Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Catholics throw to the wolves - again

who's talking here?

Carla 8
whatchamacallit 1
wayward1 5
Rubicon 1
ghostpost 3
Red Heifer 2
Lillabeth 4
Hiro Protagonist 2
zapper007 3
AwesomeTattooedDragon 3
JohnLynch 20
TexasOma 1
Gigix4 2
Work in Progress 32
LiveFreeOrDie 2
Dorothy Parker 5
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
Pat Barry 1
FluffyPenguin 4
justinCASE 8
a672999uu 24
Edgar Po Wong 1
Insurrection 6
Joker 3
Friday 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

Once again, JL and others have on other threads denied that Catholics are Christians. I know I should “turn the other cheek” however, my baser human failings are in control. I respect your beliefs and your conviction; I wonder why you cannot respect ours. We have a fundamental theological disagreement. We think your core belief in “Sola Scriptura” is incorrect. This has lead to a bit of Catholic bashing on this board by the fundamentalists, the most hurtful is their position that Catholics are not Christians.
The core Catholic belief that causes fundamentalists to deny that Catholics are Christians is we do not believe the Bible alone is the sole source of authority for Christians and the sole source of Christian doctrine. Let me give you some of our arguments.
Firstly, there is nowhere in the 73 books of the Bible where it states that the Bible is totally sufficient for Christians. Now, I know that line will spur a few out of context verses - the most used has already been quoted on other thread s from II Timothy 3:16-17 - however the word used in that quote is “profitable” not sufficient or complete. Catholics make no argument that the bible is not inspired and certainly “profitable or useful” for teaching. The other thing that is interesting about this verse is that it is clear that Saint Paul is reminding Timothy to remember what he learned and from who he learned it, and also to stick to the Scriptures which he “knew from childhood”. Timothy is urged to read the Scriptures which he has known all his life – the New Testament did not exist when Timothy was a child, the only Scriptures were the Jewish Scriptures. So, if this verse shows “sola scriptura” it in fact shows sola Old Testament – the New Testament should be abandoned. But, if we abandoned the New Testament, we wouldn't have this verse – so we wouldn't need to abandon the New Testament.
Another compelling argument was the Catholic Church was the organization who made, quite literally wrote, the Bible and that the Church is older than the Bible. The Bible itself shows that there were Christians before a word of the New Testament was written – the whole of the book of Acts, for example, describes the early life of the Church from the Ascension of Jesus onwards. There is no doubt whatsoever that these people were Christians.
A traditional argument is one I made in a post a while back. The history of the Bible itself, contradicts the concept of “Sola Scriptura” The 7 books of the Bible removed, primarily for doctrinal reason, were as much a part of the bible as any other for 1500 years. They were removed by men. So either the Bible as the entire Christian world knew it for 1500 years was in error, or its Protestant version is incomplete now. There are no other alternative answers.
To continue - If “sola scriptura” is true then it must be possible to read the same passage of the Bible and always get the same conclusion concerning what the appropriate teaching is. There are some teachings in the Bible which are explicit and reasonably clear – for example “Thou shalt not kill” in Deuteronomy 5:17 – but there are many verses which are much less clear. If sola scriptura were true, would not the whole Bible be very clear and easy to understand? Would not the Scriptures be written in plain and simple language, and in fact all be written as a form of Catechism containing many “Thou shalts” and “Thou shalt nots”.
But this is not what we see – Saint Peter himself says that the Bible can be hard to understand in II Peter 3:16. Because different Christians have different interpretations of the Bible it cannot be self authenticating.
The Bible is a book – it is an inspired and holy book, but it is still a book. Books are made up of words, not meanings. A meaning only exists when an intelligent, thinking being reads the words and interprets what they might mean. When we ask someone “What does the book say?” we do not always want them to simply quote the words to us – we want them to tell us what the words mean. That is a person's interpretation. If we are not given a person's interpretation, we have to provide our own – or choose someone else's. We have no way of reading a book without an interpretation – it is just impossible.
Catholic’s believe that the Bible needs to be understood in the context it was written, and for the understanding of the audience it was written for. So even though God knew of the wonder and beauty of the evolution of the universe “ in the beginning” however it took man, with the divine gift of reason, about 1900 years to understand it, ALMOST.
And before you condemn the Religion as being non-Christian, and thankfully in your minds only, as not worthy of the gift of salvation you may want to remember the thousands upon thousands of Catholic Martyrs that gave their lives in the name of Christ. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Why do you keep obliterating and coming back as "new" posters? 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

not sure - not that savy - just type and hit the button - mea culpa if that is wrong 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

It seems like you get mad and obliterate a couple of times a week. Then you come back to fight again. Why? 

Edgar Po Wong --- 14 years ago -

0 

Friday --- 14 years ago -

Christian - to be Christ like follow his steps.

We all are hypocrites all sin all think evil thoughts. That is the natural state of man. I have met Catholics i thought were saved. Just because your a certain denomination doesn't mean your going to heaven.

Many like me disagree with the Catholics on one premise. A man here on earth is not closer to God than a man who doesn't even acknowledge God. A group of sinners can not promote a person to sainthood that's the job of God.

There are two observances Jesus preformed
Baptism - Immersion to show the old man dead and the new man arising. Just as God will call his people when he decides too.

The Lords supper- Just as everyone tore up Jesus on the cross and spilled his blood. You remember that we all did it. Just like people claim there is no God because you cant see him. If Jesus came as a lamb again he would be tortured again.

A true Christian would not say another person is not a Christian. I don't know your heart. We have to remember where Jesus walked. He walked and talked straight with sinners. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

@ a3937500uu... One question, what must one do to be a Christian? 

Friday --- 14 years ago -

Christian - to be Christ like follow his steps. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

For the OP, I didn't even realize that you are Catholic, but that's interesting. Do your statements reflect what is being taught in your particular church?

I know that you have not identified yourself with the emergent movement, but I believe that they may have identified themselves with you. There is a big movement within prostestant churches right now that IS in the direction of Catholicism. It's all a part of the ecumenical movement.

But if you will oblige me, I'd like to try to pinpoint your beliefs for my own understanding of your view.

1. Do you believe that there is any other way to God than through Jesus Christ? Meaning, could people from other religions still be in communion with the true God?

2. Would you say that God is more concerned with your intent, rather than your actual practice of the faith. Meaning, could you substitute practices from other religions as long as your intent was to honor God, and would God accept that practice?

3. Do you think that Christians have the responsibility of ushering in the Kingdom of God through social justice and charity? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I think you'd be much better off to just let this go..I say it for your sanity sake.

Sometimes I read all this stuff and I'm utterly amazed at ONE THING...that we can't accept each others differences in peace. We WANT to force the other person to believe what we believe..deep down inside that is what lots of people do, not all, but I think the majority do. We SAY we want to debate, but that's not what usually happens. From what I see many just want to disprove what someone else wants to believe..

Catholics ARE Christians, end of story. BUT they and the rest of main stream christianity have differing beliefs..And if you want to play this whole thing safe, you can say what really is true: there are true believers and fakes in all denominations.

If you want to try and convince the folks who believe that Catholics aren't Christians that they are wrong, it will be an exercise in futility, nothing more. Trying to disprove what someone chooses to believe is useless. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Christian - to be Christ like follow his steps.

Specifically he told us one step to be born again, do you know what that step was? 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

It seems like you get mad and obliterate a couple of times a week. Then you come back to fight again. Why?

Busy, retoric didn't reach my level for action, didn't look at the board, probably a few other reasons as well.

Just every now and then I get the motivation to post 

whatchamacallit --- 14 years ago -

Don't let others with their opinions try to define you, only you and God know who and what you are. 

Friday --- 14 years ago -

a672999uu --- 4 min ago - quote - hide comments

You are who you are. If anyone wants to judge you tell them to remove the beam from their eye.

I myself don't beleive in hierarchy's. No man is closer to God than he is just as much a sinner. 

wayward1 --- 14 years ago -

'Catholics thrown to the lions' would have made a better headline. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

OP, I am definitely a sola scriptura girl. The problem with going away from that, is discernment. How can you discern what is of God, and what isn't?

There ARE other spiritual forces at work. We're supposed to test those spirits with scripture.

And I could point you to some videos that speak about catholicism, but they are pretty much guaranteed to tick you off. And they will come from the angle of sola scriptura. If you want to see them, even for the expressed purpose of debunking them, I will PM them to you. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

'Catholics thrown to the lions' would have made a better headline.

Ok Nero! 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

WIP - thanks, I am Catholic. As for your questions - I believe actions lead more to salvation than words or professions of any ideology. I believe being Christ like in action will be more important than any public proclamation of re-birth. It is not a Catholic belief to try and understand or determine if your denomination allows or prevents salvation. We believe God is infinitely perfect and His is the only judgment, and we have Faith it will be perfect. Catholics are missionary, we belief our faith is the one true faith. We have a responsibility to convert non-believers; however I have never seen any Catholic teaching in the last couple of hundred years that condemns non-believers.
SSG – thanks your post – true words of wisdom. Just occasionally I like to charge the windmill. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I believe actions lead more to salvation than words or professions of any ideology.

So you believe that we are saved through works, not faith? 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

And here is another question:

Do you believe in Satan? If so, then how can you tell the difference between his lies and God's truth? 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Who said Catholics aren't Christian? 

Friday --- 14 years ago -

I believe actions lead more to salvation than words or professions of any ideology. I believe being Christ like in action will be more important than any public proclamation of re-birth.

Then you believe more in Catholicism than Jesus?

Lets remember who Jesus rebuked more.The Pharisees and Sadducee They were " the holiest of holy on earth". They also were instrumental in his crucifixion.

Who on earth claims to be closer to God than everyone else? That's where the problems arrive. Again I have met Catholic's I thought were saved. 

ghostpost --- 14 years ago -

Why do you keep obliterating and coming back as "new" posters?

What am I missing? What are you referring to and how do you know who this is? 

zapper007 --- 14 years ago -

I feel really sorry for people who cannot let others live with their own personal beliefs.

Tey must be lacking in self confidence. By bashing others religious, sexual, or political beliefs - they are simply are attempting to elevate themselves...jmho 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I'm up for the discussion if you want to have it. But it's bound to get people fired up. I'm cool with it if you are.

I do have some serious reservations about the Catholic denomination. I have no problem with the PEOPLE, just the teachings:

1. The veneration of the Virgin Mary. This is reminiscient of the pagan goddess cults that were rampant throughout Europe. When the Church moved into those areas, they allowed them to keep practicing their traditions of worshipping their goddess, but they renamed her "Mary" for good measure. She was also considered a perpetual virgin, even though this is unbiblical, because the pagan cult worshipped a "virgin" goddess.

2. Praying to Saints. This again, was a result of moving into areas where the people were worshipping other gods. They wanted to keep up their practices, so the Catholic Church just "Christianized" them. Keep worshipping the god of fertility, but call him the name of a Saint, so that it is appropriately "catholic." 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Reading the quote regarding actions before words, when it comes to being a Christian is absolutely true. I would think god wants more than lip service and dramatic public displays like the fall riot stuff... 

ghostpost --- 14 years ago -

Who cares what someone on a message board thinks about your faith? That is why it is called "faith", it is your personal belief.

Yes, I know there are some rude and condescending posters that stand on the pulpit and preach on KU but most on here do not pay any attention to that type of poster anyway. There are also some very thoughtful and wise posters. If you are going to read religious or political threads, you will come across both types and everything in between.

Take what you can from those that inspire you and move on. A forum like this attracts all kinds. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

3. Belief that we are saved through works. How can you ever be assured of your salvation? Why did Christ have to die on the cross if we could be "good" enough to reach heaven? Was God a sadist? NO! He was our atonement! He died in our place, taking our punishment. My works are as filthy rags to God. My mind and heart can be terrible places. But Christ died so that I can be made Holy and righteous before the Father. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

4. The idea that God reveals Himself through sources outside of the Bible.

That's somewhat true, because of prayer. However, we are supposed to TEST EVERYTHING with scripture. The Bible details a spiritual realm filled with fallen angels who masquerade as angels of light. How, outside of scripture, can we tell the difference? How do we know what is from God, and what's from the other side, unless God has revealed exactly who He is through His word for us? 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

WIP - I don't see Works and Faith as dichotomous. I have faith that this is God’s judgment, and I have Faith His judgment will be perfect. However, I am not sure that we have the same definition of Faith - I read yours as more a “church” or “sect” or collection of beliefs. If I am correct in this interpretation, than yes – I believe actions are more important than that definition of faith.
Harder question – how to tell the difference between Satan’s lies and God’s truth - Prayer ( yes – even us heathen Catholics pray)
A3 – How do you measure what you believe in more. Is there a belief scale or ruler? The entire Catholic religion was founded on the core believe that Jesus is God. There are, and have been events and issues – where the Church and its leadership have been un-Godly . The curse of being human. The reason that the Church has survived these event s, is the answer to your question. In all those cases, the people of the Church have always chosen Jesus. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

No one said they were saved through works...they said actions with regard to being Christian is more important than just saying you've "accepted Jesus"...another way to say it would be to say "walk the walk"... 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

DP, I will agree with you that faith without works is dead. If you truly love Christ, then you WILL love the people he came to save, period. If you are not doing those works, then you probably don't know Christ. The Bible certainly affirms this. It's just like marriage. If you truly love your husband (and the Church is the bride of Christ), then you will do the things that are important to him, just because you love him. People are important to Christ, so people should be important to Christians.

However, it is not our works that give us salvation. We cannot earn our way to heaven, because no matter what, we are still sinful beings. Our good deeds are NOTHING compared with the awesome righteousness of God. We MUST be covered in the cleansing blood of the ultimate sacrifice--Jesus Christ to stand before God.

But we are in agreement that Christians should "walk the walk." 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

There are, and have been events and issues – where the Church and its leadership have been un-Godly .

Yes. As is always the case with humans trying to follow a religion. However, those abuses (inquisition, Crusades, selling of indulgences, etc) happened because they did not rely on scripture!!!! These things were handed down by the church leaders! If they had been tested with scripture, then they wouldn't have happpened! 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

like the fall riot stuff...

For clarification, do you mean the Occupy Wallstreet thing? 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Catholics ARE Christians, end of story.

nope...not true...just as all Methodists, Baptists, Lutherans, etc. are not Christians...being Catholic doesn't make you a Christian

Who cares what someone on a message board thinks about your faith? That is why it is called "faith", it is your personal belief.

faith (in the context of belief in God) is a gift from God...it isn't your personal belief... 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

WIP - firstly - I enjoy the discussion - Hope it stirs us both to be a little bit better of a person -

Points 1 & 2 - Think the issue with these to non-Catholics is that in their mind it approaches worshiping false gods. To Catholics it is not even close. We revere and praise Mary and the Saints, but they are not God. Never really saw it as that big an issue - but appreciate that it is to many non-Catholics.
point 3 - that position always sounded to me like the fundamentalists were looking for some guarantee. Kind of like the golden ticket to heaven. Catholic believe is that we are all sinners. We have faith that if we live a good life in Christ, are truly repented for our sins we will be saved. Big difference - we have Faith in God and his judgment - so yes – it is about what you do – not what you say – sorry.
Point 4 - God reveals Himself outside the Bible to me every time I look in my children’s eyes. And there is Jesuit saying that I kind of like - Jesuits are trained to see God in all things - What could be wrong in that. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

And I can't let it go, sorry. Once I get all fired up, I have to go full steam ahead. ..

The Bible prophecies that many will come in Christ's name teaching a different gospel. If you aren't sola scriptura, then how do you tell the difference? How can know who the REAL Christ is, except through His revealed Word? Because there are A LOT of people out there preaching crazy in the name of "god." Look up De Jesus, Maitreya, Benjamin Creme. . .there are a lot of freaks out there. 

Friday --- 14 years ago -

I am one of those JL listed I am not offended. My denomination does not make me. My walk with God makes me. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Jesuits are trained to see God in all things - What could be wrong in that.

Because that's pantheism! It's not Christianity! 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I am one of those JL listed I am not offended. My denomination does not make me. My walk with God makes me.

I think that was JL's point. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground