Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Got Democracy? Pay It Forward!

who's talking here?

smartypants 10
randyjet 4
SoupIsGoodFood 8
david 2
Perfection 2
PS 1
JohnLynch 2
james osterberg 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
steinhoister2016 1
Clovis 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

by Dave Johnson. Appeared on Campaign for America's Future, 5/13, 2011 (abridged)

You hear it again and again, variation after variation on a core message: if you tax rich people it kills jobs. You hear about "job-killing tax hikes," or that "taxing the rich hurts jobs," "taxes kill jobs," "taxes take money out of the economy, "if you tax the rich they won't be able to provide jobs." ... on and on it goes. So do we really depend on "the rich" to "create" jobs? Or do jobs get created when they fill a need?

The idea that there are producers and parasites has become a core philosophy of conservatives. They claim that wealthy people "produce" and are rich because they "produce." The rest of us are "parasites" who suck blood and energy from the productive rich, by taxing them. In this belief system, We, the People are basically just "the help" who are otherwise in the way, and taxing the producers to pay for our "entitlements." We "take money" from the producers through taxes, which are "redistributed" to the parasites. They repeat the slogan, "Taxes are theft," and take the "money we earned" by "force" (i.e. government.)

So is it true? Do "they" create jobs? Do we "depend on" the wealthy to "create jobs?"

I used to own a business and have been in senior positions at other businesses, and I know many others who have started and operated businesses of all sizes. I can tell you from direct experience that I tried very hard to employ the right number of people. What I mean by this is that when there were lots of customers I would add people to meet the demand. And when demand slacked off I had to let people go.

If I had extra money I wouldn't just hire people to sit around and read the paper. And if I had more customers than I could handle that -- the revenue generated by meeting the additional demand from the extra customers -- is what would pay for employing more people to meet the demand. It is a pretty simple equation: you employ the right number of people to meet the demand your business has.

If you ask around you will find that every business tries to employ the right number of people to meet the demand. Any business owner or manager will tell you that they hire based on need, not on how much they have in the bank. (Read more here, in last year's Businesses Do Not Create Jobs.)

Taxes make absolutely no difference in the hiring equation. In fact, paying taxes means you are already making money, which means you have already hired the right number of people. Taxes are based on subtracting your costs from your revenue, and if you have profits after you cover your costs, then you might be taxed. You don't even calculate your taxes until well after the hiring decision has been made. You don;t lay people off to "cover" your taxes. And even if you did lay people off to "cover' taxes it would lower your costs and you would have more profit, which means you would have more taxes... except that laying someone off when you had demand would cause you to have less revenue, ... and you see how ridiculous it is to associate taxes with hiring at all!

People coming in the door and buying things is what creates jobs.


Lots of regular people having money to spend is what creates jobs and businesses. That is the basic idea of demand-side economics and it works. In a consumer-driven economy designed to serve people, regular people with money in their pockets is what keeps everything going. And the equal opportunity of democracy with its reinvestment in infrastructure and education and the other fruits of democracy is fundamental to keeping a demand-side economy functioning.

When all the money goes to a few at the top everything breaks down. Taxing the people at the top and reinvesting the money into the democratic society is fundamental to keeping things going.

This idea that a few wealthy people -- the "producers" -- hand everything down to the rest of us -- "the parasites" -- is fundamentally at odds with the concept of democracy. In a democracy we all have an equal voice and an equal stake in how our society and our economy does. We do not "depend" on the good graces of a favored few for our livelihoods. We all are supposed to have an equal opportunity, and equal rights. And there are things we are all entitled to -- "entitlements" -- that we get just because we were born here. But we all share in the responsibility to cover the costs of democracy -- with the rich having a greater responsibility than the rest of us because they receive the most benefit from it. This is why we have "progressive taxes" where the rates are supposed to go up as the income does.

In a democracy the rich are supposed to pay more to cover things like building and maintaining the roads and schools because these are the things that enable their wealth. They actually do use the roads and schools more because the roads enable their businesses to prosper and the schools provide educated employees. But it isn't just that the rich use roads more, it is that everyone has a right to use roads and a right to transportation because we are a democracy and everyone has the same rights. And as a citizen in a democracy you have an obligation to pay your share for that.

A democracy is supposed have a progressive tax structure that is in proportion to the means to pay. We do this because those who get more from the system do so because the democratic system offers them that ability. Their wealth is because of our system and therefore they owe back to the system in proportion. (Plus, history has taught the lesson that great wealth opposes democracy, so democracy must oppose the accumulation of great, disproportional wealth. In other words, part of the contract of living in a democracy is your obligation to protect the democracy and high taxes at the top is one of those protections.)

The conservative "producer and parasite" anti-tax philosophy is fundamentally at odds with the concepts of democracy and should be understood and criticized as such. Taxes do not "take money out of the economy" they enable the economy. The rich do not "create jobs, We, the People create jobs.
 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

People coming in the door and buying things is what creates jobs.

Who pays for the building in which this door exists? Who purchases the raw materials for which these "things" are made and sold at these places for which the door exists? Who hires the scores of people who run the manufacturing plants and create those "things"? Who invests the capital to do all of these things?

Is it the "parasites"?

Keep up with the class warfare. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

class warfare

Always ready with the sound byte.

It is understood that for large scale business operations there needs to be capital investment. That is a given. In order for our economy to working at its best, business, labor, and government need to be working hand in hand.

I would love to see the US pass policy that gives more tax breaks to businesses that bring industry HERE, make things HERE, and create jobs HERE. They are the kinds of businesses that deserve tax breaks right now. And we don't need to take those breaks out on the hide of teachers if hedge fund managers and their ilk pony up their fair share. That part of the equation is not in balance. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

It was written with those bolded comments like they were more important?

If paying people to sit around and do nothing is wrong (assuming what he says is correct) then why does the government employ so many unproductive people? Using his logic they should be fired since they don't provide anything of value for customers.

Maybe he does make a lot of sense. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Always ready with the sound byte.

It's all that is needed sometimes.

I've found that it hits the mark, too.

I agree with you on the hedge fund managers. Tax 'em to death. It's not my ox getting gored.

But where does it stop? Today the hedge fund managers. Tomorrow the oil companies. On and on and on. Eventually they're (Dems) going to have to start eating their own to feed their tax happy spending habits. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

where does it stop?

We are stewards of our economic well being, and our children's futures. In that sense, we will always need to look at what is happening in our country and take steps to improve the way it functions. We don't exist in a vacuum. World events and other economies have impact on our own too. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

So democracy is about ensuring equal income.

Who knew. 

james osterberg --- 15 years ago -

If paying people to sit around and do nothing is wrong (assuming what he says is correct) then why does the government employ so many unproductive people?

Those are my first thoughts when I see the tens of thousands of people and the dozens of new agencies added since 2001 for our "Homeland" security.

I never see any of you talk about this wretched excess of needless layers of people literally running into each other while chasing down all those bogeymen. 

steinhoister2016 --- 15 years ago -

Who pays for the building in which this door exists?



And how do they generate the sufficient dollar revenue to pay for that building??


Who purchases the raw materials for which these "things" are made and sold at these places for which the door exists?



How do they generate the sufficient dollar revenue to pay for the raw materials?


Who hires the scores of people who run the manufacturing plants and create those "things"?


How do they generate the sufficient dollar revenue to pay those scores of people?


Who invests the capital to do all of these things?



How do they generate the sufficient dollar revenue to make those investments??


Oh yea, people coming through the door to buy things. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

Who invests the capital to do all of these things?

Who invests where there is no market? 

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

The Bush tax cuts have been in effect for 10 years now and are still in effect.

Where are the jobs?

Who creates jobs? We consumers create the jobs. 60-70% of all economic activity is consumer driven. This is why the lower and middle income earners matter, even to the rich. 

david --- 15 years ago -

Comparing the Clinton Vs bush presidency as far as tax rates/economy is apples and orange. Clinton had the housing and .com bubble in his favor. Bush in the other hand Housing bubble Popped, recession. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

0 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

Henry Ford knew who created jobs, which is why he paid his workers at FAR higher rates than usual. He knew that he needed CUSTOMERS to buy the products of his mass produced autos. So he paid his workers enough so that they could afford to buy his products. It worked quite well too and made him quite wealthy. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

Who invests the capital to do all of these things?

In most US industries of any size, it was the government which started and invested capital to start those businesses. Look at the Eire Canal, the railroads, the airlines, etc.. Then we have the chemical industry which was created by government funds during WWII and the government plants were sold off at $1/plant after the war. The titans of industry were all created with government protections in tariffs, taxes, subsidies, and the like. They most certainly did NOT do it ALL on their own. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

In most US industries of any size, it was the government which started and invested capital to start those businesses.

lol...the gov't has no money to "invest"...it's money belongs to the citizens of this country 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

And how do they generate the sufficient dollar revenue to pay for that building??

From the products they produce. But I wasn't talking about ongoing payments to the building. I was referring to the initial cost to obtain the building, the raw materials, the permits, the infrastructure, machinery, offices, etc, etc......

It has to start somewhere. More than likely, it's one of those evil "rich" people that invests their own capital or money loaned to start it. Without that initial investment (from the evil "rich" person), then none of the other things are possible. Including the 100's of worker that are paid a wage to make said product.

Do you get it now? 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

I was referring to the initial cost to obtain the building, the raw materials, the permits, the infrastructure, machinery, offices, etc,


Without that initial investment (from the evil "rich" person), then none of the other things are possible

What businesses have hedge fund managers started with their money? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

What businesses have hedge fund managers started with their money?

I'm not talking about hedge fund managers.

I'm talking about business OWNERS. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

I'm talking about business OWNERS.

Okay, well and good. You have a widget. Nobody has money to buy it. What do you do? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Nobody has money to buy it. What do you do?

Then I think we're all in a huge tub of doo-doo if no one has money.

Not sure how that figures into this discussion. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

lol...the gov't has no money to "invest"...

I suggest you learn some US history. The US did NOT have an income tax until 1913 and most of the revenue came from tariffs and fees and land sales. The government has plenty of money since it prints it. It also had lots of it since it had lots of gold before that. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

Not sure how that figures into this discussion.

Not sure why you don't understand. Do you need an example? When capital gains are not taxed at the same rate as income, the conservative approach would reward Paris Hilton because Conrad Hilton worked to build hotels that housed traveling salesmen.

I know there are people who love to look at Paris and hang on her every word, and that she employs some photographers, but frankly, I wouldn't miss her if she dropped off the planet. I would however, miss being able to have a place to stay when I go out of town on business. If my trip is successful, it will help me (the little guy) be able to consume things that in turn will help other business owners be successful.

In the grand scheme of things, I'd rather reward the father's efforts than the daughter's. 

david --- 15 years ago -

The government has plenty of money since it prints it.
Wow did you really say this **shakes head** 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

I suggest you learn some US history.

i suggest you comprehend that i made no mention of income tax...tariffs, fees, land sales ALL belong to the people...hence, "we the people"...the gov't produces NOTHING...and, fyi, printing money means nothing if there isn't anything to back it 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

By the 1990s, Converse was losing sales to Nike, who dominated the market during the decade, and by 2001, Converse filed for bankruptcy protection and was acquired by a group of investors who moved production from North America to Asia.

Yeah, that would be Nike. And this group of investors deserves to be hung out to dry! I do NOT like Chuck Taylor All Star production enriching investors who move offshore because then they don't have to answer to anyone when they practice their business unethically. Bring the Chucks home. Just do it! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Not sure why you don't understand. Do you need an example? When capital gains are not taxed at the same rate as income, the conservative approach would reward Paris Hilton because Conrad Hilton worked to build hotels that housed traveling salesmen.

Once again, I don't see how this figures into the actual startup and build up of a business. It takes SOMEONE or SOME GROUP of initial investors to put forth their OWN capital to start a business that employs "the parasites". Without this initial investment, none of these "parasites" would have jobs....... outside of government jobs. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

I don't see how this figures into the actual startup and build up of a business.

There is no start up if there is no market. You can have a great building and wonderful equipment, but if nobody wants the product, or if nobody can afford to buy it, the business is bust. The market drives the business growth and therefore the jobs. It relates to the OP. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

There is no start up if there is no market.

Exactly. That's usually the first seed in a prospective business owners mind.

Fill a need. Provide that need at a cost effective, yet profitable cost.

For this to happen, it takes the will to do it, and the capital to start it.

Who starts a business for which there is no need? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

So do we really depend on "the rich" to "create" jobs? Or do jobs get created when they fill a need?

It's this particular statement in the article by Dave Johnson that just strikes me as being completely idiotic.

Does he expect jobs just to magically appear? 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

The government has plenty of money since it prints it.
Wow did you really say this **shakes head**


I see that you flunked US history. If you will recall our Revolution that is EXACTLY what we did to finance it. We had a HUGE amount of debt from that which we paid off at par I might add. The debt was FAR worse than anything that we face now. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I would love to see the US pass policy that gives more tax breaks to businesses that bring industry HERE, make things HERE, and create jobs HERE.


So you are advocating tax increases only for businesses that outsource? No increases for businesses that ARE HERE? 

PS --- 15 years ago -

The Revolution cost us over $14 trillion! Who knew? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground