Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

No bids accepted from non-unionized, lower cost employers

who's talking here?

randyjet 3
planemom 1
SoupIsGoodFood 3
Perfection 2
Jpgirl 1
JohnLynch 1
Work in Progress 1
golfy007 1
Kyobungee 1
Are we great again yet 1
justforfun1 2
txsassy 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Wow, way to discriminate opportunity

After working in construction for many years in Canada, John Monteith had had enough of unions calling all of the shots and forcing themselves onto employers. So John did some research on the United States, and found that one of the best right-to-work states was North Carolina.

John got in touch with an immigration attorney, and worked with him to emigrate legally to the United States at a cost of $40 thousand of his personal money. Well worth it as far as he was concerned, to have the freedom to run a business without being forced into negotiations and contracts with special interest groups. So he packed up his bags and never looked back.

He eventually found himself working for a company called Heritage Printing & Graphics. Originally located in the Northeast, Heritage had decided to open up a large format print shop in Charlotte, NC, and they hired John to help with business development to grow their sales.

The company has done very well in the large format printing business. Large format are basically the types of signs you see everywhere. Think of a concert or a sports game. Now picture all the “enter here” and “ticket booth” signs that find their way into events of that type. Heritage Printing & Graphics is one of the companies that competes for that business and they did well enough that, when the DNC announced they’d be holding their convention in Charlotte, John was tasked with making the pitch to land some of the work.

According to John, statistically speaking based on their size and clientele, it was a fair bet that Heritage could land at least 25% of the available work which he estimated to be about $1 million.

After continually receiving no return phone calls from the people that would review bids and determine vendors, John started working harder to land the business. Donuts that he would send to their offices would be eaten, thank you’s would be said, but still no follow ups. No call backs. No business.

Finally, confused and bewildered, John reached out to someone he knew that might be able to help. He was so shocked and upset at what he was told by this person, that he felt he had to tell the story. I spoke with him today.

The person that John spoke to is an executive on the Charlotte in 2012 Host Committee who are central to the planning of the convention and how things will operate in Charlotte. There are only a handful of executive members of this committee, but John refrained from naming anyone specific. Ultimately, which one it is may not matter. What does matter is how the conversation went. According to John, he approached this person to see why he couldn’t get any traction with the committee.

They responded by asking him, “John, are you a union shop?” When John told him he was not, the Committee member told him, “We were just told that we cannot accept bids unless they are from companies that are unionized.”

“Cannot? Or will not?,” John asked. ”Cannot,” was the response he got.

When he pressed to find out who to complain to, he was not given a straight answer. After spending some time thinking about, accepting that the jobs would not go to his company, John decided he wanted his story to be told. Not for political reasons so much. He says he thinks that partisanship need not enter into this.

As far as he’s concerned, he was denied the opportunity to even compete for work because unions had already bought and paid for the people in charge. Maybe he could’ve let it go at that point if not for the fact that the Mayor of Charlotte, Anthony Foxx, hadn’t gone to such great lengths to assure the citizens that this would be a boon for their local economy and an opportunity for the city’s business owners. With the mayoral election in Charlotte coming next Tuesday, these broken promises of jobs has been something Foxx’s opponent, Republican Scott Stone, has been pointing out. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Wow, I hope everyone reads this. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

Um, yea. Unions are like that.
What ever happened to free country.
We are union, we will only deal with unions. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

What ever happened to free country


Guess a free country doesn't apply to the DNC. They seem to discriminate as evidenced above. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

It's sad if that is true. 

justforfun1 --- 15 years ago -

Um, yea. Unions are like that.
What ever happened to free country.
We are union, we will only deal with unions.




What is free about this? They discriminated against this man because he didn't have a union. I hope he sues. 

Are we great again yet --- 15 years ago -

Guess a free country doesn't apply to the DNC. They seem to discriminate as evidenced above.
and they are in this story,How? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

and they are in this story,How?

You obviously didn't read it. 

justforfun1 --- 15 years ago -

You obviously didn't read it.





They never do. 

golfy007 --- 15 years ago -

Unions are so outdated. I can't believe they are still relevant in this day and age. I can see why they were needed back in the day, but nowadays, not so much. JMO 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

I see that you don't think that the Democratic Party has the right to decide who to hire for its convention. You are ONLY for freedom for YOUR party and friends and screw everybody else.

Also, it is better to have the money spent in a UNION shop since that money will go to MORE people than the top execs and owners. I see the GOP only thinks that the top folks should get more money and the poor folks who actually do the work get as little as possible.

I am glad to see the GOP showing their true colors. They hate it when workers get more money, but it is great when only the top folks get it. I am also surprised that you would object to the Dems having to spend more of their money on campaign expenses, but I never expect a GOPer to have much capacity for rational thought.

As for unions in this day and age. I have had personal experience with union and non-union contractors in the oil refinery. The union workers were superb and got the job done right and quickly. The non-union ones were a disaster, though a lot cheaper. You get what you pay for folks. At my plant with a strong union, as chief operator, I could shut my unit down on my own if I saw something that I thought was unsafe. That would have saved a lot of lives at the BP plant disaster since if the union had been stronger with our safety rules, the situation could not have existed as long as it did. Being non-union costs LIVES. That is borne out in the stats in the coal industry too. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

I hope that all of you like the higher electric bills that Houston Lighting and Power stuck you with when they used the cheapest bidder and non-union contractor when they screwed up the STNP years ago. They went with Brown and Root to build it even though it was their first nuke. After they screwed it up, the whole thing had to be torn down, and Bechtel, who had lost the bid originally to the non-union B&R.got the job to tear down B&Rs work. Then after all that, they finally built the plant. It would have been cheaper to have the union contractor initially and do the job right. 

Jpgirl --- 15 years ago -

Umm this is not new news. My dh is a sales engineer- he has been for 30 years and in several different industries- he's run into it a lot. The worst was in Ohio especially in the auto and power ( coal and water) industries. It's how companies that are unionized roll. Well 30 years later Ohio is a ghost town because all th companies packed up and went to Mexico, China and India. Dh saw the writing on the wall 10 years ago and found a job here.

Unions can be bad and good. As above posters indicated there can be quality work. But also there can be shoddy work. Dh witnessed this in the auto industry. He was surprised that cars ever came off the line working at some plants! Yet the cars we get now made in different countries are even worse! So yeah sometimes it is a case of you get what you pay for 

txsassy --- 15 years ago -

Freedom to exclude gay boys from the boy scouts and freedom to accept bids from union shops only.

Gotta love freedom.

Too bad the wingnut crusade of curtailing those freedoms is in full swing. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Freedom to exclude gay boys from the boy scouts and freedom to accept bids from union shops only.

Freedom to move your business (Boeing) to a right to work state and not be harassed............ oh wait, I guess that freedom only applies to certain people.

Gotta love freedom.

Too bad the looney left and their union thug crusade of curtailing those freedoms is in full swing. 

txsassy --- 15 years ago -

Freedom to move your business (Boeing) to a right to work state and not be harassed............

If they didn't violate labor laws then you are correct. Not sure if it's been legally resolved yet.

Yep, freedom is good. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

If they didn't violate labor laws then you are correct. Not sure if it's been legally resolved yet.

They didn't. This is all a move by the Obama admin and the Unions.

It's textbook thuggery. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

Dh witnessed this in the auto industry. He was surprised that cars ever came off the line working at some plants

I was a UAW member for awhile and I agree, but once again, the fault is NOT that of the UNION since THEY did NOT run the assembly line. It was the management who dictated the speed of the line and who decided that shoddy work WAS acceptable and that it was cheaper to make the cars work once they got off the line. I guess that they made those kinds of decisions AFTER their three and four martini lunches that they were fighting so hard to preserve years ago. Then of course, they could always blame the workers since they were "drunk" after one of two beers at lunch.

In FACT it was the UAW which employed economists who told the big three decades ago, that smaller cars and quality was the way to go. They simply told the UAW to stuff it since that was management perogatives. Then they had to take action such as off shoring to make up for their bad decisions. It always make me wonder HOW is it that Germany, Japan and others can make good cars while their workers are paid more. Or how it is that Japanese car makers can make cares here at about the same wages in many places, and still make money while American ones cannot.

Of course, then I remember my economics prof telling our class that it was obscene that assembly line workers in Detroit were overpaid. Since I HAVE worked on an assembly line, I CAN tell you that they are UNDERPAID. I hate "experts" who know nothing about the subject, and yet can make such stupid statements. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

It was the management who dictated the speed of the line and who decided that shoddy work WAS acceptable and that it was cheaper to make the cars work once they got off the line.

absolute nonsense 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground