Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Question about those with mental illness

who's talking here?

Polly Ester 1
Perfection 7
Mommyto3kiddos 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 5
TheFallen 2
Emperor of Kingwood 3
Identity Crisis 2
CherokeeChick 2
Tootiefrog 1
Not KU 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

The thread about the 21 y/o has me asking this.

Should there be a different set of laws/standards for someone diagnosed with mental illness?

If yes, why? Is that fair to everyone that some are not held to the same standard.

If no, why not? Is that fair to the mentally ill?


Should someone who is mentally ill be required to be monitored? 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

No one wants to share their opinion?

Yes this is a sensitive subject. Are you afraid of your opinion? 

Identity Crisis --- 13 years ago -

I think we have to have different consequences based on their understanding, but the laws should be the same for everyone. We are all people first some just are people with a disability or mental disorder. We have to take public safety seriously. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

First there is a difference between mental illness and mental retardation, autism, and other communication and mental disabilities.

If someone commits a serious crime like murder, rape, pedophilia it shouldn't matter what their mental capacity is they should be removed from being a threat to the community.

I personally think the death penalty in those cases is even more humane than locking them up. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Oh I am strictly not talking mental retardation, autism and other communication/mental disabilities. Those truly are not mental illnesses.

So if someone is found to be "guilty by reason of insanity" for a murder you feel they should be put to death?

Do the mentally insane have more rights than others? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

So if someone is found to be "guilty by reason of insanity" for a murder you feel they should be put to death?


I think anyone who kills, rapes or molests a child should get the death penalty regardless of mental capacity. In my opinion they are all crazy on some level and should not live. Yes I'm hardcore about that but insanity isn't really a defense it's more of a reason to put you down in my opinion. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 13 years ago -

I personally think the death penalty in those cases is even more humane than locking them up. 

folks like you are the reason I fear for the future safety of my son. He is 6, autistic, has receptive language disorder meaning he does not understand, has been diagnosed as mentally retarded and functions at a 2 year old level. Because of his lack of understanding when he gets frustrated he tends to get upset. Does he hit, sometimes, does he harm anybody no he does not. His frustration from lack of understanding and not being able to communicate what he wants causes him to react.

By no means am I saying that my son will grow up to murder or hurt somebody, but for those that have no understanding of the world around them, no understanding of dangers, no understanding that hitting is wrong just killing them is your option?? Its the more humane thing to do? humane? you are talking about somebody's child. Not a dog!

This thread is going nowhere but headed in the wrong directions. I swear I feel like I am going to throw up after reading your post. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

If your child rapes or murdered someone would you rather he be locked up in some facility for the rest of his life scared of everyone and everything around him? I think that would amount to cruel and unusual punishment. By the same token if he did rape or murder someone understanding or not he should not be allowed to be a risk to others ever again. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Mommyto3kiddos, having a special needs child is not the same as a mental illness. While similar I think we are all capable of understanding the differences.

There are also differences between someone who is active in the life of their special needs child/adult and someone who passes that responsibility on to society to handle. 

TheFallen --- 13 years ago -

So if someone is found to be "guilty by reason of insanity" for a murder you feel they should be put to death?


There is no such thing as "guilty by reason of insanity." There is "not guilty by reason of insanity, but as the name suggests... it means quite the opposite of your post.

The law requires the defendant to have the ability to distinguish between right and wrong. Texas uses a modified version of the M'Naughton, which recognizes the irresistable impulse test. Insanity is a legal standard, not a medical standard and being mentally ill ALONE does not make you insane under the law. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Mommy I wasn't trying to be unfeeling towards special needs kids. I do draw the line on vicious crime and tend to want to protect everyone from being a victim regardless of who the perpetuator is. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

There is no such thing as "guilty by reason of insanity." There is "not guilty by reason of insanity, but as the name suggests... it means quite the opposite of your post.

The law requires the defendant to have the ability to distinguish between right and wrong. Texas uses a modified version of the M'Naughton, which recognizes the irresistable impulse test. Insanity is a legal standard, not a medical standard and being mentally ill ALONE does not make you insane under the law.



Thanks for the clarification. I didn't know that.

so if they are not guilty by reason of insanity they could get out of jail if later cured? 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

Thanks for the clarification. I didn't know that.

so if they are not guilty by reason of insanity they could get out of jail if later cured?


I think if they are later to be found competent then they have a trial then. they don't have a trial if they are found to be incompetent to stand trial. if they are found incompetent they receive treatment until they are able to have a trial. at least that is what happened to a man when I was on jury duty. he was brought before the judge but it was determined that he was still mentally incompetent and we didn't have the trial.

insanity is harder to prove, at least in Texas. Andrea Yates had to have a 2nd trial to prove it because the first one was over turned in appeal. theoretically after treatment such a person could be released if they improved but it is unlikely. I think most would be housed in a secure mental health facility for life, maybe coming before a parole board like John Hinckly has, but determined to still be dangerous and not released to the general population. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

they wouldn't be in jail,they'd be in an institution-and yes, theoretically, they could be released- 

TheFallen --- 13 years ago -

If they are not guilty by reason of insanity, it means that they are not guilty of the crime. A second trial would violate the 7th Amendment to the Constitution's preclusion of Double Jeopardy. If the individual was "sane" at the time of the crime, and then becomes incompetient to stand trial, the trial can and will typically be delayed until competency is found.

For an interesting (and tragic) example of this, read this story from the Chronicle. A Houston Police Officer was killed by a driver found not guilty by reason of insanity. He served three years in an institution and it looks like he is about to be released to live as a free man.

http://www.chron.com/news/houston-texas/houston/article/Accused-cop-killer-may-walk-free-after-3-years-in-4499218.php?cmpid=hpfsln

Just the way the system works... 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 13 years ago -

Mommy I wasn't trying to be unfeeling towards special needs kids. I do draw the line on vicious crime and tend to want to protect everyone from being a victim regardless of who the perpetuator is. 

i understand, but these special needs children will be older some day and probably still functioning at a 2 year old level. Sorry... continue with your discussion, its an extremely sensitive one. 

CherokeeChick --- 13 years ago -

My younger brother has Aspergers, a form of Autism and my step son has Autism .. They are both very sweet and gentle .. and I agree, there is a difference between mental illness such as bipolar, schizophrenia etc.. and developmental learning disorders such as Autism. 

CherokeeChick --- 13 years ago -

My brother's Aspergers has gotten better actually .. He is now in normal classes in high school and one honors class .. He can play the violin very well too :). Not all Autistic children stay functioning at a 2 year old level. 

Not KU --- 13 years ago -

If yes, why? Is that fair to everyone that some are not held to the same standard.

I say yes, but not with a blanket answer. Pending on the type of disability one is diagnosed with would merit scrutiny. For example Bi-polar dis-order vs Autism may or may not merit scrutiny. More to my point is the following: "Responsible" gun owners in charge of the care of those with Mental Illness/disorders be subject to proving their weapons be secure by a regulated standard set by State or Fed. regulation. I would think a study of who qualifies and under what kind of scrutiny is needed to qualify any given gun owner, I don't know. Gun ownership qualification should not stop w/just the owner. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

More to my point is the following: "Responsible" gun owners in charge of the care of those with Mental Illness/disorders be subject to proving their weapons be secure by a regulated standard set by State or Fed. regulation. I would think a study of who qualifies and under what kind of scrutiny is needed to qualify any given gun owner, I don't know. Gun ownership qualification should not stop w/just the owner.

How would a person prove their guns are safely locked away from a mental patient unless they first provided to a government entity (as you suggest) the exact type and serial numbers of all guns owned by that person? Further, are you suggesting that the government needs that information? And, are you suggesting that the government have the right to inspect at any time regardless of the 4th amendment?

Gun ownership qualification should not stop w/just the owner.

Who else should qualify to own a gun other than the owner? There are gun ownership qualifications already in place and free of mental defect is one of them. 

Tootiefrog --- 13 years ago -

I always thought autism and aspergers were more on the developmental delay rubric and not a mental illness.

That said, neither are a part of my every day life so I could be mistaken. 

Not KU --- 13 years ago -

Bob in Texas: Yes I am.

To your question: Back ground checks on who is in the house. Census reference. Question of importance. Mental disorder/Illness. Are they dangerous? 

Identity Crisis --- 13 years ago -

I think that if there is a documented developmental disorder, then the guardian should be held responsible for keeping them safe and keeping the public safe.

If it is a documented mental illness, then the doctor should be held responsible for keeping their patient safe and the public safe from them. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

If it is a documented mental illness, then the doctor should be held responsible for keeping their patient safe and the public safe from them.

so the individual who suffers from a mental illness bears no responsibility? 

Not KU --- 13 years ago -

so the individual who suffers from a mental illness bears no responsibility?

If a person suffers from a mental illness/disorder they would not be legally permitted to be in possession of a weapon. Often enough people claim insanity as a defense. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

If a person suffers from a mental illness/disorder they would not be legally permitted to be in possession of a weapon.

That's is the law now.

To your question: Back ground checks on who is in the house. Census reference. Question of importance. Mental disorder/Illness. Are they dangerous?

So your real objective isn't to help the mentally impaired, but rather ban all gun ownership in violation of the second amendment. 

Not KU --- 13 years ago -

So your real objective isn't to help the mentally impaired, but rather ban all gun ownership in violation of the second amendment.

No. I want to make sure if you want a gun and someone in your home is questionably stable, a background check could establish this and determine if its safe. Much like the case in Aurora,Co. I hope there are no more "misinterpretations" I never stated any objectives. Real or otherwise. Only an opinion. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

So if someone gets a gun illegally and harms someone but is insane, who is at fault? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

So if someone gets a gun illegally and harms someone but is insane, who is at fault? 


Both 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

No. I want to make sure if you want a gun and someone in your home is questionably stable, a background check could establish this and determine if its safe

Let me see if I understand this. You want a background check on me to make sure theres no one in my house whos mental stability is questionable? Not only would the disclosure of that persons health information be a violation of federal law, but how does a background check on me determine someone elses stability? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground