Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Should kids who achieve honors scores/grades be recognized?

who's talking here?

ladybeachbum 1
Red Heifer 5
Perfection 3
stayinalive 1
LitlJay 1
snowprincess 1
tredanis 3
JAMS 1
funkadelic 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Or is it demeaning to those kids who may or may not have tried but didn't achieve the grades?

Do honor banquets or ceremonies send the wrong message? 

ladybeachbum --- 13 years ago -

Heck, no! It is time we stop giving the awards out to everyone so they won't be upset they didn't study instead of playing video games. 

snowprincess --- 13 years ago -

They should be honored and get the financial aid to college. It shouldn't be based on finances, only on academics. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

ladybeachbum you are exactly right and a principal in Mass is doing just that.

No more recognition for good grades because grades aren't a fair way to judge because it hurts the feelings of others 

LitlJay --- 13 years ago -

When the high achievers are recognized it gives the other students something to strive for.

When "everyone gets a trophy" no one cares.

It also seems to work in reverse far too often: What about hallway banners, posters, pep rallies, fund raisers, letter jackets, rigged grades, trophies, newspaper/TV stories, scholarships, and other endless accolades for a pathetic football squad that couldn't beat a peewee team, while nobody notices a girls lacrosse team or a soccer team that has a completely undefeated season? How demeaning is that to the true achievers? That football team may have worked hard, but they haven't earned all that doting adulation until they accomplish something. 

Red Heifer --- 13 years ago -

I would give a trophy to the kid who gets the grades and scores before I give it to the quarterback or the fastest swimmer. 

tredanis --- 13 years ago -

Red Heifer --- 1 min ago - quote - hide comments
I would give a trophy to the kid who gets the grades and scores before I give it to the quarterback or the fastest swimmer.




pffffffft - you don't think it takes hard work to achieve something in athletics?

Smacks of jealousy to me. You sound like one of those bu**hurt nerds who was always the last picked for games on the playground. 

Red Heifer --- 13 years ago -

pffffffft - you don't think it takes hard work to achieve something in athletics?

Smacks of jealousy to me.


Of course I do. But we glorify athletes way more than academics. Students who excel in academics ought to be valued, rewarded, encouraged and recognized as most important to our future. 

Red Heifer --- 13 years ago -

 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

We are the generation of participation ribbons.

A few years ago, I got into a lot of hot water because as a youth track coach for a Marine Corps base, I was supposed to treat all the children as equals...they were all "superstars!!!"

Everything was supposed to be equal, and my slowest runners were to be told how amazing they were!!! This was the directive from the youth sports program.

The unwritten rule was that in relay events, it was supposed to be equal - 50/50 girls and boys.

At the last minute and last meet of the season, I switched my 4x100 relay team to all girls, and they came in first by about 50 yards.
I withdrew my two boys who were sloooooow and not motivated to run.

I had a lot of angry parents and other coaches...but we were there to win. My girls had worked too hard all season to not enjoy the fruits of their time, passion, and dedication to the sport.

I was tired of telling my girls "Oh, we're just here to have fun, sport!"

Heck no...we were there to win and kick butt!!! And kick butt they did!!

I expect my kids to make good grades, and I don't expect them to be recognized for them. Well, except for my 17 year old. He currently has a 100 in biology, a 109 in a business/finance class, and a 100 in world history. Since moving to Texas (the curriculum IS easier here) he's really excelled and dangit, he needs a certificate!!!! ;) 

funkadelic --- 13 years ago -

I'm completley ungfamiliar with this phenomenon. Everything my kids are in there are winners and losers or we don't participate.

If parents don't like it their kids should do something else. I have a feeling we're talking soccer and jump rope or something.

In school there is something called G&T and AP classes. The kids know all too well who the winners and losers are in sports and school. By the way losing at sports and grades doesn't necessarily mean much. Look at the Bush family. 

Red Heifer --- 13 years ago -

OK, so winning and losing is enough? No more letters for athletes, trophies for winners, etc? I don't think that every kid needs to get a trophy. My point is that the first violinist and the kid who has a 109 in a business class (I would check the teacher's math skills, though) deserve at least the same recognition as an athlete, if not more. 

stayinalive --- 13 years ago -

To Red Heifer:
"OK, so winning and losing is enough? No more letters for athletes, trophies for winners, etc? I don't think that every kid needs to get a trophy. My point is that the first violinist and the kid who has a 109 in a business class (I would check the teacher's math skills, though) deserve at least the same recognition as an athlete, if not more."
AMEN..AMEN!!!!!!! I'm with you!!!! 

tredanis --- 13 years ago -

Red Heifer --- 11 min ago - quote - hide comments
OK, so winning and losing is enough? No more letters for athletes, trophies for winners, etc? I don't think that every kid needs to get a trophy. My point is that the first violinist and the kid who has a 109 in a business class (I would check the teacher's math skills, though) deserve at least the same recognition as an athlete, if not more.



Well when the Boston Philharmonic generates as much revenue for the city as the Boston Red Sox and kids start wearing replica tuxedos instead of replica jerseys, perhaps your little violinists will start getting the recognition they deserve.

Until then...........pffffffffffffffft!

As for smart kids who make good grades, they will get their come-uppance when the athletes fail to make it professionally and have to find work elsewhere. That is when the athletes start referring to the smart kids as "Boss". 

tredanis --- 13 years ago -

Perfection --- 17 min ago - quote - hide comments
principal calls off honors night because others would be "devastated"

Fair?



Unfair. 

Red Heifer --- 13 years ago -

Seems to me we should be promoting and rewarding the excellence that is best for society at least as well as the kid who is a good high school athlete. In other words, I'd like to send the message that we most value the future business or public leader at least as much as a future small college running back. And that's what's best for our kids' futures, too. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground