Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

How would you feel if your child was called out for not doing well on a school project?

who's talking here?

Perfection 4
jtcitrus 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
KathyKat 4
Workinonit 1
Emperor of Kingwood 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

NPR

I found it interesting the teaching techniques used.

While here in the US, most parents would be mortified and upset their child was called out because they couldn't perform a task, in the Asian system they are given time to master it then applauded when they succeed.

The hard work is encouraged, mediocracy is not.

Very interesting.

Would you want your child called out and pushed or coddled and allowed to be mediocre? 

Workinonit --- 14 years ago -

Go back to sleep 

jtcitrus --- 14 years ago -

I remember on field day. If someone couldn't do something. Everyone knew, and cheered them on for trying and improving. (though there were always one or two hecklers)

I kind of think of it the same way, but team culture / esprit de corp matters. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

While here in the US, most parents would be mortified and upset their child was called out because they couldn't perform a task, in the Asian system they are given time to master it then applauded when they succeed.


The Asians are all about CONTROL, in just about every area of their society. They are taught to be stoic. The kids didn't make fun of him b/c they barely speak or even show emotion in the classroom. They didn't make fun of him because it is not allowed and they are all very obedient...mind their own business and speak when spoken to.

I like that the kid wasn't demeaned in any way. Learning how to do it was the most important thing. Great for the classroom. They have the utmost respect for their teachers, and elders are held up high.

The big picture is bigger tho. They have very high suicide rates in the very young....that leads me to believe that their cultural norm of keeping standards uber high and not expressing a lot verbally might have back fired? 

KathyKat --- 14 years ago -

It depends on how the child is called out. If it is a good teacher's sincere way to call our attention to an area that needs improvement, then it is fine. If it's just a lazy teacher belittling the child because he/she doesn't want to help the student, then it is not ok.

What I have the biggest problem with are teachers who won't give that extra time. I give my kids a ridiculous amount of time, if they genuinely want to improve. Some of my peers consider this a weakness. :( On the other hand, I don't give grades away; they must work for it. As a result, my grade book tends to wind up with grades on both extremes. I give way more As than my peers, but also do more failure reports. Many teachers switch Fs to Ds so they don't have to do the extra paperwork. I don't think that helps anyone. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

KathyKat, did you read the article as to how the child was called out? 

KathyKat --- 14 years ago -

Nope...reading now. I am home sick today and moving a bit slowly... 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 14 years ago -

The contrarian view is that many times a little public humiliation goes a long way towards dealing with lazy. 

KathyKat --- 14 years ago -

Very interesting article...definitely food for thought. I've had that 'American' conversation, almost verbatim, with dd many times. On the other hand, I have definitely designed lessons slightly beyond my students' grasp, so that they will stretch. My peers do this as well. The difference is this: When my kids master it I'll say, 'Look how smart you are!' Or, 'See, you're smarter than you gave yourself credit for!' I won't praise them for their struggle, however. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Yet the others praise the effort and work, not the result.

It reinforces the pride in work and effort in my view. 

KathyKat --- 14 years ago -

I am going to try this approach and change what I praise, just out of curiosity. I'll report back if I notice it makes a difference. :) 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 14 years ago -

Instead of saying "look how smart you are" why not recognize the fact that hard work pays off. I see lots of kids today that think they are smart and somehow special when in fact they are no smarter than anyone else and certainly no more special than anyone else. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Instead of saying "look how smart you are" why not recognize the fact that hard work pays off. I see lots of kids today that think they are smart and somehow special when in fact they are no smarter than anyone else and certainly no more special than anyone else.


I think that's what the article is saying. That we need to praise the work and not the result.

How we as parents look at things is what molds the children. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground