Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

San Francisco cuts cell phone service to stop protests

who's talking here?

Julmummy 1
planemom 1
Justwatching72 2
SoupIsGoodFood 2
LiveOak 3
Perfection 6
lucky dog 1
james osterberg 1
Work in Progress 1
needsleep 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Interesting tactic. I guess the liberal city doesn't completely like civil protests when they go against the city. 

Justwatching72 --- 15 years ago -

Yes much better to allow the protestors to coordinate a shut down of the rails where someone could possibly get hurt or killed by those actions. 

james osterberg --- 15 years ago -

If BART has some type of information that prompted the situation they should come out with it. If there was a legit threat- spill it. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Sounds like something that would be done in Iran, Libya, Egypt, or Syria...... hmmmmm 

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

I did not know what the protest was about...

Man shot to death by BART officer identified
PUBLIC TRANSIT
July 08, 2011|By Kevin Fagan, Chronicle Staff Writer

* Charles Blair Hill pulled a knife on BART officers, police say.
Charles Blair Hill pulled a knife on BART officers, police say.
Credit: Courtesy DMV

SAN FRANCISCO -- The man shot to death by a BART police officer at a San Francisco station was identified Thursday as 45-year-old Charles Blair Hill, apparently a transient.

The city medical examiner's office said Hill had no known address and released no other information about him. Police officials described him on the night of the shooting Sunday as being drunk and wearing a tie-dyed T-shirt and military-style fatigue pants.

Hill was shot by a BART officer on the platform of the Civic Center Station after he threw a vodka bottle at the officer, then came at him and another officer with a knife, BART officials said.

BART has declined to identify the officers. One is a six-year veteran, and the other has been on the force about a year. Both have been placed on routine paid administrative leave.

page skipped rest of story here...

One witness said the confrontation had happened quickly.

"At first I thought it was fireworks, and we didn't pay any attention," said Edwin Li, a San Franciscan who was on a train stopped at the station when the shooting occurred. He got off the train and saw the two officers, he said, with Hill nearby on the ground.

"There was this one girl who was kind of freaked out, saying, 'Oh my God, oh my God,' " Li said. "There were only a few people on the platform."

A lawyer for the two officers said they feel bad about the shooting, though they believe it was justified.

"Nobody's happy when someone gets killed like this, and officers take it extremely hard," said attorney Harry Stern, who was a Berkeley police officer before becoming a lawyer.

Stern said that when the two officers responded at 9:45 p.m. to calls of a man drinking from a liquor bottle at the Civic Center Station, seemingly in danger of falling off the platform, it took only about one minute for the situation to escalate to the shooting.

"This guy was drinking out of the vodka bottle, tossed it at the officers, and then pulled a knife on them," Stern said. "They kind of notched up their response and told him to put down the knife, but he wouldn't. They had a totally appropriate response."

Chronicle staff writer Demian Bulwa contributed to this report. E-mail Kevin Fagan at 

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

http://imgs.sfgate.com/c/pictures/2011/07/07/ba-bart08_PH_0503746832.jpg

0 

Julmummy --- 15 years ago -

How horrible. There are a lot of mentally I'll homeless in SF. Some went there to party and never got out. This is very sad, but no reason to start a riot. Prayers for all involved. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Sounds like something that would be done in Iran, Libya, Egypt, or Syria...... hmmmmm


Scary stuff that San Francisco doesn't want peaceful protests.

Didn't former Speaker Pelosi encourage civil disobedience just a short while ago? 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

What evidence of a threat did San Fran have? If it's to stop peaceful protests then it's wrong. If twitter was being used to start violent protests I can see why did it. I still don't think it's right. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

What evidence of a threat did San Fran have?

None. They just didn't want people to protest against THEM.

They're all for protesting......... as long as it's not against THEIR agenda. 

LiveOak --- 15 years ago -

These were city owned WiFi towers at the train stations. If they thought that people were using them to disrupt train service and cause trouble, then they were correct in disabling them to protect both ordinary riders and city property.

You are the sort that would be complaining that the city did nothing if any trouble started. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

So when it is POSSIBLE there MAY be a protest, then all means of communication, even emergency communication should be shut down.

Good to know. 

LiveOak --- 15 years ago -

So when it is POSSIBLE there MAY be a protest, then all means of communication, even emergency communication should be shut down.

Please, let's not exaggerate.

No emergency communication shut down. You do not use WiFi to make cell phone calls to 911 so any emergency calls would still have gone through. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

LiveOak, they cut off CELL PHONE service, not just Wifi so yes, emergency communication was impacted.

reality isn't pretty

(AP) - An illegal, Orwellian violation of free-speech rights? Or just a smart tactic to protect train passengers from rowdy would-be demonstrators during a busy evening commute?

The question resonated Saturday in San Francisco and beyond as details emerged of Bay Area Rapid Transit officials' decision to cut off underground cellphone service for a few hours at several stations Thursday. Commuters at stations from downtown to near the city's main airport were affected as BART officials sought to tactically thwart a planned protest over the recent fatal shooting of a 45-year-old man by transit police.

Two days later, the move had civil rights and legal experts questioning the agency's move, and drew backlash from one transit board member who was taken aback by the decision.

"I'm just shocked that they didn't think about the implications of this. We really don't have the right to be this type of censor," said Lynette Sweet, who serves on BART's board of directors. "In my opinion, we've let the actions of a few people affect everybody. And that's not fair."

Similar questions of censorship have arisen in recent days as Britain's government put the idea of curbing social media services on the table in response to several nights of widespread looting and violence in London and other English cities. Police claim that young criminals used Twitter and Blackberry instant messages to coordinate looting sprees in riots.

Prime Minister David Cameron said that the government, spy agencies and the communications industry are looking at whether there should be limits on the use of social media sites like Twitter and Facebook or services like BlackBerry Messenger to spread disorder. The suggestions have met with outrage—with some critics comparing Cameron to the despots ousted during the Arab Spring.

In the San Francisco instance, Sweet said BART board members were told by the agency of its decision during the closed portion of its meeting Thursday afternoon, less than three hours before the protest was scheduled to start.

"It was almost like an afterthought," Sweet told The Associated Press. "This is a land of free speech and for us to think we can do that shows we've grown well beyond the business of what we're supposed to be doing and that's providing transportation. Not censorship."

But there are nuances to consider, including under what conditions, if any, an agency like BART can act to deny the public access to a form of communication—and essentially decide that a perceived threat to public safety trumps free speech.

These situations are largely new ones, of course. A couple of decades ago, during the fax-machine and pay-phone era, the notion of people organizing mass gatherings in real time on wireless devices would have been fantasy.

BART Deputy Police Chief Benson Fairow said the issue boiled down to the public's well-being.

"It wasn't a decision made lightly. This wasn't about free speech. It was about safety," Fairow told KTVU-TV on Friday.

BART spokesman Jim Allison maintained that the cellphone disruptions were legal as the agency owns the property and infrastructure. He added while they didn't need the permission of cellphone carriers to temporarily cut service, they notified them as a courtesy.

The decision was made after agency officials saw details about the protest on an organizer's website. He said the agency had extra staff and officers aboard trains during that time for anybody who wanted to report an emergency, as well as courtesy phones on station platforms.

"I think the entire argument is that some people think it created an unsafe situation is faulty logic," Allison said. "BART had operated for 35 years without cellphone service and no one ever suggested back then that a lack of it made it difficult to report emergencies and we had the same infrastructure in place."

But as in London, BART's tactic drew immediate comparisons to authoritarianism, including acts by the former president of Egypt to squelch protests demanding an end to his rule. Authorities there cut Internet and cellphone services in the country for days earlier this year. He left office shortly thereafter

"BART officials are showing themselves to be of a mind with the former president of Egypt, Hosni Mubarak," the Electronic Frontier Foundation said on its website. Echoing that comparison, vigorous weekend discussion on Twitter was labeled with the hashtag "muBARTek."

Aaron Caplan, a professor at Loyola Law School in Los Angeles who specializes in free-speech issues, was equally critical, saying BART clearly violated the rights of demonstrators and other passengers.

"We can arrest and prosecute people for the crimes they commit," he said. "You are not allowed to shut down people's cellphones and prevent them from speaking because you think they might commit a crime in the future."

Michael Risher, the American Civil Liberty Union's Northern California staff attorney, echoed the sentiment in a blog: "The government shouldn't be in the business of cutting off the free flow of information. Shutting down access to mobile phones is the wrong response to political protests, whether it's halfway around the world or right here in San Francisco."

The ACLU already has a scheduled meeting with BART's police chief on Monday about other issues and Thursday's incident will added to the agenda, spokeswoman Rebecca Farmer said.

But others said that while the phone shutdown was worth examining, it may not have impinged on First Amendment rights. Gene Policinski, executive director of the First Amendment Center, a nonprofit educational organization, said freedom of expression can be limited in very narrow circumstances if there is an immediate threat to public safety.

"An agency like BART has to be held to a very high standard," he said. "First of all, it has to be an immediate threat, not just the mere supposition that there might be one. And I think the response has to be what a court would consider reasonable, so it has to be the minimum amount of restraint on free expression."

He said if BART's actions are challenged, a court may look more favorably on what it did if expression was limited on a narrow basis for a specific area and time frame, instead of "just indiscriminately closing down cellphone service throughout the system or for a broad area."

University of Michigan law professor Len Niehoff, who specializes in First Amendment and media law issues, found the BART actions troublesome for a few reasons.

He said the First Amendment generally doesn't allow the government to restrict free speech because somebody might do something illegal or to prohibit conversations based on their subject matter. He said the BART actions have been portrayed as an effort to prevent a protest that would have violated the law, but there was no guarantee that would have happened.

"What it really did is it prevented people from talking, discussing ... and mobilizing in any form, peaceful or unpeaceful, lawful or unlawful," he said. "That is, constitutionally, very problematic."

The government does have the right to break up a demonstration if it forms in an area where protests are prohibited and poses a risk to public safety, Niehoff said. But it should not prohibit free speech to prevent the possibility of a protest happening.

"The idea that we're going to keep people from talking about what they might or might not do, based on the idea that they might all agree to violate the law, is positively Orwellian," he said. 

LiveOak --- 15 years ago -

The decision was made after agency officials saw details about the protest on an organizer's website. He said the agency had extra staff and officers aboard trains during that time for anybody who wanted to report an emergency, as well as courtesy phones on station platforms. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

LiveOak, would that satisfy you if you or a family member were having an emergency?

Go find someone or call 911.

Seriously the fact that anyone is okay with this is beyond scary. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

I came here to see if anyone was talking about this tonight.

I understand how people are horrified that the city did this, but would you feel differently if the people had started rioting? Would that be a justified use of government intrusion in order to quell the violence?

I don't know what to make of this. . .you can either be safe, or you can be free. This is one of those murky times that it isn't clear where the line is. 

lucky dog --- 15 years ago -

Didn't we squawk about some mid-east despot doing similar things? 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

I seem to recall that tired dog. 

Justwatching72 --- 15 years ago -

they disabled it for a few hours because they were alerted by the protestors that the protestors would attempt to shut down the rail service as their form of protest, so they did what the could and voila, rail service was not shut down....


but feel free to spin all ya want, it's pathetic, but it's you.. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground