Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Should Alcoholics Get Liver Transplants?

who's talking here?

Jpgirl 1
voice of reason 1
tinman 1
RedMulch 4
Tipsyhic 1
Aah Grasshoppa 1
BlabberMouth 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 2
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
Dorothy Parker 2
crazypinetrees 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 4
SailorTattoos 2
Eros 2
rednecktek 1
momof6monkeys 1
Freckles00 5
PHSSPARTANMOM 1
sheddy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

CHICAGO (AP) —"Some gravely ill alcoholics who need a liver transplant shouldn't have to prove they can stay sober for six months to get one, doctors say in a study that could intensify the debate over whether those who destroy their organs by drinking deserve new ones.

In the small French study, the vast majority of the patients who got a liver without the wait stopped drinking after their surgery and were sober years later. The study involved patients who were suffering from alcohol-related hepatitis so severe that they were unlikely to survive a six-month delay.

The findings, reported in Thursday's New England Journal of Medicine, could boost demand for livers, already in scarce supply, and reopen a bitter dispute over whether alcoholics should even get transplants.

The controversy peaked in the 1990s when celebrities with drinking problems — Larry Hagman, David Crosby and Mickey Mantle — got liver transplants. More recently, British soccer star George Best received a new liver in 2002, started drinking again and died three years later.

Alcohol can cause lethal, liver-destroying diseases such as cirrhosis and hepatitis. Nearly one in five liver transplants in the U.S. go to current or former heavy drinkers. Transplant hospitals commonly require patients waiting for a new liver to give up drinking for six months as a way of assuring doctors they are serious about staying sober after the operation.

Drinkers severely ill with hepatitis account for a very small share of patients needing transplants. The French study suggests that dropping the six-month rule for these patients would increase demand for livers by only about 3 percent.

The study's lead author, Dr. Philippe Mathurin of Huriez Hospital in Lille, France, said a strict application of the six-month rule may be unfair to such patients. He said they are just as deserving as other liver patients, many of whom have diseases caused by poor lifestyle choices such as drug use or obesity."


Can't help it, my first instinct is to say no...but... 

PHSSPARTANMOM --- 15 years ago -

Being an Alcoholic is a life long thing.

Everyone deserves a 2nd chance. 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

That's tough...

I do believe that everyone deserves a 2nd chance at life but if they get the liver and destroy it with more drinking... someone else could have been saved.

They should at the very least have to have gone through AA before getting the transplant. 

momof6monkeys --- 15 years ago -

AA or any other program only works when you choose for it to work. My ex husband cleaned out all the beer cans out of the back of his truck when he would leave to go to a meeting. Nothing works unless you want it to. Its ALL pointless including a transplant unless they have the desire, want to and deturmination to follow through with quiting. 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

so your point is that they are worthless and should be left to die. so very nice of you. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

That's a difficult question due to the fact that there are probably a lot of people on the wait list for a liver. . .right? So the dilemma is that you could give it to an alcoholic who might destroy it again, or give it to someone with a disease that is no fault of their own and wouldn't destroy it again?

But I think that transplants only last about 10 years anyway. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

No, I don't think they should receive one.


Someone dying of liver disease through no fault of their own, should be given a transplant before someone who willingly destroyed their liver through alcoholism.

If that sounds cold, so be it. I have zero tolerance when it comes to alcoholics. They want to drink themselves to death? So be it and good riddance. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Here is another stat: "Nearly 6,300 liver transplants were performed last year in the United States, but more than 1,400 Americans died waiting for a new liver, according to the United Network for Organ Sharing. Adding more people to the list could mean longer waits and more deaths among non-drinkers."


Having known someone who's 8 year old died waiting for a liver transplant, thinking it might have gone to someone who destroyed their own liver with alcohol, just makes you ponder the whole thing. I would like for ALL of the candidates to get a liver if they need one, but there isn't enogh to go around. Hence, the dilemma of considering a way to prioritze candidates... 

tinman --- 15 years ago -

My family has been after me for years to be an organ donor and I flatly refuse to do it.

Here is the reason I give them.

I have zero control over who gets what. I am not interested in my heart going to a child molestor.

How would my family feel if my liver went to someone who ended up driving drunk and killing a family.

I know that the process is supposed to be anonymous, but in this instance, there should be a way to have some oversight over the final dispensation of the organs.

Absent that, I just can't see how, in good conscience, people can give away the gift of life like that without assurances that the person getting that gift is truly deserving.

I'm probably going to get roasted for that opinion, but that's ok too. 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

I'm probably going to get roasted for that opinion, but that's ok too.

Actually, tinman that's a good point. I am an organ donor but I haven't really thought about "what if my death saves a child molester's life"...

I'm still going to donate my organs though... I'm willing to take the chance in order to possibly save a someone good. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Absent that, I just can't see how, in good conscience, people can give away the gift of life like that without assurances that the person getting that gift is truly deserving.


That's the problem, WHO is deserving and by what standard? I think kids should get bumped to the top of the list on first thoughts. But if it was my sick father waiting (who wasn't a drinker), I might feel different... 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

kids should get bumped to the top of the list on first thoughts

I'm not so sure about that...In my opinion, obviously children should be a priority but I think single parents or people who have people who rely solely on them as the breadwinner... if they die while on the list then it not only impacts their family emotionally but in many other ways. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I'm not so sure about that...In my opinion, obviously children should be a priority but I think single parents or people who have people who rely solely on them as the breadwinner... if they die while on the list then it not only impacts their family emotionally but in many other ways.


Very good points, Freckles. A mom or dad who has kids to take care of and that depend on them is a big deal. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

No, I don't think they should receive one.


Someone dying of liver disease through no fault of their own, should be given a transplant before someone who willingly destroyed their liver through alcoholism.

If that sounds cold, so be it. I have zero tolerance when it comes to alcoholics. They want to drink themselves to death? So be it and good riddance.



I actually agree 100% with this with one exception. The only way I agree is if there is no one else that is a match in this country and the organ will be wasted. If that is the case then they can have it provided they are not still drinking. The liver is unique in that they can take a piece of a liver to transplant and it will regenerate itself.

I am an organ donor and I have a pact with my organs they are to shut down immediately if they are transplanted into a undeserving person.:) 

sheddy --- 15 years ago -

If someone is so sick that they need a transplant and won't quit drinking, then no I don't think they deserve one. Their illness didn't happen overnight. I'm sure they were told repeatedly to stop and continued. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 15 years ago -

from what i know about organ donations.. ( i have a friend who had one) is for a liver you cannot drink for a certain time before and if you do you can be removed off the transplant list.. that being said being an alcoholic is a life long batter as stated before.. i lived with one for 5 yrs before i had to send him packing.. he hit rock bottom ( homeless living in the woods and stealing) but has changed his life around and is sober ( to my understanding) he is a good man when he is sober.. but as a drunk he is a piece of .... but i would want to see him die because of a problem he fights with all the time..

and AA is only for those who want to do it.. you cant force someone to quit no more than you can force an obese person to loose weight when they have diabetes or a smoker to quit when they get sick.. it is a disease and hard to fight unless you want to. 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

I am an organ donor and I have a pact with my organs they are to shut down immediately if they are transplanted into a undeserving person.:)

hahaha :] 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

and AA is only for those who want to do it.

What i meant by going to AA is that they went themselves... not forcing them to go. I agree it doesn't work unless you want to get better. And even completing the program doesn't guarantee anything.

has changed his life around and is sober ( to my understanding) he is a good man when he is sober.

See this is why it's difficult as I feel everyone has the ability to change and some do change... but will never get the chance if they die. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 15 years ago -

Oh and i am all about organ donations.. i am one proudly.. watching my friend go through dialasis and my father too i belive in it strongly.. my father was and we found out how many people his eyes helped and it was very overwhelming.. i am not using my body parts when i am gone so if someone else can use them i would be happy to give them to them 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I actually agree 100% with this with one exception. The only way I agree is if there is no one else that is a match in this country and the organ will be wasted.


Is that even a possibility, though? I bet they could find a non alcoholic match for every liver donation they have...

I don't think you should even be on a list for a transplant if drinking is what killed your liver in the first place.

Especially considering the way alcoholism works, it IS a lifelong issue, and odds are, they'll hit the bottle again when times get tough.

I have little to no sympathy for alcoholics, can you tell? Especially the violent ones...screw them....they don't deserve to live, imo. 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

they should if they want to keep drinking...... (lol/j/k) 

SailorTattoos --- 15 years ago -

An alcoholic should not be granted such kindness, a fully recovered and healed alcoholic? Maybe. My boyfriend is 29 and waiting on a kidney transplant, he has been on dialysis for 3 years. He had made sure to be responsible and take care of himself so he has the best chance at a successful transplant and he wil be responsid after receiving one because he appreciates and understands how precious the gift of life is. I would be outraged if someone like an alcohol got a transplant before he did. 

SailorTattoos --- 15 years ago -

Wow major typo-age from my phone. Anyway, I've watched my boyfriend suffer enough, he is responsible, he deserves a transplant, not an alcoholic. That's terrible. 

Aah Grasshoppa --- 15 years ago -

No. 

Tipsyhic --- 15 years ago -

NO: I think they should get gin IV's instead. 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

NO: I think they should get gin IV's instead.


i wish i had thought of that comment..... 

Eros --- 15 years ago -

So, can someone get a liver transplant FROM an alcoholic?

If so, then maybe I could hold my booze.

I'm a lightweight. 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

If so, then maybe I could hold my booze.

I'm a lightweight.



Practice makes perfect.......... 

Eros --- 15 years ago -


Practice makes perfect..........


That's what she said. 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

My true opinion before i retire for the evening......

I think everyone should be an organ donor....and in the end, God is in control of what works and what does not work out...... 

Jpgirl --- 15 years ago -

I know a bit about organ donation and children. My son was born with a liver problem and there was talk of getting him on the transplant list. The reason children can't get bumped to the top of the list is not only does the liver have to be a match In blood /tissue type ect- it has to be relatively the same size to fit into the cavity- thus you can't take an adult liver and put into a child's body. With my son a newborn's liver would not have fit. It's extremely hard to find a match but especially in children. That holds true for most organs. A large man's heart probably won't fit in a tiny woman's chest. Not finding a match -and there are so many factors that go into a match-is why so many people die on the list. I'm not going to judge who deserves a transplant but I will say that most alcoholics would not even make the list-because by the time they need a liver transplant they have so many other systems going south like heart and kidneys they are poor surgery candidates even if they have stopped drinking.
In our case it was decided not to pursue getting on the list because it was so rare to get a newborn liver and even rarer to get one that would fit my son. Miraculously ( thank the Good Lord) 8 weeks after he was born and in ICU- his liver started working on its own. No rhym or reason. There was evidence of a virus but none could be identified 

rednecktek --- 15 years ago -

as long as the beer, wine and liqueur industries pay for it all, why not? amazing how some of the famous and super rich jump to the top of the transplant lists... 

BlabberMouth --- 15 years ago -

My non drinking father in law received two liver transplants. If someone wants to live and are willing to go through a procedure....who are we to say whether they should receive it or not. You never know what will be a life changing moment for someone. They aren't child molesters or murderers.... they have a disease called alcoholism.... it can be overcome...but not unless someone has faith and gives them the chance. 

crazypinetrees --- 15 years ago -

No when my FIL liver fails because he is a lush I do not think he needs a new one to trash. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Segmental ("Split") Liver Transplant
The liver is the only solid organ that can regenerate itself. That means surgeons can transplant a small segment of a donor’s liver (small enough to fit the baby or child), and the segment will grow as the child grows. Segmental transplants can use liver tissue from living or deceased donors.

•Living-donor transplant (related): A parent or other adult relative donates a portion of their liver to the child (about one-fifth of the adult organ). The donor faces minimal risk from this elective surgery. A living-related donor transplant gives the child the best chance for full recovery and normal health.
•Living-donor transplant (unrelated): Because a biological match is not essential for the donor tissue, an adult who is not related to the child can be a viable organ donor. However, this is an elective surgery, so we only accept unrelated donors who know the child’s family and therefore has an emotional attachment to undergo surgery. (ie, no “Good Samaritan” donors).
•Segmental from cadaver: A portion of the liver from a deceased adult or child may be used for a child’s transplant. More than 20 years ago, surgeons at the University of Chicago Medical Center performed the first split-liver transplant in the U.S., in which one organ from the donor is divided ("split") for transplantation to two children recipients.

Whole Organ Liver Transplant
This is the oldest and most traditional approach to liver transplantation. A whole organ transplant uses the entire liver from a recently deceased donor. The donor’s liver must be small enough to fit the recipient 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground