Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Men forced to pay for kids that aren't theirs

who's talking here?

Tylers Journey 3
AFWife 3
Perfection 12
classact 1
kidsfan3 6
Work in Progress 9
Bornanraisedkw 1
Dorothy Parker 9
SagaciousSighFiGurl 5
Walker Bait 1
IbarraFam222 6
justforfun1 5
snowprincess 2
LillyDivine 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Thankfully it may change soon

link title

HOUSTON – A new law aims to help fathers who are forced to pay child support for children who aren’t theirs.

“Statistically, there are 128,000 men in Texas who are paying child support for kids who aren’t theirs,” said Dennis Fuller, a Dallas attorney who specializes in family law.

Consider the case of Reggie Jones, who lives in northwest Harris County. It’s the end of the month, and his cupboards are almost bare. The same holds true for his wallet. He says it’s the result of paying $1,400 a month in child support for two children DNA testing has proven are not his. That’s 40-percent of his take-home pay.

“I lose sleep. I’m miserable. I’m angry,” said Jones. “I’m just surviving the best I can and I work hard every day.”

He says surviving wouldn’t be possible without the support of his family. After all of his bills, including child support, are paid, he says he’s left with only $23.

“He has been informed by the Texas Attorney General’s Office in no uncertain terms, he’s not the father, but he still has to pay,” said Houston family law attorney Cynthia Diggs.

In years past, if a father in Texas learned the child he’d been supporting wasn’t his, he still had to pay, because it was considered in the best interest of the child that is logic that sometimes came at the expense of his real children.

A new law gives men until Saturday, Sept. 1, to petition the courts for DNA testing that could absolve them of responsibility. They can still do so after the deadline, but only if they’ve learned they’re not the father within the past year. Critics say that’s not fair.

“I’ve had people come into my office pretty much on a daily basis bringing me DNA tests from 2007 or 2009 or 2005, and those guys are all going to find themselves under the old law,” said Fuller.

What’s more, even if you meet the Sept. 1 deadline, as Reggie Jones has, and are proven not to be the father…you still owe any back child support that’s due.

“The Attorney General’s Office takes credit for all child support paid to the state,” said Diggs.

The state also received federal incentives of $30 million to $40 million a year based upon how much child support it collects, and this fiscal year it has collected a record $3.2 Billion.

“There is no justice in a non-father paying child support for someone else’s child,” said Diggs.

“I’ve pretty much lost everything,” said Jones. “My car (and) I had a home.” 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

That sucks. :( 

AFWife --- 14 years ago -


In years past, if a father in Texas learned the child he’d been supporting wasn’t his, he still had to pay, because it was considered in the best interest of the child that is logic that sometimes came at the expense of his real children.


Best interest of the child? Yeah right...sounds like best interest for the lying mother. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Best interest of the child? Yeah right...sounds like best interest for the lying mother.


And best interest of the State who is qualifying for Federal incentives because of forcing these guys to pay. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Those are some hefty incentives! 

IbarraFam222 --- 14 years ago -

Some information that they are probably leaving out is the fact that some of these guys were ordered to appear in court and never showed up (default judgment). It's also possible they signed the acknowledgment of paternity at the hospital when the child was born.

After the fact they probably decided to check into things when they noticed money coming out of their paycheck or arrears being collected from the IRS.

They just can't show up at the AG with a DNA test after a judgment has been made. They have to hire a lawyer and get a new order. 

snowprincess --- 14 years ago -

Not trying to make this too political, but what happens if some of the right wingers get their way and rape victims are forced to have children resulting from rape. If the woman's husband divorces her, who pays child support? The husband or the rapist? What if she isn't married? Does the rapist pay child support? 

IbarraFam222 --- 14 years ago -

So technically when you're married that child is your husbands. That's why you can't get a divorce while pregnant.

The ex husband will have to pay child support until he gets his DNA test and takes her to court to stop the payments.

They mother would then be responsible for the Childs support.

The only way a husband or ex has to pay support is when he acknowledges paternity or adopts the child. Those actions are irrevocable. 

snowprincess --- 14 years ago -

I think the GOP should pay the child support, LOL. 

Walker Bait --- 14 years ago -

that sux guys who aren't the father r paying for kids that r not theirs yet men who r the father sit pretty and don't pay crap ...example my dd father..what ever she knows i am her mother and her father... 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Maybe this is a reason for women to control the reproductive process and truly think about ALL the costs.

What's fair is fair. If a man isn't the father he shouldn't be financially responsible and be able to end that.

Even more sad if he assumed it was his child and then found out it wasn't - there's only one way that happens and that's the woman sleeping with more than one person at the time of conception. If she lies, isn't the blame on her????

Yes the real victims are the kids, but that isn't the fault of the men who were paying in error, it's the mother who slept around.

And for those of you who ask about rape cases,

In a 3-year longitudinal study of 4,000 American women, physician Melisa Holmes found that pregnancy may result from forced sexual intercourse, producing over 32,000 pregnancies from rape nationally each year.[13] That study found that among victims of reproductive age (defined in the study as ages 12 to 45), the rape-related pregnancy rate was 5% per rape or 6% per victim.[14] Of these pregnancies, 38% led to birth (kept by the mother or put up for adoption); 12% resulted in spontaneous abortion, and 50% were terminated through clinical abortion.[14] A study authored by psychologist Mary P. Koss in 1987 also found a 5% pregnancy rate from rape for 18-24 year-old higher education students in the United States.[15]

source

So, since rape pregnancies are such a small percentage, while they are vile, they are not the ones we are discussing. 

Tylers Journey --- 14 years ago -

I think the father should have a say if he wants it or not when they find out they are pregnant. I think if a man wants to walk away and terminate his parental rights he can and shouldn't have to pay child support. If he wants the baby and the mother doesn't she shouldn't be able to abort that child. It take 2 to make a baby and I think a man should have the same rights as the mother.
I think if someone has to pay support they should have to take a DNA test and this wouldn't be an issue. 

AFWife --- 14 years ago -

TJ, it does take two. IMO, if he wants to walk away & terminate rights then he still should have to provide financial support since it took both of them to make that child. 

Tylers Journey --- 14 years ago -

But if a female wants to not have it she can go an get an abortion or give it up without the father's say in it. I just don't think that is fair and a father should have a say since the mother does. I think a father has the right to say I don't want it and walk away just like the mother can say I don't want it and walk away from that child before it is born. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

And the mothers who only want the financial support but won't let the fathers see the children. There are those cases too.

It isn't a one sided equation here and sadly there is not a positive outcome when adults don't make good decisions 

IbarraFam222 --- 14 years ago -

But the law that the entire family code is based on is "the best interest of the child". And you can't argue that it's not in their best interest to have financial support. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

really? even if the money is received by lying? 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

But the law that the entire family code is based on is "the best interest of the child". And you can't argue that it's not in their best interest to have financial support.


Which is why it is time to really consider what is in the best interest of the child. Is being with a parent who is not able to financially support them in their best interest? Is being with a parent who has lied and slept around and lied about it in the best interest of the child?

That standard can be used against the mother as much as it can be used for her. Be careful only seeing one side of the argument. 

IbarraFam222 --- 14 years ago -

The thing is the father in these cases had the chance to prove he wasn't the father! He either didn't show up for court or signed the acknowledgment of paternity. 

Tylers Journey --- 14 years ago -

The thing is the father in these cases had the chance to prove he wasn't the father! He either didn't show up for court or signed the acknowledgment of paternity.


Do they know they have that opportunity to get a free DNA test when going to court? 

LillyDivine --- 14 years ago -

Wow what a horrible rule. I definitely dont think its fair. As soon as the man finds out its not his biological child, if he doesn't wish to pay child support anymore, he should not be forced to. 

AFWife --- 14 years ago -

I despised my oldest one's "father" so much that I never expected anything from him. If he sent something (happened a handful of times) then fine but I didn't plan on getting money from him and that made my life a whole lot easier not worrying about if I was "entitled" to something. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 14 years ago -

You are not entitled to anything! Your child is. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

This is just wrong and I see the angle, the Texas Attorney General is scamming people. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Interesting that. And stupid as well. This is what you get when you chose to circumvent common sense and make laws and procedures that go against plain logic.. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Correct, the Federal government set up a system that encouraged the States to keep collecting from anyone they could.

Keeping the federal government out of individual issues is a priority. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

Maybe the Attorney General should be investigated. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

There are many women who forego child support so they don't have to deal with their ex.

Sadly, it seems quite a few men are out there who can and do walk away and would never look back if it weren't for laws forcing them to pay child support...but that law only works if the mother makes sure it's enforced.

As far as men paying for kids that aren't theirs, if they can prove they were duped, then they shouldn't have to pay. If they willingly signed paternity KNOWING the child wasn't theirs, and now wants to deny paternity because he and the mother are no longer together, I think that's wrong and he needs to fulfill the obligation he knowingly took on at that child's birth. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

so it doesn't behoove a man to accept a child at all.

That's a way to strengthen families. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

The one entitlement that I agree with is that a child is entitled to have their needs met by their parents.

But I don't think that a man should have to pay child support for kids that aren't his. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Laws were made to collect child support because so many men weren't paying what the court ordered them to pay. If every man or woman, paid the child support they were ordered to pay, we wouldn't need the AG's involvement or incentives for the AG to follow the law.

A stand up man claims his children and cares for them even when he's no longer with the mother. 

kidsfan3 --- 14 years ago -

If every man or woman, paid the child support they were ordered to pay, we wouldn't need the AG's involvement or incentives for the AG to follow the law.

A stand up man claims his children and cares for them even when he's no longer with the mother.



THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU!! Well said! 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

If every man or woman, paid the child support they were ordered to pay, we wouldn't need the AG's involvement or incentives for the AG to follow the law.


That is fine but we are talking about men paying for kids that aren't his. I do not care that he signed a paper claiming the child was his. I doubt seriously he knew that kid wasn't his when he signed. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

If you won't take care of your own children, then you aren't a man, period.

I have absolutely no sympathy for people who can leave their own children. 

kidsfan3 --- 14 years ago -

If you won't take care of your own children, then you aren't a man, period.

I have absolutely no sympathy for people who can leave their own children.


DITTO! 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

If you won't take care of your own children, then you aren't a man, period.

If a woman dupes a guy what does that make her? We are talking about kids that do not belong to the guy. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

If a woman dupes a guy what does that make her? We are talking about kids that do not belong to the guy.

To me, that's almost even worse. Of course the man who was duped should not be responsible for payments. That's ludicrous. And the woman needs to have her knees glued together for being so nasty that there is question about who the father was to begin with. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

If a woman dupes a guy what does that make her? We are talking about kids that do not belong to the guy.

To me, that's almost even worse. Of course the man who was duped should not be responsible for payments. That's ludicrous. And the woman needs to have her knees glued together for being so nasty that there is question about who the father was to begin with.




To be honest I think the woman should have to pay the guy back. People are always wanting fairness, this is it. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Yes....but I know men who got with a woman while she was pregnant, knowing that child wasn't his, yet still claimed responsibility for that child.

Those are the men who need to continue paying....

If a man was truly duped and can prove it, then fine, he shouldn't have to pay.

That being said, if this man has or had a relationship with the child, loves the child and the child thinks he is their father, why does he want to walk away and no longer pay child support? Just to spite the mother? That is wrong on many levels...and if there is a father-child bond, genetics shouldn't matter. 

IbarraFam222 --- 14 years ago -

No one made these fathers miss court! Or sign paternity papers! It's Luke signing a contract then deciding it doesn't suit you anymore.

I think the "fathers" that got defaulted by not showing up to court should pay what they owe then prove their not the father and move on without paying anything else.

Otherwise when you acknowledge paternity and go to court and make on oath your the father ( order of entry documents) Then you need to be held accountable. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground