Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Sperm Donor Sued For Child Support

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 2
planemom 1
Perfection 11
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
Work in Progress 1
Dorothy Parker 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 5
justforfun1 1
FabFive 4
xception 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Wow, talk about a mess!!






By Myles Collier, Christian Post Contributor

January 3, 2013|11:52 am

A sperm donor in Kansas is fighting the state over child support that officials say he owes after he gave the donation to a lesbian couples three years ago.

William Marotta donated his sperm to a lesbian couple hoping to conceive and is now on the hook for back child support and possible future charges. The state ruled that his is financially responsible for the child, whose mothers filed paperwork to receive state assistance.

Marotta maintains that he signed a written contract with the women in which he forfeited all of his parental rights, including all financial responsibility.

However, the state of Kansas disagrees and maintains that the contract Marotta signed is not valid. State law stipulates that all sperm donors who wish to relinquish their parental rights when participating in in-virto fertilization must utilize the services of a licensed doctor, otherwise donors could be on the hook for the child's financial support.

Court records show that Marotta and the couple signed an agreement in March 2009, which stated that the women would "hold him harmless" financially, in addition to his name being omitted from the birth certificate.

Under the state law that was enacted in 1994, a sperm donor is not considered the father when a donor provides sperm to a licensed doctor for the purpose of artificial insemination of any woman who is not the donor's wife. It was thought that this law would encourage donors and eager mothers to consult with a doctor.

Angela de Rocha, spokeswoman for the Kansas Department for Children and Families, said it is part of the routine procedure to determine the child's paternity when a single mother seeks state benefits for a child. Procedure requires the father to make financial payments in support of the child to lessen the burden of the state's taxpayers who fund the welfare services.

Marotta explained that he is "a little scared about where this is going to go, primarily for financial reasons," during an interview with The Topeka-Capital Journal. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

So the mother isn't going after him, the state is?

Weird case... 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Good deal.

He should have investigated the rules if he wanted to protect himself before he whipped it out. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

So the mother isn't going after him, the state is?

Weird case...



Correct, the mother wants the taxpayers to pay, the taxpayers (State) is requiring the father pay.

Seems appropriate. 

planemom --- 13 years ago -

Was the pregnancy caused the old fashioned way or was an unlicensed doctor used? Either way, poor guy. He thought he was helping out some friends and now the state wants him held liable. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Sounds like a doctor was used but not following the state guidelines for proper ways to protect the sperm donor.

His intentions may have been good, but he didn't protect himself and now since the mother is attempting to get support, the State is required to go after the father. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

The story said it was "in vitro", so he was definitely just a donor, not a lover.

I'm guessing that following the state guidelines on how to "collect" sperm would have cost them a lot more money. But in hindsight, it would have cost a lot less than years of child support! 

whatchamacallit --- 13 years ago -

This is so wrong for the "sperm donor"! Just like girls/women that purposefully get pregnant, the old fashioned way, the man is left holding the bag. There are so many women who get pregnant on purpose and without the fathers consent and then turn around and try to force child support on the man! Yes, it takes two to make a baby but that is not at all moral. Sure, they shouldn't be having sex unless they are married anyway but even if they are married, it is wrong to force parnthood onto a man without his consent. Men should be smarter than to leave it up to the woman to prevent pregnancy, no matter what she says! Yes, I know that sometimes it happens even when you are being safe but that is another story altogether. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Well if mom wanted the child she should have the means to take care of it and not expect everyone else to pay for her WANT.

The State is entirely correct to find a responsible party to pay for the child. They chose to have it, they find a way to pay it. 

justforfun1 --- 13 years ago -

Well if mom wanted the child she should have the means to take care of it and not expect everyone else to pay for her WANT.

The State is entirely correct to find a responsible party to pay for the child. They chose to have it, they find a way to pay it.




Bingo 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

It seems like such an invasion of something very personal. Here these people worked it all out to each others satisfaction and signed documents trying to make it legal. The couple split up and one wants support...how they go back and get the sperm donor back into being liable is just silly. Obviously they need to write in some caveats as exceptions in that whole child support thing...No one of the 3 people involved thinks the man should pay...but the state didn't figure on this particular situation arising, I'm sure. Now that it has, time to take a look at including some other situations bound to occur and take care of them legally. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Well if mom wanted the child she should have the means to take care of it and not expect everyone else to pay for her WANT.

She lost her job and needed help with support according to news reports. She did what anyone would do, go to the other parent. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Just like girls/women that purposefully get pregnant, the old fashioned way, the man is left holding the bag. There are so many women who get pregnant on purpose and without the fathers consent and then turn around and try to force child support on the man! Yes, it takes two to make a baby but that is not at all moral. Sure, they shouldn't be having sex unless they are married anyway but even if they are married, it is wrong to force parnthood onto a man without his consent. Men should be smarter than to leave it up to the woman to prevent pregnancy, no matter what she says! 

This case is nothing like what you've described above.

This was a friend donating sperm to a lesbian couple for an in vitro fertilization....not a guy being trapped by a woman through seduction and unprotected sex. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

they weren't even his friends...he replied to an ad-the 2 women are completely on his side, but one of the women presumably the one who had custody-(that state doesn't recognize same sex marriage) lost her job- this is on the state, not the women or the man- 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Wait, it said that donors who use IVF must use a licensed Doctor. IVF is highly specialized and has to be done by a Doctor.

My point is, it sounds like there is protection for those who DO use IVF, not ones who go the old fashioned route.

After being in the IF community for years so can assure you the people get pregnant in a lot of unconventional ways. Even if they didn't go old fashioned, they may have gone another route that wouldn't use a Doctor at all. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

The State is correct to protect the taxpayers and not pay for children who have legal parents with means.

The fact that they didn't complete the process correctly does not absolve them of responsibility.

Kudos to the State.

Another question, since the State does not recognize the same sex relationship, is the partner working and could they be responsible? If so, mom could have given guardianship to the partner which would allow legal rights to her as well. But if they aren't wanting to provide financially and be held responsible then it would make sense they weren't going through those steps and providing for themselves. 

xception --- 13 years ago -

Regardless of the morals involved, its just law. If the father did not protect himself legally than BY LAW he is expected to pay child support. Besides it's the state not the mother sueing. Still he shouldn't be in trouble for something this harmless. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

How is it not harmless when the taxpayers would be footing the bill for this

They are harmed. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

evidently, the woman staying at home, and raising the child, wasn't the person responsible for support-being that isn't Tx, we don't know the laws in Kansas...so let's not jump to conclusions about what the mothers can do or not do,or what the law says-obviously they couldn't afford to do it the "legal" way, or the request wouldn't have been in the "wanted" section! Lord, some of you are so ready to pass judgement w/o facts! 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Regardless of the morals involved, its just law. If the father did not protect himself legally than BY LAW he is expected to pay child support. Besides it's the state not the mother sueing. Still he shouldn't be in trouble for something this harmless.

That's the problem. The couple are not holding him responsible b/c they all had an agreement. It's the state that did not create a situation like this for the law. They should be able to see this is a unique situation and give him a pass and make room for such a situation in the future..

Perfection, the woman seeking aid is doing so due to a job loss and she has a child to care for. Isn't that what this kind of aid is for? She is not a serial aid seeker...or someone with a ton of kids who has a raquet going. 

whatchamacallit --- 13 years ago -

Just like girls/women that purposefully get pregnant, the old fashioned way, the man is left holding the bag. There are so many women who get pregnant on purpose and without the fathers consent and then turn around and try to force child support on the man! Yes, it takes two to make a baby but that is not at all moral. Sure, they shouldn't be having sex unless they are married anyway but even if they are married, it is wrong to force parnthood onto a man without his consent. Men should be smarter than to leave it up to the woman to prevent pregnancy, no matter what she says!

This case is nothing like what you've described above.

This was a friend donating sperm to a lesbian couple for an in vitro fertilization....not a guy being trapped by a woman through seduction and unprotected sex.


The comparison I was making is that in this case AND in cases where the man is trapped into parenthood, the woman should be held accountable, not the man who clearly was not interested in having a baby to begin with. He should not be held responsible.

The persons that should be paying for this child are the two mothers, not the sperm donor. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Perfection, the woman seeking aid is doing so due to a job loss and she has a child to care for. Isn't that what this kind of aid is for? She is not a serial aid seeker...or someone with a ton of kids who has a raquet going.


This aid is for those without other means. In this case there is other means that being the biological father.

Their decision to not do it the right way and following the law does not absolve them of responsibility.

The biological father is responsible. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Let's call a spade a spade: A sperm donor is NOT a father. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

but they are by law the biological parent UNLESS they followed the guidelines and in this case, they did not.

Ergo, he is the father and responsible. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Not following the guidelines was dumb. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Not following the guidelines was dumb.


And his mistake has led him to being responsible. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Welcome to the real world. Not protecting yourself (ha ha) is a surefire way to get in trouble. We all learn it sooner or later. He just learned it the hard (haha!) way. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Welcome to the real world. Not protecting yourself (ha ha) is a surefire way to get in trouble. We all learn it sooner or later. He just learned it the hard (haha!) way.


Yup. That's what he gets for aiming for the cup 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

My point is this is a situation that the law overlooked because of timing and other issues. You would think they could see that and fix it. I guess that's just over everyone's head. LOL

The donor should have gone over the laws with a fine tooth comb. Guess thats the world we live in. No room for common sense. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -


The donor should have gone over the laws with a fine tooth comb. Guess thats the world we live in. No room for common sense.


When you ask the government to control everything you have to accept their rules and controls.

Freedoms are eliminated when government has to run things 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground