Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Top 10% Rule: Fair? I think not.

who's talking here?

Carla 1
Going off air 1
SoupIsGoodFood 2
mommie21g1b 5
Dr Aborto 5
tennischamp 6
Dorothy Parker 3
Zombie 3
Gator 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

tennischamp --- 15 years ago -

As I'm sure many of you know the top 10% rule puts Kingwood kids at an extreme disadvantage. I have fallen victim to the wrath of the "affirmative action" bill. I graduated with a 3.8 GPA and had SAT scores over 1600, played sports in high school and had more letters of recommendation than you can shake a stick at. Turned down from Texas A&M, I attended an accredited University in Texas with the understanding that I would earn automatic admission into Texas A&M. I completed my first semester with a 4.0 GPA and over the required 24 credit hours. When I applied this time, the admissions office told me that I didn't have enough credits. When I pointed out that I met the requirement, I was told that I didn't take the "right" classes (I followed A&M's degree plan). I rolled over and played dead again and started another attempt to get into Texas A&M University. I have applied two more times and they have told me the same thing, "You didn't take enough courses. You need Calculus 1,2,and 3 in addition to Chemistry 1 and 2, Physics 1 and 2."
The advice is, well useless. Let's think about this logically. I have been in college 2 semesters...how would I take 3 courses in two full semesters. (by the way, I have taken a winter course and summer courses, so I am not a slacker).
I am very frustrated and have no idea what to do. I learned a short while ago that a Texas A&M University official told one of my friends that I had no chance of getting in because "it wasn't fair that I got an A in Calculus 1 while an A&M student failed the course 3 times." If this person wants to talk about fair, let’s talk about the top 10% rule. Is it fair that someone who worked half as hard as I did get into A&M because they went to a disadvantaged high school and have a certain race. NO!
Looking at this from a political stand point: What does this do to your property value? The top 10% rule devalues the fact that you are in an excellent school district.
I hope there is someone out there that shares this frustration with me. I know that I can't do anything, especially alone.
PS: If your kid or yourself got in because of the top 10% rule, congrats. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

I feel your pain.

I got waitlisted for A&M so I went to Blinn and now am at lonestar. Applying to A&M for this January and met with an advisor downtown and even though I have a 4.0 and am on two presidents lists he acted like I wouldnt get it because I havent "taken the right classds"...

It blows. 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

The rule is stupid, anyone with half a brain would agree. On the other hand, what is so great about A&M? 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

"You didn't take enough courses. You need Calculus 1,2,and 3 in addition to Chemistry 1 and 2, Physics 1 and 2."

Sounds like you gotta hit the books champ. Take the classes they require you to take and stop blaming minorities for you wanting to be at A&M after only 2 semesters at a lesser school.

I went to school "full time" but it still took me 6 years to graduate. Nothing turns out the way you think it will. 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

I think the point was that he was more qualified than others who were admitted. Why should less qualified applicants come first? 

tennischamp --- 15 years ago -

Dr. Aborto,
I appreciate your input, but I feel that this is irrelevant to the topic. This is about the top 10% rule and initial admission into the university from high school. By telling my additional encounters with the admissions board, I was merely pointing out that the top 10% rule presents a perpetual problem to all applicant types. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

It's not just that though. Its so many damn kids are applying and ecause of the exonomy the ones who would go out of state are going to A&M an UT. When I was waitlisted I was flat out told you are qualified but we have no room. Lol it was like a slap in the face. 

tennischamp --- 15 years ago -

mommie21g1b,
Thank you for understanding. I'm glad I'm not the only person that thinks there is something wrong with this process.
A&M is not the only school that does this to students. I found an article online about a student who encountered the same problem with UT. It is a state wide pandemic. 

tennischamp --- 15 years ago -

Gator,
Yes, I have felt that slap many times (well 3 times)! We should start a club... 

Zombie --- 15 years ago -

Life is not fair. Figure out what your dream is, make it happen. Road blocks come up...crash through them.

Good luck. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

When I was waitlisted I was flat out told you are qualified but we have no room. Lol it was like a slap in the face. 


I think that could happen regardless of the economy. College tuition has climbed steadily for the last 20+ years to the point where it's almost out of reach for the average family. Kids are graduating with $80K+ in student loans and no guarantee of a job! It's extremely frightening to think about...but, unless you're going into a trade, what choice do you have? A high school diploma is pretty meaningless these days.

As a Mom to 5 kids, it scares the heck out of me. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

Why should less qualified applicants come first? 

Think of it as extra curricular activities. Your grades aren't everything. If you go to a crappy, violent school with a big drop out rate and you end up graduating with a 3.2 GPA. You probably had to work twice as hard to achieve that goal than someone coming from a middle-high income family whose only troubles consisted of what to wear for prom. I'm generalizing here but you see what I mean. 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

Just wait until your junior year, by then half of the "top 10% and still unqualified" students will have flunked out. 

Going off air --- 15 years ago -

Life is not fair. Figure out what your dream is, make it happen. Road blocks come up...crash through them.

Good luck.


golly gee zombs that was real good

i like it 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

If you go to a crappy, violent school with a big drop out rate and you end up graduating with a 3.2 GPA. You probably had to work twice as hard to achieve that goal

Or maybe you just showed up everyday and barely passed the exit level TAKS or whatever the latest test is. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -


Think of it as extra curricular activities. Your grades aren't everything. If you go to a crappy, violent school with a big drop out rate and you end up graduating with a 3.2 GPA. You probably had to work twice as hard to achieve that goal than someone coming from a middle-high income family whose only troubles consisted of what to wear for prom. I'm generalizing here but you see what I mean. 



In my 3 years of posting on KU, most people fail to see your point. For some reason, a lot of people assume that these kids are living in the same circumstances as the kids in Kingwood and are given the "same opportunity" to do well, they shouldn't be given any sort of "preferential treatment."

I've given up even attempting this debate...they will never see your point, EVER. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

Just wait until your junior year, by then half of the "top 10% and still unqualified" students will have flunked out. 

A common misconception.

Here's a study from 1999 and another Report from 2006 with sources that discredits your ignorant post. 

tennischamp --- 15 years ago -

Dr. Aborto,
I understand your view point, but the purpose of this blog is to examine the top 10% rule. I would really like this blog to focus less on the individuals and more on the law. As a result, we can avoid personal attacks and stereo-typing. I am sure an educated individual like you understands the rhetorical argument that I am presenting. I am not upset with the people that got in due to the law, I am upset with the law. 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

A liberal "report" doesn't change what I have seen in person. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

A liberal "report" doesn't change what I have seen in person.

ha ha ha. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Take the classes they require you to take and stop blaming minorities for you wanting to be at A&M after only 2 semesters at a lesser school.

No one mentioned minorities.......... well, except for you. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

No one mentioned minorities.......... well, except for you. 

Tennis said people of a "certain race". As in non-white. As in minority. Tickets Fails Again. 

Zombie --- 15 years ago -

Lol. Tickets is on the case when race comes up. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Is it fair that someone who worked half as hard as I did get into A&M because they went to a disadvantaged high school and have a certain race. NO!


Here you go, Tickets, from the original post! 

tennischamp --- 15 years ago -

Look up the bill. It was created in response to affirmative action being eliminated from admission criteria. 

Carla --- 15 years ago -

tennischamp,

First, this is not a "blog." This is a thread, containing posts, on a forum.

(Nitpicky I know, but it bugs me when people don't understand the difference.)

Second, welcome to the real world. Life isn't always "fair."

Third, no one "owes" you anything. No one "owes" you admission.

So if your heart is set on a particular school, sit down with a counselor, lay out what you've done, and ask them, "What do I need to do to get in?"

Then do what they tell you to do. If they tell you that you need X, Y, and Z, then don't sit and whine you haven't had time to take it, you put X, Y, and Z on your schedule and take it.

And after you have had this counselor that helped you, you also take the time and sit down and write . . . hand write on a real card (no stupid ecard) . . . a thank you letter for their advice.

Going to another college for the first two years isn't the end of the world. As mommie21g1b said, apply for your junior year when it is very likely that some of those less qualified students will have dropped out. 

Zombie --- 15 years ago -

Good advice Carla. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Tennis said people of a "certain race". As in non-white. As in minority. Tickets Fails Again.

All your assumption. She never mentioned any particular race.

Either way, the rule is discriminatory. 

page 1
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

children
kingwood
politics
rant


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground