1
Dorothy Parker 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
needsleep 1
Semper 1
JAMS 1
ThisLady 2
WinstonC 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Story

Neat stuff. I have a friend from France who is stationed with his family in NC with the French Marines. His parenting style is very similar to what is described above, and it all makes sense. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

interesting so instead of masking symptoms they focus on working on the cause.

What a novel concept. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

from the article

As a therapist who works with children, it makes perfect sense to me that French children don't need medications to control their behavior because they learn self-control early in their lives. The children grow up in families in which the rules are well-understood, and a clear family hierarchy is firmly in place. In French families, as Druckerman describes them, parents are firmly in charge of their kids—instead of the American family style, in which the situation is all too often vice versa. 

Semper --- 13 years ago -

Weren't American parents like this decades ago...non permissive,disciplinarians,etc? Surely there is some correlation between the percentage of childrenn diagnosed with ADHD decades ago as compared to most recently. And as far as processed foods...there have been processed foods since the advent of the tv dinner back in the 50's. 

Jpgirl --- 13 years ago -

Hmm seems common sense to me. That's exactly how we raised both our kids but especially our son- manage to avoid meds till he was 8 and the heavy meds till he was 12. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Interesting...I mean there needs to be a core truth in here somewhere. Is ADD/ADHD biological or behavioral/environmental?

It has to be one way or the other, at the core. Not saying that other things don't influence it.

They didn't go much into the dietary differences in France/Europe and here. But I'd be willing to bet kids here eat more junk, fast, and processed food. I think food is a good place to start the investigation when almost 10% of the population has the condition. 

WinstonC --- 13 years ago -

"You know, I'd rather have my bottom impaled on a giant cactus than to have to speak to that jumped-up Frenchman. As far as I'm concerned, the only thing the French should be allowed to host is an invasion." 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

In French families... parents are firmly in charge of their kids


so.... they teach their kids to surrender?




;)

itersting and obvious... but diet is also a factor and (on average) I'd wager the french have healthier food for their kids... 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Wait.............. I thought the left recently told us that the govt is in charge of our children? 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

I'm not sure what's typical for this type of diagnosis, but my experience took me from a non-believer in ADD/ADHD as having a biological component to a believer.

My parenting style was to set rules and enforce them. When my boys were babies, they cried themselves to sleep. By the time the oldest two were 4-6 years old, they were bathing themselves at night, getting pj's on themselves and were in bed by the same time every night.

About that age I decided to start reading older age group books to them. I went with the Harry Potter series. I started to notice that WP1.1 started to lose interest while WP1.2 would stay attentive. After finishing a page I would occasionally ask them questions about what we just read. WP1.2 would always nail it while WP1.1 would struggle...often trying to guess what happened, confirming he wasn't paying attention.

WP1.1 appeared to be a bright kid but never showed signs of being a poor student until the 5th grade. His grades dropped. I responded by spending time with him studying every night after I got home from work to ensure he knew the material. I was disappointed with his learning but optimistic that putting him through a learning routine at night would help. No dice.

We tried tutoring. No dice.

We tried taking away his favorite things with an opportunity to buy them back with acceptable grades. He adapted to doing without those things and continued with poor grades.

We became stricter with dietary intake. No change.

We tried Sylvan. Money down the toilet.

We tried letting him fail and let him experience the consequences of failing - summer school. He made much better grades in summer school - Bs and As. But once the new school year started, he was back to performing poorly.

After another experience of going to summer school in HS, we got him evaluated for ADD. He was assessed as having a mild form and was prescribed a low dose of meds.

Suddenly, his grades took off. He was bringing home awesome grades in his worst classes. Better yet, he began saying, "Dad, it's really weird, but I'm making better grades than some of these kids that I ways thought were so much smarter than me. It all makes sense to me now and I really think I might be one of the smartest guys in the class." Made my eyes tear up. After all these years, we found something that worked.

WP1.1 continued to take meds for a year or two and then stopped. He said he just did not like the idea of taking meds and wanted to get by without them regardless of his grades. We respected his wishes.

He's just finishing his first year at that evil Lone Star down the street and he's getting by just fine without meds.

WP1.2 wasn't an A student either, but he never struggled like that.

So in a nearly ideal controlled environment of two boys living in the same house, under the same parenting rules, we have two very different outcomes. Numerous different strategies were tried, but only meds worked with 1.1. The only conclusion that seems acceptable to me is there is a biological component to learning. Some kids win the lottery. Some don't.

So go ahead and put me down as a skeptic on that French study. I'll study them for their cooking techniques but find very little else in that culture I value. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Very interesting Warren...but what about the fact that this is a relatively new "disease"? Was is always around? What caused the surge?

If your hypothesis is correct that there is a biological component to learning from kid to kid, where was the Add/Adhd 50 years ago? 

Donkey Hodie --- 13 years ago -

I would put money on part of the problem being dietary.

Corn syrup, I'm looking at you. 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

Untreated? 0

I'm not implying that it needs to be. I didn't make good grades either, and I'm pretty sure I didn't figure out how to focus my wandering mind until having a chemically induced epiphany during the college years. Being a late bloomer has worked well for me so I have no regrets. But I do wonder how differently things might have worked out if prescription meds had been around back in the day. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Interesting article.

I've often thought ADD/ADHD was a disciplinary issue over a psychological issue.

It takes a lot of discipline on the parents' part to stay consistent with the rules and expectations. Especially when it comes to a strong-willed child. 

needsleep --- 13 years ago -

I would put money on part of the problem being dietary.

Corn syrup, I'm looking at you.


Ingredients in immunizations, increased amounts of immunizations. ADD/ADHD is now the name on the face of hyperactive, day dreamer, air head, etc... I am in the same situation as Warren was. Maybe not as extreme, but to medicate or not medicate, crosses my mind. My thoughts... if I believe chemicals being introduced into the body may be doing this, an increased amount will not be beneficial in the long haul. If I can control things in diet i would rather go that route instead of adding more direct absorption of chemicals I am suspicious of. 

ThisLady --- 13 years ago -

It's such interesting timing for you to share this article. Just yesterday morning I was having a semi-in-dept conversation about my functioning and ADHD. The exact observations that I pointed out are that my symptoms weren't always as bad as what I view them to be right now. As a child I had an extremely significant amount of self discipline and structure that I formed on my own and very young: Same bed and wake times, same daily routine and structure that included thorough cleaning, cooking, walking to store to get groceries, taking care of baby siblings. I would just get up and do it, as opposed to now where I literally have to psych myself up and gain motivation for some of even the most basic tasks. After pushing aside my pride, I have finally come to realize that my symptoms have increased due to my lack of self discipline and maintaining a structured lifestyle.

After thinking it through, I noticed that my symptoms dramatically increased my 8th grade year which is when I started having difficulty focusing in school and was placed on meds. Up until that year, my daily routine consisted of pure structure that included at least 5 hours a day of dance training for competitions. My grades were high, and it was very easy for me to stay focused.

My ADHD medication doesn't seem to do me justice and my point was that it would do me great benefit to remove meds completely and reform my life with strict structure and high activity levels to keep me more focused.

Humans are habitual beings by nature and that very structure really does bring great sense of security and better ability to progress and maintain mental stabilization. IMO 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Teachers seem to think they can diagnose ADHD now too and are making referrals to parents that require their child be medicated.

Houston schools do this all the time and their backlog of cases is huge. What's sad is the child cannot return to school until they are given medication, all because a teacher says they act up in class. 

ThisLady --- 13 years ago -

child cannot return to school until they are given medication, all because a teacher says they act up in class. 

That's absurd. With that mentality it won't be long before half the class consists of zombified over-medicated children with a chemical dependency on unnecessary medications. Or more hyperactive irritable kids depending on how the medication effects them.. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground