Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The Myth of Income Inequality

who's talking here?

JDB2 2
ukchristine 2
SoupIsGoodFood 2
Warren Peace 5
voice of reason 1
jtcitrus 4
TexasOma 1
Quixote 1
I_won't_tell 1
Toss 1
LiveFreeOrDie 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

It's hard not to notice that when various articles come out to convince us that we must radically change the US, the statistic selected used to justify it is household income rather than individual income. Here's a few examples:

CNN article showing income disparity by household income
Washington Post article showing a growing income disparity without indicating that it's based on household income
MSNBC article showing a growing income disparity that mentions household income only once

Comparisons that rely on household data should always catch our attention when they are attempting to describe changes over time. Yet politicians and their lackeys in the media use this type of skewed data all of the time to convince the public that they must "do something" to take more money from wealthier Americans so that lower income brackets can benefit from their rightful claim of their fair share wrongly claimed by those in upper income brackets. Surely I'm not the only one who recognizes the impurity of such a measure.

Here's what I'm referring to. When you compare household income over time, you are also glossing over how households change over time. Those who embrace such a measure surely know this, because this is not a hard concept to understand. To make this point, let's take a look at the same sources cited above when they report on the growing rate of single mother birthrates over time

CNN article titled "Out-of-Wedlock Births Hit Record High"  
Washington Post article titled "Unwed Motherhood Increases Sharply in U.S. Report Shows" 
MSNBC article titled "Blacks Struggle with 72 Percent Unwed Mothers Rate

Wow. So the composition of households have indeed changed over time. This is truly shocking. 0 So maybe we would be vastly misled if we compared the household income by wage brackets over time, right? I'm no rocket surgeon, but it sure would seem that as the rate of unwed mothers increased over time, it just might be reasonable to conclude that household income may possibly NOT grow at the same rate across all incomes since the rate of unwed mothers is higher(and by that I mean vastly higher) among lower income brackets. Educational differences among single mother households also factors in to income earning potential. Single mothers who get pregnant at young ages tend not to get educated at the same rate as those who get pregnant at older ages and after getting married.

Is it really all that shocking to believe that if we track household income over time, we will also track how household income gets affected by changes in things like single parent residences, changes in divorce rates, and immigration?

So there has got to be an easier and more intellectually honest way of determining whether or not there is an actual income disparity, right? 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

The truth is there are much better and purer ways to show these changes over time - methods that don't rely on social changes as key factors. If only there was a way to look at whether or not the income gap between the rich and poor has changed according to individual income over time.

What is this Google thingy? You must be kidding. I can actually look that up? With Census Bureau statistics? It sure would be sweet if somebody out there on the interwebz actually put the results in a graph. 

0

Source 

No difference? Wait a minute...there is not a lick of difference in the individual income gap among rich and poor over the past 16 years? Well damn...why is the media not reporting this? Let's forget about why they chose 16 years instead of 15 for a moment. Instead, let's recap. The gap between rich and poor households is actually not the same thing as the income gap between individuals? That's crazy stuff right there. If only CNN, Washington Post, and MSNBC (and I'm sure others) had only checked their own offices for some indication that the CBO's figures might actually be misleading. 

Something must be wrong....., right? Wouldn't you just feel dirty if it turned out the news media is just gobbling this stuff up and spoon feeding you the same dishonest drivel that politicians with a radically different objective in mind are trying to push on us?

Read that again. No change in income inequality. 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

No change in income inequality.


biggest line of crap i've heard in a longgggggg time. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

Your evidence to the contrary is overwhelming. Let me know when you're ready for your opinion to be taken seriously. 

I_won't_tell --- 15 years ago -

The tipping point has come and gone.

The folks who are getting the free stuff, don't like the folks who are paying for the free stuff, because the folks who are paying for the free stuff, can no longer afford to pay for both the free stuff and their own stuff.

And the folks who are paying for the free stuff want the free stuff to stop
and the folks who are getting the free stuff, want even more free stuff on top of the free stuff they are already getting!

Now... the people who are forcing the people who PAY for the free stuff, have told the people who are RECEIVING the free stuff, that the people who are PAYING for the free stuff, are being mean, prejudiced, and racist.

So... the people who are GETTING the free stuff, have been convinced they need to hate the people who are paying for the free stuff by the same people who are forcing some people to pay for their free stuff and giving them the free stuff in the first place.

We have let the free stuff giving go on for so long that there are now more people getting free stuff than paying for the free stuff.

Now understand this, all great democracies have committed financial suicide somewhere between 200 and 250 years after being founded.

The reason?

The voters figured out they could vote themselves money from the treasury by electing people who promised to give them money from the treasury in exchange for electing them.

The United States officially became a Republic in 1776, 231 years ago. We have one chance to change that in 2012.

Failure to change that spells the end of the United States as we know it.

ELECTION 2012 IS COMING.......

A Nation of Sheep Breeds a Government of Wolves!

Obama: Gone!

Borders: Closed!

Language: English only

Culture: Constitution, and the Bill of Rights!

Drug Free: Mandatory Drug Screening before Welfare!

NO freebies to: Non-Citizens! 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

To help us dig deeper into the demographics behind the income brackets, .....let's take a look at the demographics behind income brackets:

0

Looking at these characteristics, is it right to say that the playing field needs to be leveled? It looks to me like differences in income can be logically explained by demographic characteristics that people have more control over than they think.

We can see that households in the top income bracket have on the average almost five times more family members working than the lowest bracket. This merely signals a reason why there is a growing statistical disparity by household income - the floor will always be 0, while any income level multiplied by any rate of increase will of course show a widening gap above 0.

We see that individuals in higher income households are far more likely than lower-income households to be well-educated. It is well documented (but rarely reported) that the unemployment rate for college educated persons is only around 4% today. We can see in the chart above that each lower income bracket has progressively LOWER percentages of people who have not completed high school.

We see that individuals in higher income brackets tend to be more likely to be married. We also know that divorce rates are higher among lower income brackets. If you have an annual income of over $50,000, your risk of divorce decreases by 30%. If you've attended college, your risk of divorce decreases by 13%. Source. We know that divorced women with children are four times more likely than married women to have an income that is under the poverty line. A single mom is nine times more likely than a married woman to have an income that is less than half the official poverty line. Although 10% of families in the U.S. are headed by a woman, 40% of poor families have a female head of household.

We see that individuals in higher income brackets are more likely to be working full time in their prime earning years.

But we also see that individuals in low income households are far more likely to be less-educated, working part-time, and either very young or very old, and tend to be living in single parent households.


What this shows is a trend line of productive decision making that leads to higher incomes. There's a recipe for success here. 

Quixote --- 15 years ago -

Right on target! 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

Stop using logic and reason!! Your going to make their heads EXPLODE!!!

On second thought..... Carry on.. :P 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

~20 million illegal immigrants counted as impoverished by US standards would add to those numbers as well.

So do clear thinking individuals actually believe we can add millions of low income immigrants (whether legal or not) every year and not expect that lower income household statistics would reflect a widening gap between the top and bottom? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

The KU liberals will avoid this thread like the plague.

Much like Halloween, this thread is full of "scary" facts. 

jtcitrus --- 15 years ago -

Here. based on individual wage data from the Current Population Survey, going back farther than 15 years.

0undefined

Why the disparity in wage and income data? I don't know. It might be the way in which the "income" was calculated. For example, if income includes all transfer payments... will look that up. I've got the data on that.

But to my mind, the inequality chart that actually matters is this:

0
(note, this looks a little off from the data I've produced. But the story it tells is consistent.)


That chart tells most of the story in growing wage inequality, but no one wants to hear it. 

jtcitrus --- 15 years ago -

crap, didn't realize how big that was...
looking for replacement....

ok. better image now. 

JDB2 --- 15 years ago -

wonder how they calculate hourly wages for many of us? How many hours do they assume?

jcitrus: I like the second chart. The first one needs a legend though.


btw Warren, your data reminds me of an old beer commercial....the one that says "I love you man!" Good stuff! 

ukchristine --- 15 years ago -

Have I understood this correctly......re the 2nd chart......

late 70's to early 80's wages were similar regardless of education. Things changed in 1982 and by mid 1990's there were HUGE differences. Was there any specific thing that caused this ...specifically in 1982? 

JDB2 --- 15 years ago -

I believe it is following a career...start working in the 70's and track the career earnings 

ukchristine --- 15 years ago -

oh thanks....I think I looked at it quite differently. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

The second chart may be a bitter pill for the "class warfare" crowd here to swallow.

I'm sure they'll have someone to blame for that disparity. 

jtcitrus --- 15 years ago -

wonder how they calculate hourly wages for many of us? How many hours do they assume?

That would be why it looks different from the data I use: my data is based on annual wages, not wage rates.

This is generated from the CPS:
Current Population Survey(N=300,000... give or take).

There are several different ways to calculate hourly wages based on different responses both using the response for "average number of hours worked" (in a week) or "number of hours worked last week" or "average daily hours worked" Though the results vary, it's not enough to change the conclusions, and the wage data has been checked against other administrative data including tax returns and payroll datasets... the CPS data is good, arguably the best cross-sectional data set we have. (Budget Hawks attempting to de-fund it btw)


jtcitrus: I like the second chart. The first one needs a legend though.


Each line in the graph displays the percent change in real hourly wages from 1973 to the present. Figures are adjusted for the affect of age (either as a quadratic or a quartic), sex, race(ethnicity), educational attainment. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -



The KU liberals will avoid this thread like the plague.

Much like Halloween, this thread is full of "scary" facts.




You are right on this --- only VOnR dared to venture into this thread at the very beginning,
spewed a bit of venom, got confused by the information and totally disappeared. 

jtcitrus --- 15 years ago -

late 70's to early 80's wages were similar regardless of education.

The graph depicts the percentage change in real wages compared to whatever they were in 1973. Wages were dissimilar, but prior to the late 70's Early 80's (postwar/...1968 is as far back as the most reliable data goes), wages had similar growth rates regardless of percentile.

Things changed in 1982 and by mid 1990's there were HUGE differences.

In the early 80's (coming out of the recession) we had an economy in transition. The consensus among labor economists is that there was a skill-biased technological change (SBTC) in the market. The Value-Marginal-Product of high skilled workers was still growing (especially in light of current and immanent technological advances). The same could not be said of lower skilled workers. 

Toss --- 15 years ago -

just get your hand out of my pocket is all I ask for. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics
work


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground