Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Not looking good for ObamaCare

who's talking here?

JDB2 1
randyjet 4
wayward1 1
SoupIsGoodFood 2
Porter Wagoner 1
Red Heifer 1
ExLady In Blue 1
Perfection 1
zapper007 1
truthmiser 1
Dr Aborto 4
TheMasticator 5
LiveFreeOrDie 6
justforfun1 1
Pat Barry 3
stephensmith 5
eremartin1 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Justice Kennedy, largely viewed as the swing vote in the case. said Tuesday the government has a “very heavy burden of justification” to show where the Constitution authorizes the Congress to change the relation of individuals to the government.

Here’s how it went down, according to reporting by WSJ reporters Louise Radnofsky and Brent Kendall: Solicitor General Donald Verrilli was defending the law before the justices, arguing that Congress was regulating the health-care market in which people were already participating, rather than breaking new ground by forcing them to buy a product.

Justice Kennedy pushed Verrilli on this front, asking whether the same reasoning could apply to food. The justice asked what limits, if any, there would be to government powers under his argument.



It was a good day in court today.. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

I will dance a gay jig once the 5 overturn it....

Until then, I remain skeptical. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Until then, I remain skeptical.

Understandable.. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

As is usual in these things (because it is a Progressive agenda item) the SCOTUS will parse it's decision and only strike down a portion of the law instead of the whole thing.....

Pleasing nobody and proving once again that SCOTUS has no courage to defend the Constitution. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

I will dance a gay jig once the 5 overturn it....

Until then, I remain skeptical.




Me too. I see some arm bending for Kennedy coming to get him to side with Bo. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

As is usual in these things (because it is a Progressive agenda item) the SCOTUS will parse it's decision and only strike down a portion of the law instead of the whole thing.....


My understanding is without the individual mandate the whole thing will fold under it's own weight..


Me too. I see some arm bending for Kennedy coming to get him to side with Bo.


I have never heard of any arm bending when it comes to SCOTUS, congress yes but not scotus.. I could be wrong tho.. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Justice Samuel Alito:

"suppose that you and I walked around downtown Washington at lunch hour and we found a couple of healthy young people , and we stopped them and we said 'you know what you are doing? You are financing you burial services right now because eventually you're going to have to pay for it, and if you don't have burial insurance , or you haven't saved money for it, you're going to shift the cost to somebody else'"

Solicitor General Verrilli:

" I think it's completely different"


Justice Samuel Alito:

"well I don't see the difference. You can get burial insurance , you can get health insurance. Most people are going to need health care, almost everybody.
Everybody is going to be buried or cremated at some point."




Another very good point made by SCOTUS..

Things are looking up..

Well unless your Obama. 

Porter Wagoner (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I will dance a gay jig once the 5 overturn it....


Will that be in leather, buttless chaps? 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

Will that be in leather, buttless chaps?

If that is what it takes to defend the Constitution, then, yes.... but I warn you, it will not be as titillating as it sounds.... 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

No real surprises. Everyone knew it was going to be 4 against 5. Interesting yesterday that Justice Roberts defended the mandate in a couple instances playing devil's advocate. We'll see. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

If the mandate is struck down, so goes the Progressive dream of Single Payer as well... 

eremartin1 --- 14 years ago -

Personally I don't like any bill that tells me I have to buy anything from the government. If I want to that's one thing have to just grates against my grain and today's youth and this so called movement started on Wall Street and what I have heard is their platform and what they want sounds like Communism to me. What's next .... what you want 4 more families to live in my 5 bedroom house that I bought and paid for out of my back pocket and they don't pay nothing?
It is my understanding that the clause that is in every bill passed by Congress concerning that if one part of the bill is held unconstitutional the rest of the bill stands is missing so if this goes down it all goes down. 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

If the mandate is struck down, so goes the Progressive dream of Single Payer as well... 

If you put it that way, then it should be passed and perfectly constitutionally legal. We are forced to pay an unemployment tax and social security when someone like me, may never actually need it. I'm just saying. 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

Personally I don't like any bill that tells me I have to buy anything from the government.

You obviously don't understand it. You're not buying anything FROM the Gov. You have to have insurance, provided by private organizations.

I also like how you are comparing this to communism. You do realize that England, Canada, Italy, France and Germany have socialized medicine which is way more government involved than the Affordable Health Care Act. Last I checked, those countries are not Communist Regimes. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

If the mandate is struck down, so goes the Progressive dream of Single Payer as well...


Naaaa it just means next time they will go full bore single payer government run system payed for by the tax system. 

eremartin1 --- 14 years ago -

Yeah I am buying insurance from a government backed company that in essence is government.... and they decide if I am viable to save and that when I turn 70 I am no longer a person I am a unit number and so if the cost of saving my life is too expensive then after all I am 70 so my usefulness to society is done so I don't need treatment cause I am not worth saving.
As for socialized medicine - Yeah look at how many come to the US for treatment because they can't take the time to wait until they can be accepted into a hospital for treatment. I had a friend die in England with congestive heart failure because she was told that no one even a hospital could take her in for a month. I had another friend who's sister died of pneumonia while waiting to get a doctors appointment and was told on the phone that she was not ill enough for a work in. 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

England with congestive heart failure because she was told that no one even a hospital could take her in for a month. I had another friend who's sister died of pneumonia while waiting to get a doctors appointment

Same can be said about US hospitals and doctors. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

Same can be said about US hospitals and doctors.

Lies said here do not lend you credibility on other topics to which you may post. 

wayward1 --- 14 years ago -

Naaaa it just means next time they will go full bore single payer government run system payed for by the tax system. 

I think this is spot on. Probably how it will play out next time. 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

I listened to the two days of arguments. Kennedy didn't tip his hand. Pushed his questions in both directions. This is going to be interesting. It would be very interesting to see what the Republicans come up with as a real alternative. 

stephensmith --- 14 years ago -

I also like how you are comparing this to communism. You do realize that England, Canada, Italy, France and Germany have socialized medicine which is way more government involved than the Affordable Health Care Act. Last I checked, those countries are not Communist Regimes.

Just because France, the UK and Canada don't use the term communism as a desacriptor for their healthcare programs, doesn't mean it's not. There are many definitions of the word communism, and on a scale, none of those countries are communist to the degree that Cuba is, or the USSR was. Regardless, their healthcare programs would be better described as communized medicine over socialized medicine, based on the accepted definition below. . Any step our government takes in the direction of communism or socialism (communism light) is not a step I condone.

Communism: a theory or system of social organization based on the holding of all property in common, actual ownership being ascribed to the community as a whole or to the state.

Stretching the definition a little, one could make the argument that we may even be considered communist as ultimately, the "state" can exercise emminent domain and individual property rights and freedoms (i.e. patriot act) are subordinate to the collective "good". 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

listened to the two days of arguments. Kennedy didn't tip his hand. Pushed his questions in both directions. This is going to be interesting. It would be very interesting to see what the Republicans come up with as a real alternative.

This WAS their alternative to Hillary care. They forgot that though when the black guy took over.

You know...when the main goal was to topple a presidency.

Losers. 

stephensmith --- 14 years ago -

This WAS their alternative to Hillary care. They forgot that though when the black guy took over.

You know...when the main goal was to topple a presidency.

Losers.


Seriously? Couldn't just be about policy, you've got to make it about race... And we wonder why we continue to see racial distress in our society. Don't be a biggot... 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

Don't be a biggot...

A what? 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

Couldn't just be about policy, you've got to make it about race

Did I really. Is it a fact that the President is black? YES

Is it a fact that the GOP became raging "make this president fail" proponents? YES.

Is it a fact he's called a Muslim? A terrorist? An indonesian and an African? YES

Who injected race and exclusion? 

stephensmith --- 14 years ago -

Did I really. Is it a fact that the President is black? YES

Is it a fact that the GOP became raging "make this president fail" proponents? YES.

Is it a fact he's called a Muslim? A terrorist? An indonesian and an African? YES

Who injected race and exclusion?


I don't personally equate the terms Muslim, Terrorist, Indonesian, African (there are a lot of white persons there as well) and a desire to see poor policies fail with being "black".

You shouldn't make such stereotypes.

Take Hermann Cain for example; he's black. Are you saying he's african, indonesian, a terrorist? That would be an inappropriate supposition simply because he's black. Shame on you for profiling him as such simply because he's black. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

TheMasticator --- 1 days ago - edit - quote - put user in the ice box - put user in the ice box and remove recent comments - hide comments

As is usual in these things (because it is a Progressive agenda item) the SCOTUS will parse it's decision and only strike down a portion of the law instead of the whole thing....



-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------




Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy, regarded as the swing-vote in the Obamacare hearing, disagreed with his more liberal colleague, Justice Sonia Sotomayor, when she was making an argument against overturning the entire health care bill.

The disagreement hinged on the question of what would be a greater act of judicial activism: overturning all of Obamacare, or simply overturning the individual mandate and leaving the rest of the law in place.

"Why don't we let Congress fix it?"
Sotomayor asked, referring to what would remain of Obamacare without the individual mandate. When Justice Antonin Scalia and attorney Paul Clement suggested that "legislative inertia" would impede that process, Sotomayor suggested that a full repeal would amount to judicial activism. "Are you suggesting that we should take on more power to the Court?" she interjected. "Because Congress would choose to take one path rather than another. That's sort of taking onto the Court more power than one I think would want."

When Deputy Solicitor General Edwin Kneedler repeated that idea later in the oral argument, Kennedy rejected the position. "When you say judicial restraint, you are echoing the earlier premise that it increases the judicial power if the judiciary strikes down other provisions of the Act," Kennedy said, before continuing his counterargument:

"I suggest to you it might be quite the opposite. We would be exercising the judicial power if one Act was -- one provision was stricken and the others remained to impose a risk on insurance companies that Congress had never intended. By reason of this Court, we would have a new regime that Congress did not provide for, did not consider. That, it seems to me, can be argued at least to be a more extreme exercise of judicial power than to strike -- than striking down the whole."


It can be dangerous to read too much into a justice's comments during oral arguments, but that line of reasoning suggests that the swing voter on this case -- who expressed deep skepticism about the individual mandate yesterday -- leans toward overturning the entire law in the event that the mandate is found to be unconstitutional. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

Couldn't just be about policy, you've got to make it about race

It's ALWAYS about race with textual.

It' only shows how weak his argument is on almost every thread.

Reminds me of allday and/or evolved. A lot. 

stephensmith --- 14 years ago -

It's ALWAYS about race with textual.

That saddens me. With all of the collaborative effort that went into the civil rights movement, and how many people were persecuted for their beliefs that race, religion and gender should not be characteristics by which a person should discriminate... all that effort and you've got a racist running around kingwood underground trampling on and undermining those sacrifices... terrible. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

I wonder if anyone has finished reading it yet... 

zapper007 --- 14 years ago -

His approval ratings are at a new high...

Get a life pubs!

Many people on KU are caught up in sterotype he!!...

Obama is just as white as he is black - he's actaully an AMERICAN... 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

His approval ratings are at a new high...

For the day?

Because he's still not averaging over 50% 

truthmiser --- 14 years ago -

His approval ratings are at a new high..

You must be on de conji mon! 

randyjet --- 14 years ago -

the SCOTUS will parse it's decision and only strike down a portion of the law instead of the whole thing.....

That is ONLY true IF they had inserted a severability clause into the law. My attorney, Prof. Turley addressed that to Pelosi when the bill was being passed. Either she could not do anything about it at the time or she screwed up. The SCOTUS has no choice but to strike the whole law as it is written. 

randyjet --- 14 years ago -

I am very concerned about this because it means my wife will LOSE her health insurance and she cannot get it with her pre-existing conditions. THANKS GOPers! 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

She can get Texas Risk Pool and you know it randyjet, you choose not to.

Yes it cost more, it is what obama care is based on. High risk people buying insurance which means more payments going out for more usage.

However you want cheap insurance that covers high expenses. Sorry other people are not going to subsidize that 

stephensmith --- 14 years ago -

Zapper007: "Obama is just as white as he is black"

I'm really tired of the bigotry on this post. Being black doesn't make him stupid. And I'm appauled that you would even make that suggesstion. Every time someobody doesn't like something obama does, I see people say that it's because he's black. Why do you equate negative stereotyes with black folks?

Obama's policies have nothing to do with his race, they have to do with his unamerican agenda. There is some serious racial profiling on this site, and the irony is that it seems to come from several of the same people who believe that "profiling" is wrong, based upon their quotes on the trayvon martin case. Principles people, principles... 

randyjet --- 14 years ago -

She can get Texas Risk Pool and you know it randyjet, you choose not to.

I already checked into that and by law the rates are set to FIVE times the normal rates for health insurance. If I could afford that, I would have NO NEED for insurance dummy! The current Federal insurance is NOT subsidized by anybody! I pay the full premiums and the difference is that it is run by the government agency and requires NO multi million dollar salaries for the execs. Right now the premiums are at $420/mo with a $2,500 deductible for one person. 

randyjet --- 14 years ago -

However you want cheap insurance that covers high expenses. Sorry other people are not going to subsidize that

So I should subsidize YOUR cheaper rates then? By kicking her out of the pool that makes it cheaper for you and she gets NOTHING! Thanks, but that arrangement goes against the whole idea of insurance. Hell, it would be even cheaper if the insurance company could kick you out after you get sick. 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

randyjet --- 10 hours ago - quote - hide comments

THANKS GOPers!


No, I believe you have that wrong! You should say, "Thanks, Nobama for shoving through something that was not thought out in relationship to our Constitution. Thank you for rushing to push through something that was a piece of excrement from the beginning."

In other words, LAY THE BLAME WHERE IT BELONGS! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground