Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Ellis pools

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 2
JDB2 7
AuthorMan 1
Perfection 1
AngieKaye 3
JohnLynch 2
SparkleShine 1
TinktheSprite 5
not a stepford wife 12

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

not a stepford wife --- 14 years ago -

To all you people who think Jeff Ellis pools are the best Kingwood has to offer...think again. Just saw on the news they actually FIRED a lifeguard in Florida for saving someone! I certainly won't be swimming in those pools any more!!! IMO our kids are much safer at the Crystal Pools

ABC News Story  

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

Which community pools are run by Crystal Pools. Are we allowed to "pool-hop"? or stuck with whatever the pool bracelet says? 

not a stepford wife --- 14 years ago -

Crystal has Sandcreek, Foster's Mill, Riverchase, Woodstream, Elm Grove, Sherwood Trails, Kingwood Place, Greentree, South Woodland Hills, Trailwood, maybe more? I think that's most of them. Just avoid those Ellis ones at Mills Branch, Bear Branch, and Hunter's Ridge.

And we've been told that the bracelets are good at most neighborhoods pools. There are a couple neighborhoods that use a key or something but my kids have been able to swim at several pools without any issues 

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

Ok, great. Thanks for the information. I remember that news report. The lifeguard said he would not do anything different. I am sure someone is thankful for him and his skills even though his employer isn't! 

not a stepford wife --- 14 years ago -

I'm glad to help! And yes I completely agree. The whole point of having LIFEguards is to save lives! I'm glad this kid did what he knew was right even if it meant losing his job. And it sounds like he has a lot of support too! 

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

What was he to do? He did his job. People came to him as a lifeguard for help. He did his job whether it was within the boundaries of his company or it. Life-saving will always be his job due to his training no matter where he is. He is a hero. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

IMO our kids are much safer at the Crystal Pools

please explain? Do you or someone you know work for Crystal?

I'm not saying I agree or not, but how would you be safer if your lifeguard at your pool left that pool to help at another pool?

The beach is a little different, I wouldn't have fired the guy, but essentially, he was responsible for covering one area and he left those people unattended. If I were the lifeguard, I'd have helped if I thought it was necessary but I'd have known I was risking lives by doing so. We don't know the entire story either. The lifeguard "attended to" the near drowning victim. Doesn't sound like he was doing CPR or anything like that. Was it necessary? 

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

Even if a beach emergency was within company boundaries as soon as a lifeguard leaves his station, others become at risk. There are limits to what one person can do. The victim was near drowning". Who knows what would have happened had the lifeguard not intervened? 

not a stepford wife --- 14 years ago -

Irrelevant question, but no actually.
I'm well aware that a beach setting is different from a pool setting. And a lifeguard would never leave a pool to help somewhere else because that doesn't make any sense at all. I just believe that someone should not lose their job for attempting to save someone in need of rescue. According to Ellis' website, he too thinks the guard did the right thing and apologized publicly for the way the whole situation was handled!
I know from living in the community and being a frequent pool visitor that Crystal Pools does not treat it's employees in such a way. All the guards seem happy with the way management works. All I was saying is that I don't feel as safe with a company that values following their rules over the safety of the public. Yes, the boy put swimmers in his zone at risk by going to attend to this man- but he seemed to realize the risk he was taking and prevented what could have been a tragedy from happening. It didn't get to CPR or anything more serious BECAUSE the kid acted so fast. It was definitely necessary. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

According to Ellis' website, he too thinks the guard did the right thing and apologized publicly for the way the whole situation was handled!

exactly...they acted too quickly and Ellis believes they made a mistake. They apologized and offered him his job back.

Crystal Pools does not treat it's employees in such a way

I think you are making assumptions. I also personally am not concerned about whether Crystal Pools would have done the same thing if they had beach guards. I care about how they protect my family at the local pools. As you said, it's unlikely a lifeguard would leave the pool to help elsewhere, but that would apply to Ellis guards too.

You are assuming it was necessary and you are assuming that he needed to stay for as long as he did. You are also assuming that nothing could have happened at his post when he left it...how would you feel if your kid had an issue at that post after the guard left? 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

how would you feel if your kid had an issue at that post after the guard left?

i have to make the comment that the lifeguard made sure his post was covered before he left to go and rescue the drowning person 

not a stepford wife --- 14 years ago -

You can "what if" all day long. But the fact is, it's Ellis' company policies that got the lifeguard fired in the first place. Several other lifeguards who supported the lifeguard in question resigned in protest- obviously that means there was a perceived internal problem with the company. He only offered them their jobs back once he started getting negative press and it got attention. If you read the article attached, it states
"Lopez said earlier today that no one from Jeff Ellis Management has contacted him yet regarding the investigation. 'There was someone who was fired before me for saying he wouldn't obey the rule,' said Lopez, of Jeff Ellis Management's policy of only patrolling zones it's paid to cover. 'Now that they're in trouble, they want to fix it.'"

You can say I'm making assumptions all day long but obviously the kid did the right thing- he saved a man and no one in his zone was adversely affected. If I was in that kid's shoes, I would be proud of myself. He was trained to protect the public and keep them safe, and that's what he did. And as for me- I watch my kids attentively when they're swimming, so if a lifeguard went to do his duty and protect the public, I would make sure that I watched my kids more closely. An incident DID NOT occur and that's thanks to the quick thinking of the lifeguard. I know zones are in place for obvious reasons, but are you saying that if you were trained to help someone, you would knowingly abandon them if they were beyond a certain area? That's just inhuman to me. 

not a stepford wife --- 14 years ago -

i have to make the comment that the lifeguard made sure his post was covered before he left to go and rescue the drowning person 

Thank you for pointing that out! Seems like that would make jdb's argument pretty much invalid... 

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

Once a person learns how to save a life i.e. CPR he has an unwritten duty to come to a person's aid. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

but obviously

that is your opinion...and your opinion would be different if your family member suffered as a result of his decision.

and no, I didn't say that I wouldn't do exactly the same thing. I would expect consequences and I would understand that rules usually exist for a reason.

John - the article says his post was not left unattended. That really doesn't address the rules with regards to being fully covered. If the station requires two guards and one leaves, it is still attended, but no sufficiently

not a stepford - here is a quote from the article:

"who attempted to save a drowning man who was 1,500 feet away from the area of the public beach that the contractor patrols. Lifeguards had strict instructions not to venture outside the patrol zone."

Imagine the lawsuits that could have happened under any circumstances...if the guy died, Ellis could and likely would be sued. If anything happened in the zone that was contracted, Ellis would definitely be sued. I would have done the same thing, but the bottom line is that he broke the rules. Ellis is backing down because emotional people are getting upset. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

Once a person learns how to save a life i.e. CPR he has an unwritten duty to come to a person's aid.

you have that duty even if you don't know CPR and this particular incident makes no mention of CPR being necessary. Jeffery Ellis is an attorney. I'd be willing to bet that his rules are pretty well thought out for public safety and for his own.

Anyone that doesn't work or have relatives working for Crystal Pools cannot deny that the Ellis lifeguards are more attentive and more professional. They also are allowed to use some discretion. 

not a stepford wife --- 14 years ago -

I think you're the only one that thinks the kid was in the wrong so enjoy playing devil's advocate. The media all think he's a hero. Jeff Ellis says the lifeguard did the right thing. Anyone with common sense can see that as the kid saved a man who was "coughing up water and turning blue" when he got there, the lifeguard did what was in the best interest of the public. His duty is to protect the lives of the public and that is what he did, without letting boundaries limit that.
I understand that there have to be consequences for breaking rules such as that, but do you really wanna say they handled it as professionally as they could have? Firing a kid for doing the right thing is nonsense to me. And Ellis is embarrassed by it clearly- which is why he's changing his company's policy so that an employee cannot be terminated without the situation being reviewed by HR.

Lawsuits are also completely extraneous to the point. You're pulling at straws and going off of "what if's" as was pointed out before. But actually, Good Samaritan Laws are in place for a reason. People who are trained to save lives are protected from such lawsuits, or else no one would ever help anyone for fear of getting sued!!! Ellis is backing down because HE KNOWS THEY MESSED UP. He says so on his website-
"Our company has always been extremely vigilant in our requirement that lifeguards never leave their post or become distracted from the critical task of scanning the water. On July 2, this vigilance went too far. Firing Tomas Lopez in this context was wrong. Firing other lifeguards who supported Tomas’ decision was also wrong." 

not a stepford wife --- 14 years ago -

Anyone that doesn't work or have relatives working for Crystal Pools cannot deny that the Ellis lifeguards are more attentive and more professional. They also are allowed to use some discretion. 

Are you kidding me? *deleted- keep it civil* American Red Cross trains and certifies each and every lifeguard or they wouldn't be allowed to have that job. Crystal Pools lifeguards have been extremely attentive and professional in every experience I've had with them (I've lived in the community for about 8 years so that would be a great number of experiences). Just because they don't put on a theatrical performance for the public with all the hand signals and stuff Ellis has them doing doesn't mean they aren't attentive!!! It sounds like YOU are the one that either works or has relatives at Ellis pools, jdb. How would you know he's an attorney? 

AngieKaye --- 14 years ago -

I think its more like NSW wants to BOYCOTT Ellis pools.. I know I will from now on! There is no way that people that have no feeling for the safety of others even though they are in the business of keeping people safe.. will never get my business!

Just like if you dont like how you are treated somewhere with the "word of mouth" others will boycott the place too because of your experience.. soon enough either they will change thier ways or leave! 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

The media all think he's a hero

how important is that?

Anyone with common sense can see that as the kid saved a man who was "coughing up water and turning blue" when he got there

what exactly did the lifeguard do?

Firing a kid for doing the right thing is nonsense to me. And Ellis is embarrassed by it clearly- which is why he's changing his company's policy so that an employee cannot be terminated without the situation being reviewed by HR.

I agree that they acted too fast and that firing was probably extreme...but it didn't happen because he did the right thing, it happened because he put others at risk...others that pay for his services...he went into a situation that you assume was necessary.

Are you kidding me? Hahaha you are so ignorant. American Red Cross trains and certifies each and every lifeguard or they wouldn't be allowed to have that job.

there you go with the assumptions again. What do you know about me and my training? What do you know about Crystal Pools or Ellis? Did it occur to you that being trained does not mean too much necessarily. Plenty of people are trained properly but still are less professional than others.

Living in the area doesn't mean anything either. Plenty of people don't even go to the pools. Sounds more like you or someone you care about works for Crystal so you are unable to be objective. By the way, I did work for Crystal Pools a very long time ago...and for the Red Cross...and for the Army.

I know he is an attorney because I was on the board that hired them to replace Crystal Pools. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

There is no way that people that have no feeling for the safety of others even though they are in the business of keeping people safe.. will never get my business!

first, you aren't giving any business to them. The board hires them and whether you go or not has no bearing. Secondly, if you look at this more objectively, the firm was paid to protect one area of the beach. They didn't do that despite having clear instructions to do so...they actually put far more people at risk...the safety of those that were in the covered area.

I would have done the same thing the lifeguard did. I would not have fired the kid if I was his supervisor either. BUT, you guys are making completely emotional comments and are not looking at this from any other perspective. You would if it impacted you. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

and nsw, the "theatrical..." shows your bias. There is far more that goes into a pool contract...I suspect you know that! 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Seems like that would make jdb's argument pretty much invalid... 

not at all...his argument wasn't solely based upon that 

AngieKaye --- 14 years ago -

The board hires them


Then I feel the board needs to fire them ! Send them a message that here we value the safety of EVERYONE! 

AngieKaye --- 14 years ago -

i have to make the comment that the lifeguard made sure his post was covered before he left to go and rescue the drowning person


yeah everyone forgets that part JL 

not a stepford wife --- 14 years ago -

what exactly did the lifeguard do?
The story didn't go into detail on what the boy did to attend to the man so I'm not sure.

Living in the area doesn't mean anything either. Plenty of people don't even go to the pools. Sounds more like you or someone you care about works for Crystal so you are unable to be objective.

My kids go to the pools all summer long. They like several pools in Kingwood so we are frequent travelers, and thus have experience with both companies in question. I would consider myself very objective based on that fact, and as I have previously stated- NO I do not work or have relatives at Crystal Pools! Regardless, I have personally NEVER noticed a difference in the care, attentiveness, or professionalism provided by either company. They are both great at what they do and Kingwood is lucky to have them. But after hearing about the way this incident was handled, it has definitely shown that Ellis has internal issues and is attempting to fix those. For me, I feel safer with a company who doesn't have an incidence of prioritizing following procedures over public safety.

So yes, I am in favor of boycotting the Ellis pools.
Also,
I know he is an attorney because I was on the board that hired them to replace Crystal Pools. 
Seems like you might have a personal problem with Crystal Pools if you got them replaced by Ellis. BIASED! And of course you're a board member!! Hahaha now it all makes sense. *deleted* 

not a stepford wife --- 14 years ago -

and nsw, the "theatrical..." shows your bias. There is far more that goes into a pool contract...I suspect you know that! 

Explain what you even mean? I'm simply referring to the fact that while I'm at Ellis pools they do these hand motions and signals that seem to be a bit exaggerated. Crystal Pools is trained according to American Red Cross standards as I would hope all lifeguards are. As far as I'm concerned, the extra stuff Ellis has them doing is unnecessary and "theatrical" looking. 

SparkleShine --- 14 years ago -

If I were a trained lifeguard......pause so that you can grab your snorkel and protect your loved ones while I delegate cover for my post (which for a beachfront I hope has the manpower) ....I'm swimming with strength beyond measure to save a life. Good riddance to policy and paycheck if that dedication is not acceptable. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Amazing so many others FAILED to assist.

That's the sadness about this story. People there failed to help, people elsewhere over analyze. 

AuthorMan --- 14 years ago -

Amazing so many others FAILED to assist.

The story I heard reported that other swimmers pulled the swimmer in trouble to the shore. That is when the lifeguard showed up. If the swimmer was expelling water, he is showing signs of recovering, and since the lifeguard did not have to perform CPR, there is very little else to do but wait for the medical professionals to show up and take the situation over. 

not a stepford wife --- 14 years ago -

If the swimmer was expelling water, he is showing signs of recovering, and since the lifeguard did not have to perform CPR, there is very little else to do but wait for the medical professionals to show up and take the situation over. 

There was no way for the boy to know whether someone was helping a drowning victim. People came to him and told him someone needed help. He felt called to act based on his training and he did so. And even if the swimmer was "showing signs of recovering", his condition could have changed at any moment- which would require the help of a trained professional.

And it's irrelevant whether or not the boy had to do CPR or anything like that. My concern was based on the fact that this company had a policy of putting their own rules (regardless of circumstance) above the safety of the people 

whatchamacallit --- 14 years ago -

I know MANY of the Ellis lifeguards and they are very well trained. I feel safer at the pools run by Ellis than by Crystal. I have been around guards trained by both and quite honestly the Ellis guards simply are better trained and take their job more seriously than those trained by Crystal. It is a deciding factor for me when choosing which pool to go to as to which company is in charge. When I have small children with me I feel much more relaxed at pools run by Ellis.

There must be some reason why a person would go on a website and try to trash a company that has offered a great service to our community for so long. 

not a stepford wife --- 14 years ago -

Since you say you know them, whatchamacallit, it would seem that your opinion is a little biased. As is that of jdb's who clearly doesn't like Crystal Pools if he was on a board that elected to replace them.

As I said before, both companies do a fine job from my experience. I've never had a complaint about either one until seeing this story on the news. I have never implied that Ellis lifeguards aren't doing a great job. I feel safe bringing my kids to all of the Kingwood pools which is quite a luxury. Ellis' policy is what made me upset, and I would think that would be a concern for most people in the community. THAT is the reason I decided to share. I don't have any ulterior motives as you seem to be hinting 

whatchamacallit --- 14 years ago -

The title of your thread says it all!

Your agenda is clear but your true motive is still a mystery. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground