Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should having an obese child be considered child abuse?

who's talking here?

hdavidson 3
wayward1 1
marathonmom 2
gumbeauxgirl 1
RX8LVR 1
SleightOfHand 2
Ersatz 2
mommie21g1b 4
Frio 12
SighFiGurl 4
Dr Aborto 1
Eyes Of Green 2
Work in Progress 7
Butterfly Kisses 1
Puss In Boots 4
Mabs 3
Dorothy Parker 6
Gator 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should having an obese child be considered child abuse?

Should having a child that is obese be considered child abuse? Yes or No? If yes, should the child be taken away from the parent?

Yes Vote
 
 42.4% (25)
No Vote
 
 44.1% (26)
Depends (explain) Vote
 
 13.6% (8)
Gator --- 15 years ago -

Should having a child that is obese be considered child abuse? Yes or No? If yes, should the child be taken away from the parent? 

Eyes Of Green --- 15 years ago -

are you watching Dr. Oz? 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

Why yes I am!

:] 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Wouldn't re-education of the parent be easier and cheaper and less traumatic for the child than taking the kid away? 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

Wouldn't re-education of the parent be easier and cheaper and less traumatic for the child than taking the kid away? 

I agree. Most people don't know how to eat right. But I voted Yes because I think it's child abuse. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

Yeah I think taking the kid away is a bit intense... but that's the argument on Dr. Oz that a few people on the show are saying is the only way. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

I have a cousin with an obese child. She knows how to eat right, the mother is thin! But she doesn't know how to discipline. So she gives the kid food to keep her quiet.

It's awful. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

I don't think it's abuse in the way that harm is intended, like the traditional abuses. Maybe your question should be, is stupidity a crime?? And while being obese is unhealthy, most of the cases stem from poor eating habits and nutritional ignorance. The sad thing is, it's an easy fix if you want to learn about health and implement it. It usually means the parents have to lead the way, that's the problem. 

hdavidson --- 15 years ago -

I have a friend who is way, way, WAY overprotective of her kids. But the kids are all obese. Can't figure that one out!! 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

There are so many obese kids now compared to when I was in school...it's unbelievable! But, we've become a more sedentary society, so, the less you move, the more crap you eat, the bigger you'll be! Not too mention that every activity now entails having a snack and a drink! We NEVER had that as kids....it's ridiculous how kids can't be at an activity for more than an hour without expecting a snack.

Same with adults. When entertainment is sitting around on a computer or cell phone, it's going to have an adverse effect on folks. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

There was a kid on here that was 500+ pounds... she was bed ridden because of a bone disease and had food brought to her... what is your opinion about that? 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

When entertainment is sitting around on a computer or cell phone, it's going to have an adverse effect on folks.


lol, now you quit preaching and have gone to meddlin'! 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

it's ridiculous how kids can't be at an activity for more than an hour without expecting a snack.

It ticks me off that I have to send a "fruit break" with my kid everyday. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

lol, now you quit preaching and have gone to meddlin'!


Sorry! But, I think this is why we're such a large nation...lol. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -


It ticks me off that I have to send a "fruit break" with my kid everyday.


hahaha omg I totally remember fruit break! Kids got away with 'fruit' roll ups and 'fruit' gummy snacks because it said fruit on the package... even though it was supposed to be healthy 

hdavidson --- 15 years ago -

it's ridiculous how kids can't be at an activity for more than an hour without expecting a snack.

Seriously! Scouts from 6:30-7:30 and they have to have a snack for the last 15 minutes! They just ate dinner! 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

Kids got away with 'fruit' roll ups and 'fruit' gummy snacks because it said fruit on the package...

Guilty as charged....on some lazy days I do send fruit snacks so I can just throw the package in the backpack and go! LOL. 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

And don't forget a water bottle. It is suggested that the kids bring a drink every day too. :\ 

Eyes Of Green --- 15 years ago -

Seriously! Scouts from 6:30-7:30 and they have to have a snack for the last 15 minutes! They just ate dinner!

I know. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Sorry! But, I think this is why we're such a large nation...lol.

Of course it is. People in past centuries didn't have access to the large amounts of food and large amounts of free time that we do.

But you are right about that snack thing. What is that about? We do very little snacking during the day, but every activity requires one. WTH? 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

Not too mention that every activity now entails having a snack and a drink! We NEVER had that as kids....it's ridiculous how kids can't be at an activity for more than an hour without expecting a snack

I agree, it is stupid. My kids always decline because they know the packaged crap with a capri sun is garbage. When it is my turn I send fruit and water, LMAO!

Yes, having obese kids is abuse. No, they should not be taken away- there aren't enough foster homes as it is and who can afford to foster a 200 pound 10 year old on the stipend they get??????? 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

But you are right about that snack thing. What is that about? We do very little snacking during the day, but every activity requires one. WTH?

True....example of a typical day for us...

-Breakfast
-Morning snack at school
-Lunch
-Afternoon snack at daycare
-Grab a snack or piece of candy when you get home if mom isn't looking
-Dinner
-Softball game/practice snack

Now that I look at it....geeez! 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

And I bet they eat squat for dinner, because of all of the snacks! 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

We use food as a filler in this society. Got some time? Eat. Need a break? Eat. Just had dinner? Eat!

Millions would lose weight if they did nothing else besides eat when they are hungry, and stop when they are satisfied, not stuffed. 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

And I bet they eat squat for dinner, because of all of the snacks!

I leared a long time ago to cut out the snack as soon as she gets home and she cleans her plate. 

Ersatz --- 15 years ago -

If not child abuse it is at least neglect. We teach our kids to say please and thank you, potty train them, teach them to walk and talk. Then fill them with cheesy poofs.
-
I do not get it. Oh and lead by example parents. 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

Then fill them with cheesy poofs.


Mmmmmm says the fat kid deep down inside of me. :) 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

The snacks wouldn't be a big deal if they were healthy snacks. A banana, a yogurt, some trail mix etc.

But, that's never the case. It's something like a pop tart or a rice krispie treat with a capri sun or kool-aid juice box.

I love capri suns and rice krispie treats as much as the next guy...(probably more!) but, it's not something you should be eating EVERY DAY along with full meals. 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

I agree. Of the entire group of 15 we were the only ones who sent fruit the entire year. Lots of cookies, "fruit" snacks, chips etc. and always a sugar filled artificially colored drink. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I do wish I had a freshly made, warm rice krispie treat right now! I won't lie!!! 

gumbeauxgirl --- 15 years ago -

It's not always as simple as some of you are making it.

I have a younger sister who is today, as an adult, morbidly obese.

She came into my life when I was 10 and she was 3. As a three year old she had a little baby fat, but was otherwise a normal, healthy child.

The only thing I might disagree with how my stepmother handled food/meals was perhaps insisting on having her "clean her plate" when she ate. My stepmother always prepared homemade healthy meals. (I know, I was often forced to eat certain vegetables, etc. that I HATED. But, that's another story.) We almost never ate out, or ordered pizza or had fast food. In fact, I don't have a single memory of eating out with my Daddy, stepmother and little sisters while I was a kid living there from the ages of 12 to 17.

My sister's weight issues are complicated. Some of it is genetic as her paternal grandmother was a very large woman and obese. I would say that there was a predispositon under the right circumstances. I also know there are emotional reasons why she gained so much weight. I can promise you that she was not fed crap by her parents on a regular basis. 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

I do wish I had a freshly made, warm rice krispie treat right now! I won't lie!!!

and some fire hot Cheetos with a cold Dr. Pepper! 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

and some fire hot Cheetos with a cold Dr. Pepper!

switch that to crunchy, regular cheetos and I'm right there with ya!

and maybe some warm chocolate chip cookies to balance it all out...LOL! 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

Mmmmm....Doritos has a throwback flavor on the shelves...Taco Flavor. Amazing. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Mmmmm....Doritos has a throwback flavor on the shelves...Taco Flavor. Amazing.

Doritos in any flavor....mmmmmm. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

Mmmmm....Doritos has a throwback flavor on the shelves...Taco Flavor. Amazing.



Hahaha, I had some last week!!! DD brought some home and I ate some. I cannot tell a lie, they were guuuuud. They should bring back the taco!! 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

I think we need to be VERY careful before advocating taking a child away from their parents. That should be rare, and only in cases of sexual abuse and physical abuse.

Kids are almost ALWAYS better off with their parents than in the "system." With, of course, the exceptions stated above.

Separating a child from their parents creates long lasting complications, so the reasons for removing the child have to be worse than the trauma the child will experience from the separation. 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

I cannot tell a lie, they were guuuuud. They should bring back the taco!!

I think we might be the only people that like them! LOL!! 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

I cannot tell a lie, they were guuuuud. They should bring back the taco!!

I think we might be the only people that like them! LOL!!




Momo5 likes 'em too!! Doritos are my weakness. Cool ranch? Yep, like those too. Salty, crunchy, fried stuff just tastes good to me. lol 

Butterfly Kisses --- 15 years ago -

Remember when we were kids and we were NEVER in the house??? We played outside literally from the time we got up until mom called us in for dinner. We NEVER had snacks. And we got a lot more exercise. Things are very different these days. Most kids just don't play outside anymore. :( 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground