Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The Fair Tax Plan

who's talking here?

David 1
AFWife 3
Perfection 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
Warren Peace 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 4
JohnLynch 1
kidsfan3 1
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 4
SparkleShine 2
crazypinetrees 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 8
DatBoyHooD 1
Beer 2 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Just wondering what you all think of this..Our tax code is 77,000 pages long. The IRS takes 13 billion dollars a year to operate. That's all I need to hear. lol

"Chronicle-Houston became the fourth-largest city in America because of the can-do resolve of its founders, decades of entrepreneurial effort and the vision that drove residents to dare to think they could make a port city 50 miles inland from the Gulf of Mexico. What has kept Houston growing, in spite of national downturns, is a pro-business attitude and one of the lowest state and local tax burdens in the nation.

Today, however, with U.S. unemployment holding at higher than 8 percent for more than 42 months, and an August Bureau of Labor Statistics report that showed a disappointing 96,000 new jobs created last month and four people dropping out of the job market for every one who found a job, Houston's economy - like that of the rest of the nation - needs a boost. There is much national debate over how to stimulate economic growth - whether to spend or save our way out of debt. However, many are failing to address a major root cause of the problem - the 77,000-page federal income tax code, full of loopholes, contradictions and inequities that stymie business growth and polarize Americans into haves and have-nots.

For a growing number of Americans - more than 3,500 of them in Houston alone - the only solution is replacement of the current federal income tax with the FairTax, a federal consumption-based program that taxes citizens on what they spend, not on what they earn. The FairTax is a new, simple, transparent and totally equitable system of revenue generation that levels the economic playing field, does away with the $13 billion-a-year IRS bureaucracy and brings a $1 trillion efficiency to U.S. business every year.

The FairTax is a comprehensive plan to replace federal income and payroll taxes, including personal, gift, estate, capital gains, alternative minimum, Social Security/Medicare, self-employment and corporate taxes with a 23 percent consumption tax on new goods and services - no exceptions, exclusions or exemptions. Included in the plan is a constitutional amendment (HJR 16) that repeals the 16th Amendment and makes a federal income tax unconstitutional.

Last November, Americans for Fair Taxation released estimated incremental revenue projections had the FairTax been enacted in 2009 and 2010. The estimates, developed by Dr. David Tuerck, Chairman of the Economics Department and Executive Director of the Beacon Hill Institute at Suffolk University in Boston, demonstrated that the FairTax generated revenues for 2009 would have been $171 billion more than the IRS revenue and in 2010, $267 billion more.

It is also important to note that under the FairTax, Social Security and Medicare funds are no longer triple-taxed as they are under the income tax: first, when payroll taxes are initially withheld; second when the withheld payroll taxes are counted as part of the taxable base for income tax purposes; and finally, when the promised benefits are received. With the FairTax, Social Security operates exactly as it does today, except it is funded from a broad-based, progressive national retail sales tax versus a narrow, regressive payroll tax.

With the FairTax, consumers will pay the actual price of a product or service with no hidden taxes, and workers will keep 100 percent of the wages they earn. Additionally, the FairTax will eliminate the 15 percent to 25 percent cost discrepancy that manufacturers of American goods face when competing in international trade.

The FairTax lowers business compliance costs and eradicates the tax wedge that drives up the costs of U.S. goods both at home and overseas. Under the FairTax, imported and domestically produced goods incur the same U.S. tax. The FairTax removes all taxes on exports, restoring the international competitiveness of American manufacturers in the global marketplace, thereby further stimulating trade.

What all this means to America is the increased availability of funds to apply to debt retirement, positive economic growth and desperately needed job creation. Consider, for example, the plight of young Americans ages 18-29, 1.7 million of whom have been jobless for the past year, the highest unemployment rate for that age group since World War II. This is a generation in danger of becoming a lost generation, jobless and without meaningful prospects to become productive, contributing members of our society and future leaders of American commerce. The FairTax provides hope for bringing hundreds of thousands of lost jobs back to all Americans, young and old." 

crazypinetrees --- 14 years ago -

I think its fine but food and medications need to remain tax free as thy are now.

Ive never had a problem with this. It means everyone pays their fair share, BUT some people will argue it taxes businesses and the poor unfairly. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

It taxes everyone fairly including the poor and businesses. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Why hasn't something like this caught the eye of our esteemed leaders?? You know, the ones who think it's a viable solution to just keep printing money... 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

The fair tax plan should really be called the anything but fair tax plan.


Poor and lower class families spend a much larger percentage of their income than people that have more money. So essentially you have a wealthy person paying taxes on the 20 to 30% of their income that they spend(saving or investing the rest), while a poorer person ends up paying taxes on 90 to 100% of their income, because they have to spend what they have to survive. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

Poor and lower class families spend a much larger percentage of their income than people that have more money. So essentially you have a wealthy person paying taxes on the 20 to 30% of their income that they spend(saving or investing the rest), while a poorer person ends up paying taxes on 90 to 100% of their income, because they have to spend what they have to survive.


Food and medication would still not be taxed. They would only be taxed on non essentials so I still think it is fair. 

DatBoyHooD --- 14 years ago -

On randle the flip side that million dollar yaught that is a write off for business purposes is now 200,000 in revenue for the govt. Essemtial items like food with still be tax free. I see it as the only true fair tax, everyone pays in and their fair share. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

It also captures cash only businesses and others who do not report all of their income. Its a win win. It was also a part of the Paul Ryan plan that was shot down by the democrats. 

David --- 14 years ago -

I agree totally for several reasons you did not mention. First, it has been reasonably estimated that as a country we spend over $1 trillion in tax preparation, tax departments to minimize taxes, etc. This talent could be used much more efficiently. Second, our tax code is the politicians tool to force investment into areas they decide to prefer. Look at real estate. These preferred areas ALWAYS attract more investment than they should and you invariably get into very economically devastating boom and bust cycles. Thirdly, almost all of the crony capitalism practiced by both parties occurs through the tax code. Special provisions for individual companies or industries are spread throughout the tax code for no other reason than political payoffs. People that think our so-called progressive tax laws create fairness are sadly mistaken. Notice that many of the sanctimonious ultra wealthy, such as Warren Buffet, and the Rockefellers, are deemed as progressive because they support higher rates on income. What self serving garbage - The super wealthy have under the tax code many ways to be able to receive money without it being taxable. Tax free muni's, etc. At lease a fair tax or a consumption tax would in essence tax their wealth as it is spent - a truly level playing field. Also, there is no doubt that there is huge dollars of income that never get reported by the large underground players - drug dealers, cash based businesses, etc.

The irony is that the people who advocate staying with the current system and only raising the rates are not hurting the wealthy and support most of the crony capitalism they claim to hate. Wise up to the real world. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I think it is an incredibly intriguing prospect. It sounds wonderful but what would keep the government from ever increasing the tax rate?

I usually hear of a 20% tax rate being proposed. What is that number based on? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

this has been my choice, for a while now-SiFi, you brought up something that a lot of people don't seem to know- SS is taxed, like any income-and as you said, triple taxed-it seems like a win win to me- 

AFWife --- 14 years ago -

How it works

I've read both Fair Tax books & am a supporter. 

AFWife --- 14 years ago -

Book 1

Book 2 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

I think use taxes are a great way to ensure everyone pays. a lot of people don't report all their income and this ensures everyone pays based upon their purchasing.

Seems fair. It also eliminates a lot of deductions that are unfair and discriminatory. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Thanks AFW, great info. And those magical words, 'the IRS is no longer needed' were right there in black and white! 

kidsfan3 --- 14 years ago -

AFWife, thanks for sharing the website. Interesting stuff and sounds like it could be a good thing! 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

So, where's Warren Peace?? This is no convo without his in put. lol

Also any negatives to this? I don't know, I'm just learning too. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

I agree- I miss WP-I think he's brilliant- 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I agree- I miss WP-I think he's brilliant-


I know. Don't give him the big head..he's on now so I'm going to shamelessly bump my own thread. hehe. 

Warren Peace --- 14 years ago -

Thank you ladies for the kind words. Such comments do not go to my head. Instead, I think to myself, "if they only knew the rest of the story."

But of course I'm drawn to a Fair Tax thread. What's not to love? Any tax system that avoids the modern abomination which chooses sides and incentivizes economic activity that favors the pet projects of politicians is something I'm going to embrace, especially if it also treats economic transactors equally.

The easiest observation to make even on this thread is that most of the opposition is based on fiction rather than on understanding. For example, take a look at Randle McMurphy's statement which reads, "The fair tax plan should really be called the anything but fair tax plan. Poor and lower class families spend a much larger percentage of their income than people that have more money. So essentially you have a wealthy person paying taxes on the 20 to 30% of their income that they spend(saving or investing the rest), while a poorer person ends up paying taxes on 90 to 100% of their income, because they have to spend what they have to survive."

Some people rely on other people to tell them what to think. When I watch Rachel Maddow on MSNBC for example (great entertainment), she often makes this very statement that Randle is regurgitating. If Randle had resisted the temptation to merely regurgitate and chose to understand before speaking, he would have known that a critical piece of the Fair Tax system is the prebate.

Thinkers such as Randle and Maddow get no further in their scrutiny than the statement which suggests there are no exemptions or deductions in the Fair Tax. That is all they need to know. They stop reading. But if they would continue, they would see more details which permit persons living in poverty to effectively have a 0% tax rate.

A Prebate is in place to allow the tax to still be progressive in effect. It provides a monthly, universal payment in advance of their monthly purchases to ensure that each family unit can consume tax-free at or beyond the poverty level, with the overall effect of making the FairTax progressive in application. More information can be read here - FairTax Prebate explained 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

So now we have to ask why are the politicians fighting this? 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

So now we have to ask why are the politicians fighting this?

because if the fair tax passes...the libs can't play the class warfare card anymore 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

So now we have to ask why are the politicians fighting this


One thing might be it would require a repeal of the 16th Amendment fordibbing a federal tax. The other thing might be what Warren mentioned, " Any tax system that avoids the modern abomination which chooses sides and incentivizes economic activity that favors the pet projects of politicians". THAT. 

SparkleShine --- 14 years ago -

" Any tax system that avoids the modern abomination which chooses sides and incentivizes economic activity that favors the pet projects of politicians". THAT.

THAT in a nutshell is going to hell in a handbasket and enjoying the ride at any cost and zero fairness. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

THAT in a nutshell is going to hell in a handbasket and enjoying the ride at any cost and zero fairness.


Yeah, killing the cash cow is probably not going to be so popular AND the very people who got us here, are in charge of how and IF we ever really do something about the debt and failing income to the government. 

Beer 2 --- 14 years ago -

Prebate is just another gimmick, you want the Gov to mail everyone a check each month - I'll have what you're smoking... Only solution is flat tax across the board, bump up the welfare payments (reparations) to the layabouts to make you feel good. The tough problem is ending welfare, too many people and too much identity theft. Mailing another check is not the solution. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

hmmm.....I think I'm sticking with the Fair Tax.. 

AFWife --- 14 years ago -

Prebate is just another gimmick, you want the Gov to mail everyone a check each month - I'll have what you're smoking... Only solution is flat tax across the board, bump up the welfare payments (reparations) to the layabouts to make you feel good. The tough problem is ending welfare, too many people and too much identity theft. Mailing another check is not the solution. 


Link

The flat tax and the FairTax share some important similarities. They are both flat-rate taxes that are neutral with respect to savings and investment. The flat tax, however, retains the invasive income tax administration apparatus and can easily revert to a graduated, convoluted mess, as it has many times over many years.

Very few people really understand the flat tax. Its authors will tell you it is a consumption tax that uses the income tax system for implementation. Only an academic or government bureaucrat would dream up a consumption tax that needs the invasive income tax apparatus for its application, when one can simply have a retail sales tax and reduce the bureaucracy by 90 percent or more! In addition, a large part of the burden of the flat tax -- the business tax -- will remain hidden from people in the retail price of goods and services.

In contrast, the FairTax is simple, easy to understand, and visible. It cannot be converted into an income tax.

Under a flat tax, individuals would still file an income tax return each year similar to today’s 1040 EZ. While this is a simple postcard, the record keeping required to fill in the blanks is still long and burdensome. Under the FairTax, individuals never file a tax return again, ever! Under the flat tax, the payroll tax would be retained and income tax withholding would still be with us. Under the FairTax, the payroll tax, which is a larger and more regressive tax burden for most Americans than is the income tax, is repealed. Under the FairTax, what you earn is what you keep. No more withholding taxes; no more income tax.

Notwithstanding flat tax proponents’ honorable intentions, income tax reform has been less than a success in the past. Congress has tried to reform the income tax again and again, with the result being greater complexity and, generally, higher rates. The problem is the income tax, and it is time to stop tinkering with it.

Flat tax supporters have made major political attempts to pass their reform, including the efforts of former Majority Leader Dick Armey and presidential candidate Steve Forbes, and yet their efforts have not progressed politically for several years. With every debate, the flat tax loses grassroots and congressional support to the FairTax. It is time to junk the entire income tax system and start over with a tax system that is more appropriate for a free society and better able to meet the needs of the information age. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

It is time to junk the entire income tax system and start over with a tax system that is more appropriate for a free society and better able to meet the needs of the information age.


From your mouth to God's ears. 

SparkleShine --- 14 years ago -

It is time to junk the entire income tax system and start over with a tax system that is more appropriate for a free society and better able to meet the needs of the information age

From your mouth to God's ears.

The idea sends warm fuzzy hopeful adrenaline coursing through my veins! 

Warren Peace --- 14 years ago -

One of the many reasons I like it is that it encourages responsible consumption.

But the #1 reason I favor it over the current system is that it's a consumption tax and not a productivity tax.

The worst thing we can possibly do to an economy is to tax productivity. Economics 101 stipulates that when you tax something, you get less of it.

So is it better to have less productivity or less consumption? Surely, even the green energy nazis can get on board with this. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

if they stop and think, i'm sure they will- 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground