Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should a teacher be fired for expressing her opinion?

who's talking here?

randyjet 2
sunshine1881 3
ukchristine 1
Tylers Journey 1
rEVOLution 4
Perfection 2
Hiro Protagonist 2
oneyedman 3
jessemyles 1
Dr Aborto 1
Tipsyhic 2
Work in Progress 1
Dorothy Parker 1
itstxdaddy 2
Rollinglettuce 2
Kyobungee 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should a teacher be fired for expressing her opinion?

Patricia McAllister, a teacher in Los Angeles was recently fired after making the following anti-Semitic statement at the Occupy Los Angeles protest: “Patricia McAllister, I’m here representing myself but I do work for the Los Angeles Unified School District. I think that the Zionist Jews who are running these big banks and our Federal Reserve — which is not run by the federal government — they need to be run out of this country.”

Yes. There is no place for her in our schools Vote
 
 55.3% (21)
No.Where are the defenders of free speech? Vote
 
 44.7% (17)
oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

Patricia McAllister, a teacher in Los Angeles was recently fired after making the following anti-Semitic statement at the Occupy Los Angeles protest:

“Patricia McAllister, I’m here representing myself but I do work for the Los Angeles Unified School District. I think that the Zionist Jews who are running these big banks and our Federal Reserve — which is not run by the federal government — they need to be run out of this country.” 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

" target="_new">link title 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

What a dummy. Why even mention her employer? Firing was well deserved. 

jessemyles --- 15 years ago -

Sometimes the truth will get your big butt fired.

When it comes to the jews you better bend over and take your medicine.

Ask an unrepentent Mel who has been blacklisted due to not kissing that azz. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

For this opinion, yes.
For her favorite color, type of pet, no. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

If she was representing her employer - yes

Not representing her employer - no

Right to work State - doesn't matter 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

CH I think in some circumstance it matters what your job is.
In this case, she could have students that see her opinion, than develop their own like opinion based on their teachers.

Saying it in the public media can always present a problem.

We like to think giving your opinion can be free, after all it is just an opinion, but lets go check the ice box and see how many opinions have been penalized here...... 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Kyobungee, I never said there shouldn't be consequences to free speech but I don't believe losing a job is appropriate in this case.

Counseling, suspension, reprimand yes but termination is a bit extreme 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

Counseling, suspension, reprimand yes but termination is a bit extreme

Because counseling, suspension, reprimand works so good on bigots?

Well, typically nothing works, it only teaches them to keep it suppressed. The problem with what I see and why termination is about the only valid response is because she is a teacher at a public school. So Politics is involved also. Once working for a public school, or anything public such as that, you have to know there is a certain visibility you just do not want.
Now if she worked at Joe's Crab Shack, or Green Energy Services than I think it would be a little severe. 

sunshine1881 --- 15 years ago -

Why would she even mention who her employer is? It's one thing to protest on your own time, it's another to bring the name of your employer up in an interview. By doing that, yes, she opened herself up to whatever consequences the employer felt necessary. Had she not mentioned who she worked for, no. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

Why would she even mention who her employer is?

Because she thought it would lend her some credibility... 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

If that's what she teaches her students, then yes. Because we all know that you only teach what the government says you can teach.

If she said it in public exercising her first amendment right then of course she should not be fired.

But the moral of the story is don't talk negatively about Israel or you'll pay the price like Charley Sheen, Megan Fox, Mel Gibson and anyone else that has been publicly demonized for their views on their Jewish bosses or the Zionist in Israel.

If you restrict this woman's first amendment right, you restrict ALL OF OUR first amendment rights.

Is it wrong for her to voice her opinion in public that these men should be run out of the country? I don't think it is but that's my personal opinion. Many of these men after all are involved in the worlds largest ponzy scheme that is destroying our economy.

* Lloyd C. Blankfein, Chairman and CEO of Goldman Sachs[1]
* Ivan Boesky, Wall Street financier and arbitrageur [2]
* Asher Edelman, Wall Street corporate raider ("Wall Street" movie character)[2]
* Andrew Fastow, former CFO of Enron[3]
* Marcus Goldman, co-founder of Goldman Sachs investment bank[4]
* Alan Greenspan, Chairman and president of Townsend-Greenspan, economic consulting firm; former Federal Reserve Chairman[5]
* Michael Milken, Financier, Junk-bond specialist[2]
* Ronald Perelman, American billionaire investor [6]
* Marc Rich, Oil trading[7]
* Robert Rubin, former Treasury Secretary, director of National Economic Council, and Chairman of Citigroup[8]
* Samuel Sachs, co-founder of Goldman Sachs investment bank[9]
* Jacob H. Schiff, Wall street banker, leader of Kuhn, Loeb & Co.[10]
* George Soros, Wall Street investor and foreign currency speculator[2]
* Michael Steinhardt, Wall Street hedge fund manager[2]
* Paul Warburg, Chairman of Bank of the Manhattan Company (predecessor of Chase Manhattan Bank), director of the Federal Reserve Bank[11]
* Bruce Wasserstein, American investment banker and businessman, CEO of Lazard and controller of Wasserstein & Co.[12]
* Sandy Weill, former Chairman and CEO of Citigroup[13] 

sunshine1881 --- 15 years ago -

By bringing the name of her employer into it, she's no longer just an individual expressing her own opinion. The moment she mentions her employer by name, she becomes a representative of them and therefore open to any repercussions that may come of that. I think that would and should apply regardless of who her employer is.

I know that was standard for me when I was a reporter. I couldn't take part in protests, political campaigns, etc. even on my own time because it could be connected back to the paper.

Even now, I wouldn't attend a protest, speak to a reporter and tell them who I work for even though it is a private company because it could come back on me. That just seems like common sense to me. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

By bringing the name of her employer into it, she's no longer just an individual expressing her own opinion.

It's no different than the President of the United States deciding he doesn't like Gaddafi and waging an all out war that is destroying his nation.

Our politicians are always caught saying things about people they don't like.

Just because she works for a school system does not mean that she has given up her rights as a citizen. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

What she said is pretty bad, but is this the precedent that we want to set for teachers? If a teacher ever publicly expresses an opinion that is not in keeping with the "accepted" opinion, they can be fired?

What if a teacher states in his/her own church that homosexuality is wrong? What if a teacher states, outside of school, that they don't like the President?

Is it right to fire them over this? 

itstxdaddy --- 15 years ago -

the school has the right to fire any teacher if they violate any terms of their contract.

that's it. people who sign employment contracts give up their "right" to free speech. 

sunshine1881 --- 15 years ago -

Just because she works for a school system does not mean that she has given up her rights as a citizen.

No, she doesn't give up her rights as a citizen, but it's not her RIGHT to be employed by that given employer. It is a privilege that can be revoked the moment the policies and/or rules of that employer are violated.

It is her personal responsibility not to violate those policies otherwise the consequences are hers. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

The government may, however, impose reasonable limitations upon the time, place, and manner in which speech is exercised in order to protect public order and the smooth functioning of public administration. In imposing such restrictions, however, the state may not discriminate on the basis of the content of speech since such limitations would permit the state to favor one type of speech over another. Narrow exceptions are drawn for special categories of speech, particularly obscenity and so‐called “fighting words,” which could lead to public disturbances. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

What if a teacher states in his/her own church that homosexuality is wrong?

Didn't something like that just happen, and the teacher was "let go"? 

ukchristine --- 15 years ago -

I am pretty sure the UTLA (union) will step in to have her reinstated. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

She was well within her rights and should not have been fired. She was stupid for advertizing her affliation with the school system, but she did not cross any line that should cause her dismissal. If cops can endorse candidates for public office, then she certainly has the right to her personal opinion and state it. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

How would she feel if her superintendent spoke publicly about how he didn't like African Americans and they should be run out of the country?

Think she'd be excited to work for him? Think the district would tolerate his views and keep him employed?

She deserved to be fired. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

he didn't like African Americans

Big difference since she did NOT say ALL JEWS! She only referenced Zionist Jews who are prominent in banking. She did not even say ALL Jewish bankers either, only Zionist ones. Now I would have no problem if the supt said he hated Black Muslims and Farakhan. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

the school has the right to fire any teacher if they violate any terms of their contract.

that's it. people who sign employment contracts give up their "right" to free speech.


I agree with that but we don't know what her agreement with the school was. We can only assume that if they are firing her over this then it's in violation of her agreement.

But if she signed no agreement that she can't voice her opinions in public, then her right is till valid.

I can only assume that she mentioned the district that she worked for to let everyone know that even normal, everyday people are angry with what's going on. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

the school has the right to fire any teacher if they violate any terms of their contract.

The school district and any other boss has the right to fire you if you say something that they believe negatively effects their image.

You have the right to express any opinion you want and be free from any type of gov't persection or prosecution. That doesn't mean that you are free from any repercussions. No one is forcing her to stop expressing her opinion or throwing her in jail, she can express her opinion all that she wants. She just won't be working for the school district any longer.

If I went on the news or online, and it went viral with some really conroversial view, I'm pretty sure my company would fire my butt too. 

Tylers Journey --- 15 years ago -

the school has the right to fire any teacher if they violate any terms of their contract.

The school district and any other boss has the right to fire you if you say something that they believe negatively effects their image.



Teachers don't fallow dress code and they aren't fired and this happens in the schools. This woman has the right to do what she wants outside of school. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

Freelancer heard on NPR stations fired for protest

maybe it is catchy 

itstxdaddy --- 15 years ago -

This woman has the right to do what she wants outside of school.

no she doesn't. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

This woman has the right to do what she wants outside of school.

no she doesn't.


The only thing in this situation that is higher than her constitutional rights to say what she wants to is the contract she signed with her employer. But even our government has proven to us that contracts and the constitution do not matter. Like I stated above, if you say something negative about Jews, or Zionist Jews (Since most people have not clue what the difference is) or Israel, you pay the price. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -


The only thing in this situation that is higher than her constitutional rights to say what she wants to is the contract she signed with her employer. But even our government has proven to us that contracts and the constitution do not matter. Like I stated above, if you say something negative about Jews, or Zionist Jews (Since most people have not clue what the difference is) or Israel, you pay the price.



The only thing the constitution guarentees you in regards to freedom of expression is this:

the right to express any opinion you want and be free from any type of gov't persection or prosecution.


It has not ever protected you from losing your job, or from being ostracised if your expression is deemed abhorrant by others. 

Rollinglettuce --- 15 years ago -

Since she is the one who brought her employer into it, I would say yes. 

Tipsyhic --- 15 years ago -

To learn to keep her mouth shut that darn teacher needs. 

Rollinglettuce --- 15 years ago -

I can't stand ignorance and hate. The thought of her in a classroom influencing the next generation with her venom makes me want to vomit. 

Tipsyhic --- 15 years ago -

Stand ignorance and hate, I cannot. The thought of her in a classroom influencing the next generation with her venom makes me vomit want to.
If you can stand the heat get out of the kitchen not. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground